I got so excited when I started reading the title of this article that it'd be about Daleks and Sontarans, and then it was about comic books and violence. I'm disappointed?
Have you ever read Seduction of the Innocent? It's just about the least compelling set of arguments I've ever read, and that was AFTER he manipulated the data.
The UW library system has one beat up ancient copy if you're ever curious.
Nevertheless, Dr. Wertham has left an indelible mark on our culture. For the worse.
From Ed Meece's attacks on pornography in the 80's to the NRA's current "blame the video games" mantra, a long parade of over-zealous do-good-nicks have have followed in his footsteps, plowing deeper and deeper furrows into the fertile memetic ground Wertham --falsely and with unforgivable bias-- first broke.
And so now we live in a world where the idea that "portrayals of violence or sex cause violent & sexual behavior" is taken as common sense knowledge -- despite a total lack of any supporting evidence for that claim over the years.
Actually the Senate hearing concluded that it was a BS argument anyway based on other testimony, so it was never really considered valid by anyone with half a brain.
So, thanks for highlighting my work on Wertham. It's absolutely true that there was considerable doubt about the quality / veracity of Wertham's work at the time it was published. It's also true that he wasn't single-handly responsible for the decimation of the comics industry. Still, it's satisfying - at least for me - to have some closure, even if it's nearly 60 years in coming.
Even--perhaps especially--an agenda with which you are inclined to agree.
The UW library system has one beat up ancient copy if you're ever curious.
Say...I don't know... like how the many are pointing to violent video games/movies as contributing to gun violence.
From Ed Meece's attacks on pornography in the 80's to the NRA's current "blame the video games" mantra, a long parade of over-zealous do-good-nicks have have followed in his footsteps, plowing deeper and deeper furrows into the fertile memetic ground Wertham --falsely and with unforgivable bias-- first broke.
And so now we live in a world where the idea that "portrayals of violence or sex cause violent & sexual behavior" is taken as common sense knowledge -- despite a total lack of any supporting evidence for that claim over the years.
And there's just no going back.