Wow, the beginning of this is so incredibly stupid it defies belief. OF COUSE craiglist made it easier for pimps and pedaphiles to exist as it was practically free advertizing. Make it harder and more expensive for folks to advertize and you're obviously hurting their business, duh. And no person who has, you know, READ the U.S. Constitution thinks the 1st amendment trumps EVERYTHING else in the U.S. justice system (you obviously can't advertzie for burglars, arsonists, forgers, or murderers either, to name just a few illegal acts where you have no freedom to advertize your skills). So, I have no sympathy for those whining about their free speech rights being violated. As for those too stupid to figure out how to otherwise market their business, well, that's evolution in action (and perhaps a prime reason why they're in the sex business to begin with?).