Features Nov 19, 2009 at 4:00 am

How Mike McGinn Broke the Seattle Machine—and Why the City Will Never Be the Same

Comments

1
Pretty solid article!

I especially like the nod to food carts. We need more. I want to be able to pick up a tofu kebab on the go, or have a nice pad thai while standing on a corner in Belltown.
2
Agree that Nickels never cared about more than getting re-elected and also agree about the empty 'green' mayor campaign. It's amazing how litte gets fact-checked by the MSM. It'll be nice to have someone who actually has some foresight and cares about the city in the mayor's office.
3
Interesting, Grant.

Some technical asides, other than the correct point about Conlin ...

1. McGinn actually led the primary, contrary to early vote totals.

2. The Billionaires Tunnel is dead, partly due to the rural voters (who don't want to pay for it) and partly due to Seattle voters (who don't want to pay ofr it) and totally due to the State - who can't afford to pay for it. Elections have consequences. Especially when you can't put a project up for a popular vote that nobody wants and nobody is willing to pay for.

3. Timing is everything. Sadly.
4
Fun, insidery stuff. I'm sad to be stuck with the mistrust of Mike I learned twenty years ago. Talking with him during the campaign helped me see how lightly he did in fact jump up on the shoulders of folks like you.

Glad you enjoyed the race, and please keep an eye peeled. If I were you, I'd use the Gyllenhaal connection to hang out with Pete Dexter if you don't already.
5
I really don't understand waxing pre-nostalgic about a waterfront given over to more Belltownesque condos, while loosing the other North-South freeway between the lake and the sea.

On top of all of its other issues, the viaduct is ugly and the area underneath it blighted, but I can't help but think that redone properly, we could have both a limited access highway and a roof over a waterfront park and arcade.
6
Grant unfortunately McGinn is going down like the monorail and will be voted out of office so loud and clear that any good of it, will be washed away. Remember its about governing, not ideology. Idealogues whether on the right or left -- always fail.
7
"because the city's consensus- by-default in last year's election was to remove the viaduct without replacing it on the shore."
--
Liar.
8
Amen. I voted for you before I knew you, and I'd vote for ya now. And you got Hawthorne and 'fungible' into a local political article. Heh, heh. >:)
9
I love the noobz @6. You are so funny.
10
Best thing printed in the Stranger or on Seattle, or Seattle politics in a long time.
FUCK the Seattle power brokers, along with the State and Federal power brokers.
11
awesome job grant, you hit the mark. i continue to be hopeful that seattle politics can change for the better and that we can start to focus on getting stuff done. it will be a nice change from our reps worrying so much about the next election that they are too scared to do anything...

12
awesome job grant, you hit the mark. i continue to be hopeful that seattle politics can change for the better and that we can start to focus on getting stuff done. it will be a nice change from our reps worrying so much about the next election that they are too scared to do anything...

13
Grant: That is very poetic, but devoid of any kind of reality. For one thing McGinn didn't win because of the reasons you wish he had had won for - he made it only because we all wanted Nickels regime out of City Hall, but he had scared off any serious challengers. Mallahan was an empty suit, while McGinn's pot belly at least filled his. And the second is your premise that the tunnel will be a disaster, the real disaster would have been the asinine surface option, which would have killed the streets for pedestrians, bicycles buses, light rail - everything except the monorail (on that I lament along with you). Cars are evil, but for Pete’s sake get them under the city instead forcing them into our urban environment. Get a grip on reality, man, this city isn’t fiction.
14
Wow. Amazingly abundant content in those first two run-on-sentence-laden paragraphs hooked me to this well-written article. Grant Cogswell, welcome home. Writing like that should be op-ed for the NY Times! Clap clap.
15
Great article, but it ignores the elephant in the room, Referendum 71. Like McGinn's facebook presence, the Approve 71 campaign had an enormous (40,000 member) fan page that drove out young progressive voters, also known as McGinn supporters.
16
>>a waterfront for human beings where we can look out on the finest urban sunset on earth

over carcass of our maritime industry.....

and hoping for the finest network of bike paths "more extensive than any in the world"???? Oh, ha ha ha ha ha Any city in Europe is decades ahead of us.

A piece strong on style, weak on substance: rose-colored puffery. After seeing his "work" on the parks levy, I'm just gonna keep my fingers crossed for a few years, hoping he doesn't do too much damage.
17
When will you Sonics fans stop blaming the Seattle politicians and realize that it was a swindle put together by Bennet & Stern. It didn't matter if Seattle built a solid-gold stadium and promised the NBA 100% of all public revenues, the Sonics still would have been stolen.

Why can't you people wrap your heads around that? Is it because Bennet & Stern are basketball people, and people in the sport are somehow above blame or retribution? It's like blaming your spouse after the both of you sign a toxic mortgage. What about the asswipe who sold it to you? Why not blame him? The real criminals are dancing in front of your face and all you can do is gripe about Nichols, et al. Get real.
18
what #15 sayd.
19
@13- The surface option does not mean what you think it means. It's not a surface freeway, it involves forcing traffic to either go elsewhere, go real slow, or go by mass transit.
20
We're going to have to find other solutions for 8 years while they build the tunnel. If we can figure out how to make it work for a decade, we can make it work permanently.
21
Tim Ceis was not nicknamed "the Shark" by anyone at City Hall. His former wife's family gave him that nickname long before he entered City Hall. Your article is heavy on opinion, light on actual facts, but you and folks like you won't care.
22
@17 - The problem was when the City of Seattle (Nickels) and Schultz could not get a deal done. Shame on both of them. To your point, once the team was sold - it was a goner. Agreed.
23
You ever notice how much of an almighty clusterfuck N. 45th St. can become at certain times of the day? Multiply that by two. Just sayin.

It's not quite as simple is you would like people to believe.
24
Grant, do you still have the City of Seattle's official logo tattooed on your shoulder, or did you have that lasered off before you moved to Mexico (or Portland, or wherever)?
25
Just like the monorail was short on sensible engineering, the poorly engineered Deep-bore Tunnel likewise fails to live up to the hype.

The most structurally sound Seawall and Alaskan Way Plaza and surface streets is only achieved with the Cut/cover which handles traffic that the Deep-bore displaces onto the new Alaskan Way and Mercer Street. Imagine 40,000 additional vehicles on the new Alaskan Way, and maybe 5,000 more on Mercer. Take your fingers out of your ears!

The monorail was shoe-horned onto 2nd Ave, disgracefully bulldozed through Seattle Center, and through Interbay its station area development would be little more than parking garages. It was poor engineering that stripped the energy from alternative routes that were more productive, less invasive, less expensive and still viable.

The monorail dream is not dead. But like the monorail, the Deep-bore tunnel is a nightmarish reality the result of incompetence and corruption in high places. I hope Seattle's powers that be are pissing their pants afraid of Mike McGinn.

26
The one good thing from Joe Mallahan's campaign:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nSlTMUd8c…

Enjoy...
27
It's both. Let's have a beer...
28
@3: Will, I know McGinn got the most votes in the primary, but Mallahan was by all accounts favored to win. @7: Ivan, glad to see you keeping up your old hot-headed and hostile ways. You can call me whatever names you want, that doesn't change the value-free observation that the majority of voters (divided, yes, on the means) chose options which did not include an elevated or surface highway along the shore. @15: Sorry I didn't mention 71, also very true. Was keeping it local, but that was worth a nod. @21: However far back Ceis' charming nickname goes, it was reported early in the Nickels administration to have come from his negotiating style, and if the shoe fits, etc.
29
@23- Oh it's real simple, I ride by on my bike while all the people in cars sit there and think about how much it sucks to be in a car.
30
This piece would benefit from some quality time with an editor. The ideas are interesting but the writing is poor. I realize the Stranger's editorial standards are low, but don't you have at least a copy-editing process?
31
Grant Cogswell shows us why he was run out of town by showing us that his understanding of politics only goes as far as who he is able to swindle into giving him money for his badly conceived agendas.

Mike McGinn has turned nothing upside down. He is a front man and subsidiary for Vulcan's agenda. They like him and funded his Great City because they know he'll tell the activists what they want to hear while maintaining the developer-friendly status quo.

He won by several thousand votes because he ran against a loser with no substance. He rounded up a bunch of unemployed subsidized college kids and gave them unpaid jobs to run his campaign that they could slap on their resume. He kept the best ones as underlings, because they'll work harder for less than incumbent City Hall staffers and they obviously take orders well.

Go back to L.A., Grant. You were a political cancer to this city and we're glad we're in remission.

32
You are an idiot who believes that "retrogressive" is the cool, locapolitico version of that real word, "regressive." Go back to your Uptight Utopia, and continue to fight for a Seattle with white progressive values.
"GrassRoots, a dramatic feature film based on Phil Campbell's book about that campaign, will be directed by Stephen Gyllenhaal and shot in Seattle this spring."
You are also a tool.
33
Cogswell, ya got a lot of heart. I have never seen a writer as close to Veblen since Thorsten - damn, what a job parsing those transitparkinglot parentheticals. It's great that you came back refreshed, knowing all you do, to sketch the realities so cleanly.

I'm glad you got out, out, out before you went bananas. There's a reason politicians tend to be old: they're the only ones stunned enough to face the insanity every day.

Seattle will get what it deserves. If that means more people like you need to leave to work the magic elsewhere - too damn bad for Seattle. It's just a hunk of property. Pretty as it is, it ain't worth that much.
34
Wow, what a load of self-aggrandizing BS couched in sophomoric, barely-readable prose. That was 20 minutes of my life I'll never get back, and I couldn't even make it ot the end.

Does Christoper even bother to edit any more?

There are plenty of places to point out gaping lapses in logic or basic understanding of civics in this piece but his rambling lead tips off what a wank job this story is.

He claims he "nearly made it" onto the City Council?

He lost that race by 22%.

Only a megalomaniac would translate losing by 22% a close race. We've all moved on, Grant. You should to.

36
Great article. Seldom do we get to read a piece that is so over-brimming with ideas. The usual Stranger article is so often like spittle. This article was a fire hose. Quality writing whether you agree or not.

I don't understand the negative comments that address nothing that was said with any valid counter point. They are only empty insults from the brain dead, e.g. @34. Let's raise the bar a little folks even if it's just the comments section.
37
Sgt Doom, If there was no corrupting influence on the monorail project, why was its destructive route through Seattle Center approved by City Council? Why did the existing line have to be pulled down and rebuilt? Why was the Interbay route chosen over the East Queen Anne route along Westlake where double the ridership awaited and along the scenic Waterfront instead of shoehorned on 2nd Ave? Why was its cost overrun announced at the last minute? By the choices made, there must've been plenty of backroom deals that had nothing to do with building a productive monorail system. There may have been sincerity in management, but the planners had about as much integrity and sensibility as all the other Seattle transporation planning beaurocracies. You think Metro system is run efficiently? I think not.
38
Who wrote the headline for this article? I hope McGinn's election means the end of this frickin' myth of the "Seattle Machine"

I know from machine. A machine is a tight, closed operation. A machine is generally gleefully corrupt to a level unknown in Seattle.

On the other hand:
A machine controls votes by giving voters something.
A machine DOES THINGS.

If Nickels had had an actual machine and actually did useful things for the voters, (starting with plowing the streets--you would think a Chicagoan would know that one) he would still be mayor.

I would love it if McGinn actually did good things for the city. I would also be pretty amazed--he looks like someone else who will get bogged down in the precious Pwocess.

Prove me wrong, Mikey--for god's sake, prove me wrong and do something to move this city off its whiny smug butt.
39
I wish that progressive politics could be separated from pretentiousness. I get it - I went to school in the Midwest. Some people don't have a clue and it feels good to know that some of us do get it. But must we continue to alienate others with distasteful holier-than-thou ostentation like St. Grant?
40
@6:
"Grant unfortunately McGinn is going down like the monorail and will be voted out of office so loud and clear that any good of it, will be washed away. "

We'll just have to wait and see about that. I think it takes a certain kind of arrogance to whole-heartedly assert that a politician is "going down" immediately after that politician just finished winning an election.

...I should say: a "special" kind of arrogance.
41
I supported Mallahan and I truly wish the best for Mayor-elect McGinn...none of us can afford to wish him ill in taking over a very tough job.

Like all the true-believers on the left and on the right, the whiny Mr. Cogswell really does think he is morally superior to those who manage to see shades of gray rather than black and white. In that way, he's sort of a male Sarah Palin...who also quit politics but still likes to sound off!

My favorite part of his silly, breathless, I'm-a-victim pile of run-on sentences and convoluted, self-absorbed asides was when Grant said he'd rather be "an artist" than a politician, AND that he was only back in Seattle for a short time and would be leaving soon! Three Cheers! Take your tender heart out of here and let the rest of us try to manage life in the city...sorry if it's just too much for you to handle.
42
This self-serving article includes a statement comparing traffic counts on N 45th to traffic counts on the viaduct. Before those statistics are repeated, please check their accuracy. As I read the City of Seattle's traffic count maps at http://www.seattle.gov/transportation/tf…
N 45th gets 24,100 cars a day and the viaduct gets 109,300 per day. (2006 map, the most recent on the City website.) That is, the viaduct gets more than four times the amount of cars as N 45th. And N 45th is backed up for blocks, including busses, as it crosses under 99 at rush hour.
43
I can see the Seattle Big Thinkers are out in force. The man hasn't even been inaugurated yet. Why don't you wait a bit and see what happens before you all start making grandiose statements?
44
Huh, one might think that someone who claims to be as liberal as this would be aware that calling a woman 'shrill' can easily be perceived as sexist.
45
@41 yeah, @41 is right. How dare you not stay in Seattle. anyone knows that anyone who goes to another place is worthless, and we here in Seattle can't learn anything from anyone from anywhere else, and we don't want any "outside perspectives"....no, unless you're ready to live here forever, and chime in when we sing kumbaya, just go on, and get out. Becuase you fail to get how superior we are to all those inbread provincial self absorbed other areas of the nation with their southerners and their crackers and their east coast egoism, and their california superficiality, my god, we are soooo superior to everyone else, THEY are SO SELF ABSORBED and EGOSTISTICAL MY GOD DON'T YOU REALIZE WE ARE THE BEST IN TRANSIT, THE BEST IN URBAN DESIGN, AND THE BEST IN HUMILITY AN OPEN MINDEDNESS!!!!!!!!!!11

YOUR PERSONAL THOUGHT ARE WRECKING OUR DIVERSITY SO SHADDUPT OUTLANDER!!!!
46
"But in Boston's defense, that project undid a snarl of highways to open up a most unique city's divided heart, on arguably the most vital road corridor in the world, I-95"

Interesting point except that I-95 loops around Boston. The road in question is I-93 which connects Boston to Canada and is mainly vital to Bostonians who want to go to Vermont. Fact checking is your friend.
47
This whole screed reads through such a distorted lens of monstrous egotism that it was hard to locate the ostensible point. Then we get to comedy like this:

He said, "You've been through all this" or "You kind of laid the template for this" or "You helped us get here"—I would like to remember what exactly, but I could barely concentrate on what he was saying.

Hahaha... seriously? Wow. I look forward to the Grant Coswell: I Am The Cosmos autobiography in my local bookstore's science fiction section.
48
I just read the article, and I think Grant Cogswell just ejaculated all over me. I need a shower.
49
I tried to read this, but my knowledge of english grammar prohibited me from combining the words into understandable sentences.
50
definitely a nice read, excluding how it exudes of self-importance while playing up the author's role in seattle's near past politics.

oh and you're working on a film? how many times could you shoehorn that into an article about the seattle's mayoral election? i guess apparently at least three times ...
51
GRANT, not a bad "piece," revealing more about you than about Seattle Politricks, which isn't a bad thing but falls short of the excellence that The Stranger is flirting with. Eli Sanders, for instance, has become Seattle's best Journalist Eli's South Park Slaying coverage is Pulitzer worthy. This type of piece, frequent in The Stranger's past (I have read almost every issue since inception), now seems nostalgic. Don't get me wrong, this is good writing, sort of a Seattle Post Hipster piece, like the contraptions in the NY Times magazine. It's just that The Stranger truly has evolved into Seattle's best ink and paper Newspaper, and not just some concert, movie times ad rag.
52
@42: Here's the 2006 map, I think your math is choosy (The tunnel will have capacity for 85,000 vehicles):

http://www.seattle.gov/transportation/tf…

@46: Boston is on the I-95 corridor, just as Seattle is on the I-5 corridor. To talk about 405 here for instance, from the other side of the country without indicating it is part of the I-5 corridor would be misleading. So would designating the Big Dig as something unrelated to I-95. Trees, meet forest.
53
The text on that link after the last backslash should read "tfdmaps.htm"
56
Gag me with a spoon. I'm so sick of Gregoire and her stances. "I will take the Viaduct down", "I won't call a special session". Take a walk, Gov. G. Your State is in deep doo doo, and you don't seem able or willing to lead.

Here is what we need ASAP: Rural communities need infrastructure, NOT cities. Now. Our future is dependent on the independent minded populations who live in rural areas, not in cities.

It is time for heavy money to go into infrastructure, which was originally promised. SEWERS will help clean up natural aquifers, lakes and streams. Small communities need infusions of capital, not big cities.

Big cities have taken, taken, taken for decades, leaving small communities to decline. Our future will come from our small communities, where small businesses can and will thrive - but we need SEWERS, WATER SYSTEMS, ROADS, AND TRANSPORTATION MOBILITY (bridges, ferries, airports) to succeed.
57
what was the point of this article? i missed it.
58
you forgot that McGinn is also fat. i think if you are going to name call nickels on this, its only fair to call out Mcginn who also dresses slovenly. You don't have to be an asshole grant. Keep to the politics.
59
wow, really poorly written. i dont know who this guy is but clearly has not been involved in the city recently.
60
The point of this article was to try to make The Stranger, once again, appear as the entity that got McGuinn elected. Not true, and a boring pointless article.

61
The monorail didn't go down because of the politicians. Indeed, they snubbed it, and didn't help, but it went down because proponents set up the hippie-dippie little government loaded with amateurs who relied upon staff who hid stuff. They got caught and the public gave up.
62
I´m down, except for one factor that no one seems to consider: Liquefaction. Look it up.

Otherwise, props. I can´t wait to hop on a train and get to Ballard faster than I can ride my bike. 45th is hell.

Also, I´m starting an empenadaderia. Not vegan, but the opposite: Chilean.

We Seattlites are way to concerned with our self image, and it costs us our warmth.
63
i just ate a bag of krackel chocolates.
64
Once a gain a another sometime Seattle liberal progressive (whatever label you like)demonstrates his inability to read maps and do simple arithmatic and think clearly about the past and the future. By the time we get a new 520 bridge, viaduct replacement tunnel and we have the popular with politicians but remakably useless Sound Transit to go with the toy train SLUT and the scrap metal scupture to replace the waterfront trolley we will have blown our wad and WPPS will have looked like a bargain
65
Let me get this straight. You left Seattle for your warm Mexico (now THERE'S a well-run place)because you don't like the rain, but you come back still pissed since we didn't build your toy train and rant like you know something about the last election. You don't. The errors in your tediously long, unedited piece are too many to list, but the good news is that you've swum the Rio Grande and won't inflict this claptrap on us again-- right?
66
As always, Grant, your perspective is interesting. I'd like to think of McGinn's victory as both a cause and effect of the tipping of power away from short-sighted, "get off my lawn" populists to younger and more worldly progressives. Seattle has been heading that way for years - perhaps we've finally arrived.
67
Simple minds stumble from others' (as judged) "bad grammar".

Grant, your testimony is an invaluable gift. It's also a laser beam to help the young people daylight the hidden workings of this city and the coop-tors of our dreams.
68
Well Grant, you ran it up the flagpole, and now you get to see all the trogs crawling from under their rocks to flick boogers at it. Do you honestly believe McGinn's support will remain sufficiently focused and cohesive to fight off the pandemic passive-aggression that sustains the Seattle status quo?
69
Mike McGinn is the accidental mayor. He didn't so much break the system as take advantage of a broken mayoral race.

The establishment held their noses to vote for Nickels. Nickels could get things done and if you crossed him made sure things didn't get done. He lost due a rare and usually strong snowstorm. His battles with the council led to Drago sealing his fate. She robbed him of enough votes to win the primary in a campaign seemingly more about spite.

That left two unknowns, neither who received more than 30% of the votes. Mike McGinn running on the anti tunnel platform and Joe Mallahan running on the pseudo Republican pro business platform.

The Democratic establishment again held their noses and supported Mallahan. Mallahan's lack of politics was bad, but his pathetic voting record was toxic. Even still McGinn saw the writing on the wall and disgarded his tunnel opposition to broaden his voter pool.

McGinn ran a good race, but he was also very lucky. I wish him the best, but his lack of experience makes me very queasy.
70
Most change happens because of broken systems not in spite of them. Drago running against Nickels is part of the brokenness caused by Nickels & Co.

McGinn has experience working with people, thinking outside the box etc. Those are essential to helping the city get on track.

No one has mayoral experience but those who get elected mayor.
71
Oh, and for the record, @34, I lost that race by 10.5%, not 22% - and I'm sure I'll get hate-heckled so let me say I don't intend in any way by mentioning it to minimize the memory of the huge tragedy that happened on September 11, 2001 - naturally incomparable in scale to put it super super mildly - but it is worth noting that our grassroots campaign was effectively destroyed by the deep shock felt subsequent to that event, which took place a week before the 2001 primary.
72
Didn't really read the article sorry. On the other hand, the first paragraph is all one sentence.
73
You lost me at your douchebag comments about seattle being impossible to live in compared to fucking mexico.
75
this article reads like corn flakes in my eyes feel. you don't need to write the bible in order to get the point across that you are a pro at bitching.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.