Film/TV Dec 17, 2009 at 4:00 am

Avatar Is FernGully Meets Space

This is what James Cameron sees when he closes his eyes.

Comments

1
you, reviewer, are an undeniable asshat. the type of woman every man hopes he doesn't have to wake up next to.
2
i'd wake up to you anytime lindy...
...anytime
3
"Does it have any nudity?"

http://auer83.files.wordpress.com/2009/0…
4
Lindy West, you are my hero. By the way, I now work at the Shedd Aquarium in Chicago, and do you know what they have here? That's right, Araipaima. They are as scary and terrifying as you say, and I'm pretty sure the other fish in the aquarium are in fact scared out of their scales.
5
What a wonderful review. Sigh.
6
apparently, James Cameron was the first to post. Lindy, a splendid review! Just superb darling, I'm sweating. bahaaaaaw! (ashes cigarette)
7
Dances with Smurfs!

This looks like the most high budget otherkin porn ever made.

That said, I will probably still watch it.
8
The definitive big box-office smash of the year, and the Stranger sends their lulzy fucking intern to cover it? To quote Lindy West, "WTF??! Okay that's the MOSTEST AWESOME DECISION EVAR!!!!"
9
Whoa, whoa. No need to shit-talk Kombucha lovers. There's a reason we always talk about it, it fucking amazing! Tiger Woods, ok, that's reasonable
10
Sounds like Peter Jackson's King Kong: 3 hours of giant, fantastical CGI creatures and bad acting from the humans.
11
@10, I had the exact same thought, which is why the "fool me once" adage applies here.
12
@10: Oh, it's so much less boring than King Kong.
13
Oh sweet fucking Jesus, King Kong was boring. Anytime there's a big CGI monster fight and you say "This is still happening?" is time to pack it in.

Will I see Avatar based on the review? Mmm, probably not.
14
I once thought Lindy West wrote rather humorous movie reviews. The problem is her style wore thin very quickly but she's a one-trick pony. Now she both bores and annoys the shit out of me.
15
Great review!
16
Oh hell yes on some ferngully!

Loved that shit when I was little.
17
At almost three hours, when would be a good time to take a pee during the movie. These things do happen.
18
I worked on Avatar here in New Zealand,and yes you are right....James Cameron is a blowhard too say the least!...I won't divulge what the majority of his crew thought of this asshole but lets just say....the movie is pretty wicked all the same!
19
Saw the movie last night. I too had low expectations, but guess what? Cameron hit one out of the Ballpark here!!

Excellent movie, enough action to keep it good, enough romance to satisfy the teeny boppers (and they actually glow just like New Moon), plus a really over told story about greedy Humans and the depths to which they will sink to acquire things.

I saw it in 3D and it was done well. None of the crappy flying in your face every few seconds like "Final Destination".

Cameron better hope that word of mouth works very well because this hog cost over $500 million dollars to make. It will take several weeks of blockbuster weekends to make that tidy sum up.

I wonder if he bought any Carbon Credits to offset all the computer processing power that went into this?
20
@3 There was some "boobage" in the movie, but it was not blatant and most of the time it was coverd in beads and necklaces in the style of some African Tribes you see in National Geographic in the 60's.
22
Did Cameraon really call the McGuffin material in Avatar 'unobtanium'? That was used a couple of years ago in 'The Core', a rather poor movie with a fairly good cast, including Delroy Lindo, who called his McGuffin propulsion material 'unobtainium.'
23
#22: Unobtainium is apparently standard scientist slang for extremely rare/mythical materials. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unobtainium

That Cameron doesn't miss a trick.
24
Can't wait to see this
25
love your reviews lindy, but no thanks. can't make me go see that one. ewwww.
26
So this film isn't just the good old noble red, ...er blue man versus the land-raping disgusting euro, ...er earth invader trope?
27
Seems like this movie would be amazing to see .... on weed!!
28
Dearest Lindy,

If it somehow were biologically possible, I would ask you to have my children. Well, after marrying me, depending of course which state you live in.
29
Question Lindy: Do you think the trailer properly represents the film? Because frankly every time I see the trailer I just laugh at how horrible & cheesy it looks.....
but If you really think its great maybe I'll check it out...
30
This is good news. As soon as I heard about this project (years ago), I knew it could only go two ways: Mindblowingly Awesome or Amazingly Atrocious. Cameron doesn't do mediocre.
31
Andy @ 29:

Have you seen the trailer in the theater recently, like in the last 2 or 3 weeks? They re-cut the thing from the first trailer I saw, which made it look about 40% more awesome in my opinion.
32
ps. If you were an engineer, chemist or probably involved in any science you wouldn't be amazed by unobtainium.....we use it all the time in lame, lame work jokes....

god I hate nerd jokes.....
33
@31 I will look it up and check it out, thanks
34
I like you, Lindy.

But I suspect you have a lot higher tolerance for terrible writing and gaping plot holes than I do.
35
Bulldozey. Avatoodle Jar-Jartica Scratch and Sniff Prequal. 2D.
36
Bulldozey Avatoodle Jar-Jartica Scratch and Sniff Prequal. 2D.
37
Thanks for the review. I'll see this now. Wouldn't have before.
xo
38
@7- that episode of South Park was awesome, i like how they started making fun of Glenn Beck then somehow tied this movie into it.

Sigourney Weaver's interview on "The Daily Show" actually got me more interested than i would have been with just seeing the previews.
click!
39
This is exactly what I needed to know about this movie. Thank you Lindy and hello IMAX EXPERIENCE. (BTW, did you see the 3D version?)
40
oh, and @17, keep an eye on http://runpee.com/ for your movie bathroom break needs.
41
I love that people get bent out of shape about your reviews. Taking a movie like this any more seriously would be offensive. I'd probably pay $10 see most anything that cost $500M. I'm gonna see it drunk.
42
I refuse to see it because of the I-need-an-exotic-looking-font-for-my-school-poster use of Papyrus as the title font. Yuck.
43
i needed some mike and ikes. i went to the HUB. the mike and ikes weren't there in their usual spot. instead: double stacked raisinets. a very nice staff person went back into the vault and got me some mike and ikes. i walked back to my office wondering why i would be so much happier if i got a bag of original fruits mike and ikes that happened to be all strawberry (the freakish chances!) than if they actually just *sold* a bag of mike and ikes that were only strawberries. i made it to my office. i pulled up slog. there is red chunky mike and ike on my screen now because of Lindy. i eat the red ones first and save all the strawberry ones for last.
44
you didnt just trash talk Sigourney Weaver, did you?

this means war.
45
Lindy West is the best.
46
I've never read one of West's reviews before and if this is typical I'm never going to read another. There's so much unnecessary literary tap dancing in her writing the subject takes a back seat.
47
Titanic could have benefited from a giant Lizard-lion chasing Leonardo DiCaprio around.

At least until the ship was well on its way towards sinking.
48
but is it awesome enough to earn its golden globe nomination for best pic? (???????????)
49
fired. you. are. fired.
50
I just want to hang out in Lindy's hot tub.
51
After months of anticipation I bought "King Kong" like the day it came out, also "Team America". I was extremely disappointed both times, to put it mildly. (In "Team America"'s case, probably the worst big budget movie I've ever seen!) Even though I probably will get burned again, I really hope "Avatar" lives up to its hype. From Lindy's review, and a couple others I've read today, I think I've got a chance.
52
I run to the bathroom immediately after a big fight/chase scene. Hasn't failed me yet.
53
Great review, and like some others will now go and see it, having previously had a "no damn way" attitude.
54
Was I the only person who read the front page headline as "'Family Guy' Meets 'Space'"? Now THAT would be a great movie.
55
@42, your font-critique touches my design-nerd heart. I haaaaaaaaaaaate Papyrus.
56
@55
I'm sure you've seen Papyrus:
http://xkcd.com/590/
57
@55
I'm sure you've seen Papyrus:
http://xkcd.com/590/
58
@54: I agree. I'd like to shoot everything to do with "Family Guy" (including its fans) into space.
59
The only thing that can destroy Avatar now is if Avatar stands between Lindy West and a just delivered pepperoni pizza.
60
The 3D is much better than Cats. I will see it again, and again.
61
I can't wait to get sooper fuckin' baked and see this flick!
62
Kombucha is a symbiotic combination of bacteria and yeast.
63
@ 46 Agreed. All the verbosity causes the initial point to get lost. Its like reading something by my 9 year old niece.
64
Hold the fuck on - did someone up there actually complain about a movie like this having plot holes?
Plot holes.
In AVATAR.

Ok so in tabletop gaming (best way to start a sentence ever?), there's a concept called: SUSPEND DISBELIEF. It's entirely self explanatory, and it enables fun-having.

Y'know. Fun?
65
Lindy you are terrific, and your reviews are even better. Laughed out loud several times while reading this one... I'm looking forward to seeing the film.

BTW - just how much cocaine do you reckon has gone up Cameron's nose? He has that cokehead "my face is about to implode at any moment look" going on somethin' fierce.

And fuck the Lindy haters. I'm apparently not alone here in thinking that she's really fuckin' funny.
66
I wish the Lindy West haters would give it a rest. We get it: you fucking hate Lindy West. No, but, for real: you really, really, REALLY fucking hate her. (And in the case of the first commenter here, you also hate women in general. But especially Lindy West! Lindy West is, like, a woman times three. Three times as hateable.)

Now that we're all clear on this point, you can quit posting your nasty comments every time she posts a column or review.
67
@17 There's really no good time to go, but if you must, go any time right after the dude wakes up back into the human world - you can miss all the military mumbo jumbo and none of the magical blue-people stuff.

@26 It's exactly that, but visually just incredibly, incredibly amazing.

@61 That sounds like an excellent plan.

Everyone go see it.

PS I love you Lindy.
68
@64
The problem lies in the fact that we keep giving blowjobs to all these twats who think having plot-holes is a valid/expected/acceptable characteristic to perform in any any storytelling. We need to stop it, its not a virtue to be admired or even tolerated....its just shitty storytelling...plain and simple....asking someone to "SUSPEND DISBELIEF" is asking them to become a thoughtless drone..... a shit vacuum..... a vomit sponge.
please, lets take a step forward in screenplays for once..... even shitty action films
69
@68
Worse than that - what about the racism? Stop rewarding prejudiced moviemaking with your $$. Ditto Transformers 2.
70
I was about to say "Stop it Lindy, no one finds your forced fourth grade writing style endearing" but apparently there are many, many people around here who do.
71
LAMENESS. I don't mind James Cameron--most people act like complete buttholes, especially if you cut them slack. It's his stupid movies that bother me. I always thought Terminator was silly, that Aliens was a moronic step back, that Titanic had fakey effects and stupid characterizations, and so now I'm supposed to get all juiced up over blue aliens? Please.
72
@64 yeah, i remember fun and i'm gonna go have some at 10:45! whether this movie is good or not, it at least looks entertaining, and if not - BIG FUCKING DEAL!!! some people really need to get over themselves. i'll leave the nit-picking freaks to what they obviously enjoy as a pastime. i, on the other hand, have better things to do, like enjoying a little mindless "shit vacuum", "vomit sponge" entertainment.
73
I know several people that also watched this movie, expecting it to be crap. Everyone so far has said it was an absolutely amazing film. I can't believe it. I guess I have to go watch it now.
74
See, Lindy displays the penultimate characteristic of the Hipster Douchebag: She hates it when people get excited over things. If they do, they are "annoying blowhards." Displaying strong *positive* emotion about something is the worst thing anyone can do, and it is up to the Hipster Douchebags to deride, sneer & mock them.
75
This movie was incredible. Lindy is one of the more entertaining reads in Seattle. Keep it coming. I read Lindy things and laugh out loud. Apparently some people are jealous, or they are taking themselves WAY too serious.
76
HEY 71

Remember in Titanic when that guy falls of the ship and his legs hit the propeller and he goes into a cart wheel on his descent to the freezing ocean.

That was AWESOME. I laughed.
78
Everyone who faults Lindy West's style for being, well, stylish, or childish, or for its hipster contrarianism... look, we get it. Go back to messily beating off to a Raymond Carver collection or dryly chortling over Masterpiece Theater or whatever it is you people do. At least Lindy's is *aware* of her distilled-4Chan, post-liberal-arts-degree, white-privilege-conscious prose, unlike the douchebagels over at pfork.

I mean, c'mon. What, you want Mudede to review everything instead?
79
@32- As someone in the bicycle industry, I also groaned at "Unobtainium." That joke is ancient.
80
I think this is a pretty perfect review. Any more words would be a waste of breath--I don't care who the reviewer is. The movie is what it is: fun. Even Lindy herself agrees that the script and plot leaves much to be desired. But if you want to check your brain out for 3 hrs and give your eyes a treat, then Avatar is a fine choice. You may think it's a simple formula, but making an enjoyable brainless action movie is tougher than it seems. (See: Transformers and GI Joe for examples of how to do it wrong)

To me a movie review should tell me why or why not I should watch a movie--whether it's entertaining or thought provoking. Otherwise, it would be a film school-style analysis of the technical aspects of the film that I couldn't give a rat's arse about.
81
The film was visually gorgeous, and technically flawless.
I just wish Cameron wasn't such a piss-ant primadonna that he can't recognize that his films would be THAT MUCH BETTER if he'd hand off the scripting to someone else. There were so many times that the dialogue had me chuckling in embarrassment (Could he really be serious? Is he having a laugh?). By the end I had a headache, but I wasn't sure if it was because of the 3D or all the eye-rolling I was doing. Surely $300M could've purchased a decent script? Jeez, I bet Harold Pinter would've risen from the dead and written it for that price.

And the critique: I'm not overly impressed by the review. I prefer being addressed as if I were an adult, most of the time.

@42 and @55: Prepare yourselves...all the subtitles are in Papyrus.
82
@78 I didn't realize 4Chan was giving out post-liberal-arts degrees now. If that's the case, There are clearly not enough Tay Zonday references in the review to qualify her for a Master's, which would bring your whole "Lindy is aware" argument into question.

83
your articles eat dog shit.
84
I think Sam Worthington burned a hole in my sexual reproductive organs.
86
#7: Dances with Smurfs. Right ON.

Awesome funny review, Lindy. I emailed it to some friends in the sticks who were hesitating seeing this psychedelic CGI-fest.

And the movie was totally awesome. Good news: the right-wing nut columnists at the NYT are already dissing the flick for its "heavy-handed enviro/pantheism message" (READ: Hollywood=devil worshipers). Any movie that pisses the Right off is worth seeing.
87
Great movie. Crippled gamer guy withdraws into his virtual world where he joins a mythical pure-of-heart race of noble savages to overthrow other white males who are more powerful, brutish, and evil than he is, the guys he has to rub elbows with in the real world when he's not plugged into his fantasy game. There's the fairy tale ending where he becomes his avatar and the bad guys are forced to leave the planet (that should appeal to people who are not satisfied with how real history plays out).

Lindy West's review is not very good. She trashes the only female actor (I guess she doesn't like competition). She is also troubled by the "clumsy indictment" of the army. Maybe she is just uncomfy knowing that her attraction to big powerful thugs is shallow and wants to believe said thugs are actually heroes. Yes somewhere buried underneath the thick neck of that evil general is a heart that can be tamed haha.
88
Uh 86, the NYT Film critic gave it a rave.....what you talking about?
89
http://movies.nytimes.com/2009/12/18/mov… NYT Critic's Pick...."On the face of it there might seem something absurd about a movie that asks you to thrill to a natural world made almost entirely out of zeroes and ones (and that feeds you an anticorporate line in a corporately financed entertainment). But one of the pleasures of the movies is that they transport us, as Neytiri does with Jake, into imaginary realms, into Eden and over the rainbow to Oz."
90
ALSO, 87, off thread, but which NYT columnist is "right wing?" (such an outmoded concept at that, the French notion of Right and Left), Krugman, Freidman, Dowd, Brooks?
91
Uh, I meant 86, DOH!, Tuttle? Buttle? what does it matter
92
While I guess I did enjoy reading this review, I found it distractingly enamored with its own cleverness at times. Murder your darlings, Lindy!

I also don't get the animosity toward Sigourney Weaver (though her costuming in one segment was fairly ridiculous).
93
Wow. A moldy ham sandwich is more of a salary then this reviewer deserves. Oh, Stranger why do you have to be so god damn cool all the freakin' time. Don't you get tired?

Also, it's weird that the majority of the chicks who are posting really, really like "Lindy" and the dudes who are posting are the most annoying hipster wanna-be critics that start every response to something you like by saying "yeah, but..." See the movie, like it or not and stop over analyzing everything! It's supposed to be over the top and fun. Remember that word, fun? You used to know it when you were a child until your dad beat it out of you.
94
Freaking fantastic film... in a word: Transformative. And I hate hyperbole, but this one chins the bar. See it in 3D.
95
yeah, what Lindy said.
96
Jesus that was the most grating "review" I've ever read. You are not funny, you are not clever. Go fuck yourself. But I agree, Avatar is the shit.
97
Wow! Not only did i find this review insulting, it actually made me angry to the point where I actually had to post a comment on it. Granted, being a funny writer is something that is hard to achieve, you either have it or you don't, and Lindy West, god bless her heart, just doesn't have it. I think someone should sit her down and have a chat with her about how her reviews need to be a little more weighty and insightful rather than trying to be cutesy and funny by using stupid pop culture catch phrases such as "'bout it, 'bout it" and "realsies". I know Lindy is probably a bright girl so she should do herself and stranger readers a favor and write like one.
98
Avatar ruled like no other move I've ever seen has ruled, and Lindy was right on. If I regret anything it's being such a big dick to you guys over petty bullshit.

Avatar's like the original Star Wars in terms of impact, at least it deserves to be. Even if it isn't, fuck you losers, I love it.
99
Yes, if James Cameron were to eat "Star Wars" and digest it, the turd that would come out of his ass might be labeled "Avatar". In terms of impact, that is(?)
God, what a hopeless piece of crap.
The animation in "Fern Gully" was more believable than the aweful CG in "Avatar". Disgraceful.
Seriously, pull that guys directing license.
100
I understand the "Fern Gully" reference, but I picked up more of a "Pocahontas" vibe from Avatar. When the girl cat/alien took the avatar cat/alien to meet the chief, it was so damn predictable it the chief was girl cat/alien's father. story was ok, and the graphics were amazing of course (I saw it in 3-D and I felt it didn't add a damn thing to movie), but the chief's daughter angle made me lose respect for the whole thing
101
How long has The Stranger been publishing articles scribbled by illiterate and gullible school kids who drink too much caffeine? I can't remember the last time I read such a boring review here. I hope this is just a passing phase!
102
I also thought I was going to hate this movie--saw one trailer and said, "That looks like the stupidest crap I've ever seen." Then I saw it, and loved it. Loved it, loved it, loved it. Couldn't stop thinking about it. Yes the visuals are great, but the story and the raw emotion of it knocked me on my ass. Your review is absolutely hilarious. Thanks for this! I like that you are at once realistic about the movies (I think purposeful) shortcomings, but still giving it the positive review it deserves, in a completely outrageous way. Good one. Hats off to you.

    Please wait...

    Comments are closed.

    Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


    Add a comment
    Preview

    By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.