Line Out Music & the City at Night

Saturday, August 8, 2009

Grim & Beer It: Sunn O))), Pelican, Earth @ Neumos

Posted by on Sat, Aug 8, 2009 at 4:25 PM

(Apologies for the lateness of this report. I am now just recovering from the punishment this show meted out.)

I’ve written about Earth so often in recent months that I can’t face another straightforward critique of this Seattle institution. So I spontaneously composed this free-associative string of fleeting thoughts that occurred to me during their set Thursday night Aug. 6 at Neumos. A transcription follows:

sexual frustration beer musk//implied violence power twang plod//methodical menace//methodrone precision//lumberjack languor//yogi heartbeat metallodrone//glower power//slo-mo decay dirge dispersion//19 miles of beard in the house

Well, it seemed like a good idea at the time.

Okay, on to Pelican. In recent years, Pelican have received substantial hype, which you should not believe. Live, they create a middling rumble, a gray trudge, a soporific shoegaze metal of lean beefiness. I felt extreme ambivalence about their set, which repeatedly hit mediocrity's bull’s-eye.

Time finally for Sunn O))). Fog everywhere, of course. Three robed figures—bassist Greg Anderson, guitarist Stephen O’Malley, and vocalist Atilla Csihar—move with sloooowwww ritualistic mannerisms. Bass frequencies emerge with a vengeance, rippling clothes, tendons, and molecules, and penetrating expensive earplugs. Rampant violations of body cavities commence. Even if you knew it was coming, the assault was shocking. I can’t push my plugs in far enough. My eardrums itch like crazy. “Ear rape!” you feel like shouting, but you’d go unheard. Dudes—most of very serious mien, most of whose beards could use a trim—outnumber women by about an 80/20 ratio. Testosterone simmers in the all-encompassing bass-sickness radiating from the stage.

Amid the obsidian-monolith grind, one can hear what sounds like the faint snarl and whorl of Vanilla Fudge’s Hammond B-3 organ emanating from the Pacific Ocean’s floor. This and Csihar’s guttural, grave voice were the only real diversions from the low-end bombardment O’Malley and Anderson sent from their guitar and bass. For 90 minutes, Sunn O))) steadfastly summoned tank-motor growls with hints of circular-saw embellishments. Csihar sporadically intoned deep, foreboding incantations that came across as a hybrid of Latin mass and Tuvan throat singing. “They look like they’re gonna burn a virgin,” a friend noted, and he had a point.

Besides one clown who was probably on his first acid trip (he repeatedly jumped around, shouted, and threw hand gestures while sporting the most blatant butt cleavage seen at a show in ages), most of the audience stood stock still, engrossed by Sunn O)))'s gargantuan, sepulchral borborygmus. The concert had the air of a purging ritual, but it was a bit static (understatement of the decade). Amid such monolithic dimensions, the slightest fluctuations in tone became monumental.

Sunn O))) don't really create metal, though they're commonly considered a metal band. Rather, they are minimalists who just happen to work with extreme frequencies while projecting an enveloping doom-laden vibe. Basically, they're closer in spirit to Folke Rabe, Phill Niblock, and La Monte Young than they are to your favorite hair-farming descendants of Black Sabbath.

By the last half hour, I had to constantly screw my earplugs deeper into my noggin to deal with the unbearable itching. This made it hard to maintain my worshipful stance in the temple of demonic frequencies, but I stuck it out to the end and left deafened and spiritually drained.

(Special shout-out to the lighting guru. Never thought fuchsia and periwinkle would enhance such heavy music.)

 

Comments (11) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
That video doesn't even come close to doing them justice. Seriously, it was like being at the gates of hell. So cool.
Posted by Avtar on August 8, 2009 at 5:55 PM
Brian Cook 2
i suppose i'm subject to some bias, but i thought Pelican was fucking great. very excited about the new material.
Posted by Brian Cook http://www.last.fm/user/bubblegutz on August 8, 2009 at 8:56 PM
3
19 Miles of Beard in the House is my favorite new band.

Seriously. Someone should take that name (drop the in the House part, tho).
Posted by Dod on August 8, 2009 at 10:18 PM
J. Burns 4
Number of complaints I heard about Pelican's drummer at that show: 5.
Posted by J. Burns on August 9, 2009 at 4:36 PM
bunnypuncher 5
@4 - And all 5 of them were right. I love that band, minus the drummer.

Sunn O))) were definitely louder the first night. Great both nights, though!
Posted by bunnypuncher http://twitter.com/princess_wolfie on August 10, 2009 at 1:57 AM
Brian Cook 6
Where's the love for Eagle Twin? i swear, they seemed to be the most talked about band of the evening while at the show.

i find the complaining about Pelican's drummer to be a little curious. No one really complained about the drumming during the s/t and Australasia years. in fact, the griping really only started after Pitchfork decided to dedicate the entire City of Echoes review to bitching about it. likewise, i've never heard any criticisms of his work with Tusk or Lair of the Minotaur.

Herweg's drumming seems in step with a lot of classic metal drummers. less flash, more stomp. a fiercer Bill Ward, a Lars Ulrich minus the double kick, or perhaps even Dale Crover without the odd syncopation. Maybe the criticism stems from Pelican's recent explorations into less heavy soundscapes, where the inherent metal roots of the drumming become more prominent against the juxtaposition of the prettier and spacier guitar parts. Either way, i thought he was in perfect step with the rest of the band at the show.
Posted by Brian Cook http://www.last.fm/user/bubblegutz on August 10, 2009 at 10:29 AM
7
I saw Pelican in Bellingham a few months back and have to agree about the drumming, and I've been a Pelican fan for several years. I caught myself noticing several times that there was just something very "not right" about what was happening. And I'm a huge fan of "less flash, more stomp", that wasn't it.
Posted by Hollie H. http://www.flickr.com/photos/mscrimson/ on August 10, 2009 at 11:44 AM
8
Brian: Arrived too late for Eagle Twin, but heard good things about their performance. Will keep a close ear on 'em.
Posted by Dave Segal on August 10, 2009 at 11:48 AM
9
My issue with Pelican's drumming stems from the sound the drums make and less the drummer himself. The sounds of the snare and bass drum are the same as the awful drums on of the Epitaph Records releases and other punk records. Not sure the physical difference that cause the terribleness of the drum sounds but Pelicans drums are the same sounding drums that ruin records for me.
Posted by Andrew C on August 10, 2009 at 11:55 AM
J. Burns 10
@5: I think you were one of them. I didn't put two and two together until later. Also, I wasn't sure if I wanted to out both of us as internet nerds in front of our friends. Lulz.

@6: Pitchfork may or may not have had a lot to do with it (I've heard people complain about Pelican's drumming since I've heard of the band, didn't read the Pitchfork review until a year or two after the fact), but I think that particular album brought Pelican a wider audience where more people started noticing it. If there are fewer people to hear your drumming, there are fewer people to complain about it. That may also account for the lack of complaints about Herweg's side projects. I don't know anyone who actually owns any Lair Of The Minotaur albums.

FWIW, Thursday night was the first time I've ever actually listened to Pelican. I heard a lot of flubbed and awkwardly placed fills. Something about his "feel" (completely subjective, I know) was off. I was working at a record store when "Australasia" came out, and I may have spun the promo once as background music. I forget.

Overall, I don't think he's a terrible drummer. He's better than I am (then again, I don't play drums in Pelican) but I don't think he's very suited for that kind of music. With all of the subtle and interesting guitar interplay going on, I don't think "less flash, more stomp" is necessarily the right approach.
Posted by J. Burns on August 10, 2009 at 12:13 PM
bunnypuncher 11
@6 I really dug Eagle Twin, but I'm a fan of Gentry's stuff in general. Can't wait for that album to get released on wax now! And regarding Pelican's drummer - you hit the nail on the head. The less heavy Pelican get, the more his drumming sticks out. He's a good metal drummer, but maybe not the best fit for Pelican.

@10 I wasn't there for Pelican's performance (I've seen both them and Earth too many times to still be interested in seeing them), but I may have been complaining about the drummer at some other point during the show, haha.
Posted by bunnypuncher http://twitter.com/princess_wolfie on August 12, 2009 at 12:36 AM

Add a comment

 

Want great deals and a chance to win tickets to the best shows in Seattle? Join The Stranger Presents email list!


All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC
1535 11th Ave (Third Floor), Seattle, WA 98122
Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy