Slog Comments
A Collection of Terrible People Celebrate a Terrible Man
1
The sad thing is, compared to G.W., even a paranoid, Machiavellian creep like Nixon comes out looking pretty statesmanlike.
3
@1 - Agreed. Each successive Republican president seems to make their predecessors look good.
@2 - What do you mean? Obama, Clinton, Carter, and Ford came from fairly modest backgrounds.
@2 - What do you mean? Obama, Clinton, Carter, and Ford came from fairly modest backgrounds.
4
4 decades? They're doing it now! I have ties to right-wingers who yearn for the days of GWB and talk about how great he was.
5
Nixon was a catastrophic mess of a president, but he was a fascinating mess all the same. Compared to the wingnuts and insubstantial gerbils who have led the Republican Party since, he was a giant. I'm not going to give him any points for "peacemaker", which is ludicrous, but I will give him credit for the EPA and OSHA, which he created, and for visiting China -- if you weren't around then you really have no idea how breathtaking a move that was. Oh, yeah, and Food Stamps, the Clean Air Act, the Endangered Species Act, NOAA, SSI...
Nixon also proposed national health care and a guaranteed minimum national income, which is far to the left of our current Democratic president.
Unfortunately, he was crazy. Watergate and the attendant coverup scandal was a wholly self-inflicted wound, but the paranoia and skulking wound-nursing were well-noted long
before he ever won the presidency. The politics of resentment never had a more perfect statesman.
I often wonder that the two smartest but most peculiar presidents we've ever had were right in a row -- Johnson and Nixon. And, in this era of double-degreed Ivy Leaguers, it's fascinating to think of these two men of genuinely humble origins, who went to Southwest Texas State Teachers College and Whittier College. Both were defeated by Vietnam, too -- though in retrospect that misadventure looks more and more like an early showing of an endemic national affliction than a specific policy failure (though it certainly was that too). Stupid, hopeless, endless wars are as American as apple pie these days.
In short, was Nixon a good man? No; he was awful. But in so many riveting ways.Those were interesting times.
Nixon also proposed national health care and a guaranteed minimum national income, which is far to the left of our current Democratic president.
Unfortunately, he was crazy. Watergate and the attendant coverup scandal was a wholly self-inflicted wound, but the paranoia and skulking wound-nursing were well-noted long
before he ever won the presidency. The politics of resentment never had a more perfect statesman.
I often wonder that the two smartest but most peculiar presidents we've ever had were right in a row -- Johnson and Nixon. And, in this era of double-degreed Ivy Leaguers, it's fascinating to think of these two men of genuinely humble origins, who went to Southwest Texas State Teachers College and Whittier College. Both were defeated by Vietnam, too -- though in retrospect that misadventure looks more and more like an early showing of an endemic national affliction than a specific policy failure (though it certainly was that too). Stupid, hopeless, endless wars are as American as apple pie these days.
In short, was Nixon a good man? No; he was awful. But in so many riveting ways.Those were interesting times.
6
@3, but they ended up with access to Harvard, Yale, and Oxford. Nixon never did. Right now is an unusual time; it's the first time in American history we've had four consecutive Ivy League presidents. Quite a few presidents never went to college at all, even as recently as Harry Truman (Washington and Lincoln among them).
8
There is absolutely no comparison between Nixon And George W.
One was brilliant and implemented some good policies, but was brought down by his own personality flaws.
W. was just a dumb guy who got run over by powers he didn't understand and never will.
One was brilliant and implemented some good policies, but was brought down by his own personality flaws.
W. was just a dumb guy who got run over by powers he didn't understand and never will.
10
#3
Historians have turned around on other Republican presidents over time.
In my day, it was Eisenhower. Although he was significant in proposing an agenda of arms controls, and warned against the military-industrial complex, after his Presidency he was portrayed as ignorant and backward and a kind of do-nothing presiding over Happy Days. While Kennedy gets credit for space exploration, for instance, it was during Eisenhower that the main apparatus was put in place for the development of space planes and rocketry ("The Right Stuff" even suggests that we may have taken a giant leap backward during the Apollo era from the X-15 space planes.)
Modern analysis paint Ike as quite intelligent, and having great foresight as a President.
It took decades of revisionism and more scholarly research to set the record straight.
Historians have turned around on other Republican presidents over time.
In my day, it was Eisenhower. Although he was significant in proposing an agenda of arms controls, and warned against the military-industrial complex, after his Presidency he was portrayed as ignorant and backward and a kind of do-nothing presiding over Happy Days. While Kennedy gets credit for space exploration, for instance, it was during Eisenhower that the main apparatus was put in place for the development of space planes and rocketry ("The Right Stuff" even suggests that we may have taken a giant leap backward during the Apollo era from the X-15 space planes.)
Modern analysis paint Ike as quite intelligent, and having great foresight as a President.
It took decades of revisionism and more scholarly research to set the record straight.
11
@5 Well put. Instead of the old "Power corrupts" stuff, I like to say that "Power amplifies a person's worst qualities." Nixon was a pathological liar. He had several admirable qualities, but magnifying that bad one was nasty business that cost a lot of lives.
12
He will always be "Tricky Dick" to me. Oh yeah, and the guy who illegally invaded Cambodia and Laos. Which (ahem) doesn't make him any worse than our current president.
Comments (13) RSS