Tools

Map

Pegasus Pizza (West Seattle)

2758 Alki Ave SW
Seattle, Washington 98116
(206) 932-4849

Categories: Cafe, Restaurant

Restaurant Details

 
 

Average Rating:
  • 3.50000/5 Stars.
Reviews/Comments (4) RSS

Newest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a review of Pegasus Pizza
4

I'm glad I was drunk the first time

Otherwise I never would have consented to sunflower seeds on my pizza. I'm a pizza traditionalist, having grown up near Chicago and therefore some of the world's best pizza, and I usually feel like fancy-schmancy, creative toppings just cover up a lack of inherent deliciousness in terms of crust, cheese brown-ness, sauce, etc.

But I was drunk, and so I let my date order the Greek pizza (minus the meat, of course). And it was fantastic. Several return trips confirm: the crust is good, the cheese is nicely crisped on top and gooey and oozy inside, and sunflower seeds are a great idea. It's still not my beloved, sorely missed deep-dish, but for hearty pizza in Seattle Pegasus is great, especially in terms of the price/quality ratio you usually get on Alki.
Posted by tm on April 13, 2009 at 7:04 PM · Report
3

AWSOME

PIZZA,PASTA AND GREEK SALAD WAS AWSOME,SERVICE WAS VERY GOOD TOOO.WE WILL GO BACK AS OFTEN AS WE CAN.
AUBURN WA
Posted by Brian on April 3, 2009 at 4:14 PM · Report
2

Soggy Crust

I found that the toppings are really good, especially the one where they put the shredded pepperoni on top. However, I did not find anything special about the sauce nor the crust and the crust was not able to support all the moisture from the combo. Had the combo we ordered been a "build your own", I would not fault Pegasus for the soggy crust, but this is their house special I am referring to. Anyone can put good toppings together. What separates a good pizzeria from all the others is it's crust and sauce.
Posted by SloppyJoe on September 2, 2007 at 8:35 AM · Report
1

great pasta

Gotta love the white spaghetti. It's worth the trip!
Posted by seajunc on May 20, 2007 at 2:55 PM · Report

Add a review


Click the stars.

Optional

Pegasus Pizza
Nearby and Recommended

Elliott Bay Brewery (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4720 California Ave SW    phone (206) 932-8695
  • 4.00000/5 Stars.
 (based on 6 reader reviews)
Talarico's Pizzeria & Lounge (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4718 California Ave SW    phone (206) 937-3463
  • 3.00000/5 Stars.
 (based on 17 reader reviews)
Seattle Hog Heaven (Restaurant)
West Seattle 4417 Fauntleroy    phone (206) 257-4946
Buddha Ruksa (Restaurant)
West Seattle 3520 SW Genesee Street    phone (206) 937-7676
  • 4.50000/5 Stars.
 (based on 4 reader reviews)
Mission (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 2325 California Ave SW    phone (206) 937-8220
  • 3.71000/5 Stars.
 (based on 7 reader reviews)
West 5 (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4539 California Ave SW    phone (206) 935-1966
  • 4.14000/5 Stars.
 (based on 14 reader reviews)

Are we missing something?

Need to correct our info about Pegasus Pizza?

!Add or Edit
Location

The Stranger Suggests

Critics' Best Bets
Music Arts & Food