End of the Ride Free Area
Losing Metro's "Magic Carpet Zone" Isn't Such a Bad Thing
By Diderot's dreams at en.wikipedia [GFDL or GFDL], from Wikimedia Commons
Tools
Get ready to whip out your ORCA cards, Seattle bus riders: Our free ride is over!
After months of debate, weeks of controversy, and a dramatic half day of last-minute, behind-the-scenes partisan bickering, the Democratic majority on the King County Council finally secured the Republican votes necessary to avert a 17 percent cut in Metro bus service via a temporary, two-year $20 car tab fee. The political price: a series of "efficiency" reforms, most notably the elimination of Seattle's downtown ride free area (RFA) by October of 2012.
Stranger Personals
"This is all about statesmanship," declared Jane Hague in justifying her swing vote in favor of the fee. Yeah, well, maybe. But in a tough reelection year, it probably doesn't hurt the council member from Bellevue Square to at least make the appearance of screwing over big, bad Seattle by taking away its freebie to bus riders.
But the truth is, it's hard to find many Seattleites willing to lament the loss of the RFA, let alone suggest that it wasn't worth sacrificing in exchange for 600,000 hours a year of Metro bus service. "The city has changed," explains Metro general manager Kevin Desmond. "[The RFA] was put in place for very different reasons at a very different time."
What was then called the "Magic Carpet Zone" was first established in 1973 to support economic development in the central core, and later expanded to include the International District and Belltown. At its inception, the city funded 100 percent of the cost of the RFA. But over the decades, that subsidy failed to keep up with rising costs. Today, when lost fares are adjusted for operational benefits (such as faster boarding times), the RFA costs Metro about $2.2 million a year, of which Seattle covers only $400,000.
That said, the RFA was never much of a free ride. Last year only about 28,000 one-way trips were taken entirely within the RFA, but after accounting for pass holders and transfers, only about a third of those were actually "free," leading even transit activists to acknowledge that the money could be better spent elsewhere. Eliminating the RFA could slightly slow boarding by forcing all passengers to enter through the front, but with two-thirds of riders in the zone already using an ORCA card or a transfer, Metro doesn't expect paying on entry to cause significant delays. But while the RFA may have outlived its original purpose, its loss could still prove devastating to the homeless and other low-income riders who have come to rely on it.
"There's a concentration of services in the ride free area because it's there," explains Real Change editor Amy Roe, pointing out that shelters, clinics, and other social services have specifically located within the RFA because that's the area accessible to clients. As government budgets have shrunk, the poor have already absorbed a disproportionate share of the cuts, laments Roe. "This is the one thing they had left. It wasn't made for that purpose, but that is the purpose it has come to serve."
Council Member Larry Phillips agrees and promises that both the county and city councils will work to mitigate the impact over the coming year. But, Phillips insists, "the RFA as we know it is coming to an end." So catch your free ride while you can.
What does the Republican war on working people look like? See Madison, Wisconsin earlier this year. What does the Democratic war on working people look like? See the King County Council's protection of billionaires and corporations and Gregoire's tricking for Boeing in Paris while demanding state workers take cuts.
3
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/lo…
10% over 100,000
http://crosscut.com/2010/09/29/metro-tra…
10% over 75,000
http://www.king5.com/news/local/All-King…
Paul Guppy said! average pay is over 60,000
http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archive…
6
7
9
whats it going to cost in over runs to put out the fire and fill it in? is that a road tax a metro tax a sin tax or the hot foot dancing tax?
There is nothing to stop DSHS from providing vouchers for those who are in need and using the system correctly.
Boarding will be faster, getting off the bus will be faster. Drivers will be able to open up the back door at all stops because riders pay as then enter.
What I can't believe is that so many people had to deal with cramming through a crowded bus to get off at their stops outside of downtown, simply to appease the minority of riders.
13
However #4 and 12 make some excellent points.
Next to go will be the trolleybuses. Can't have those ideal hill-climbers downtown. Someone might question why more aren't installed.
Transportation planning in Seattle and Washington State is controlled by automobile-related interests. GM didn't just buy up all the national streetcar lines years ago. They also hired their own system planners to pervert their design. These planners are still employed by agencies like Metro, Sound Transit, Wsdot & SDOT.
Henry Ford claimed he cared about factory workers in paying them $5 a day, enough for them to buy a Model T. His like GM's real intent was to reduce customers of the competing public transit system and create a dominant monopoly of travel by car.
The bored tunnel will lead to the demolition of historic Pioneer Square buildings whose foundations will be undermined. The elite conservatives don't care about the rest of us. We're all going to burn in hell anyway according to their mythology.
16
as they don't have a home and don't have a job! duh!
this is about a free ride area?
since the RTA has never been able to pay itself enough money and has fallen short since RTA took over Metro?
and need lawyers as they will take money for anti Israel messages but wont display them?
no christian adds? no atheist adds?
the circle jerk runs off a cliff faster then you can jump off the bus?
I'm happy Seattle city council is not as bad as L.A. city council but yup! its really bad.
case in point they lost half the sidewalk to places putting tables on the sidewalk as they lost parking to absurd parking prices as they lost free buss service downtown?
I don't what rock these freaks crawled out from under but I wish we could pick the rock up and place it back on top of them as these clowns just do not know Jack about business and worse will run the city out of business before they devlope any sort of brains,morals,savy?
Typical liberal fags whining about the loss of a service most of them rarely or never use in the name of being oh so concerned about the welfare of homeless scum they are nicely segregated from in their Wallingford/Ballard/insert trendy expensive hipster neighborhood here. I had the lovely experience of actually RIDING the 358 for nearly 5 years and amassed quite an array of stories involving homeless sh1tb@gs doing everything from jacking off, oozing bile and or blood, and openly drinking and pissing on the floor - not to mention smelling like rotten shit - so hopefully the loss of the RFA will make USING the mass transit system more pleasant again. And maybe all the fine black "youths" will finally have to PAY for a fare instead of wadding up some random scrap of The Stranger in their hand and shoving it at the driver shouting "dis my mo fokin tranzfur yo" before walking off.
Downtown Seattle and surrounding neighborhoods have been bending over and losing service to Eastside for years, ever since they put Metro into King County government (1995). Before then Metro was an independent public/private corp, and service was outstanding. Any long term rider who remembers it could tell you the same story. Modern-day metro is a joke.
24
as they don't have a home and don't have a job! duh!"
OBVIOUSLY you don't ride the bus very much. DUUUH.
"This is the one thing they had left. It wasn't made for that purpose, but that is the purpose it has come to serve."
Cry me a fucking river. Maybe now Metro buses won't be a rolling dayroom/insane asylum now that the useless scavengers can't board for free.
Consider converting the oldest, worst buses for free ride use. Paint them urine color, with a smattering of feces and vomit. Put the driver in a protective cage, with his/her own fresh air system. Make the seats of hard plastic or steel, and clean those bus's insides with a fire hose.
You see, there is a solution.
28
29
Since the ride free area was the alleged reason against it, maybe now Metro will do what every other transit system in the universe does: make everyone enter through the front door, and exit through the rear. Well, we can hope, anyway...
30
That's something you'll immediately notice about riding the bus there... it's so much quieter.
31
but again the title is "King County" killed the FRA and King County is not dealing with down town? or you could say King County is making Downtown worse as its not able to provide the same service that has been in place for decades
As to say the end of the FRA could be the goodbye kiss?
what I miss about Chicago, CTA and its wonderful soap opera shenanigans! I think King County is going to be crying for more and giving less until it fails Seattle.
I'm not happy!
This message is purly selfish, and I mean no disrespect to Seattlites that give a damn about their city, but..
I consider myself a humanitarian and nice guy. I'm one of those guys that hands out a few bucks, a sandwich, or a blanket to the dude at a corner in a wheelechair and cardboard sign, but I have a question....
As an "East Sider" can you please tell me about how bad I'm going to get screwed? I'll guarantee the entire state will see the $20 car tab increase, not just the fine folks of King County for which this entire proposal benefits (again, only being selfish) and due to cause and effect, I will have less to help those who smile when I make the effort to help them.
Seriously, the east side of the Cascades gets some sort of rogering to "assist" the west side, usually for projects that have no particular use to the general public. I have paid for stadiums I don't frequent (that pesky general fund) and will get to fund a tunnel I have no use for, or quite possibly will never, ever pass through.
So if you can help me understand, I will start a petition that those of us "over here" get our much earned "reach around", smile, and take what we will eventually have to live with.
PS: I love Seattle, you are truly the nicest I have ever met. See you at Bumbershoot.
Um, seriously, the dry side is a charity case. King County had 28% of the state's people but generates 42% of the state's tax revenues. We export $2.5 billion a year to the rest of the state.
Specifically, this sentence makes no sense:
"Last year only about 28,000 one-way trips were taken entirely within the RFA, but after accounting for pass holders and transfers, only about a third of those were actually 'free,' leading even transit activists to acknowledge that the money could be better spent elsewhere."
If only a few of the trips were free, then the difference in revenue can't have been much. If it cost a lot, then the volume must have been much higher than described. Goldy's sentence implies that, after the numbers were crunched, the lost revenue per free trip turned out to be too high... but this is nonsense. Before the numbers were crunched, we already knew that the lost revenue per free trip was at most $2.50, depending on peak hours and whether the person wouldn't have taken the trip if they'd had to pay.
Thus, as @10 already pointed out:
28,000 rides
x 1/3 of them free
x $2.50
= around $23,000, not $2.2 million.
Is there something I'm missing, here?
Also, of course, it's even less than that, because presumably some of those riders wouldn't have taken the bus at all if it weren't free. (They would've either walked or skipped the trip.) Any intro econ student can tell you that demand decreases as price increases.
And of course, if the change causes some people to drive instead of taking the bus, there is an environmental cost we're not factoring in. If it causes some people to skip a trip on which they would've spent the $2.50 on something else, there's an economic cost to that too. Public transit is one of the most wholesome institutions we've got.
I agree that it was always a little arbitrary and business-y having the ride-free area only in downtown, but better somewhere than nowhere... Good public policy, especially during a recession, would be to expand free public services, not shrink them. Think of the environmental and economic benefits if we made the whole transit system free, or pay-what-you-will!
Plus, the impact on homeless and other low-income people seeking services is of serious concern. Sure doesn't seem worth a measly $20K savings.
41
Yup! and we are going to remove Saddam from Iraq? and if elected I promise I will bring the troops home? and Hot dogs cause cancer and left handed women are more susceptible to breast cancer and Rick Perry would make a great president and many other American dreams?
It may be that PC generation that has been letting software do it thinking and Sexual stimulation and detective work and Election rigging and Media manipulating has woke up and realized the entire middle east is killing each other in civil wars and conflicts and no Americans could have told you about jack shit from 9-11 to Katrina to wall street to Iraq or anything?
Your puzzled how king county cant get its numbers right after its had to slash and burn after it sat on its lazy ass and stuffed its face for 20 years?
Then again I should realize these comments are the ramblings of the "great pretenders".
42







RSS
Comments (42) RSS