After a don't-worry-this-isn't-an-orgy tour by a woman whose melonious breasts were not concealed by the sheer fabric she had tied together in the name of shirthood, I was loosed upon the fourth annual Seattle Erotic Art Festival at Consolidated Works. Landing straightaway at a large ceramic fortune cookie shaped as a shaved vagina while overhearing an escalating argument between a couple about her failure to have orgasms and his lack of sympathy was, in fact, a bit much, especially when the argument turned out to be a performance that culminated in the man being escorted to a stage in the middle of the room by a band of underdressed floozies who held him down and tore off his clothes. As much as I support the message of the sex-positive community, at heart I am an appreciator of a little old-fashioned repression, which I believe makes me a sex-negative.

Whether I am qualified to review John John Jesse's frothy pink painting of a woman in a bunny mask snorting cocaine off the vagina of another, bored-looking woman, well, I suppose that is the question. I felt sure that the man standing in the corner near the painting, wearing something between a sumo diaper and Speedo held up by a leather harness and watching me scribble in my notebook, knew just by looking that no one had snorted coke off my business, and that I had a questionable understanding of the representation's relationship to its subject matter. I retreated to the unisex bathrooms, where a plump gentleman at the sinks flirted with and surveyed the miniskirt and knee socks of a woman he called Bliss.

It's not that all the art was bad, just that most of it was secondary to somebody's idea of erotic: saliva, stilettos, vice grips on nipples. One photograph of a penis and a smoky-looking emission had a note scrawled on its wall label: "Shot underwater—not smoke!" There were a few delightful contributions by Seattle artists. Toi Sennhauser, Steven Edward Miller, Walt Jones, and John Jacobs offered a raspberry-sauce-licking machine, a landscape of queer bunnies, photographic portraits of naked women unnoticed in public places (the 76 station at 15th Avenue West; the Central Library, eighth floor), and burlesque performers acting out the Self-Peeling Shrimp with Lemon striptease, respectively. Kevin D. Boze and Stasia Kato undertook a charged social experiment, recording on-site testimonies and turning them into biographical comics about the sitters' first sexual experiences. Yet the good stuff could not make up for a pencil drawing of a scrotum with nipples titled Balzac, the writhing and chirping of two trash-loving dancers dressed as dirty birds in geisha lipstick, a poet yelling for a nastier lover, and the faked orgasms of performers wearing gold and electric-blue lamé.

When an organizer heard about the orgasm scene, which evidently was unplanned, she praised the performers for their initiative taking. Then she asked them, "Did you come together?"

jgraves@thestranger.com