I am a straight female who has been with my boyfriend for close to six months now. We love each other very much and can see our relationship extending far into the future, possibly even into marriage. Here's the catch. My boyfriend suggested a threesome to me, saying that he believes in your philosophy on swinging and monogamy as you expressed here.I would have been comfortable experimenting with threesomes, foursomes, all kind of "omes," before I fell in love. I am extremely liberal and open and, in the abstract, agree with all you say about the benefits of "opening the door just a crack." Unfortunately, I am having a very strong visceral reaction to the idea of having sex with anyone but my partner or the idea of him having sex with someone else. The thought of it makes me feel sick to my stomach.
The rest of ASM's letter—and my response—after the jump.
I hope that, in the future, I will eventually feel more comfortable with the idea. My thought is that, once the chemical haze of new love wears off, perhaps I won't be so adamant about only having sex with him or so upset about the idea of him having sex with others. Although, judging by the letter you read in that clip, in which the couple has been together for 15 years, time doesn't necessarily make one feel more comfortable with sharing oneself or one's partner with extra lovers.I feel horrible that I can't provide my boyfriend with this kind of sex life, especially because I agree with the concept but can't shake my feelings about it. I also feel less progressive and less in control of myself than I'd like to be, when I think about the fact that my emotions are preventing me from engaging in a lifestyle that makes good sense and that would make my partner happy. While the things I'm willing to experiment with between the two of us are endless, I deeply wish I could provide him with this lifestyle that he believes is right for him. He says that he loves me and that I am the most important thing to him, so if I don't want to do it then he completely understands. I've said things like, "Maybe you need to find someone who wants to live the way you do." His reply, "I want you." He has expressed that, while he would love to sexually explore other people with his partner, that his partner is the most important thing to him.
Is staying with him setting myself up for future heartbreak? If we have such conflicting desires now, will they rise up later in the form of his dissatisfaction and my being deeply hurt? Is the fact that he's beginning our relationship with little faith in a monogamous lifestyle a sign that perhaps we shouldn't pursue a life together?
A Silly Monogamist
First, ASM, no two people are an exact match sexually, emotionally, socially, etc. In this, that, or the other area, each of us settles for a little less than what we we wanted—or a little less than what we thought we wanted—and each of us is a little less than what our partners thought they wanted.
So if he says he's willing to forgo this fantasy and remain monogamous in order to be with you, ASM, and you love him, well, why not choose to believe him? And if you say you might get there at some point, ASM, that you might, in time, be more comfortable with the idea, and he loves you, why shouldn't he choose to believe you?
All that said, ASM, you should ask yourself why you would be willing to do certain things—indulge in certain "omes"—with a man you don't love but not with a man you do. I don't think your relationship is necessarily doomed, but that impulse is going to complicate your love life considerably, ASM, whether or not you two remain monogamous. And deciding in advance that indulging in certain sex acts and fantasies—threesomes, other omes—means "the chemical haze of new love wears off," that the intensity is gone... that's a bad policy, a potentially fatal self-fulfilling prophecy. It's fine to want him all to yourself right now; heck, most successful, long-term, non-monogamous relationships start with a long, effortless period of sexual exclusivity. Better to think that, should the time ever comes when are ready for a threeway, that it means you're just so in love with him, and so secure of his love for you, that you don't regard a MFF threeway as a threat.
And he ought to feel the same way about a MMF threeway by then too.
12
17
18
23
25
27
32
36
41
46
50
51
56
57
60
61
62
67
68
70
71
73
Comments (74) RSS