Comments

1
someone tell Dan he should not be so quick to tell us fatties we just need to get out and exercise....
2
@1 You need to get out and exercise.

Your brain (apparently) won't recognize you are getting fat so you have to -- gasp-- think about it actively and do something about it. Sorry, chub. No free pass for overeating.
3
"Fat makes you fatter by telling your body that it's not fat."

And capitalism makes you poorer by telling your social group that you're not poor, but consuming your way to the happiness of success.

Pie + Sky = Sheep on Earth
4
Just another thing for fat people to point to in order to deflect blame...

This reminds me of alcoholics who can't tell how drunk they are but continue drinking. Just because the body isn't reading the signals does no mean they aren't knowingly abusing the substance.

The fault still lies squarely on the person reaching for the bottle. You know it's bad for you, but you're still doing it, regardless of the signals.

So don't eat such fatty foods all the time. Exercise.

Manual override.
5
It seems like the main problem in this country is a high-sugar diet, not a high-fat diet. How does this study account for that?
6
'cruel and devious' are part of a human value system. leave the anthropomorphizing of science to the intelligent design crowd.
conversely, humans manipulating African rat behavior could be argued to be cruel and devious, esp. if done by Christians.
7
@2

LOL!
8
One would think your eyeballs would suffice in letting you know if you are fat, or do the guilty brain cells make you blind as well?
9
Well, that helps explain things a bit more.

But I agree with others: Time to engage Manual Override. It ain't obviously going to fix itself on it's own.
10
Holy crap, that is the worst-written bit of science journalism I've ever seen; everything about the way the results are described lead you away from understanding what was actually discovered and how the brain works.

All that "insulation" talk is rubbish. Basically, the high fat diet causes one kind of neuron to lose synapses. Glia (non-neuron brain cells) move in to take up the space where the lost axons were, which is their job, and once all the glia are in place, they make it harder for the fat-signal cells to be in contact with the blood-brain barrier and get feedback from the blood.

Misusing the word "insulation" this way is problematic problematic because there is literal, electric insulation in the brain -- made of fat, basically -- that surrounds axons and makes their electrical impulses speedier. This finding would be better explained in terms of a physical impediment in a feedback loop.

I realize nobody cares, but this kind of thing irks me.
11
@10, my interest in shame outstrips my interest in science, but I do thank you for trying.
12
@10: i'm with you. not only is it crappy science writing, it's crappy writing. for example:
..."Obese people are not necessarily lacking willpower. Their brains do not know how full or how much fat they have stored, so the brain does not tell the body to stop refuelling. Subsequently, their body's ability to lose weight is significantly reduced."
he says that obese people are not lacking willpower. then he goes on to explain exactly how obese people are lacking willpower. if their brains aren't telling them to stop eating by telling them they're full, the only way they will stop eating is to use their powers of observation (wow, there was a whole pizza here when i sat down) plus their intellect (eating a whole pizza in one sitting is a bad idea) to stop eating. that's precisely what willpower is. and that's precisely what is required in the absense of other signals from the brain.

seriously. people are dumb.
13
Oh well, roughly 2/3 of the brain is fat anyway. The myelin sheath that protects the neurons is mostly fat.

The things you learn when you have a horrible disease that attacks the fat (myelin sheath) in your central nervous system.
14
AmyC (12) very good point


the only way they will stop eating is to use their powers of observation (wow, there was a whole pizza here when i sat down) plus their intellect (eating a whole pizza in one sitting is a bad idea) to stop eating. that's precisely what willpower is. and that's precisely what is required in the absense of other signals from the brain.
15
This is, of course, the perfect capitalist wet dream:

The more high fat food we sell the public the more demand we create for even more food sales -- an insidious feedback loop of ever increasing profits! (and waistlines)

And, from looking at THIS infographic, you'd almost think someone planned it that way...

16
Saturated fat? Hydrogenated fat? Coconut oil is a fat, and I have found the extra virgin organic nonhydrogenated oil, with the medium-chain fatty acids, to be terrific for restoring energy and for alleviating skin issues like eczema.

Robert Lustig's entertaining YouTube seminar on fructose and leptins is better at explaining how the body's signals to stop eating are shut off than a few paragraphs describing an Australian study.
17
"I couldn't, it'll go straight to my brain."
18
PROOF: There is NO intelligent design. Or, if there is some deliberate being attempting to do the design, they are like BP.
19
Fat cells have figured out how to get you to make more fat cells. Evolution in action. Soon we'll all be 100% fat.
20
VEGETABLES ARE THE ANSWER

Please wait...

and remember to be decent to everyone
all of the time.

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.