Comments

1
Choi should have worked on his combatives more.
2
Uhhh let me get this straight. An American (former) military officer travels to Russia to break the law and march without a permit knowing that the government has specifically sanctioned the opposition and he wants Hilary Clinton to speak out against the Russian Government?

Doesn't he know how international politics works? Why would we strain a relationship with another country just because some citizens of ours went over there to start trouble even if it is a noble cause? It is one thing to support these protesters but if Hilary Clinton spoke out against these government actions it will have real consequences.
3
No, from what I read, the police let a bunch of angry civilians beat up a bunch of other angry civilians and THEN started arresting people.
4
This is pretty much how it works - groups deemed anti-government (or anything "anti-Russian") are denied permits, while the government musters (or allows and/or encourages) huge amounts of gov't supporters and police to quash the opposition. I was hoping things might change after Luzhkov (former mayor of Moscow and vehement homophobe) was sacked, but alas, things are status quo. Interestingly the police and the anti-gay protesters (one wearing a "God is with us" t-shirt) are obviously working together, because the anti-gay protesters seem to be carrying off the gays to the police vans. Looks like a small gay rights demo was allowed in St. Petersburg, but they've always been ahead of the curve up there.

Oddly enough I spent the summer of '92 in Russia when the first roving gay clubs where happening in the capitals, and I remember a night in Moscow when hundreds of skinheads and nationalists surrounded a rented dance hall, hoping to beat the shit out of everyone inside. The Moscow police kept them at bay and safely escorted all of us out at the end of the evening - and they were completely supportive of those of us inside. I haven't been to Russia since 2007, but every time I went, it felt like things were getting worse in terms of gay rights. Good for Choi and others for speaking out. It probably won't do much in the short term, but at least it draws attention to the situation.
5
Wait, *skinheads*? In Russia?
Looks like Hitler got farther than we thought...
6
We Shall Overcum...
7
@5, yes, skinheads in Russia. There are tons of them (and many more non-skin racists/nationalists). You'd think that the sick irony of the situation might sink in, but no.
8
@6: Actually, marching in a gay pride parade to raise awareness about LGBTQ issues is a tempered expression of libidinal urges moderated by the reality principle.
You know what beating up people different from you is? Well, that's a manifestation of raw libidinal energies governed only by the pleasure principle.
BITCH PLEASE.
9
As a black gay man, the furthest east I've gone in Europe was Poland that's as east as I'll go. I experienced a good bit of racism in Poland for being black. I won't go into Russia out of fear of getting attacked or killed by these damn NeoNazis and their sympathizers and my Russian friends in the states agree with me as well.

Google "blacks in Russia"

http://cnettv.cnet.com/racism-russia/974…

10
@6: Why is the haters' attention so focused on sodomy? Does that mean you would all be ok with lesbians (I'm pretty sure they have less buttsex than straights, and you know, they're women, so no libido at all anyway) having the same rights as you?
Is that really your problem, you're all either disgusted (bad santorum experience maybe) or jealous?
If, when you see a man getting beat up while marching for his rights, all you can think is "cum, lust, libido, buttsex", really that's your libido that is the problem.
11
I have great respect for Choi, the guy is 100% fearless, but still: The outcome of this was obvious. Russia is Russia. Russia has never changed because a U.S. secretary of state politely asked it to change.

Didn't we learn our lesson in Iraq and Afghanistan? You cannot impose cultural change from outside a country.
Cult
12
10

We give up. Why?

Here's one for you:
Why is the homosexuals' attention so focused on sodomy?
And feces?

Just how many times a day does Danny post about frothy feces?
13
The letter for Clinton is very optimistic. It supposes Dan Choi will be soon released and still able to walk.
14
@12: that wasn't really a trick question. I'll try an easier one next time. And I gave two possible answers, read again. How can you say someone is focus on feces when you name is "Poo Bear"
You're mistaking the santorum joke, which is a funny way of remembering that this man isn't worth more than a piece of crap, with you're own obsession, which draw you to project your lust on a act of bravery.
15
Well, we're talking Russians here. Not exactly a civilized place; basically a third world country with some good writers.
16
@2

Exactly. Well said.
17
Hm. I dated a Russian national, and they have a crazy level of homophobia there, but it doesn't seem to have any genuinely religious basis, unlike in this country. So very few people there are really religious, and even if they slap the label "orthodox" on themselves, it doesn't mean shit, as they don't attend services, and they couldn't name the gospels if you held a gun to their head.

It seems to be, perhaps, some weird ass sexist, nationalist bullshit, if anything.

Which is why some foreign agitator (for lack of a better word, sorry, Mr. Choi) really has no place trying to upset the status quo there. Homosexuality is un-masculine, and in Russia, men are supposed to be hyper masculine in order to be hyper-Russian. So I'm pretty sure that in order for change to come, it can't come from us (no matter how sexy Russians can be). If, however, Putin came out and said he enjoyed the occasional bit of penis, something might change.
18
Christ, most of you are terribly stupid and ignorant. Just sign the letter, and shut the fuck up.
20
Yes, the old East Europe has a lot of problems with Teh Gayz. Similar events happened in Latvia, in Lithuania (where I think an anti-same-sex marriage was written into the constitution), in Poland, and of course in Russia itself. I'm married to a Russian-Ukrainian, and everybody in her family is quite anti-gay (she's the only exception, and she used to be anti-gay when she was living in Ukraine).

My own experience in Ukraine is that homosexuality is seen as a disease -- they keep thinking about "unnatural practices" (and yes, they fixate on anal sex). I sometimes wonder if Eastern European homophobia is a bit like a blood feud: Teh Gayz did something horrible (sodomy) that soils the honor of All Manly Men Everywhere, and we can't just let this go without some sort of reaction to save our honor and show the world there are Real Men(tm) in here!

There's some of the disease/contagion aspect to it as well: judging by my father-in-law's reaction in one occasion, they won't even touch someone who is suspiciously gay lest they should be "contagious" (заразно).
21
#2 & #4 basically have it right. Going off to Russia expecting to spark change in the way that change traditionally happens in the U.S. is horribly naive. An *Asian* American gay guy showing his support for LGBTQ folks in Russia is sooo NOT going to impress Russian - for lack of a better term - rednecks. For a certain degree of perspective I'd like to note that the police in Moscow cracked down on a protest/funeral procession (arranged by the Moscow equivalent to The Stranger) to mourn the passing of historical buildings that were being demolished to make room for new Luzhkov monstrosities. (They weren't given a permit to demonstrate so they organized a funeral procession to get around the legalities of the thing... and still had the police on them). And a lot of regular Russians would actually side with their efforts to preserve historical buildings.

Few average Russians, on the other hand, would back a Pride Parade. The level of just general public support isn't there -- yet. And certainly not now where strangely enough the increased (REAL) terrorist threat in Russia has created stronger feelings of fear against "the other." Not saying it shouldn't happen. Just saying that Choi is naive.

Run the following through Google translate for a better idea of the situation there:

http://www.bg.ru/article/8273/
http://www.bg.ru/article/8662/
Bolshoi Gorod hasn't posted anything yet about events on May 28th, but when/if they do, I'll share. It's one of the issues they occasionally cover.
22
Yeah, I live there and I can tell you this: homophobia is overwhelming. It's not just the skinheads, it's everyone, even people with liberal politics. Tolerance is a very bad word here.

And actually, from what I see in the news, what Dan Choi and some other foreign protesters did at least created a level of visibility for the problem. No one would even talk about it otherwise. Now the newsline is not just "Illegal Gay Parade Broken Apart By Police".
24
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kkGxfTiii…

The footage at Red Square of Choi and his friends is, comparatively speaking, a non-event. By comparison consider viewing the above link to a YouTube clip of four policemen defending a bunch of teenaged boys who'd been set upon by a bunch of skin head/soccer hooligans after exiting a pizza parlor. Three of the boys were dark skinned. The cops were all white-skinned small town boys (ie. not native Muscovites) who were unarmed and just doing the right thing (they'd been posted to patrol the area and keep hooligans away from a monument statue during an anticipated rally/protest, but got caught up in the one big extremely cowardly attack - 50+ grown-ups beating up five 15 year-olds. They'd thought that someone was in the ambulance, but it turned out to be just parked and locked, so they shoved the boys up against the vehicle and put themselves between the mob and the kids while waiting for back-up -- at one point they even had the boys lie under the van.)

The sick thing in both the clip of Choi and the clip of the cops protecting the boys is that the ones leading the charge ahead of the hooligans in both cases all seem to be members of the press. Not sure what to think about that.

(Oh, and the T-shirt in question says С Нами Бог or literally With Us God).

An interesting story about skinheads and soccer fans in Russia can also be read at http://www.bg.ru/article/8418/
(You'll need to put it through Google Translate to get the details, but the pictures alone are compelling enough...)
25
Thank you puddles @22. And to everyone calling this naive, I don't think the plan was to send Choi to Russia, get Clinton to back him up and, voila, happy-gay-Moscow!

The idea--as in Uganda--is to make some room for the voices against bigotry. However small, however inconsequentially at first, it is necessary to make efforts for equality [starting with simply making the issue visible] or equality will never be realized.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.