Comments

1
Exhibit A for why I detest facial hair.
2
Fish sauce can resemble the odor of a not 100% well kept pussy, but then again the LW said it was the healthy kind here.
3
What did the blind man say when he walked past the cannery?

Helloooo, ladies!
4
er... I just realized why beards are gross.
5
I can't think of any one thing that smells like pussy, but I can think of several combinations (generally alcoholic beverage + shellfish) that can duplicate it together and might be on a beard: Oysters +red wine, Lobster +midori, Soft shell crab + Long Island Tea. If the dude likes seafood, I say give him the benefit of a doubt.
6
@3: Har har. Pussy doesn't smell like fish unless you have a bacterial infection.

I'm hoping you're not a straight guy, but if you are it's pretty clear you don't get laid regularly.
7
I remember fooling around with a dude who was officialy with another chick and once as i was leaving i was mentally all dude! i can smell my pussy all over your face! your woman is gonna smell it too!
sadly i never asked if she really did smell it and then what happened.
8
@4: Beards are no more gross than the hair on one's head as long as they get washed.
9
Someone's been munching on Doritos.
10
Ditto, @7. Ditto.

In my case, the dude in question had a reduced sense of smell because of the C-PAP machine that kept him alive while he slept. He didn't believe me that he reeked of pussy and that if he kissed any human woman with that face she would know how he'd spent his day. But I never did ask the followup questions.
11
Also, I sure can't think of anything that smells like pussy that would also have any reason to be all over his face. Maybe mild shellfish in a sweet sauce can smell like pussy, but how did he get it all over his face? It should've been restricted mostly to his mouth.
12
Well, what was the dude's explanation of his distinctive aroma? When his fiance smelled something that unique, he should have SOME idea of what it might be. If he tried to make her think it was all in her head (ie. denied smelling of ANYTHING), then she should DTMFA. That's headfuck manipulative bullshit behavior for sure.
13
Occasionally butt juices can smell the same way. Not that this is any help in the fiancee's case.
14
There's a caviar paste served at breakfast tables in Scandanavian countries which kinda comes close, especially on a piece of smoked salmon with a caper or two.
15
Seriously, what the fuck purpose does facial hair serve? Ew.
16
@6 I bet you're fun at parties.
17
I wouldn't describe pussy scent as "sickly sweet". More like salty, stale, and pungent. But not sweet. So makes me think its possible that's not what she smelled at all.
18
@ 15 - Some of us are into rough rimming.
19
@14: That's it exactly!: Wet cat who you've had to bathe because he's got in the caviar and champagne. That was one hell of a New Years. I've even had that scent on my beard because the cat in question likes to sleep on my face. (He's the cat in my avatar pic. Hi name is Edmund.)

Seriously, I do find the scent a little not quite fishy, a little not quite fruity, and a little almost boozy all mixed together. But then again, I use a C-PAP to keep the cat off my face while sleeping.
20
So, uh, there are mild cheeses and some cured meats that have mild, sexual smells, usually more like semen, but sort of like pussy sometimes. But they're none of them cheap, so she should be pissed that he didn't share.
21
Has no one seen, "Let Me Smell Your Dick"?

http://youtu.be/mzyW1QZGNpc

22
@17 - When my guy goes down on me, and then comes up for a kiss, I think it tastes sweet. I am diabetic, though. Maybe that has something to do with it? I've never tasted any other woman, so...
23
@15, For my part, it's because without a beard I resemble a dead actor named Charles Laughton. With a beard, I look a little like my distant kinsman Henry VIII (who I believe Laughton played at one point). I'd rather be mistaken for a guy who beheaded two of his wives than for playing Captain Bligh.
24
The actual "evidence" isn't really the point here. Since there wasn't enough respect and trust in the relationship to avoid getting here in the first place (regardless of who's actually at fault), they're done.
25
The only thing I've ever smelled that came disturbingly close was Thai Curry with Fish Sauce. Sweet, salty, a bit vinegary, like a clean pussy.

Maybe LW's BF went for curry for lunch?
26
I'm still confused by the "sickly/sweet healthy kind" of pussy.

How about this: pretty solid circumstantial evidence aside— when your first thought is "he's cheating", and your second thought is, "I'll see if Dan Savage thinks I should dump him", um... this is not the person you should be marrying.
27
The lemon soup at The Continental in the U District?
28
I'm not the type to get my face near vag, but a friend once told me green tea frozen yogurt tasted exactly like pussy.
29
If the discussion ended with his denial, then isn't it immaterial whether there's anything that would replicate the smell? Otherwise, he'd have said, "Oh, it must have been (blank)."
30
I dunno, #25, I've eaten a metric fuckton of curries all over the world, and never gotten one that smelled like snatch.

Also, when you kiss a bearded man, his beard does not normally smell like what he's been eating. His breath may, and you can taste it on his tongue, but normally he doesn't shove his face in a plate and get stuff all over his beard...like he would when he's giving a woman some oral lovin'.

My $.02, as the owner of a snatch, is that it's most likely he's having sex with someone else on the side. Not definitively, but it's the most likely explanation. Either that or the OP has an illness that makes her hallucinate smells and makes her paranoid.
31
@21: I believe the headline is a play on that ...
32
@23 - You've made a good choice with Henry the VIII Charles Laughton, it can be a good look, assuming you keep the red velvet and fur-lining to a minimum. Should you ever get sick of it, I DARE you to go King Herrod Charles Laughton.
33
@14: I wonder if the fiance reads SLOG? And is taking copious notes: "Honey, I had Scandinavian caviar paste and green tea frozen yoghurt on the way home! It's all an innocent misunderstanding!"
34
Another possible theory: he wasn't with another woman, but he was getting off rubbing your (or someone else's) used panties on his face and didn't want to admit it? I can't think of any food-type thing that smells similar, but I did have an ex who stole my dirty underwear to keep in his car.
35
@32--I actually did something quite like that once back in the mid-90s when I was doing Banquo for 4 not-so-wonderful performances for a truly infernal Shakespeare in the Park in a large southern city that shall remain nameless. The dude doing Mackey the Beth looked a little too much like me or I looked a little too much like him and the director knew what things I'd do for the part.
36
As a happily hirsute man six months out of every year (winter), I can definitively say that whatever you've been eating will most certainly end up in your beard.

More to the point, though, this is an issue of trust. Either she has a good reason to think he's screwing around on her, or she's a crazy, jealous bitch.

Either way, he's probably better off without her. He should dump her.
37
First time I ever smelled pussy was when I was very young and got a kiss from my Sister's (then) husband. He had a full beard. They split, and I never smelled that smell again until I was, oh, 17ish and put a few fingers in my (then) girlfriend's pussy. I thought, hey, there's that smell! Just like...oh...ok I get it!

So, yeah. It's a unique smell!
38
Green tea frozen yogurt or green tea ice cream is really pretty damn odorless. Or is that just me having a defective sense of smell? I'm not talking about the taste here (although it doesn't taste to me like ladyparts, I'm not going to argue with a prior commenter's friend, who may go down on delightfully tea-flavored ladies).
39
This is my favorite SLLOTD of all time.

I don't know if there's another explanation here, but if starting now he starts occasionally coming home with his beard smelling like soap... there's your answer.
40
@3: Well, I do try to invent my own material rather than recycle tasteless and unfunny jokes... but we may attend different kinds of parties.
41
The only pussy that smells like fish is a pussy with Bacterial Vaginosis (BV). Lots of women have it and don't know it. Lots of women have a temporary overgrowth of the bacteria and then it goes away. In any case, if your pussy smells actually bad, get to a doctor. Healthy pussy smells delicious.

My partner has a beard and he for sure smells like yummy pussy after going down. He washes his face and beard afterwards. I've never smelled anything like it, and I'm pretty familiar with the scent. Mine and otherwise.
42
I dated a guy once who claimed to love sushi with roe because it tasted (grin/leer) "female". He told me that every fucking time we had sushi, which was a lot because he lived near Shiro's. Plus he wasn't very good at oral. The relationship didn't last long.
So maybe Mr. Beard had just had an innocent sushi lunch.
43
Forget about this being a guy who performed a sex act on someone else. Dump him BECAUSE HE DIDN'T WASH HIS BEARD.

After all, if there are vaginal secretions, there's probably year-old peanut butter too. Yeeech!
44
If it tastes like chicken
Keep on lickin'
If it tastes like flounder
Go around 'er
45
@6: in my experience as the owner of a vag, it never smells like fish except after an unwrapped encounter with a penis. I think urea has something to do with it. That's my optimistic explanation for all the guy-jokes about the fishy smell of pussy.
46
I question SIM's ability to distinguish pussy from... anything. Maybe she recognizes her own and her own is... unlike others.
47
I can't believe no one has mentioned truffle oil.
48
I grew a goatee because without it I looked like Dougie Howser.

I retain a goatee because (I think) it hides how fat my face has become, and my distressing lack of chin.

My facial hair has never, to my knowledge, smelled like any sort of female "business". But there have been times it has smelled like sloppy foods I have eaten.

Do with that what you will.
49
Dump him, pussy smells like pussy. Once at a hotel my girlfriend and I had a joint and some happy cunnilingus and later asked a friend "does our room smell like smoke?" and he said (with a huge grin) "No, it smells like fucking puss!"
50
I'm a penis owner with a non-monogamous husband. One night he came home after I had gone to bed and gave me a kiss. Dude your face smells like crotch!!! I thought it was funny.
51
It's unlikely to be anything else. But before simply dumping someone you were planning to marry because a bunch of Slog readers think that not much else smells like pussy, SIM, why don't you, you know, talk to the guy.

Just a thought.
52
I'm going to stay out of the main discussion here. I want to hear more about Ann Lander's desk! I musta missed an article somewhere.
53
Okay, thanks to the interwebs, I found out in seconds that Dan bought Ann Lander's desk for $175 clear back in 2002.
54
Put Roast Beef on a pizza and it smells/tastes like a girls business. Maybe he had a roast beef pizza?

I had to learn that after having made some pizza for my father and uncles. It was not as fun an experience as you might imagine.
55
As @41 stated, if it smells like fish then the woman has a pretty severe bacterial infection.

Now, some women's pussies have a slight pungent smell of ozone...but only if they are not particularly clean.

LW: Unless your guy has been working on high voltage electronics or has been doing some soldering, then he has been eating out some chick with a slightly unclean vag.
56
After going downtown, I love the smell of pussy in my mustache/beard. Nothin' else quite like it.
57
As a woman who has been with women, I'm amused at the range of things people are saying woman bits smell/taste like. There's usually something kinda salty - I'd say "ocean" definitely more than fish. Sometimes a smoked almond kinda flavor. There was one lady who had a sort of black tea taste, like a smoky tea.

But guys have tasted different to me too, some salty, some more kinda earthy.

Although these responses have all been somewhere between enlightening & almost distressing, @51 has it. Talk to him! Be helpful if you can find a way to bring it up that isn't all YOU'VE BEEN SNACKING ON SOMEONE ELSE'S LUNCHBOX, I JUST KNOW IT. Ask what he had for dinner. & if he asks why, go from there, I guess.

*shrug* Doesn't sound like you trust him, AND who wants to marry a guy who doesn't know how to wash out his facial hair, no matter who or what he's been eating?
58
If you think you should dump him, dump him.
Dirty beards are gross.
59
You know, I frequently think my boyfriend's beard smells kinda like pussy to be honest. I just thought it was weird, and didn't think anything of it. Pretty sure he's not secretly cheating on me or anything, because the smell will show up after a day we've spent the whole time together, walking to the market or alone in the house. I notice it especially if the day is a little bit sweaty. Without other indicia of cheating, I wouldn't worry about it.
60
I tried a sauce at a Vietnamese restaurant that tasted a LOT like pussy.
61
@54 - O___O Really?
62

Is there pussy in Seattle?

63
dump him because he has a beard, but use the suspicious odor as your cover story
64
"And if there was something out there that smelled like pussy, straight guys like me would know about it and we'd be putting it on our faces all the time."

This sentence has really confirmed my gayness more than anything I've ever read in my life.
65
Butt tastes like pumpkin.
66
Periodically a someone's bad hygiene can smell like pussy. Not "I just finished a work out and smell sweaty" bad hygiene, more like "I haven't showered today or yesterday." However, even then it is a 1 in 100 chance that the odor approaches pussy. The only way I can think of getting a pussy smell on my body w/o going down on a woman would be a stripper giving an "aggressive" lap dance. But even then, your boyfriend would be doing something I am sure you would not agree with.
67
@45 - Male secretions amplify BV odors. If you've a mild case, you often you can't smell it except after sex.

See here: http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/bacteri…
68
No such thing as a vagina with a pleasant aroma.

Women don't like beards because they detest a man with a threatening visage and prefer only easily-dominated beta-males.
69
It's a side issue. Anyone capable of writing such a short letter in such a situation shouldn't be marrying the party in question.

I'm just thankful that Mr Savage had to outsource this one.
70
@68: Disagree with the first, half-agree with the second. I think a lot of women are scared by the threatening visage, but I also think a lot of women have grown up thinking of body hair as gross (otherwise, why would they have to shave it?), and facial hair kind of falls into that category. When I was a teenager, I was mostly against facial hair, but having a bearded boyfriend changed my mind and now I don't want to go back.
71
My bi girfriend insists Brooklyn lager smells like girl. I knew there was a reason I like it so much...
72
@43 has a good point here.
73
When passing judgement on this we must consider these variables:

A) Does she know what other pussy actually smells like?

Sure there is a distinct odor to individuals but in all honesty a wide range of olfactory stimuli en masse. I am sure she has smelled her own, but our association with our own bodies is a lot more tempered (rather, we think we smell better than we actually do most of the time.) So what she MIGHT think HER pussy smells like, in fact, is akin to prosciutto.

B) How often does he wash his beard? This will get technical but a few days worth of saliva, flesh, hair, and food particles can pretty easily make a scent that is eerily close to a labia.

C) (Which I would put money on) It could be a case of super psycho cold-feet, creating a bizarre scenario with her fiance to play victim when everyone finds out that she DTMFA.
74
There is a product called "Vulva" that is a cream made to specifically smell like pussy. It is marketed as a masturbatory aid. Maybe your fiancé bought some and was jerking off using it. But other than that, nothing smells like pussy.
75
I would think that IF he wasn't actually cheating but she has been worried that he is or has reason to suspect he might be, then this would be the actual cause of the smell:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmatio…
76
Not enough evidence.
77
Lox on marscapone with capers.
78
I have had a beard for over a decade and there have been numerous times I've eaten stuff that ends up smelling like pussy a couple hours later (I remember a fantastic sweet and sour soup!). No, I don't dive into my food but if I'm eating anything with sauce or soups, you can bet that some of it splashes into the beard and can't get wiped away with a napkin. So until I do a thorough washing of my face (not really something I do after every meal), the smell will stay behind.

That said, the smell is never has never been strong as it is when I go down on someone.

The most obvious answer would be that it's probably your pussy on his face, since your perception of what your pussy smells like on you vs on someone else is totally different, just like when you think you sing awesomely but really sound like a dying sheep to others. The only way to know for sure would be to have a third party (or parties) smell your pussy, then smell his face and ask some simple questions:
Do they both smell like pussy?
Do they smell like the same pussy? (sweetness, saltiness, etc).

That seems like a lot of trouble to go through when talking it out and doing some additional investigation might reveal the truth faster.
79
If she can't open her fucking mouth and ask, they should break up and she should grow some ovaries.

In other news, my ex came home from a work party and went right to the bathroom to brush his teeth before kissing me. That's when it ended.
80
Dried peaches
81
What the hell, I say to the non-gay man commenters who would seriously confuse anything for the scent of vagina. The healthy ones have a variety of scents, acrid-sweet, fresh crayon, but are not easily confused for ANYTHING.

Yeah, she should communicate and be aware and not dump the guy necessarily, but pussy-on-beard is a pretty good sign that something is amiss.
82
Anyone who claims nothing smells like pussy has either never actually smelled one, or has really, really boring eating habits.
83
To me pussy has always smelled like pennies. Can't imagine why that'd be all over his face, unless he'd been pulling a Scrooge McDuck in a mountain of spare change.
84
Bearded male here. Mucho experience dining at the Y. Not sure if my beard has ever carried the smell but I know that good that the intoxicating smell of good pussy can linger in my nostrils for days dedpite persistent and agresdive face washing both with and without a beard. Enough to drive me mad with desire for more. IMHE There is a wide variety of smells and tastes and some food do smell like some pussy as do some armpits snd male crotches.

Sounds like she wants to bail based on limited evidence, lack of trust and probably limited experience with the wide range of pussy smells. If he did have pussy smell on his beard he will likely never own up to it anyways. So talking about it may be pointless.
85
If he's cheating, there will be other clues, in his behaviour or a paper/text/email trail. Look for those. Then decide if cheating means the relationship is over.

86
@40 Way late in replying but what the hell.

Dan said that he couldn't "rattle off the names of what else you might've been smelling on your boyfriend's face." The joke was pointing out Dan has somehow never heard of the stereotype that pussy smells like fish.
87
I'd propose three alternate explanations:

1) It's the LW's pussy. Some women have a particularly assertive (not necessarily unpleasant) musk that can hang around hairy bits for a long time. (I had a girlfriend like this once, and my junk always smelled a little like hers while we were together, even after bathing.)

It's also worth pointing out the the LW is not a good judge of whether she falls into this category, because she smells herself all the time.

2) Odors and flavors are complex, the result of many chemical components. Some are water soluble, and will go away with a quick splash on your face/beard. Others are more lipid-soluble, and you really have to scrub to get them out. In other words, the beard could be acting as a crude chemical filter, and possibly retaining a component of something that smells a bit like pussy, even if the food that left it there does not smell like pussy itself.

There are probably a lot of pungent foods (cheeses, mushrooms, fish, shellfish) that could do this, at least theoretically.

3) Sensory perception is highly suggestible. If you have other reasons to think your boyfriend is cheating, you may have been anticipating smelling another woman on him, and did.
88
@15:
Well, a 'beard' makes one seem more masculine than otherwise---that's why it's named after the term for a woman married to or dating with a gay man to make him seem more manly (for barbarous definitions of 'manly' and inaccurate suppositions about homosexuality).
89
First - congratulations on a letter that actually shocked my husband when I read it out loud to him.

Then he said, the bigger issue here is if you really can't believe his explanation then you should break up, because either you can't trust him, and he's lying and cheating on you = DTMFA;

or, he's looking you straight in the eye and telling the truth and you don't believe him, and in that case the guy deserves someone else, so dumping him would be doing him a favor.
90
The comments on this post are the #1 reason not to eat meat. Meat eating vagina smells awful. Vegetarian vagina smells wonderful. No exceptions.
91
I'm really curious if this is an ends-justify-the-means sort of situation. If she wants to break it off and is looking for an excuse. People tend to bend a line of inquiry to justify our own internal concepts of narrative. I'm a touch shocked that anyone would smell something that isn't directly a pussy and be able to say "that smells like a pussy!" There are tons of things that supposedly smell like a pussy, and there exists a lot of difference between the smell of individual pussies.

Or he's cheating.
92
My boyfriend is supposed to tell me when he hooks up with people, so I was a little miffed when he came home one day smelling like pussy and he hadn't mentioned any new friends. Except the pussy was actually a microwave egg roll. I know because I ate one later and then I smelled like pussy. Also, microwave egg rolls are gross.

Also, is she suuuuuure she knows what pussy smells like? Not just her own, but other people's?
93
If you believe this bearded guy is capable of eating strange pussy and then not washing his face before coming home, dump him. Whether or not he did it is immaterial - anybody that hygienically challenged and that stupid is not worth hanging on to.
94
As someone who is presently deprived of one of my favorite activities, this letter and all the comments are like a cruel joke but I have enjoyed all of it very much. In my experience as someone who has eaten a lot of . . . food . . . pussy is such a distinct smell that I don't think I'd confuse it with anything else (or anything else with it). It would be a really fun blind-smell test for sure (perhaps one of our non-monogamous friends can rig one up and report back). My $0.02 is that the guy went down on someone and the LW should revisit it with him. And then decide whether it was a one-time thing, something that's been ongoing, whether he is very remorseful, etc. In a moment of panic, the guy may have lied. So, that alone, does not lead me to DTMFA. The next conversation is the key. And then only the LW knows how important his response/behavior is to their relationship.
95
Having spent about a week in Madrid, my pee smells like latex condoms for reasons I cannot fathom. I don't think that's helpful, but there it is.
96
Aaaand boy is it easy to tell the sexuality of the responders here (in some cases possibly in spite of what they themselves might think it is... Central Scrotum we're lookin' at you....)
97
Random pussy odor story.

Years ago my daughter was in the dollar store and found cheap incense called "Pussy." There a picture of a fluffy black cat on the package. We had a cat a lot like that and she was just old enough to know the various meanings of the word, so she bought it as a joke. It smelled exactly like you would expect dollar store incense to smell (like dead artificial flowers and old lady perfume) so we only burned it once. But we kept it around for laughs.

I brought it out at a small party once. All straight women except for a friend's boyfriend, whom I was just getting to know. All the women joked about what pussy incense would smell like: vag? cat box? wet cat? kitten? And the advantages and disadvantages of each smell.

I finally said (rather loud and drunkenly) "However you define it, why incense? Why would you ever want your whole house to smell like pussy?" Justin waited for the laughter to die down and quietly said, "Oh, I don't know . . .."

I knew right then (well, after I caught my breath and cleaned my spit take off the front of my shirt) my friend had chosen well.
98
That's a golden moment for Justin, @97. Often times we'd like to be a fly on the wall and here he is, the fly in the room. My best friends in HS and college were girls/women - I learned so much being the only guy in the room on many occasions.
99
My personal experience would say DTMFA. I smelled pussy on my ex-husband's face one night when we were laying in bed, but at the time had no legit reason to suspect him of anything. But definitely had a sinking-stomach feeling that I shoved under the rug until eventually the awful truth came out. It turned out that he was not only cheating with one woman, (owner of said pussy smell who is now his [crazy, alcoholic, needy] girlfriend) but had a sex-addiction and ongoing multiple illicit liasons, the confession of which blew my world apart. It turned out that our 9-year relationship had only been monogamous for the first two. He is an expert of deceit, a genious of facade, a masterfully manipulative narcissist. He had no facial hair, and was OCD about hygeine, but that's a smell that often lingers even after a good wash. Anyway, the now GF likely doesn't know that he cannot keep it in his pants, has to masturbate several times a day when he's not getting off on someone or something else, won't get legit psych treatment, and will lie about anything - say, what he had for breakfast - just to see how close to crazy he can make her. I wish I could tell her that what she smells on his face now and again isn't just her own pussy. Smelling that on him was the beginning of the end for us, the first pulled thread that unravelled the entire cloak. As an aside, I think pussy smells sweet and delicious. I'm a hetero chick, but when my ahhh-mazing BF comes up for some passionate kissing after a toe-curling warmup session, that sweet perfume of sex is a major turn-on. And thank the gods for its distinctiveness, because without it I would never have known how much better off I could be and how awesome my life would become without that mess of a human fucking with me. DTMFA.
100
@82: I've eaten every sort of fermented food and seafood out there, and no. There's a very distinctive odor in healthy people that's unlike the rest.

    Please wait...

    Comments are closed.

    Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


    Add a comment
    Preview

    By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.