Comments

1
Also campsite rules.
2
21 year old guy's these days. Really! So sensitive and caring. What's wrong with making a gentle pass? I have made many passes in my time and being rebuffed quite a few times. I managed to pick up the pieces and move on with my life. In his case he would have got laid!
3
This is exactly like that one movie.
5
When I was 34, I met a guy who was highly intelligent, socially mature, and extremely interesting. I had no idea that he was only 22 until we'd already gotten involved. I was a little freaked out to be dating someone so much younger than I was, but he wasn't at all typical for 22, and I was a pretty naive and unworldly 34, so we were actually about the same age. :-) We were good for each other for a number of years, and although we've parted ways now, I'll always think of him fondly.

People belong to categories, but they're individuals FIRST. If you click so well with this guy, don't worry about his age. (Do be kind, though.)
6
Yup. I'm terrible at reading people when it comes to their interest in me, and consequently rarely make the first move. So I empathize with her.

However, this might be a case where the genders are equal, but not symmetrical. A clumsy pass by a male [to a female] is often quite different from a clumsy pass by a female [to a male].

In any case, LW: when a young man brings you coffee--and conversation--in bed the morning after not having sex with you, it means he's into you. Make a move, or ask him.
7
" self pollinating flowering shrub"; gee you Americans are way ahead of the curve. Wow.
LW; age is irrelevant ! Say that to yourself ..
Now, just front this Man, and say straight up, that you have feelings for him. Romantic feelings. Dan is not that up on the ways of MF courtship.
Yes, may be old fashioned, but this guy didn't jump you, so maybe a little bit of courtship is what is needed..
So, nice and slow. If, this guy is not interested, then it can be just a hiccup , in what sounds like a pretty cool connection..

8
Jump dat kid's bones.
9
I'm assuming you gave him all the usual hints - flirting, extended eye contact, lots of smiles, touch him on the arm, ask him to remove his pants, etc. He's young, so he may not be dialed into those cues.

Or maybe he's just shy in that respect. I know that for me to make the first move, sometimes it helps if the lady makes the first move first.
10
What #8 said.

Make a move on his boner.
11
Here I was practically masturbating about the fantasy of getting in on with a hot 32-year-old "older woman" then I realized I was even older than that. Fuck me.
12
Ms Phile - What the flip was that all about, and would you kindly desist?

*****

I am actually going to hope now that LW does use the F word and that, whether the recipient is or isn't interested in her, he has a gay twin brother, takes offence and never speaks to her again. Casual anti-gay slurs in the interest of heterosexual conjugation is a major Don't.
13
Now, just to be fair, for LW's benefit, I shall relate that I once went to visit a friend in Texas for a week back when I was quite inexperienced and had never initiated. We shared a bed for a week, nothing happened, and, when I mentioned that in a letter afterwards, he replied quite simply, "You never asked."

Make of that what one will.
15
If he's anything like me when I was 21 (34 years ago), BTS, he's dying to find a way to ask but afraid you'll see him as a child. I was hot for the thirty-something women for most of my twenties. Don't be to hard on him, though, if he makes the standard slip-up in a moment of sexual excitement and praises you as a remarkable, beautiful, sexy, youthful "older woman." I can honestly say I never stuck that particular foot in my mouth, but I can remember hearing friends do it.
16
Ms Phile - If that was a serious question, ask me again when the word is no longer used to bully 14-year-olds. Until then, I think Mr Savage is a little blinded by self-interest, but I don't blame him for it. Still, even when times are fairer, I doubt I'll take kindly to the prevalence of words that came up often during (involuntary) conversion therapy.

If you absolutely must call me something that will let you snicker at me behind my back, I can be entirely good-humoured about being called a drama queen. Mr Savage called me thus once, and I felt honoured. But this is the last civil answer anyone addressing me in the insulting way of #14 is ever going to receive. Please don't do so again.
17
Gee Philo; you are being brazen! Was gonna add Hussy, oh why not- if reclaiming is what you going for;
You are a Brazen Hussy!
18
BTS, so you're confused because a man didn't fit your preconceived idea of what all men are like sexually. My advice? Drop your chauvinism and, you know, talk to him. Like a human.
19
Not to be a wet blanket or anything but if LW does manage to bed this 21 year old kid, the sex will be over in 3 minutes.
20
Did people catch that part about the guy turning 21 this month? So if she wants to avoid the awkwardness, she can ask him if he has any plans for his birthday, and then take him to a bar or bring him a bottle of champagne and give him a hot passionate kiss on the lips, and then see how he reacts. Then after she gives him his birthday present, they can talk about this without awkwardness.
21
You know George Clooney, 53 is marrying Amal Alamuddin,36
@ don't read anywhere she's going with " an older man".


22
@vennominon: Conversion therapy?? Wow. You've seen some things.

I understand your point, but still, I think "Hey Faggot" was a net positive in its day as it took the shame out of the word, at least for those without lasting traumatic associations. It said "Yes, I'm a faggot, so what?" When you consider how the N-word is used in hip hop, one might speculate that reclaiming slurs is a natural step in the progression of acceptance for minorities.

And yes, it was also good marketing.
23
He's 21 and slept in the same bed as you... and you didn't have sex?!?

Gotta be gay.

Either that or you breeders have become so uptight about sex that both of you were too afraid to initiate anything, regardless of how obvious an opportunity you had conspired to arrange. Our species is doomed if neither of you can manage to grow a spine.
24
@19, but it can start up AGAIN 10 minutes later... (lol, wink)
25
I think you're confusing permanency for seriousness.

Nice. Note that for many people seriousness implies permanency, and I believe many people even consider permanency more important than seriousness.
26
Dan, Dan. Most relationships "fail?" Aren't you the one constantly reminding us that the fact that a relationship ends doesn't mean it was a failure, and we shouldn't define "success" as meaning the relationship ended only when someone died? Most relationships end. Ending does not equal failure. Whether a relationship that ended was also a failure depends on the relationship.
27
Dan: your advice was perfect!

I seldom dish about my own personal life / past, because I have kind of a big online mouth & I respect my partners' privacy. But since she's wavering, let me add my experienced two cents..

BTS: DO IT. I was in your exact same shoes. I was 30, he was 19 & I thought it was going to be a weekend fling that wound up lasting about a year & a half. It was so hot! & so sweet, initially. & when he wasn't anymore, we broke up. But there was a good period of time where we were both genuinely smitten with each other. We spent most of our free time in bed. I was upfront with him that it wasn't going to last forever, as we both would fit better with people more at the same stage of life. Was fun while it lasted & I was very clear & patient about what actually worked, as opposed to what he'd been seeing in porn. So I smile to myself sometimes thinking that somewhere, there's likely been another few (at least) physically satisfied women out there who should raise a glass to me. ;)Make sure to be open to whatever the reaction will be: he might not be flirting (though like Dan does, I think he is) & y'never know, he might teach you something new.

Somewhere I still have a couple of pictures of him.

& BTS..if you're reading this..I don't think us Sloggers would mind if you checked back in to let us know what happened. ;) You know, for research reasons.
28
@22, @14 - I think reclaiming words is powerful.

Since I recently had some guy in a truck on a local highway - I live in Northern VA - drive next to me, pointing at my car, yelling "fag!" at me repeatedly as he passed me, I kinda lean towards Mr. Vennominon's feelings at @16 about that word.

Say as ye will, I'm no thought police. It's not my favorite, though Dan has used it well.
29
@16 It was a serious question, although the rest was overblown reclaiming attempts. It was meant as a compliment, and I'm very sorry to have offended. Thank you for spelling it out for me, a sharp lesson, you're strong to have gotten through that.
30
Ms Phile - Apology accepted.

Dr Sean - Not really all that comparable, are they? It's not as if it's a word we get to be the only ones to use, which would be marginally palatable. It is to Mr Savage's credit, though, that he doesn't actively push other same-sexers to welcome straight usage of the F word.

I had this all out with Mr Ank in a long thread about Mr C K. Mr Ank eventually admitted that hearing the F word used did give him a miniscule pleasurable jolt referring back to his anti-gay (arguably with cause) youth. Common usage gives cover to really obnoxious people who get to laugh at us while pretending they're laughing with us. I don't see sufficient compensation for that in any benefit; others may well disagree.

Ms Hopkins - Not a fun experience while driving; I entirely sympathize.
31
Almost choked on my cheerio's over "identifies as a self-pollinating flower shrub"! Thanks for the laugh, Dan! :)
32
Reclaiming words is a tricky business, and I think it's best done when initiated by the people the words have historically been directed towards in a hurtful way. Often times people who have been on the receiving end of a word used as an insult want to control that word and its usage and want to be the only ones to use it--perhaps because then they can be sure that the intended meaning is benign.

I don't know what conversion training is like, but I imagine if I was forced against my will to go someplace where I was berated by a "professional" using the same language as schoolyard bullies taunted me with (perhaps before beating me up), in an attempt to change my very nature and make me be someone I wasn't, at my parents' insistence, that I'd be extremely sensitive to that word's use.
33
I have a feeling that the young guy might be gay. Maybe BTS could offer to take him out to celebrate his 21st birthday and ask him if he wants to bring along a few friends, including anyone he's dating. Listen carefully to his response and see if he drops any orientation hints.
34
@30 - Oh, of course the words "faggot" and "nigger" are comparable. All social/ethnic slurs partake in the same dynamic: majority out-groups mocking minority in-groups. They only differ in the degree of emotional heft they possess for the in-group in question, and most of them tend to be "claimed" by the in-group, in the sense that they can use the term ironically with each other.

I think these two particular slurs are actually relatively close to each other in terms of their cultural intensity, when you consider the full range of historical slurs that exist. When you look at outdated terms like "wop" or "mick", for example, you can see how words that once really stung have now come very close to being nothing but quaint historical curiosities. The same will happen for these two terms. And new ones might take their place. Language changes. But the phenomenon of in- and out-groups never goes away.
35
@ 29 - The golden rule: "Don't call me a faggot, not unless you are a friend." (Joe Jackson, "Real Men")

The way you did it didn't look friendly at all. For a further explanation, read Nocutename's post @ 32, first paragraph.
36
He's 21 and slept in the same bed as you... and you didn't have sex?!?

Gotta be gay.


So glad I'm not the only one that had this reaction or thought this. If she were a Mrs. Robinson - say a 2+ decade age spread - then I'd buy (maybe) the notion that he's just shy or timid or whatever...but at roughly a decade? And they're classmates and somewhat peers? I dunno...that's a pretty man-whore-y age range for young men.
37
The way he wrapped her in blankets was the best clue. He just wants to be friends.
38
Dan,
the update link-'what almost 21 said', is not working! It takes us to 'comments'. Please fix; the suspense is killing me!
39
@38: Dan didn't mean 'almost 21'--Dan referred to the first comment here, where Chef Thunder wrote, "Also campsite rule".
40
@22 "When you consider how the N-word is used in hip hop, one might speculate that reclaiming slurs is a natural step in the progression of acceptance for minorities. "

Except that despite black people in hip hop using the N-word, white people still, as a general rule, can't get away with calling a black person the N-word.

Yet everyone thinks it should be fine to call a gay person the F-word. It's not an equal situation. If it were a matter that gay people are using the F-word amongst themselves the way that some black people use the N-word that's one thing. But straight people always use the fact that black people use the N-word as some justification that they should be able to use the F-word.

Go use the N-word towards a black person if you are white if you dare. If not then why would you think it OK to use the F-word towards a gay person?
41
>> But I also don’t want to tell him that I like him and ruin a great friendship if he isn’t interested in me. >>

My initial thought was: yes, that's how he feels too. Men are equally anxious about facing rejection, so it's a kindness to make the first move once you know how you feel. You're not taking any greater risk in asking than he would be.

My next thought was: it's possible that he has a secret, which getting sexually intimate with you would require him to share. He may be transgender, or have an unusual fetish, or a birth defect, or be married, or have some trauma overshadowing everything else in his life. He may have been raped. So go gently, and if he does turn you down, or give you an ambiguous answer, don't take it personally. Just try to remain close to him and let him open up when he's ready.
42
@40, yes, I did think it was odd that Dan told the LW to use that term, rather than just "dumb online advice columnist."
43
I disagree with the first part of EricaP's theory @41 (he's just hesitant to make the first move because he's afraid it will sour the friendship if she doesn't reciprocate). But there might be an answer in her second thought :t's possible that he has a secret, which getting sexually intimate with you would require him to share. He may be transgender, or have an unusual fetish, or a birth defect, or be married, or have some trauma overshadowing everything else in his life. I doubt he's married, and it may not be a fetish, but he could be fearful of her reaction to some condition that's in his past or under his clothes.

Or he's just not into her that way, gay or straight, with or without a secret.

44
@19 Not my high school boyfriend. He had taught himself and all his friends about edging, could last at least and hour and a half (had to talk him out of that one, damn), and rebound within 5 minutes. Apparently you weren't spending your high school masturbatory time productively. I trained him up the rest of the way and still get very sincere thank you's from every girlfriend since. I have no idea what plane he's operating on now but I'm sure he's devastatingly good. Not all young guys are clueless, shoot fast, or bad in bed. Some are just damn good from the start.
45
Slip him a note saying "fuck her right in the pussy".
46
@ven, @Fortunate: white people still, as a general rule, can't get away with calling a black person the N-word. Yet everyone thinks it should be fine to call a gay person the F-word.

Really? I've never heard straight friendlies use the F-word unless maybe they've achieved insider status or if it's used in the service of ribald humor of the sort popular among my burner friends (most of whom are considered trusted insiders by the gays in our group anyway). Even in that context, I've rarely (if ever) heard the term used.

Misuse of the F-word may not have the quite the same level of stigma as the N-word, but I think it still carries a sizable cargo of awkwardness. See, for example, this thread.

@EricaP: I did think it was odd that Dan told the LW to use that term

I read that as self-deprecating humor, not something intended to be taken literally.
47
@34 I don't know that the racial slurs you cited as having come "very close to being nothing but quaint historical curiosities" were "claimed" so much as the targets became "white"; the minorities in question were assimilated into the powerful group robbing the distinction and the epithet of its power.

I do agree that "faggot" and "nigger" are comparable, but that is not to say equivalent, and I believe that gay people are much closer to being "white" than I think black people will be even 50 years from now.
48
@46, I was being a bit hyperbolic when I said "everyone" true. But the very context that this was brought up in this discussion was Dan telling a straight woman to use the term (even though it was a bit tongue in cheek).

The point is that I have definitely heard straight people use it, some meaning it to be derogatory and some not. I have also heard people who you know mean it derogatory but claim that it isn't because gay people use it too just so they can get away with saying it without accepting that it is a bigoted thing in their own minds.

If you have never heard it used by straight people who claim that it is OK to use and no insult meant then you live in a very privileged environment. But you seriously have never heard the argument that it should be OK to use? Because that argument is out there. The idea gets bandied about time and again.
49
@44, fair enough, but let's face it, most of them aren't. Good for you, though, in preparing your high school BF for his sexual future.
50
You should go for it, dude is doing everything he can to get you to make a move in him. Teach him how to pleasure you (youngin's tend to be very interested in learning) and you'll set yourself and those that come after you very well. Enjoy!

Regarding word reclamation, the amount of people who are "allowed" to call me a fag is very very small and it's only in specific circumstances. It's good for me in that I get to hear the word in a positive and controlled way.

Re: word reclamation - I'm white, my husband is black and I never ever use the n-word, even when I've been given "permission." To each their own, but my moral code says that white folk just shouldn't.

@27 - Eva it's good to hear from you. :-)
51
Am I the only person who reads this as a humblebrag? Someone in their 30's needs to ask Dan about this?
52
@Fortunate: you live in a very privileged environment

Yes, I basically live in Sodom and rarely leave unless it's to go to Gomorrah. We definitely see bridge and tunnelers come in and use the term as a slur, but allies seem to understand the nuances, and none of them would argue that gay people have to tolerate the term because they use it themselves.

@ven: hearing the F word used did give him a miniscule pleasurable jolt referring back to his anti-gay (arguably with cause) youth

I entered college in the late 80s, just as gay acceptance was starting to gain steam and promptly made my first out gay friend, a 28-year old "towny" I met through work. He'd often refer to men (including me) as a "big fag" and/or "slut". I thought he was hilarious and I loved (and identified with) his irreverence. I credit him with planting the idea that men are by and large total sluts, and that's OK. I felt like Dorothy in Oz that whole year (except with women, drugs, and sophomoric philosophical debates, oh my!). It was a different sort of "pleasurable jolt".
53
As a 30 year old woman that spent a lot of time with a barely 22 year old man last summer, I can relate.

We got along great, talked, watched movies, walked the dog, had dinner, went grocery shopping, quietly read books together... I was losing my mind with how attracted I was to him, but assumed if he hadn't made the pass then he wouldn't be interested.

Until one day I got sick of it all and cuddled up next to him making it pretty clear that I was interested. Sure enough, one thing led to another...
It was a fairly brief relationship, but it was lovely. He was truly kind and interesting and we had tons of fun. The sex was incredible! So, go for it girl. I know it is cliche, but he's probably just shy/intimidated around you.
54
I was a 38 year old college student hitting on a twenty something. I made a pass and got the message that he was sorry, but he thought he was gay. Oh, Gawd! I was totally embarrassed. Well, the one good thing to come out of that pass and others I made is that I have lifelong friendships with young men who adore me. Maybe they aren't into me sexually, but they have a soft spot for me and always make me feel special when we run into one another. I wouldn't trade this for anything.
55
As a 30 year old woman that spent a lot of time with a barely 22 year old man last summer, I can relate.

We got along great, talked, watched movies, walked the dog, had dinner, went grocery shopping, quietly read books together... I was losing my mind with how attracted I was to him, but assumed if he hadn't made the pass then he wouldn't be interested.

Until one day I got sick of it all and cuddled up next to him making it pretty clear that I was interested. Sure enough, one thing led to another...
It was a fairly brief relationship, but it was lovely. He was truly kind and interesting and we had tons of fun. The sex was incredible! So, go for it girl. I know it is cliche, but he's probably just shy/intimidated around you.
56
There's just as much a chance of this guy being gay as there is any other guy out there. I say go for it and make the first move. Better to try and find out than wonder. I'm 34 and a few lovely rendezvous with a 22 year old and it was fantastic! We got along insanely well and had fantastic chemistry. We're still friends to this day. I made the first move on him and it was well worth it. He was sweet, intelligent, funny and also mature for his age. A lot of times that does make the difference. Not all relationships have to be serious, long term things. Sometimes relationships are short stories as compared to epic sagas. Hell, sometimes they're even better off as dirty limericks.

Chances are if he didn't make a move is that he was unsure, just as you were. Age or experience doesn't negate confusion in how to proceed in relationships. You can only figure things out if you use your words.
57
This sounds a lot like my college experience, I was 21 and she was a returned-to-school 40-year-old. We had a great friendship, physical and emotional connection. Eventually we made out a couple of times but I wished it would have gone further, but I was inexperienced and didn't make any moves. You should definitely make it happen, and don't slam on the breaks because you're worried about it not being permanent, like Dan said. Even though it didn't lead to sex, we have remained friends to this day, and now I'm a 30-something.
58
I'm 35 and just married my love of 23. Love is real!
59
I was in nearly the exact same situation a couple of years ago, but with a slightly smaller age gap. After five or so nights of strictly cuddling, he finally made a move. It didn't end up turning into anything "serious" but was a fun add on to our friendship for a while. We've now both got other partners but are still good platonic friends. Make the move!
60
I was in almost the same situation a couple of years ago, but with a slightly smaller age gap. After five or so nights of strictly cuddling, he finally made a move. It didn't end up turning into a "serious" relationship, but it was a fun add on to our friendship while it lasted. Now that we've both got other partners, we're still friends. Make the move there's nothing to lose!
61
The link at the bottom of the article says "update: what he said" --- but it only links to the comments! Am I missing something?! I'm dying to hear his response if Dan has it!
62
I read it as Dan saying it was ok for the LW to call him a F..
63
I met my, now, husband at work when I was 33 and he was 22. We had serious chemistry but I didn't want to get involved with someone that much younger than I. He would hang out at my house and occasionally slept on the couch. Even though the sparks were undeniable, he never made a move. Finally, I did.

It was the best decision! I appreciated his lack of jaded disillusionment. He adored my independence and self-sufficiency. What he found in me was something many younger women haven't achieved yet. We often talk about how the dynamic between an older woman and younger man is highly synergistic. Of course, if the guy is an immature youngster, it doesn't quite have the same appeal.

Lastly, the age difference also makes for an amazing sexual experience.
64
I met my, now, husband at work when I was 33 and he was 22. We had serious chemistry but I didn't want to get involved with someone that much younger than I. He would hang out at my house and occasionally slept on the couch. Even though the sparks were undeniable, he never made a move. Finally, I did.

It was the best decision! I appreciated his lack of jaded disillusionment. He adored my independence and self-sufficiency. What he found in me was something many younger women haven't achieved yet. We often talk about how the dynamic between an older woman and younger man is highly synergistic. Of course, if the guy is an immature youngster, it doesn't quite have the same appeal.

Lastly, the age difference also makes for an amazing sexual experience.
65
"Identifies as a self pollinating shrub" is amazing!
66
@61, the update was to add the "campsite rule," after @1's reminder.
67
β€œIs there really a chance that a soon-to-be 21 year old could be interested in a 32-year-old woman?”

Yes. It’s a thing. Lots of young men prefer sexual relationships with confident and experienced older women β€” sometimes much older. Women who know what they want and don’t play games.
68
i had a lovely and sensual afternoon in a northern england hotel with a 18-year-old boy whose cherry i popped (i was 45 at the time). we'd met a month previous in a sleazy chat, and i never saw him again after our one and only meeting. i like to think i left him better than i found him, but i don't know. and i doubt he ever spoke of it to anyone, whether in the future or present, so the tea and sympathy rule didn't apply. it was a lot of fun, though i could have done without traveling to an unremarkable town in Lancashire for the pleasure.
69
Dan ...... Your killing us!!!! The link doesn't work. We NEED to know what the 21 year old said! Don't tease us like this.
70
@69, the "what he said" link works fine. It's a link to the comments section, specifically comment #1. Dan's not teasing us.
71
Dan, I don't care if you're gay and I'm the wrong gender: I LOVE YOU!! haha! ;)
72
@71 what she said

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.