Comments

1
"Alarm clock."

Okay.
2
I feel like the biggest trap of polydom is thinking you can build what you really want on top of a shaky foundation. No. Ya can't. Panacea it isn't.
3
Seems like pretty good advice. As for the kids, they're 15. Potentially emotionally vulnerable, but also practically an adult. LW should do what he needs, but first see a lawyer.
4
What @2 said. Also, have some self-respect; your wife is manipulating you and neglecting you. DTMFA.

If not for you, for your kid - he should have at least one parent he can admire. Seek out a poly arrangement (with someone who is worthy of your trust) after the dust settles.
5
What @2 said.
6
I think the lw should introduce his wife the adult-baby-who-threatens-suicide-if-his-wife-doesn't-let-him-get-mommied-and-go-down-on-other-women guy from yesterday's letter. He deserves better.
7
@6

Kind of just realized a moment ago that it's basically the same letter.
8
@7/seatackled: Yes, it's exactly the same, except for the part where at the beginning of the relationship one partner clearly states their price for admission, and the other person agrees to that condition, but then fails to follow through.
9
Sad.. It's easy to say DTMF, but it's hard to do when you actually still love a person, and I get the sense he still loves her.
Even so, DTMF, and take that chance, this does not sound fixable.
10
That marriage was over a long time ago, when the wife decided to cheat on her spouse and use him like a dirty dishrag.

Dump that asshole, LW, and move on. Nobody needs that shit.
11
@2, 7: yup and yup
12
>> and am open to exploring the three of us, but she is too sexually hung up and won’t go there. >>

I love this guy. Wife brings home a bi boyfriend, and husband is like, sure, that could be fun. Sounds like bi boyfriend would be up for it too, if it weren't for wife working to control both of them.
13
"...our gay (or so I thought) best friend and her have basically fallen in love. He is living with us in a poly-ish set up."

Okay. First of all: she not her. She is part of the subject of the sentence. Her isn't.

Secondly, if you aren't clear on the orientation of your BF, you might not be BFs.

Thirdly If your BF shoehorns himself into your home and marriage, and you're not cool with that, you might not be BFs.

And fourthly, if your wife has cheated on you, does not satisfy you sexually, and has a live-in emotional--at least--affair, she might not be your wife. Or might need to not be.
14
"then physically with a couple of people. This was more of an escape from life thing, as she has never been a particularly sexual person."

She's not a sexual person but she fucks a variety of other people including the gay male best friend? That's pretty fucking sexual. Just not with you.

Sorry, LW, you sound like a nice guy. Who is still in love with his wife. But she's not in love nor in lust with you. She's got you wrapped around her finger ("I cheated because I was depressed"?!?). People in love with you are more concerned with your well-being then your wife's behavior indicates she cares about you. People in lust with you fuck you more than twice a month.

Short term: "do what you need to do to stay sane" and, as Dan says, announce it and then do it, don't ask permission, hard though that is (it's pretty clear who wears the pants in this marriage).

Long term: Do you want to be with someone who isn't in love or in lust with you? Projecting your feelings onto her only goes so far for so long. Like 16 or 17 years, apparently.
15
Wife can have other lovers but you can't. Wife can fall in love with gay(?) guy that lives with you in a "poly-ish set up" whatever the fuck that is. Wife is deeply insecure and has a jealous streak. You're having "vanilla" sex twice a month.

You're a glutton for punishment. I wouldn't change a thing.
16
Dan's advice is pretty good, but I think her behaviour is a giant "I WANT OUT!" air raid siren. I they'd both be happier not with each other.
17
What everybody has already said. Plus, don't forget about the kid, who is probably in a constant state of amazement at the fuck-uppedness of his/her home life. Getting a divorce is probably (a) the least fucked-up thing you could do in this situation and (b) the best thing for the kid, who could then split their time between residences like a normal kid.
18
One born every minute, LW. Agree with Dan.. He's so forceful when he's sleep deprived.
Your child is 15 yrs old, just about on their way. Suggest you do the same.
19
Agree with the comments thus far, but will add that it's one thing to, as a poly couple with kids, bring in a committed third to live with you and your children. It's totally different, and morally/ethically/etc. suspect to bring in some dude your wife happens to be fucking in a "poly-ish" way into your child's home. Being poly does not excuse shitty judgment, and allowing this obviously destabilizing force into your home was shitty judgment by you, your wife, and the BF.
20
Dude. You're good people,you try to make peace but if you allow this business to continue, it'll destroy you and you're worth more than that. She has no right to complain about who you hook up with while she's withholding affection and spreading it freely with others. This is not an equal energetic exchange on any level. There is NO justification for the type of manipulation she's pulling. I've been with someone like this and yeah it gets way the hell better. I wouldn't be surprised if she is controlling your circle of friends and other agencies that might give you more perspective. As you step out into a broader world with more people you'll find those who would delight in meeting you an honoring you. She however does not. DTMFA
21
Well played, Ms Cute. It will be interesting to compare the threads.
22
The problem here is that you have basically let her know that she can act out any way she wants, ignore you any way she wants, cheat on you any way she wants, and control you any way she wants. And you put up with all of her steaming bullshit because you're trying to be such a wonderful, accommodating spouse to all her issues.

" I consider myself poly, but I’m almost certain that if I hooked up with someone else it would end my marriage. "

You say that like it's a bad thing.

Seriously, if you want to SAVE your marriage, a good way to start would be to start standing up for yourself. As it stands, she has zero respect for you, and she probably would walk if you weren't so fucking convenient of an enabler. On your end, it's only a matter of time before your capacity for putting up with her emotional diarrhea overflows, and you FINALLY response by divorcing her ass in one glorious supernova of anger. If you don't want either of those to happen, time to start setting some healthy boundaries and requirements on your relationship.

If she gets to take a lover, then you get to take a lover. Period. And she pays more attention to the guy she wants to keep long-term.

If she ends the relationship over that, then she's a hypocritical piece of shit and you are well rid of her.
23
Dan you need to give advice sleep-deprived more often. Admitting that parents aren't hostages, and neither are spouses, is one of the wisest things you've said.

LW by your own admission your wife is a cheating, miserable, scold. If she wants to live her life this way, fine. But neither you, nor kid are obligated to go down in flames with her.

Let her stay with gay-boyfriend and be miserable together.
24
GRIPPER's wife's reluctance to allow him the same leeway as she has in sleeping with other people is probably because she knows whatever new lover he takes will be less mental, more sexual and less hard fucking work than she is, and will therefore serve as a trigger for him to DTMFA. Which he needs! GRIPPER, Dan's sleep-deprived advice is sound. If she wants to be poly, she has to accept that you are going to be poly too, that's how poly works. If she can't accept that, you are well rid.

I can't imagine how this whole situation appears to the poor kid. I mean, living in a house with your dad, your mom, and your mom's formerly-gay boyfriend? That's not inherently bad for a teenager, but only if everyone involved is on board and setting a good example of a healthy non-traditional relationship arrangement. This is anything but.
25
"I consider myself poly..."

LW: Do you want to be poly? Think about the question. If the answer is no, then stop. Divorce regardless.

The fact that your abuser forced you into a fake poly relationship (it's not actually poly, she's just cheating on you and forcing you to pretend to be okay with it) doesn't change your identity. Even if she insists that it does.
26
Wait, what is "gay" again? I'm suddenly lost on that one.

Forget your wife. What kind of role model for your kid are you?
27
Well, your marriage is fucked, and all this nonsense you have allowed into your home by being a doormat for your horrible, selfish wife has probably effed up your kid pretty well too.

Get yourself and your kid out of that environment immediately. Make sure you have evidence of your wife "cheating" on you, call a lawyer and move out with the kid. NOW.
28
@24,25 &27

Ding, Ding and big fucking Ding.
LW, get out with your kid now! Get some therapy and learn how to set healthy boundaries and start emulating them to/with your teen, before they are out on their own.
29
I think the LW should skip the shitshow that his dating will create, and proceed directly to the divorce that is going to happen anyway, in the interest of making the divorce that is going to happen anyway as non-traumatic for the kid as possible.
30
@13: I liked your comment not just for its content (with which I agree) but also because of its highly readable form. You devised that numbered list most skillfully. Thank you.
31
Personal experience about kids and divorce: 1) Two happy parents living separately is much better that two angry parents living together. Toxic environments are never in the kids' best interest. 2) Kids are resilient, and while divorce is not the optimum, it's not the end of the world either. Half of their friends' parents are probably divorced. If they're old enough to understand, they are familiar with the concept. 3) Divorced parents working together with their kids' best interest in mind makes the transition easier on all involved. Get counseling if you can't handle this on your own. 4) Even if you can't have both parents on board working together, single parenting is still better than living in a home filled with conflict. 5) Get your kids counseling to help them deal with the fallout. Talk with them. Reassure them. Be the sane and stable oasis in their life. 6) Don't overcompensate because of guilt. You still have to be the parent. Just because they want something, doesn't always mean they get it. Set reasonable limits and stick to them. They will push the limits because its no longer two parents in a united front. Doesn't matter. Stick with your principles. If your ex is more permissive, stick with your principles. 7) The first year is the big adjustment. It gets better.
32
Holy shit, DS, you rock when you've had no sleep. I need to hang this over my bed:

The moment someone's insecurities become weaponizedβ€”the moment they become tools used to dominate and control a partner, not emotional vulnerabilities requiring understanding and compassion from a partnerβ€”is the right moment to call that someone's bluff.

YES YES YES OMG YES YES YES OMFG YES.

Damn near orgasming here.

That is. EXACTLY. so so relevant to my life. So relevant.
33
LW, light's wasting. Get out and find someone else.
34
re31: "1) Two happy parents living separately is much better that two angry parents living together. "

Along those same lines, I imagine that one happy and one unhappy parent living apart, or two unhappy parents living apart are probably still better than two angry parents living together. Two angry parents living together might be the worst possible scenario.

Your kids' idea of marriage comes from yours. Do not model abuse. It doesn't matter whether you're on the giving or receiving end; if it's what they see, it'll be what they think is normal.
35
@34. I agree. I also note, though, that a dysfunctional relationship between parents can remain, with all its beauty, after the divorce. If they aren't handling coparenting, etc. well before, they can get much worse after, especially with new spouses/girlfriends/steps in the mix. The hope is that some of that negativity is tamped down with reduced contact between the the parents. Unfortunately, I still think that kids gain their relationship models from their parents, even when divorced. I know that my mother never entered another relationship (but one, and it never went farther than dating) after they split when I was five. I have limited memory of them living together, but they still left a very f-ed up model for me to learn from.

I've counted my blessing and I do so here that one thought crystallized for me why I had to leave marriage no. 1. I realized I could never have children with him. He'd be nothing but a jerk and we'd be tied together forever in coparenting. Having him in my life like that.... no. way.
36
What they ALL said
37
More like GRIPER, amirite?

Dude, Bi BF needs to GTFO, regardless. You have a kid at home.
38
Wait, did Mom already move bi boyfriend into the house? That's going to have a much bigger impact on the 15 year old kid than him finding out that Dad also had a fling. And if his parents get a divorce? That might actually provide him with MORE stability. My parents got divorced when I was 14, and I will say that I would rather have parents happily divorced than constantly fighting.

I agree with @31 a thousand percent.

39
Poly isn't the answer to this in my opinion. Poly takes a lot of trust, mutual respect and love which you basically have none of that here. I would first seek a lawyer and legally separate, she seems very manipulative and depressed and in a court battle that can be brutal to go up against! I wouldn't want for her to be able to pin anything on me that could be viewed as cheating. Technically if she doesn't approve then it's infidelity, not poly, right? The kid will be a lot better off in the long run if you're mentally healthy and happy...ya it's not ideal but the kid will be fine!

I consider myself poly and have been up one side and down the other with it...it's not easy and it really requires an extremely strong base. Basically the way I see it is if you waited around and started seeing other people you will eventually find someone you click with and probably have zero desire to hang out with this bitch!
40
@38: "My parents got divorced when I was 14, and I will say that I would rather have parents happily divorced than constantly fighting."
Basically the same here.
41
Hotthumbs @39: Yeah, actually, I'm with you. Skip the part where his seeing other people ends the marriage and just end the marriage.
42
Yeah the 15yo seems like the absolute least of his problems. What is hard to explain to a teenager, a divorce or the gay guy who lives with us now and is fucking mom? I think the LW is just really desperate to save a thing that is not very saveable.
43
My understanding of poly relationships is that BOTH parties are allowed secondary partners or they both share the third in their relationship. I'm not sure, but I think a relationship where wifey moves her sexually ambiguous pal into the house and fucks him while the husband has to be satisfied with crumbs from her and can't even get her to go in on a MMF romp would not qualify as poly. It does qualify as selfish. And she may not have been a sexual person before, but she is now, just not with you. And anyone, male or female, who wants to be able to have multiple partners but doesn't want to afford his/her spouse that right, is a selfish fuck.

I gotta say, this marriage doesn't seem worth worth saving. Your kid's a teenager (pity the woman from yesterday, whose kids are probably all under 7), so the custody arrangements should be a bit easier, and in a few years, your kid will hopefully be mostly independent.

DTMFA.
44
I'm thinking the wife is sexual as all get out -- just not with the letter writer. She's having multiple affairs and moved a boyfriend in; she's just not into sex with her husband. (Similarly I am sexual as the day is long, but rarely have sex with my own husband, because sadly the sex is not good, but I stay because so much else about him is wonderful).
45
p.s. Overall I like Sleep-Deprived, Cranky Dan better than well-rested, chipper Dan. Sorry, Dan!
46
Hey Gripper:
1) you are not hostage to your kid, but your kid should not be a "oh yeah, btw" afterthought.
2) you are not modeling being a understanding, supportive spouse.
3) you are modeling being a doormat.
4) the water is boiling, frog. Jump out.
47
Drunken @44: Your post makes me sad. Husbands (and partners of all genders) can be trained. If he's so wonderful, sit him down and tell him you're not satisfied and that rather than cheat you want to show him how to be a better lover. Unless you already have an open relationship and are getting those needs met elsewhere. Good luck either way!
48
@44: Exactly. This is just like the common "mysterious" problem, where someone's like "My libido mysteriously disappears (around old people, fat people, smelly people, ugly people, and that loser I married) but mysteriously reappears around anyone who's even moderately attractive! SUCH a mystery!!!"

General rule: If you think someone's "not very sexual," but they're having all kinds of sex with other people, it means they're just not into you. It's easier to see the truth from outside, but it's still not a complicated problem.
49
Thanks, sax @30. It was my pleasure.
50
Yeah, Dump the Mother AND the Mother-Fucker Already, as in immediately.

Skip the part where you have an affair and hand the Fucking Mother a ton of ammunition to retaliate with (sleep dep doesn't lead to great advice). Your chances of getting through the divorce unscathed are a lot higher if you just acknowledge reality, which is that you're being used by a POS and setting a terrible example for your kid. This marriage isn't worth saving or fighting for.
51
If you got a kid in the house while allowing your wife to fuck your best friend who lives in the house as well...

uh

I mean I am sure these are Mormons but

it's kinda like the horse if already out of the barn.
52
I'm with @16: "I think her behaviour is a giant 'I WANT OUT!' air raid siren."
She wants to end the marriage but is too scared/ashamed/religiously_brainwashed to do it herself, so she will continue escalating her behavior until the LW pulls the trigger and ends the marriage. I hope the LW decides to spare himself & his son any more misery & insanity & does this sooner than later.
53
What 4 and 6 said.
Seriously, the cognitive dissonance and mental gymnastics lw is engaging in to keep imagining that she loves him... are we sure Dan isn't being trolled?Astounding. For example: She's never been a sexual person, and all the sex she has when she's cheating is just from depression?
Yeahyeah, i bet she's super sad about being the only one in your relationship getting as much sex as she wants, while you bend over backward to make excuses for her! LOL, cry me a river!
Lw is being fed a line of ridiculous manipulative lies, and his willingness to keep pulling the wool over his own eyes to keep believing it makes it very hard to feel any sympathy for him.
She is a PLENTY "sexual person", she juat doesn't want sex with lw and is too gutless and dishonest to say so, one reason is probably that its impossible to respect him when he's so desperate to continue being her doormat, although that's certainly no excuse for her nasty behavior.
Face it lw, what this creature feels for you isn't love. All she loves is how easily manipulated and exploited you are.
Grow a spine and get rid of her, or if you're really a glutton for this punishment, formally adopt the cuckold lifestyle and accept it for what it is.
Lol, she's made you the cuckold not of a bull, but of a queen! That's how little she respects you!
although, to be fair, this is a conscious fetish lifestyle choice for many. If so, at least try to be man enough to own your choice, ffs.
54
Kind of amazed that everyone is seeing this as an "unfair, onesided, hypocritical, poly-ish" marriage, instead of calling him out for what he is; which is a willing, bisexual cuckold who merely has a penchant for drama and selfpity.
Yawn. If I had a nickel yadda yadda yadda...
55
Speaking for myself, I hope RestingB sticks around for a bit...
56
JibeHo @55: I thought you didn't like dicks?
57
Hoo boy. Dollars to donuts that kid is going to grow up and become super conservative!
58
@54 that's a pretty strong leap you are making there, as it basically directly contradicts what LW wrote.
59
BiDanFan @56 - I see what you did there...
60
@ 58.
Not when one analyzes the actual behaviors stated of the parties involved, instead of their mewling, mealymouthed, ludicrous attempts at justifying said behaviors. Nope, not a leap at all.
Bottom line, she's cuckolded him many times, and every time he's accepted her terms unquestioningly. It's a textbook cuckold relationship.
Given your username, I'm surprised you were too obtuse to recognize it. But lots of people enjoy using provocative words, with only minimal grasp of their meaning.

And BiDanFan, since your username indicates you do like dicks, the compliment is appreciated.

Toodles!
61
Bitchmode: off.

In seriousness, look at the terminology you guy sare applying to Lw' s situation, minus the subjective emotional value judgments like "hypocritical", and what is left? A one-sided poly relationship where male partner stays faithful and submits to the female partner's need for extramarital affairs. Textbook cuckoldry.
Oh, but he wrote to Dan asking about changing it, so he's not really accepting the cuckoldry, you say?
... The fact that he has accepted it thus far, and doesn't feel he can change his situation without first seeking permission from another male surrogate, in this case, Dan, only further supports my point.
Okay, maybe that last bit is only 80% serious... 85...

And JibeHo, you're lovely, but most likely I'll be banned fairly quickly, in which case I will simply be forced to find more productive uses for my time. But I shall miss you most.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.