Blogs Jan 6, 2009 at 7:34 pm

Comments

1
I know it feeds the terroristic aims of the sender of these letters, but why the fuck is the Stranger the only media in town with a word about this???
2
The only way you could pull off something like this, especially on 11 bars, would be with the element of surprise on your side. That makes me guess this a-hole is bluffing. Not that you can count on that.
3
Yeah, I don't see how someone is going to sneak poison into the drinks of 55 people after publicly announcing their intention to do so. Not bloody likely!

On the other hand, someone cuckoo enough to write those letters has probably had suspicious behavior in the past that will lead the authorities straight to their door, as in the case of the Unabomber.
4
Thanks Science! You're always there for us.
5
He's counting on public confusion between anthrax and ricin. Fortunately, there's no such thing as chemical or biological weapons.
6
remember the guy in kirkland that was cooking up a big batch of ricin in his garage four years ago?

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/1688…
7
The author's sentence structure kind of reminds me of Lord Basil.
8
I am a science nerd, and have to point out that it is not a good idea to scale up LD50 by weigh. The doseage will depend on metabolic variation, organ size, etc.
9
Fnarf--

Hence the post. JAMA is by no means my favorite journal, but they do this sort of article so well.

Kateness--
"Mice aren't little people." Yup.
10
meanwhile, in supervolcano news:

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/wo…
11
Jonathan, with your background, I would have thought you would know this, but apparently not: a pill that says "200mg" weighs a lot more thatn 200 mg; it contains 200 mg of the active chemical but most of a pill is just buffer substance. 2g of ricin is nowhere near as big as 10 ibuprofin pills, and 70mg would be a barely visible trace amount. It would be no problem to hide that much in a drink, even if it didn't dissolve.

By the way, here's another scary thing about ricin: it's not too hard to prepare without sophisticated equipment. You can get it from castor beans.
12
From the Q13Fox website (the only mainstream media to mention this so far)

"Seattle police say they are taking this threat very seriously and are working with multiple agencies to resolve this case."
13
Okay... so it's hard to get people to eat enough of it. What about snorting? Is it possible for someone to cut coke with it?
14
It's on the King 5 website now as well and mentions both the Seattle police and the FBI but says the joint terrorism task force isn't involved yet.

I was going to say something similar to David, but I didn't want to contradict anything Mr. Science says because he makes me nervous. I'll just add that it may be difficult but not impossible to manufacture ricin but it is a big risk to the person doing it (for example the guy in the Las Vegas hotel room).

I think at the very least someone could, if all their ducks were in a row, pull off making a bunch of people very sick. The question is if the purpose of writing the letters was to make people fearful or to actually carry out the threat. In which case, it was probably kind of dumb to send the letters ahead of time.
15
KOMO 4 news at 11 had a short blurb about it, but just mentioned poison and didn't say ricin - which is curious.
16
PopTart's comment contains the key insight that explains why the police probably aren't too worked up about this danger: Anyone who seriously wanted to do this and was smart enough to pull it off wouldn't make his task harder by advertising it beforehand. Almost certainly these letters are from someone who couldn't or wouldn't pull do the deed, but saw in it an easy way to instill fear in some people he hates.
17
Paranoid @ 13: If you are snorting white powders you got from strangers in bars, there is a very long list of risks you should be more worried about that ricin poisoining.
18
Anyone know if people could die because they don't follow dad @17's rules?
19
"Anyone who seriously wanted to do this and was smart enough to pull it off wouldn't make his task harder by advertising it beforehand."

Why do people believe that a crazy person will behave rationally in the prosecution of a hate crime? You sound like a smart guy, David, I'm sorry to pick out a quote from you but it was handy.

It's likely the person is just a blow hard, but also possible that he thinks himself smarter than the police, or worse, on a divine mission. Regardless, the threat in itself is a crime and should be taken seriously.
20
Isn't Ricin the planet in Star Trek where Picard had to walk around with a big phallic totem pole that signaled his desire to, you know ... ?
21
@11 -- even going with J's numbers -- if 2.1 g of ricin is the same as 10 ibuprofen pills (are we talking normal 200 mg version or the 800 mg super ibu pill?), 70 mg of ricin (enough to kill a person) would be one third of one pill. I could crush that in a drink. Unless it was one third of one 800 mg ibu super pill, then no.

God, who's making up these numbers?
22
Let's not forget that injection is -- by far -- the most dangerous way to administer the stuff.

The KGB executed a man with just the amount of ricin that could be injected into a tiny hole in a BB. They administered the BB via a glorified pellet gun.
24
Oh Jeez - if this person is so smart why would he/she be wasting their time on Seattle's gay bars?

25
Honestly, the only way this person could target this and have it work is to go for the airborne route - putting it into individuals' drinks would just not be effective given the number of sites they say they're targeting. All the sites might want to make sure that their ventilation systems are reasonably secure or keep an eye on them.

Given that they say they'll do "at least five" targets at each location, airborne may not be the plan... but it's a good thing to keep in mind.
26
The bars have ventilation systems?
27
I read that the guy swallows the stuff sealed in a balloon then farts it out in the bars.
Silent but Deadly.
28
In January its so nice
While slipping on the slidey ice
To sip hot chicken soup with ricin
Sippin' once, sippin' twice
Sippin' chicken soup with ricin!
29
@28: I hate you.

Maurice Sendak and Carole King I hate just a little more.
30
You know, you can find many lethal things, some of which can destroy entire buildings, just under your kitchen sink and in your bathroom cabinets. And in your laundry room.

Just saying.
31
@14, @16

However... If they're in it for the attention and celebrity, they might realized that after an attack, lots of goofballs will come out of the woodwork and claim credit. Sending the letters ahead of time helps to make sure that doesn't fly. And if he succeeds even after giving warnings, then pulling it off increases his stature.

I think it's fake because the letter is so preciously written and overly melodramatic. But you never know...
32
Clearly, Dr. Moriarty is behind this.
33
So how often do you see people doing lines in the back room of your average gay bar? That seems like a good way to distribute the stuff by inhalation. Don't know how common that is but I think I would lay off the nose candy if I lived in Seattle.
34
There's a potentially fatal error in real-life scientist Jonathan Golob's research. The generally-accepted LD50 for ricin in humans is at best 30 MICROgrams(mcg)/kilogram(kg) - not 30 MILLIgrams/kilogram.

In short, he's off by a factor of 1,000 - 10,000 (most sources give LD50's in the 3.0 mcg/kg ballpark).

Did nobody bother to check this?

google ricin + ld50 + microgram
35
RonK, you need help with reading comprehension.

The LD50 for ingested ricin (like you'd get in a drink) is a thousand fold higher than for inhaled or injected. As it says in my post. My numbers are correct, coming from a carefully curated medical site. Yours are from random shit found on google. You fail.

Don't believe me? From TFA to which I linked: "The median lethal dose (LD50) in mice is 30 mg/kg, or approximately 1000-fold higher than by injection or inhalation."


Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.