Blogs Nov 13, 2009 at 4:31 pm

Comments

1
Maybe that's why I'm feeling so conflicted - I'm a John Hodgman fan myself.
2
ralph and Mr.Baker quickly switch to Linux.
3
I voted for McGinn, but this seems like a silly thing for him to concern himself with. I can't see what purpose this serves other than personal preference, and the last time I heard, we were in a budget crisis.
4
There really isn't anything a PC can do that a Mac can't.

Mind you, we mostly use Linux, with a few dual-boot Linux/Win machines around here, but Win wastes a heck of a lot of cycles on graphics that really makes no difference.
5
Ug. Really? Macs are so overrated. I don't know how anyone can still talk seriously about those being the superior product.
6
Also, most other businesses and government organizations use PCs so wouldn't this just make it unnecessarily difficult to share info and network with other entities?
7
If McGinn was a mac, wouldn't he have only gotten about 7 percent of the vote?
8
hmmm...well there is the fact that mcginn is running his transition team 'open-source' and mac computers run on proprietary software/hardware. i guess that makes him more of a flavor of linux. kuki linux maybe?
9
My only concern would be that they might throw away perfectly functional pcs for the purpose. Better to just buy macs as the old pcs are phased out.

Better yet to get a mac capable of running windows and letting the operator decide on a platform.
10
Really? This is a fucking priority? Idiot.
11
Really? Way to support local business. Microsoft is LOCAL. Why would you want(as a function of city government) to stop contributing to the largest company in the NW.
I have never understood Seattle's obsession with Apple. I think it really speaks poorly of Seattle residents that they would not champion their own local company. Where is the pride?
12
@9 - turnover for executive level computers is usually two years anyway, so they're due to be replaced.

FACT: Microsoft makes way more each time you buy a Mac (due to the software you end up using) than when you buy a Windows box.

Unless you go with totally open source software like most of the world uses. You know, Firefox, Opera, OpenOffice.
13
See, I think McGinn is not stylish enough to be a Mac. Have you seen those shoes? The brown sportcoat?
14
Hahaha nice one #7

I think Linux might be a nicer label for McGinn...

""We're not just going to talk to important elected officials, nor are we just going to talk to the same old people who advise new mayors about how things should work—we're going to talk to everybody."
Sounds very Linux, and VERY un-Mac.

Mac would be all "We're going to only talk to important elected officials, because they're the experts at this, and clearly superior to Joe Common".

And Windows would say "We're going to only talk to the same old people, because they've been here so long they must know how it's done".

But, I might only be rebutting this Mac-praise of a post because I hate Macintosh and their smamy ads. Oh, you have no viruses? That's great, you forgot to mention that it's mainly because no-one has bothered to make Mac viruses yet, because you own diddly-squat of the PC market.
15
Yeah, this is a pretty idiotic thing to be concerned with. And knowing the old and outdated, bizarro, hacked-together proprietary software that municipal governments often have to work with, I'd be shocked if any or most of those programs worked on Macs. I suppose you could run Bootcamp or Parallels, but then that's even more money wasted.
16
That's a smart thing to spend money on in the middle of the one of the biggest budget shortfalls in the cities history. What a bunch of fucking idiots.
17
But, you GUYS! Aaron Pickus wants a taxpayer-funded iPhone!!!!!!!
18
Doubtful, Microsoft made a deal with the city in the early days, which is why all city workers are on PCs.
19
yes, let's replace perfect functional computers to suit personal preference while we're in the middle of a budget crisis. way to lead us into a brighter tomorrow!
20
@12, only twats turn over their machines every two years. We're on a four-year cycle, stretched to five about half the time.

The city probably has two hundred Dells sitting around still in boxes at any given moment.

This is a good full-employment plan for McGinn, as every geek in the city has to learn all new stuff and then spend all of their waking moments trying to (a) make it work and (b) figure out why it's not compatible. There are, I'm sure, dozens of specialized apps the city runs that don't work on Macs (indeed, barely work at all).

And everybody knows that, while PCs are not "better than" Macs, or vice versa (the phrase doesn't even have meaning), Mac users are assuredly stupider than PC users on almost every measure.
21
"We’ve asked the city IT folks about it and they’re looking into it for us"

I can almost here the collective *sigh* from here.
22
Wow, already finding ways to piss away our money. These folks are gonna be great.
23
#11: Microsoft licenses out of Reno to avoid paying local taxes. Palo Alto is closer to being local.
24
I bet Richard Conlin uses a ThinkPad.
25
How much software does a mayor run anyway? I'm guessing e-mail, a browser, and maybe excel. His time is more valuable in meetings and on the phone than at a keyboard.
26
As you can run both WIndows an OSX (not to mention almost any flavor or Linux) all at the same time on a Mac, it seems pretty silly to use a Windows machine.
27
I work in a mixed OSX and XP environment, and we don't have any problems. We decided to skip Vista, so we'll see what happens when our Win people switch to 7, but I'm betting it will still work. As long as everybody uses standard file formats, everything's cool.

As for the iphones, I'd rather have one than a Blackberry any day, and they can actually be cheaper.
28
Microsoft doesn't want McGinn's pity. Microsoft doesn't want Seattle's pity. Or ANYBODY's pity! OK?

If you don't want a PC, that's FINE! Microsoft will find buyers for their stuff somewhere; don't you worry. Just don't say you have to use a PC because you feel sorry for the local company. Leave them a shred of dignity. Can you do that much?
29
Waste of money.
30
@11,

Are you kidding? There's no way I'm going to buy crappy products out of loyalty. Do you throw a shit fit when you find out you'll be flying on an Airbus and not a Boeing plane?

Besides, Microsoft products are ubiquitous. Anyone not actively trying to avoid them will have some Microsoft products on their computer.
31
So McGinn (controlled by the AT&T subsidiary Mercury Group) wants to ditch the T-Mobile Blackberries the city currently uses for iPhones (that only run on AT&T's network). And his prime initiative is for public broadband, which would destroy the Starbucks/T-Mobile private Wifi Hotspot network?

The mayoral campaign was nothing but a power grab by the local telecom giants, wake up sheeple!!!
32
Ha ha... Good luck to that IT department!
33
I love how Apple has been able to market a high-end luxury product for upper-income consumers as some kind of hip, counter-cultural form of social rebellion. Only in America.
34
Why doesn't someone do an expose of the Mercury Group, and their impact on McGinn and his campaign- as well as their other clients?

Might be nice to get full disclosure on this from Mike. What is he hiding?

Why spend the extra money? Our new mayor is too dang hip to use what the lowly city employees use - we're not his people, clearly.
35
I freaking hate those "I'm a Mac" ads. They make me hate Mac. Mac's are snide hipsters, PCs are bumbling incompetents, I don't want either of them on my desk or lap.
36
"I love how Apple has been able to market a high-end luxury product for upper-income consumers as some kind of hip, counter-cultural form of social rebellion. "

And now they think they should use them in City Hall...these guys are headed for a fucking financial cliff and they want iPhones and Macs? Seriously, could you look more like the privileged upper middle class college educated white liberals you are?
37
This thread says a lot more about most of the commenters here than the McGinn team.

The Seattle city government is not all going to convert to Mac just because the McGinn team is more comfortable with Macs. It's not brain science to get Macs and Windows machines to coexist and talk to each other.

It's probably healthy if we have a city government that familiarizes itself with both platforms (and Linux too) to sone degree.

...I say this as someone happy with a Windows XP desktop machine plus an iPhone.
38
I like my mac, but I hate the ads. And the hype. A bitchy friend had the nerve to tell me I may look like a mac, but I suck dick like a PC (I'm a little gaggy, so what).

I remember Obama caught shit for wanting to use a device with poor security. How's that work with an iphone?
39
"It's probably healthy if we have a city government that familiarizes itself with both platforms (and Linux too) to sone degree"

In the middle of its worst budget crisis?

Earth calling...
40
If someone who's going to lead needs extra time to ramp up to a whole different computer platform, isn't that more of a waste of money and time?

You'd all be complaining if McGinn said "I will take time to learn this Windows Vista or XP thing" surely.
41
i'm using a commodore 64 with a 300baud dialup modem right now, so i'm getting a kick out of these replies.
42
@39 Yes, the budget is so bad, let's buy nothing to help who we elected, and communicate with sticky notes instead. Because computers cost millions of dollars obviously.
43
I bet a Mallahan election dinner at the Edgewater alone (something that likely would have happened if Mallahan won) would have cost more than a few extra Mac computers and iPhones.
44
congrats on finding an intensely flame-prone mix of topics of very minor significance to keep PC/MAC battles raging all weekend.

(oh, and remember way back in january when the same thing happened to the Obama administration?)
45
@44 FTW!
46
To everyone who thinks this is a "waste of time or money": Let's be clear about one thing: the request was to look into running the MAYOR'S OFFICE on Macs, not the entire city government. The Mayor's office has perhaps half a dozen staff. The City as a whole has thousands. Even if they bought top-of-the-line Macs it would cost perhaps $10,000. Put that in the context of a $4,000,000,000 annual budget and you have what we call "budget dust". It is so insignificant that it is not even worth mentioning, and if it makes the Mayor and his staff (whose time is in overwhelmingly high demand) even 1% more productive due to familiarity, then it is well worth it to the taxpayers.

Note: this comment has nothing to do with Macs vs. PCs. I would say the same exact thing if the Mayor's office was run on Macs and a new Mayor asked if they could switch to PCs.

Trying to save money by refusing to give your executive team the tools to maximize their productivity is penny wise and pound foolish. Thank god you idiots aren't in charge of any sizable amount of money.
47
I am still using a TRS-80.
48
all my mayors are on vinyl.
49
I like Mike McGinn, I really do. But this is the Seattle version of dog-whistle cultural cues. A hell of a lot less pernicious than in other parts of the country, sure, but it's going to get real old real fast if it keeps up.
50
@11, hahahahaha! "Pride" in fucking Microsoft..??

Right, that's just what Seattle residents should do: take pride in a company that makes shitty products with preplanned problems that can be "fixed" and "upgraded" for the next release you're supposed to shell out for.

Fuckin' A, man... Just because it's next door in the fucking EASTSIDE doesn't mean we're going to reflexively take pride in it...
51
@50 Microsoft is on the eastside, but a major prectage of their employees live on the WESTSIDE. I notice he says this after the election.....it would have not gone down so well before.

DUMBASS!
52
Macs are cheaper than PCs, duh! It's a fact, look it up!!

I'd suggest Big Blue hardware on every desktop (64 proc and 4TB ram). It'll keep the electrical and hvac unions happy, at least.
53
What I want to know does McGinn wear boxers or briefs. You folks should know since you like to kiss his ass all the time. This is hipster drivel. Mac or PC what a civic breakthrough. Save money stick with the PC's
54
I don't like the idea of city computers using MAC. It's way too expensive and you can accomplish everything with Ubuntu, which is free. Replacing all the computers to new computers that cost 2-3 times as much as other brands that do the exact same thing would be a giant waste of money. I'm not saying the city should be exclusively PC or MAC, but the majority of everything is currently on the much cheaper PC platform.

If they want to spend their own money switching every computer system platform that's fine by me. If Mike, and a few other select staffers prefer a mac over a PC, or need something that's exclusively on mac I see no problem with it. I'm a little concerned with the price of upgrades, that are usually necessary for some software upgrades, something that also makes windows cheaper as even something like windows XP can play 99% of the programs.

I had no idea McGinn was a mac guy, but as you say whatever works for you. Technology kicks ass even if it's way overpriced. I don't think it really matters what you use, so long as you get whatever it is you want done. I think in terms of social media iPhone was really created ot serve that crowd, but I would hope when the campaign is over and the real work starts to get done a few of those staffers will think twice about a blackberry. :p
55
@50, you mean like upgrading from Leopard to Snow Leopard?
56
the troll has always and only used macs-
those who question their superiority are morons.
however in the grownup world there would be compatibility issues, it would look bad re:hometown microsoft and most important- mcginn only wishes he were cool enough for mac.

it is a typical style over substance shallow hipster gimmick.
57
I'm with the folks who have said that this seems like an odd thing to be at the top of the transition list. It costs a lot of money and time to revamp office network hardware. And I don't think McGinn was the Mac to Mallahan's PC. You may like McGinn's politics, but the guy is as cranky and uncool as they come, IMO.
58
What makes you think this is at the top of the transition list? It sounds like something you should ask about while setting up a new office, which appears to be all that has happened. Get a grip, windows fans.
60
Wow. This is such a glaring example of immaturity of the "transition team" -- thousands of people are unemployed, 20% vacancy rate, housing values in the tank, but first things first McGinn wants a Mac office.
61
Who cares about budget cuts so long as the person doing the cutting has an iphone?
62
Hey, McGinn should be purchasing refurbished Macs. Much cheaper and still more power than is needed for web/word/spreedsheet. Or better yet just purchase Seattle residents macs from craigslist.
63
I'm sorry, iPhones are cool, but in an actual WORK setting they pale in comparison to a blackberry. Good luck with that shitty email client and softkeys, guys.

Unless this isn't actually about work... I hear the iPhone has lots of nifty apps.
64
#50 preplanned problems? What the fuck are you even talking about?

Also, I thought the first sentence was the stupidest sentence in this post, but no, it's actually the second: http://www.tuaw.com/2009/01/02/apple-mar…
65
I still hate those ads. I change the channel when they come on, I am that sick if them. And all the lame copy-cat ads? Fuck them, too.
66
The total cost of ownership for Macs is lower. They're easier to secure, easier to maintain, and easier to use. Plus, they can run NeoOffice and save a bundle on Office licensing. The mayor has the right idea. But they should look at Android phones as an alternative to Blackerries and iPhones.
67
Macs: the Fisher-Price of computers
68
@58 is right. And even if they really want to switch, right now they're just giddy with winning. It happens with every new regimes, and always takes a few months to come back down to earth and be real. Like, you can't change everything into your dream world right away, when you have a constituency of over 500,000 to answer to. Take a deep breath... there...
69
66: I've had the same PC for seven years, and it works just fine. I've never had to have it repaired. It was cheaper than a powerbook. I have a windows-based laptop right now that cost me about 400 bucks. Maybe I'm just careful with what a I own or perhaps I just know what I'm doing, but the idea that it's more expensive to buy or maintain a PC is pure fucking myth, probably perpetuated by rabid Mac users finding new reasons for their superiority.

Now if you're talking about an office setting specifically, you may be right.
70
Just wait until we find out McGinn got his coffee at Peet's.

OH SHIT
71
His decision will still support local business. If McGinn takes out the old PCs and installs Macs, he'll likely have to install Microsoft Office on each machine, if for no other reason than to access email and calendar, but also to run the word processor everyone uses and the spreadsheets everyone uses. He could try to go with OpenOffice, but I'd expect compatibility issues and, considering the volume of documents that march through the office of a mayor of a major city, it'll become too aggravating. The differences between Outlook and Entourage may be too aggravating.

If he decides to use Omni Group software, that's also a very capable local outfit.

It is possible to select a lower-end PC that is cheaper than an equivalently geared lower-end Mac. Machines geared for desktop publishing or video editing require higher end gear and more RAM; that's where Macs are more competitive on overall price. It is also possible to equip a high-end PC with gear that simply don't exist for Macs; those are high-end gamer systems.

The iPhone is obviously not the cheapest phone on the market, either, but Apple is selling a lot of them, despite AT&T.
72
"McGinn: The BigMac Mayor" is more like it
73
We were thinking 'Mayor McCheese'...
74
I do all my slog postings from a Telex machine.
75
I love McGinns supporters who are too dumb to realize this is not whether he buys a Mac or a PC...it's whether he buys a Mac AND doesn't use the computers already available.

You all understand what a deficit is right?
76
The fact that these hipster dipshits who ran McGinn's campaign can't use PCs (and I have always used Macs) is proof that they have NO experience in the real world, whether government or business. God fucking help us.
77
I don't get it. To me, this election seemed to come down to Spacely Sprockets versus Cogswell Cogs: Two boring guys spouting pretty much the same line, which was not that different from what Nickels had to say. How anyone could get worked up about either one is beyond me.

You want to get worked up about stupid waste in the city? Get your panties in a bunch about this: There are thousands of reams of city letterhead with Greg Nickel's name on it that are going to get trashed come the inauguration. Every department, for some reason, has to have the Mayor's name on their letterhead. I'm sure it's some custom that dates back to the founding of the city, but why are we still doing it?

But no - it's much more exciting to get in some dreary argument about a handful of computers and cell phones.
78
@71: Precisely. Microsoft has been the #1 software vendor on the Mac platform for a loooong time, mostly because of Office.

Honestly. Mac vs. Windows has been presented as something akin to English vs Japanese. As a user of both, I can say it's more like Swedish vs. Danish. At this point they're so similar, there's little justification for much fuss.

Well... Aside from the fact that Macs sometimes do snow crashes. I've never seen a Windows machine do that.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxmMufSin…
79
Let's try that Mac snow crash link again, since I had to confirm my acct:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QxmMufSin…
80
Support a local company that makes local products that suck!
81
Yes, lets waste our already strangled budget buying overpriced hype machines.
82
"It is in part a way to stick with the technology we were most comfortable with during the campaign, and in our personal experience." Does it really take *that* long to figure out how to use a fucking PC? If it does, I seriously worry about your mayor and his staff.
83
Eh, let them use whatever they're comfortable with, as long as it helps them get more done with their time.
84
I've used both PCs and Mac (didn't realize that was a particularly special skill), but mostly use PCs because of the business I'm in. Working with graphics? Get a Mac. Working with numbers? Get a PC. I'm really hoping that the Mayor's Office will be doing a lot more work on numbers than graphics...
85
the reason why this is such a big story is because it demonstrates that McGinn and the "advocates" are really amateurs and are not up to the job of managing 11,000 employees and billion dollar budgets. just wait..... sometime next spring Wall Street will lower the bond rating of the City due to these clowns.
86
Wow people... get a life. The new mayor gets to buy new computers because the old ones are up for replacement. Technology marches on, making five year old computers obsolete, much to our collective chagrin. Fucking deal with it.
87
Why do they even need new computers if they are checking email and writing word documents? Send them all Pentium-II beige boxes. That will keep them off the youtubes as well, further increasing productivity!
88
I think the mayor's office should use clay tablets and abacuses.
89
@11 and others: last time I checked, Microsoft doesn't actually manufacture computers, they only create software that runs on computers. By switching to Apple, the only software they may not be buying is the OS. Of course, if they run BootCamp or Parallels (as I do) then they WILL be buying XP/VISTA/Win7 anyway. I still run MS Office on my Mac. I still run Entourage (soon to become OutlookMac). How are they not supporting MS?

@23, great point. Hopefully more folks will read that.

You all should be happy they are considering a change to Apple just for the SECURITY reasons. Unless you want the mayor and his staff running around with laptops that could be breached easily at any given time....
90
@79 Never seen that before. Have been using macs for 20 years. My office currently has 18 Macs, various models and ages. Our 2 Dell laptops are used for a propitiatory Boeing accounting system that they force their vendors to use. These machines SUCK.
91
Due to Microsoft's predatory behavior, organizations now have a choice if they stick with Windows: Buy all new computers, or use a combination of Windows versions which have very different user interfaces. Also, the new Office 2007 has a radically different user interface from all old versions of Office (and no option to keep using the old interface).

The new versions won't work on old computers as Windows 7 requires 1 GB of RAM and 16 GB available disk space. This is 8 times the RAM requirement of Windows XP which has been discontinued.

So this is a pretty smart time to switch to Macs if an organization is so inclined.
92
The less policy McGinn's office inflicts upon us, the better. Let them buy Playstations and beanbag chairs instead of computers and maybe they'll just leave us alone.
93
All we are seeing here are Microsoft payroll-patriots. Fuck you. Fuck you very very much. You turn on a Mac, and it will probably work for a few years. With windows, you have viruses, and general rot, after 6 months the thing just bogs down and nothing works, and you have to reimage it. Gimme a fucking break. In terms of human lives lost, Microsoft is up there with Pol Pot, Hitler, and Stalin. http://www.aqdi.com/death.htm
94
So the Mayor's office, which is quite comfortable using Macs, is supposed to learn how to use an inferior system just because the company's headquarters is over the lake aways? Nonsense.

And for those who think you have to use Microsoft programs on a Mac, that is also utter nonsense. The Mac comes with all the programs you need and works great right out of the box. Normal people never have to buy Microsoft software to do word-processing, email or surf the net.

Not only that, you won't have to worry about getting all those viruses that PC's do.
95
Macs have better security. They don't crash all the time. Just because they know how to advertise themselves (yet another arena pcs suck at) doesn't make them all hype.

The mayors office will spend less on tech support and general hair pulling and time wasted in the long run. And when the rest of you come down with a virus they'll still have functioning computers.
96
This is the most idiotic proposal. MSFT is a major (perhaps the major with Boeing moving on) employer in our region. To not support MSFT and the employer of a large number of Seattle residents is stupid and ego driven. There isn't a thing in that the Mayor's office does that a Mac can perform better than a PC. Here I thought Aaron Pickus was smart with the campaign that he ran with Bill Broadhead and they come out and propose this idiotic idea. Very disappointing.
97
I know for a fact that some city applications only run in IE7 on a Windows PC. Even IE8 breaks them (well, IE8 breaks lots of things, most of them on purpose). Now, since the mayor doesn't actually do any real work, this won't matter much, and any old email client will do; but for his whole department?
98
it's called a transition, people. hello?
99
So he was expensive, elitist and smug?
100
Which applications, Fnarf? I'm wondering which vital function the mayor's office staff will be unable to perform on a Mac.

Of course, you can run Windows on a Mac and and not even in a special window, AND that requires a Windows license which means Microsoft still gets their cut. Which will avert the layoffs in Redmond that McGinn is going to cause by not using a Dell.

    Please wait...

    Comments are closed.

    Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


    Add a comment
    Preview

    By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.