Comments

1
The important thing is that we are driving as much as we were before the disaster. The last thing we should talk about is conservation!!

2
"The government is in charge. We have been in charge and we'll continue to be in charge."

Nice to know who to blame when we vote this November.
3
FYI - her name is Carol not Carl
4
It is bizzare at best to suggest the government hasn't been doing enough. The same people that wanted off shore drilling want to blame the government. The same people who want no government now want to blame the government for not doing enough (what ever that is). It's a cynical attempt to find something to pin on Obama.
6
Obama voter here. Obama donor here Vince. Democratic socialist who lovves france and sweden here, Vince. Now hear this:

Obama is to blame.

He said drill baby drill.

His agency kept giving waivers.

He's letting BP get away with not fixing it.

He's letting BP be in charge.

the "well" is a filament that is twenty inches in diameter at the top...it gets narrower as you go down...it goes down 18,000 feet to an oil reservoir. Contrary to the imagination of some, an oil reservoir is not a huge pool but is oil amongst sand. In any event it should be fairly simple to collapse the well and use an explosive to do it. What BP ha been trying to do is preserve its ability to draw oil ($$) out of this well; it doesn't want to wreck the well to stop the gusher.

This thing bould be turned off in one hour with a 500 pound bunker busting bomb or a torpedo. The well is three and a half miles deep (fom the ocean floor down...this does not include the 5,000 feet of water on top the ocean floor) it does not seem like forcing earth to move around down there will "blow up the entire oil reservoir plus the five gulf coast states." Oil wells have been bombed in many wars, it does not cause the entire oil reservoir down below to explode. There's too much dirt on top, and that's not where the bomb would go off.

7
Because the US govt is exceptionally equipped to fix oil leaks at 5000 ft that were supposed to never be able to happen in the first place. Really?

I have no doubts BP is doing everything they can to fix the leak. Every day it continues BP looks worse so it's in their best interest to get it fixed as fast as they can. That doesn't take away their blame for this or the frustration by us at the lack of results. BP deserves our ire.

As for blaming Obama for his response, my first question to the blamer is always "what should he have done?" I've yet to see anyone answer that question in any realistic manner.

What I want from the administration isn't help capping an oil well but serious regulation and oversight for an industry that holds the world hostage.
8
See how well the free market regulates itself?
9
See how well the free market regulates itself?
10
i just don't get the sequential nature of these fixes. 1st we'll try the containment dome, that'll take 2 weeks. nope? ok, 2 weeks till the top hat. nope? ok, let's take 2 weeks to stick a pipe in the pipe. nope? ok, now let's spend 2 weeks talking shit about a junk shot. nope? ok, let's s l o w l y prepare and study a top kill. if that doesn't work, i guess we'll drill a relief well.

why the fuck aren't these things all occurring at the SAME TIME?
11
Why aren't the families of the top ten oil execs for all the firms doing ocean drilling in GITMO right now?
12
4
To suggest that the Federal Government is powerless to plug a 22 inch diameter hole a mile deep in the ocean is to accept a staggering degree of ineptitude and impotence.
Otherwise known as Obama, the Community Organizer.
13
BP is currently drilling two relief wells to pump a kill shot directly into the original bore hole. Only one is needed. They're drilling a second one in case they encounter a problem with the first. This is the final solution, but it takes months to drill. All of the stuff they're doing at the ocean floor is just a sideshow for the public until the relief well is complete.
14
I agree with Max Solomon. There should be as much parallel processing going on as possible. Sure, not every option can be tried simultaneously, but they can all be getting on deck. For example, if they'd built the big and small containment domes simultaneously, they'd have shaved a few weeks off those failures....

Start assembling the relief well platform now, while getting ready for the old concrete injection, etc. etc.

Also: is it a question of equipment? Can't any other oil companies pitch in and help out?

15
@10: Limited underwater robots, in three words.
16
@10, they're already drilling a relief well: http://www.marinelog.com/DOCS/NEWSMMIX/2…

not to say they're handling this well (haha, well) by any means...
17
I think the reason they're taking so much time is that they pretty much know everything except for a relief well has almost no chance of working. So they know that they're going to be in the public eye for three months of total disaster. So they need to string out the solutions so that it looks like they're doing something the whole time.

I keep hearing that the government has teams of scientists working on alternatives but nothing is happening except stuff that's been tried unsuccessfully on more accessible leaks in the past. That suggests that they've come to the conclusion that nothing is going to work.

I think we need to accept that nothing is going to work. Oil is going to gush at tens of thousands of barrels per day for the next few months. And large parts of the Gulf of Mexico and parts of the Atlantic are going to be ruined for years. And all of this for a source of oil that's a few percent of what the world is using.
18
Perhaps in the future it should be required to drill kill-bores/relief wells AT THE SAME TIME as the well is drilled, so that if something happens and there's a fucking OIL VOLCANO we don't have to wait three months for them to fix it.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.