Dear Stranger readers,
2020 is finally behind us, but our recovery is just beginning. Reader support has ensured that our dedicated and tenacious team of journalists can continue to bring you important updates as only The Stranger can. Now we're imploring you to help us survive another year. Ensure that we're here to ring in our upcoming 30th anniversary by making a one-time or recurring contribution today.
We're so grateful for your support. Thank you.
Comments are closed.
Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.
Sign up for the latest news and to win free tickets to events
Buy tickets to events around Seattle
Comprehensive calendar of Seattle events
The easiest way to find Seattle's best events
All contents © Index Newspapers LLC
800 Maynard Ave S, Suite 200, Seattle, WA 98134
Comments
1. The 2am pushout encourages binge drinking. When someone slams a couple of shots, the liquor takes some time to take full effect. In that time the person will be pushed out of the bar, and will be behind the wheel of their car before they realize the effect of the liquor. By then, it's too late.
2. If the person leaving a bar is buzzed, legally too drunk to drive, but not showing many signs of drunkeness, and they go out to get a cab at 2am, due to the massive number of people looking for cabs at once they will have a difficult time, giving them some incentive to drive drunk instead.
This is the current scenario. So if we do away with the 2am pushout, then we do away with these causes of drunken driving.
additionally, by doing away with the pushout, there will be less people driving at the same time at 2am, resulting in more police monitoring the driving of fewer people. This too should help.
In places where liquor service hours have been extended, these is not evidence of an increase in violence or drunken driving, and there are many indications of the opposite being true.
Extending service hours by itself isn't a cure all, but it is an important piece of solving the problems around nightlife. Add to it the other 7 parts of the Mayor's initiative and we're going to go a long way towards making nightlife better and safer.
Of course, people drive home drunk in Kirkland too, they just do it at 9pm.
I suggest that we infill the revenue lost from Tim Eyman's initiative to stop red light traffic light tickets with DUI busts of drunk drivers at ... say ... $2500 fine plus $50 for each passenger.
you can always take the bus - or walk.
And I agree, staggering service hours isn't the solution, per se, if only because it gives some establishments an unfair economic advantage, not to mention that it simply creates a new problem in that people in inevitably attempt to travel from an early closing location to a later closing one.
What I suggested to Rathburn was that the WSLCB simply grant a blanket license for establishments to remain open for as long as they choose, while keeping the cut-off time for alcohol sales - but NOT consumption - to 2:00 a.m., as it is currently. That IMO would minimize to a great extent the negative effects of "last call binging", since people wouldn't have to guzzle their drinks in order to beat the staff pulling glasses. They could sit, with the drink(s) they ordered before 2:00 a.m. for as long as the place stays open, which means the outflow is going to get spread out over a longer period of time, and people are going to have the opportunity to either sober up, or at the very least not get super drunk as quickly, before venturing out.
His concern was that it would be difficult to enforce the cut-off, because, how would you know when that drink someone is nursing at 2:30 a.m. was actually served? But, I think that's actually a very minor issue, and easily dealt with using modern technology: practically every receipt I get for purchases these days has not only the date but the TIME of purchase. All that needs to be done is to check an establishment's register receipts, and if it shows any alcohol sales after 2:00 a.m., then fine them for serving after hours.
Will, that was actually one of the major points brought up last night: many folks in fact CANNOT "take the bus or walk" from where ever they are at 2:00 a.m., because: A.) there's no freaking bus service, either from where their coming or to where they're going, and B.) walking seven or eight (or 20 or 30) miles is simply impractical. And as one unfortunate person noted, sometimes even a cab isn't an option, because, if you live too far away (say, beyond the currently mandated restricted city/county service boundaries), the cabbie is likely to dump your ass back onto the street after a couple of blocks because he'll calculate the trip as a net loss and decide it's not worth the fare.
Addressing alternative transportation options is going to have to be major component, if this initiative is going to get any traction from the community, and I believe Mayor McGinn acceded that point last night.
Just saying.
Get used to finding drunks sleeping on your front porch and under your bushes, everyone, cause you're going to see a lot more of that.
The transportation part is important, but the solutions will be longer term than the rest of the initiative.
In other places with extended or no closing times, there has not been an increase in drunk driving accidents or violence. Even within cities like Miami where a certain zone is allowed to stay open 24 hours there has not been a problem with drunk driving accidents increasing (though I generally don't like Miami's solution).
Places that have extended service hours include:
Australia - In New South Wales, there is no specified closing time. Non-residential bars can be open 24 hours.
Belgium - There is no legally mandated last call in Belgium; many bars will stay open all night.
Vancouver BC,. - Last call is 2:00 a.m. provincially, however municipalities can raise last call up to 4 a.m. if they so choose. Downtown Vancouver's last call was moved to 4:00 a.m. but was subsequently lowered to 3 a.m. People may purchase "off sales" bottled beer and the like from local Pubs until 11:00 p.m.
London/ all of the UK - From late 2005, drinking establishments could apply for licences to stay open and serve alcohol for 24 hours a day.
US City specific laws
• Albany, New York - 4 a.m.
• Atlanta - 2:30 a.m.; 4:00 a.m. in Underground Atlanta.
• Atlantic City, New Jersey - 24 hours
• Bloomington, Indiana - 3 a.m.
• Buffalo - 4 a.m.
• Chicago - Some bars may choose to close at 2 a.m. or earlier. They may alternately get an extension which allows them to close at 4 a.m. or earlier. On Saturdays, closing times are shifted an hour back to 3 and 5 a.m.
• Cleveland - 2:30 a.m.
• Columbus - 2:30 a.m.
• Florence, South Carolina - 2 a.m. for hard liquor, 3 a.m. for beer.
• Granite City, Illinois - Weeknights 2 a.m. Weekends 3 a.m.
• Indianapolis - 3 a.m.
• Kansas City, Missouri - 1:30 a.m. for most bars, 3:00 a.m. for specially licensed bars in certain geographic areas. 6:00 a.m. for one bar only, the Mutual Musicians Foundation.
• Las Vegas, Nevada - Bars may stay open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
• Lexington, Kentucky - 2:30 a.m.
• Louisville - 4 a.m.
• Miami - 5 a.m.; Bars may stay open 24 hours, 7 days a week in the Downtown Entertainment District
• New Orleans - Bars may stay open 24 hours, 7 days a week.
• New York City - 4 a.m.
• Pensacola, Florida - 3 a.m.
• Peoria - 4 a.m.
• Savannah, Georgia - 3 a.m.
• St. Louis - 2 a.m. on Weeknights, 3 a.m. on Weekends
• Tampa - 3 a.m.
• Tuscaloosa, Alabama - 2 a.m. Monday-Thursday and Saturday. Close at 3 a.m. on Friday nights.
• Washington, D.C. - 3:00 a.m. on Friday and Saturday night, 2:00 a.m. other nights.
These cities have later closing times than their neighbors. They have not seen significantly higher drunk driving accidents resulting from their later closing times.
That being said, I thought several good ideas for alternative transpo were brought up: jitneys, limited route buses, smaller coaches with flexible routes, etc., etc., but at the same time, McGinn admitted that issues such as increasing the number of taxi licenses, breaking down the geographic restrictions, and even the cab lobby itself were going to be perhaps the most difficult things to work out, even more so than dealing with WSLCB, if I heard him correctly.
I do think that if this happens, we will see an increase in DUI arrests. No matter how many police are dispatched at 2AM, there are guaranteed to be some drunk drivers who slip through the cracks due to police officers being tangled up with other DUI arrests. Having the closing times staggered will allow for the police to have more opportunity to punish those who make the bad decision to drive home drunk.
It's as if some of them had never left Washington state, never seen a place where adults are presumed to be able to moderate their own consumption.
With all the overpriced and unavailable parking, no drunk is going to hightail it to Seattle after his favorite watering hole in Issaquah shuts down.
Most likely he'll have stocked up at home from Costco.
1. Let the bars serve all night. People will drink if the want to drink. Bingeing is bad. Overloading police is bad. Long waits for taxis are bad.
2. Require bars to make water freely available and easy to find.
3. Require bars to stay open for one hour after they've served their last drink.
4. Relax the street-food laws. Food is the drunks best friend.