Comments

1
Yes, let's fix unemployment and the economy by getting people to not spend any money. Genius.
2
They've already rented buses for the trip down to Olympia. Fact collecting, how does it work?

The Stranger's coverage is just as faulty as the rest of MSM.
3
I have had this sentiment from the beginning. The stranger seems to have changed its mind about the occupy Seattle movement. The moral: occupy Seattle is useless and the stranger really is the sum total of A. Birch Steen's weekly assessments.
4
@3: It's not so much that they've changed their mind as it is they flip-flop more than Willard Romney and are utterly opposed to taking the five minutes to collect facts before spouting off in their little blog here.
5
Tell me about the rabbits, George.
6
@3 and 4: From where I sit, the overall message has actually been pretty consistent:

There's a lot of potential in the Occupy Seattle movement, its focus on income inequality is right on, and it sucks when the movement loses focus and/or engages in misdirected, unhelpful actions.
7
Olympia is a scant 60 miles away. I think Occupy Seattle can protest labor conditions at Walmart, celebrate community at Westlake, march in Solidarity with Cario on Friday, and still make it to Olympia by Monday. Also, if you read the signs at Wal-mart (From the Seattle Times video I suspect you weren't there, Eli), they were not anti-consumer signs, but rather focused on Walmart's labor policies.
10
@7: You can't possibly expect him to spend more than a few minutes actually TALKING to the smelly hippies, could you??? I mean, I know he's supposed to be a reporter and all, and part of reporting is talking to people and collecting both sides of the story, but this is someone who can't be bothered to check the occupy website and see that they already have plans for a carpool to Olympia. In fact, he would also have seen that the trip to Olympia has been in the works for at least a month now.

But it was very important that he get his reactionary images up here on his blog. Gotta get those pageviews, you see. Eli Sanders gotta make some dough from ad revenue, and he doesn't really care how he gets it.
11
Doom, you, of all people, should be the last one calling anyone else "stoopid."
12
Bunch of white college kids yelling at working class black, brown and Asians. Lol!
13
Hopefully while you watch reality unfold in Olympia (ie. watch our government learning to live within its means) SCCC will clear out the lord of the flies camp you've built. Don't hurry home. And remember to leave your mascot Jennifer 'the boil' Fox in a rest area.
14
@7:

"It's not your purpose in life to be a consumer!" yells one protester at the people going into Walmart.
15
@14: One protester? Not all of them?

Flip-flop.
16
Buy worthless Chinese shit at Walmart, support the economy.
17
oh, come on now. be nice to the stranger. it's a blog, not a newspaper.
18
Eli, there's a fuckload of carpools (and buspools and transitpools) going down to Olympia. If you attempted something approaching journalism by walking the two blocks down to SCCC from your office, you might not have embarrassed yourself and your paper so much.
19
... and you use a Seattle Times video as basis of your criticism. What a fucking hypocrite.
20
@15:

A 23-year-old protester, who goes by "Brit" and says she works as a barista, explains, "If we all chose to pay a little more, we could shop locally," meaning not buying the cheaper, imported products.


@18: Click here and check the date.
21
LOL at all goofy bumbling naive white Seattle libtarded "progressives"!!!!
22
@20:

That's the Seattle Central Community College Student Lobbying Committee, not Occupy Seattle. In your blog post, you criticized Occupy Seattle for not organizing carpools, which they are.
23
@9, what does what you said have to do with what I said? Also, thanks for calling me "stoopid." Very civil of you, shithead.

Obviously jobs going overseas is hurting the country and made-in-China-headquarters Wal-Mart is not a good place to spend your money, but I've seen many postings on OWS pages and other sympathetic places talking about how Black Friday is the worst thing in the world and that we shouldn't spend any money on anything. I just think that's not the real issue, and obviously if "we" (why did you keep putting that in quotes?) were to not spend any money, the economy would be affected and even more jobs would be lost. Shopping on Black Friday isn't going to fix things, but railing against the idea of putting money into the economy isn't either. Weakening middle class income and the associated lack of spending is one of the things screwing up our economy.
24
@9, actually, I read your comment again and I really have no idea what you're talking about, except that you like replacing "u" with "oo" in various words.
25
Mercer Islamd.

Ever hear of it.

Hard to walk around without bumping into a one percenter.

Why not go to the source??
26
I think Occupy Seattle should stop attacking normal citizens. Seriously, when you block traffic, you piss off most of the people you are seeking support from. When you stand out in front of a Walmart and criticize their spending habits, you alienate yourself from the 99% and come off as condescending douche bags.

Occupy Seattle, stop attacking citizens! Get off your ass and give us a reason to support you, so far your striking out.
27
@25, Mercer Island actually has plenty of areas that are full of quite modest homes and apartments. And Capitol Hill has some pretty big mansions.
28
#26

I am all for class warfare, as long as it doesn't affect my ability to get a spectacular bargain at Target. Like yesterday, a Kitchen Aid mixer for $199...so I could make that ancient bread that SLOG told me about.

There are thousands of one percenters around Seattle...almost none of them shop at Walmart or Southcenter.
29
#27

Even better...take Metro...go to the source and leave us Middle 80% alone.

30
Amen Kinison, well stated. The Occupy Seattle people do not get that, however. They thrive on rattling controversy, no matter if it hurts their cause or even the people they purport to support. It is really a shame, too--I would love to say I support this cause, but myself along with the vast majority of my very liberal and potentially "supportive" friends just think these people need to give it up, and stop annoying us all with their street theater. And then once you walk by the tent city on SCCC's lawn and get a whiff of that...whew...a pungent mixture of booze, cigarettes, pot, and poop...
31
@18
Perhaps he avoided walking to the SCCC encampment to ask questions because he wanted to avoid the stench.
32
This is what happens when your movement is controlled by anarchists and communists and others who just don't really get the 99% that is not them.
33
I'm on the east side of the state, where the Most exciting thing for people to do is shop at walmart on black Friday They defend walmart, vote republican, hate taxes and the chinese. Occupy crowd would do better to come up with a rational way to tell these people that walmart doesnt care about the community, the republicans only want your votes, the taxes they raise in the community don't pay for basic services so they take from Seattle, and 99% of the stuff in the house is cheap Chinese crap.

Until they can come up with that rational argument these people will view the crowd as a bunch of dirty hippies. I don't like it either, but it is the truth.
34
The ability of local Occupiers to take constructive criticism, especially from reporters for media outlets they thought were in their pocket, is truly inspirational.
35
If The Stranger's coverage has seemed inconsistent, it's because some "reporters" (like Goldy) think OS can do no wrong, while their actual reporters may turn a critical eye on the dumber things OS does. Like waging war on the 99% they are supposed to be fighting for, as @ 26 astutely points out.

The Occupy movement should jettison all the anti-Capitalist dopes (who I'll label "the other 1%) and focus on income inequality, unfair taxation, and trade policies that benefit no one but the wealthy, and stuff the other shit down a hole.
36
I support/participate the OWS movement and OS. I do not agree with all the actions they/we take. The movement is a lot of people, some with ideas I love, some with ideas I very much disagree with -- and some with the boldness to actually act on their ideas (which I respect).

I am planning to go down to Olympia Sunday night/Monday morning and it sounds like a lot of OS folks are planning to do the same.

I have found the coverage in The Stranger/Slog to be pretty fair, even when critical (and even when critical in a way I disagree with).

I also am reminded that when something with this movement, which I appreciate and have high hopes for, happens that is contrary to how I feel things should go -- it only means I need to get off of my blog-commenting ass and participate a little more.
37
I'm in solidarity with OWS, and I went Thursday night black Friday shopping. I am unsure if I could get a power drill or steam mop made locally. I'm not anti-globalization though I do believe it's effects could be different. The job creators are individuals with disposable income. You can't supply with out demand.

I have a small tribe of nieces and nephews and plan on getting them presents from Top-Ten Toys, Math & Stuff and University Bookstore. They'll all grow up to be engineers if I have any say about it :p. I was down in Enumclaw for Thanks Giving, and I am at work today here in Seattle. I'll pay whatever prices in the ensuing weeks for their gifts.

And I've got a carpool to Oly already squared away.

38
Why are Walmart shoppers so...poorly spoken?
39
If you think Occupy should be different, I would encourage you to participate. It's a collation of those who've showed up. If you think occupy should be more moderate and well considered, then round up a bunch of your moderate and well considered friends, propose your idea to the group, and make it happen. If that process doesn't appeal to you, come up with an idea, organize people, motivate them, and make that idea happen independently. Just do something because comment quarterbacking doesn't accomplish anything.

As much as Eli's coverage of the Walmart protest and carpooling was a bit thin he's at least using his megaphone to propose an agenda.
40
@22: No, I suggested they focus on arranging more carpools to Olympia rather than wasting time on things like the Renton action.
41
#39

Right, because writing something in a blog is so much more proactive than writing a comment in response to the blog.

What many of us are saying seems to be that we think what OccupySeattle is doing is stupid and counterproductive and we wish it would go away. Clearly when ever someone proposes anything rational...like actually protesting a 1% person, there is either a stunned silence or a vague grumbling about "Chase bank"

At this point, I have my suspicions about what drove Occupy and it ain't social progress.
42
I like to imagine the crowd that might have shown up if this had been promoted as news before the event, like the "earnest", sanctioned, non-major advertiser disturbing Westlake event was.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Occupiers 'Flash' Message to Black Friday Shoppers‎
NBC San Diego - Gene Cubbison - 6 hours ago
Walmart opened their doors before midnight to encourage early shopping.(AP Photo/Noah Berger) For Occupy San Diego activists, Black Friday was a time for ...
Occupy San Diego Goons Invade Wal-Mart - Leave 75 Carts Full of ...‎ Human Events

Occupy OKC protesters in Wal-Mart
‎KFOR - Tara Blume - 6 hours ago
A group of Occupy OKC protesters are arrested inside a local Wal-Mart in Del City. The activists began chanting inside the store when managers asked them to ...

Occupy Honolulu Protests Black Friday at Walmart
‎Honolulu Civil Beat - Sanjeev Ranabhat - 22 hours ago
Walmart shoppers encountered Occupy Honolulu protesters who encouraged people not to spend their money at the store. ...

Occupy New Port Richey Performs Flash Mob at Area Businesses
‎Patch.com - Alex Tiegen - 7 hours ago
The Occupy members left and moved on to a nearby Wal-mart, in which they performed the complete routine. The Gulf View Square Mall is owned by Simon ...
43
occutards damage north seattle bank

http://spdblotter.seattle.gov/2011/11/26…
http://tinyurl.com/75xotye

« Previous post  |The Blotter Home Page

Significant property damage at North Seattle bank

Posted by Detective Mark Jamieson

On November 26th, at approximately 2:50 am, unidentified suspect(s) used unknown tools to shatter and/or break holes in nearly all of the windows and the ATM screen at a bank located in the 1000 Block of NE 63rd Street.  A large spray paint tag was left on the bank’s southwest exterior wall that read, “REVENGE FOR OCCUPY OAKLAND”  No entry was made into the bank.

It is estimated that the damage to the building in the tens of thousands of dollars.

Responding officers canvassed the area for any potential witnesses and additional evidence.  If anyone has any information on this crime, please contact the Seattle Police Department.  Detectives will now handle the follow up investigation.

45
Black Friday shoppers spent over 11.4 Billion. This was over a Billion more than they did last year. Occupy, the 99% has spoken. What no twinkle?
46
@44: Ken, employment and civic engagement are not mutually-exclusive. Some people work and find time to watch Wheel of Fortune or people throwing balls around on TV. Some people work and find time to make political demonstrations happen.
48
"Why are Walmart shoppers so...poorly spoken?"

Because they are poor. But thanks for looking down on those you claim to support; is it any wonder so many vote Republican when liberals like you sneer at them?
49
@47
For those with limited time, which is most everyone with work and kids, one way to support the 99% is with economic choices, like not shopping at corporations whose ideals and goals are antithetical to the 99%. I agree that it's a complicated message to transmit, but I don't feel @3 useless, @6 misdirected, @32 controlled, @40 time wasting, or @41 stupid and counterproductive trying.
50
Eli, I figured you and The Stranger would be lauding this type of activity. The Stranger's position on so many government policies is to make people hurt in order to change their behavior. You think people shouldn't drink soda? Tax the soda! You think people should be taking the bus? Tax the living shit out of them so it becomes prohibitively expensive! You want people to stop supporting businesses that have shitty labor laws? Make them go through a wall of protestors!

#OccupySeattle: The people going to Black Friday are already hurting in the wallet, especially at Wal-Mart...probably especially in Renton. But, they're part of the problem, right? They're part of the problem for shopping when all the best sales are going on so they can stretch their dollar at a place that has shitty labor laws and shitty pay so people who are already getting shitty pay can pay as little as possible. They're the problem, right? Because they're the cogs in this cycle of abuse with the least individual leverage.
51
@23 'they' keep putting 'we' in quotes because this 'movement' locally was never about 'us' but always about 'them' and their skewed, cherry picked professionally outraged idea of the world.
52
@49

"too complicated to transmit"

WAhhh,,,,you just dont understand!!!!!

Normal person: Hey, look, occupant, theres a billionaire right there

Occupant: Oh, no, that is a super special person who saves the world..we only protest walmart shoppers trying to prepare waffles fort their kids

Waaahhhhhhh....Im a rebel...cant ya see?1?!
53
#50

Note they never criticize any behavior that really hurts people when its part of the high tax, densifying, urban agenda run by super rich 1% Democrats.

54
A few people sent me this link to an Al Jazeera post on Occupy by Prometheus Brown of our own Blue Scholars. Definitely worth a read, whether you share his optimism or (like me) not so much.
http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion…
55
@SRotU
*points to the sign* The 1% billionaire's right there, even part of his name in it.
I must admit I haven't looked at the vid. If there were Occupiers using shame tactics on individuals, that's just gross, but they're individual Occupiers, and not the movement. They don't represent the 99% any more than you do, or any less. Obviously the focus by media on the event (any event) was whatever confrontation arose. Would a confrontation with management/authority have made it more successful?
I am totally confident that you understand the issues about Walmart and its global economic implications. As I'm confident you could come up with something snarky to say about organ harvesting in Chinese labor camps.
re: the minivan. Obviously you mistake me for some sort of empire stooge who would choose inefficient big oil supporting individual transport. People really do consider what they buy.

Have you read about how some Gates project tried to get kids in Africa to use merry-go-rounds to pump water, and then bailed when the logistics/maintenance became expensive, leaving damaged wells, and press release apologies? If you haven't it's because he has a better press agent than the individual Occupier.

Are you hatin' the message, the messenger, or the movement? (and/or my pissy blather, which would be totally understandable)
56
Yeesh, and you didn't even quote me correctly, I didn't say "too complicated," just "complicated." And it was wrong of me to conflate my presumptions of the capabilities of the proletariat with your willful suspense of reason. I apologize to both of you.
57
Occupy Seattle == Burgermeister Meisterburger
58
Does anyone else see the irony of a bunch of white college kids from Cap Hill and Seattle going down to Renton, a place they'd rather die than live in, to lecture the actual working class on their shopping habits?
59
I'll take the criticism with a grain of salt here. It's coming from a newspaper staff who said they'd rather hear Chris Gregoire speak at OS than any of their boring fellow citizens--how democratic!

"The Occupy movement should jettison all the anti-Capitalist dopes (who I'll label "the other 1%) and focus on income inequality, unfair taxation, and trade policies that benefit no one but the wealthy, and stuff the other shit down a hole."

I'm confused. Talking about the disparities in income inequality, unfair taxation, and "free" trade policies--you know policies that benefit actual capitalists, not middle class pretenders who think they're capitalists--isn't that pretty much anti-capitalist?

Oh, and consumerism isn't a way to exploit those people? I'm all for finding a friendlier way, but "jettisoning" anyone is just as silly. But this is coming from people who think the only valid function of OWS should be a Democratic GOTV operation.
60
I love shopping at Walmart...
62
I'm troubled by the unstated assumption behind these coordinated WalMart protests.

Do OWS organizers think WalMart shoppers don't know that working for WalMart is a crappy job? Or that they don't know perfectly well that the stuff they're buying is made somewhere overseas under terrible working conditions?

Are protesters hectoring shoppers in parking lots on the assumption that the poor are stupid?

Or do they just want it to look that way?
63
Those Black Friday shoppers are a serious hardcore bunch in search of steep discounts. Its a good thing nobody actually tried to physically stop them from shopping. It really could have gotten ugly. The anarchists would have had no chance.
64
"I don't think it's anti-capitalist to suggest that Warren Buffet should be taxed at the same rate as his secretary." That's neither here nor there, but that's OK. The fact is that without someone offering a counterpoint to the intoxicating fantasies of never-ending consumption and making limitless money from money, we'd be even worse off than we are now.

Also, I like the tapeworm inside me but I'd hardly stop there with my search for the cure to obesity.
65
dirac makes a great point, people have been protesting walmart for years and always the counterpoint has been, "ohhh they provide cheap things for poor people".

& during that same time the people protesting walmart also have pointed out walmart is paying shit salaries and hurting poor people with their labor policies/practices.

it would be different if all this was out of nowhere but this race to the bottom is at least 20 years old now, and in this marathon of attrition it now is obvious that no one but the waltons and their corhorts win.
66
@ 59, no. Capitalism, when well regulated and taxed (meaning the corporations and wealthy pay their fair share), does more to erase income inequality than anything else. This is what we saw from Roosevelt's time to Nixon's, and this is what we need to bring back.
67
If Walmart went bankrupt tomorrow it would fuck over working class people the most.
68
It is not bold, brave, nor worthy of respect to act thoughtlessly or in a way that harms one's own cause.
69
@67 If the global economy or significant subsections went bankrupt tomorrow (or say, slowly over the last few years as the culmination of Walmart-style hypercapitalism) it would fuck over the working class people even more.
70
@69 -- Shaming people who can only afford to shop at Walmart for doing so won't help.
71
@70
We totally agree on that. I would've rather seen the efforts in the dozens of Walmarts across the US go like this "Seventy-five Occupy San Diego activists shopped at a crowded local Wal-Mart Friday. As they approached the checkout lines, they abandoned their full ..." The ten arrests in OKC seem more a single authoratay's tackle-the-hippy over-reaction, but obviously just chanting about economic choices is a threat. Do you think that Walmart shouldn't be protested at all?
72
Look, if you want to create jobs in America, it's pretty darned simple.

1. Buy American.

2. Buy Local.

3. Stick your money in a small bank or credit union, where it will be reinvested in the local community, creating US jobs, since most of that money goes to job-creating US small business, and since they make a median $25,000 a year (the owners) they aren't 1 percenters trying to take your money and ship it overseas.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.