Books Apr 29, 2014 at 10:33 am

Comments

1
There is racism and sexism in every aspect of US culture. The only way to change that is to force a counter-narrative. If a little sexism or racism is enough to make you consider walking away from comics (a medium I honestly don't care about), you might as well reject all popular culture.
2
@1: If you don't care about comics, why are you commenting on a post about comics? Because it's just that annoying to you when someone talks about racism and sexism? Tell us more about how to force a counter-narrative, you sound like a highly successful orator.
3
I'm commenting because I keep seeing self-described "nerds" complain about how sexist and racist comics and video games are. And so I'm simply pointing out that everything--from movies, to television, to genre literature (and a good deal of non-genre fiction too) to popular music--is full of sexism and racism, and that if you're going to despair at the condition of comics (which is a waste of time), then you have to extend that to pretty much everything else in our culture. In other words, I'm telling Constant that it's just not comics, and there's no reason to pretend that they're a particularly bad area of pop culture "geekdom." They're kind of par for the course.

You make a counter-narrative by doing things like what the website he links to is doing, you do it by creating your own comics, by creating safe spaces for women and people of color to enjoy comics collectively, by providing constructive criticism of the medium (not just getting angry and ranting about how horrible it all is, which seems to be the default of cultural criticism from the Internet hordes these days) and showcasing comics that buck the trend. It's good to be critical, but emphasizing the positive tends to be a more productive channel than fixating on all the dirt of white nerd culture. If you get a diverse range of people working in the medium, the racist/sexist majority (or loud minority) will eventually find themselves marginalized.

Paul Constant does these things, but he also like to whine a lot. And I feel a little perspective is necessary. I'm not commenting just to be snarky. I'm just pointing out that this isn't just video games and comics.
4
And for the record, while I don't care to collect comics anymore, I once was a collector so I generally know what he's talking about.
5
When she gets taller, she can read comics in the shower.

Source: I got taller.
6
@5: I'm 6'5", and I can't read in the shower. What sort of low-gravity mutant giraffe-man are you?
7
Nine year old girls have no business reading Liberty Meadows. Not because I'm prudish, but because Frank Cho is a brain dead cheesecake hack.
8
High five to that 9-year-old for reading Calvin and Hobbes. That strip did more for my vocabulary and love of art than anything else growing up.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.