Recently, I was talking with my friend Jim about different kinds of BDSM scenes. Jim's a top, and one of his favorite games is acting out intense mock rape scenes with female partners. And he must be good at it, because I know he's got plenty of eager volunteers. He negotiates the scene extensively for weeks--sometimes even months. However, once consent is in place and the scene starts, I'm guessing an uninformed observer wouldn't easily be able to distinguish it from the real thing.

This is what I call a heavy fear and resistance (F/R) scene. I say "heavy" because it involves deep victim/perpetrator role-play. That's edgy stuff, because if it's done right, it feels very real. That's what Jim likes about it. "The fear, the struggle--that's what gets me high," he says. "Even though intellectually they know it's a scene, they still respond to me from that instinctive, fight-or-flight place."

When I listen to stories like this, I reflect--not for the first time--on how many different ways there are to be kinky. I think Jim's scenes are great--for Jim. But while I can be a pretty mean girl, I just don't get turned on by people I'm playing with being afraid of me. Nervous as hell, yes--that's natural. But nervous in that excited, squirmy, riding-the-roller-coaster sort of way. Not deeply afraid. So although I've had people ask, I invariably decline to do deep F/R scenes, because feeling that my play-partner trusts me is part of my turn-on.

The reverse is also true. I've dealt with kinky people who annoyed me by behaving, in the tamest of social surroundings, as if I might attack them on the spot and drag them off by the hair. It's a brand of flirtation, of course, and I think they believe I'll be complimented by it. Oooh, you're so frightening, Mistress, look how you're making me quiver! However, I don't find it flattering, and it doesn't attract me at all. It's tempting to give them a card with Jim's e-dress. You want scary? Here's scary!

Or I might say to them: Rather than imagining me to be like a kinky werewolf who could suddenly leap at your throat during, say, a dinner party, think of me instead as one of those mannered, elegant vampires. Like them, I won't come into your house--or your head, or your body--unless you explicitly invite me.

matisse@thestranger.com