Columns Feb 10, 2011 at 4:00 am

She Will Not Be Ignored

Comments

103
@98: i wasnt condoning her bad behaviour, I just think this woman has more serious personal issues than meet the eye. And advising her to stick to a unhappy sexless marriage for the sake of her kids just bcoz she is a serial cheater n deserves nothing better.

And it doesnt look like she enjoys her behaviour..she seems to practically loathe herself by openly inviting the brickbats. Again: is that all a justification for hurting so many human beings?--No! But IMO the solution lies in her getting professional help and changing her behavious patterns, not in taking the option of remaining in her unhappy marriage/ or eloping with her destructive 'true love'.
104
@103
I didn't say you were condoning her behavior, just that you were holding her less accountable because she probably needs therapy. I think her behavior shows that she knows this and doesn't care. She's always at the mercy of her passion or some shit. It sounds like she enjoys being a mess, and that's why she wouldn't give up until Dan Savage paid attention to her and posted her story for the world to see. Such a person does need therapy and will probably not get it because it's too much fun to fuck up people's lives.
105
SCIL,please, please, please get yourself fixed so that you can no longer give birth. Please do not bring anymore children into your world!

That said, I feel NO sympathy for her currant husband. He new that she was a cheater when he married her. What goes around, comes around.
106
Regarding SCIL, I completely agree with Dan. I am saddened and ashamed that the writer can claim that she is a human being, woman and parent. She needs to seriously get some therapy. She is a disaster waiting for anyone who gets involved with her. I hope she never writes in again and I feel absolutely sorry for her children who will grow up thinking their mother's behavior is normal. I can only hope that the children will come to realize that their maternal biological parental unit is a POS.
107
Please help me. I grew up in a family where we hugtged and kissed each other daily.l When I was 11 I had a Traumatic Brain Injury. I was comatose for two and a half weeks My left arm and leg were paralyzed for many more weeks. I grew up not particularly aware of the unspoken rule.DO NOT TOUCH OTHERS. Mom lives in a Senior independent living complex. The man who,lives directly across from her is a retired Episcopal priest. I have hugged him. On time intentionally teasing h im I thought I gently lifted my knee between his legs. I do not think I touched the perineum. I have been notifiedl I may not set foot on the property or in the building to visit Mom. Please advise me how to not touch anyone.

Thank you.

I 2 am nice

108
@107, a lawyer would be able to help you evaluate whether your mom's institution is acting reasonably and within the law; a therapist could help you evaluate your own behavior to make necessary changes before you face other social or legal consequences.
109
I 2 am nice, good try but total fail. Your retarded perv act is undermined by details such as your accurate spelling of "perineum." Try again, if you must. Or not, that is probably best.
110
@57
Thanks for the link to the original letter/response. Made my day.
111
Regarding SCIL, in one word: "SELFISH". Thank you so much Dan for letting her have it. She deserves far worse than what you gave her. She is willing to mess up her kids lives and the only father they have ever known just so she can get sex from a guy she knows is no good for her. Everyone knows that SCIL is gonna cheat on him too, unless he cheats on her first. On top of being selfish, her problem is that she thinks highly of men that treat her like crap and looks down upon men that treat women with respect. She gives women and mothers a very bad name and for you guys out there...RUN AWAY FROM THIS WOMAN!!!
112
Dan - Yeah she's a piece of work. But doesn't deserve to have children? wth?
113
I don't think it's possible to have a FWB relationship when one partner has strong emotional/romantic feelings and the other one doesn't. I am not sure if it's even possible to have a healthy friendship (benefits or not) with this arrangement. I am currently the "in love" side of an equation like this and it creates a perpetual motion machine of hope and misery. The person who wants less intimacy holds all the power.
114
SCIL should just keep doing what she does so well and what she wants and that is to fuck men.
115
GEEEEEEZ, just about the only smart choice I ever made in my one shitty marriage from Hell to an abusive asshole who didn't love me (yes, I knew it before stupidly tying the knot and was in complete denial way back then)--was NOT to have any children with him.

6 months after our divorce finalized, he got married to some mail-order bride from the Midwest.
My condolences to her--and any kids they might have had.
116
No, I'm not anti-kids, I just never planned on having any, especially when their would-be father was a mentally unhinged psychopath.

Okay. I'm done, and grateful not to be SCIL.
117
Dan.. Maybe you should put up a special web site with SCIL's letter and other fine examples of heterosexual marriage gone bad. Be sure to throw in some some stories on politicians and televangelists gone wild. Give it a catchy domain name and send the link to all the tight-assed senators and representatives who still think marriage needs to be protected.
118
SCIL: Please go bother some other advice columnist. Like one who is straight and specializes in dumb, yet annoyingly self important twats such as yourself. I want queer and kink topics and timely political diatribes in Dan's columns. I've got straight drama around me all the time. You people have had marriage for centuries yet you still can get it right. Dan is a treasured oasis of queer culture; don't waste that resource!
119
@ #73 ... today's euphemism for fucking is the word "dating". Let's be honest here, saying "we used to date" is therefore a lie, as the FWB guy is still fucking his ex.

In reality, FWB setups are simply this: you get to fuck someone NSA. Pure and simple. Forget being friends with them; it rarely works out, since someone is always wanting more/less. It's usually a very temporary fix for people on the go between real relationships.

But let's be clear that anyone seeking FWB setups should always make their motives known to prospective sexual dalliances, otherwise, they find themselves hooked with someone who had no idea they were being played. And in case any of you nymphos don't know: when you have sex with someone, your body releases oxytocin, otherwise known as the love drug, into your system... this is why you get hooked on the sexual partner, of course, dependent upon chemistry. This is why some people find it difficult to make the split. And this is why the FWB guy should put some time between making a NSA decision with his ex. Eventually, the oxytocin will subside and he will see the light of day. You don't want to be where you're truly not wanted, do you?

It's a cruel world.
120
YO C.R.A.P. GTFO NOOOOW UNLESS YOU WANT A CLUSTERFUCK OF HURT AND RAGE AND SHAME AND OTHER UNSEXY THINGS THAT GOES ON FOREVER
trust me, i just got out of that same situation and its still haunting me.
121
@109, doh! how could I have missed that?!

@115, they have mail-order brides from the Midwest now?
122
I really like that second later, simply because I broke up with someone, did the extremely ill-advised FWB thing... and got over him while I was fucking him. Yay! And now he's got a girlfriend and I've got a boyfriend and we are actually genuinely happy for each other!

I love being the exception that proves the rule.

I really hope CRAP (haha) doesn't make the same mistake I did, because it could have been simply horrible. Also, sounds like he/she and the ex have a good friendship; I would advise CRAP to make sure the friendship is ALWAYS first and foremost in his/her mind. Then, if they continue this ill-advised fucking, they might be okay.
123
"THIS BITCH CAN GET LEGALLY MARRIED AND I CAN'T?!?!" - love it, Dan.

SCIL, please do all the straight guys a huge favor by only getting involved with those who are looking for FWB.

Speaking of FWB, I once got myself into the same situation with an ex that CRAP is considering getting himself into. Still had feelings for him, too. And the sex was amazing. But the only thing that sucked worse than getting dumped by him the first time was getting dumped by him a second time and feeling totally used after he proceeded to completely cut me out of his life shortly thereafter.

124
SCIL should go ahead and go for her life love. Thats the only way she will be able to get over the need to be with this guy. (which had such a profound effect on her other relationships.)

When her ideal relationship finally fails, she will be able to see that she was basing her life on an unrealistic dream, and start maturing and understanding herself.
And if it doesn't fail then great.

125
for SCIL, why don't you stop thinking with the wrong end of your body and start thinking about your children? Your selfish and will always be. Why have kids if you can't think of them first? Why get married if you can't keep your legs closed? YOU are the reason I will NEVER get married, people are selfish and have no compassion anymore! Give yourself time you WILL fuck this affair up like you have every other relationship you have ever been in. NO RESPECT! NONE!
126
Dan your response to SCIL failed to offer a third probably MORE stable and responsible option. DON'T LIVE OR BE MARRIED TO ANYONE. Get your own place, have 1 stable home for your children that won't change regardless of who you think you are currently inlove with. Your love life can be lived OUTSIDE your home. They don't become your carpet bags...they are your home, you are theirs, and the dad's have a safe place to offer them too. Instead of the insane madness of a home you are offering them now.
128
I'm surprised no one's yet hit on SCIL's diagnosis. There's a word that perfectly sums up SCIL's personality, and that is this:

Sociopath

People like this are nothing but trouble; they're manipulative, charming, pathological liars, incapable of feeling any remorse for their actions, incapable of feeling love, are usually sexually promiscuous, have a constant need for stimulation, are callous, have poor impulse control, and are adept at exploiting others to support their parasitic lifestyle. It's always All About Them, and anyone who's ever had to deal with someone like this quickly learns that there's no helping these people - there's only avoiding them in order to save one's sanity.

SCIL needs some therapy, and she needs it now.
129
To SCIL:
Your life has the makings to a total train wreck and the only movie that Madonna could successfully A C T in.
When you leave your second husband for the Love of Your Life, please leave your children with him. They deserve to be raised by an adult. Whatever you decide to do, stay or go, have your tubes tied now. There is enough of your spawn in the world as it is.
130
Regarding SCIL, a lot of you guys have the assumption that she is sane. Not that I can diagnose people, but I read a lot of me me me in your letter from the opening sentences where she tells Dan she will not be ignored. I cheated on one of my boyfriends. After learning how disrespectful and painful it was for him, I never did again because I have empathy for other people and try to treat them with some kindness even if we are breaking up.
Yes, I get it that it would be frustrating if your husband isn't interested in sex. That's why you try the counseling then go your separate ways if you can't make it work. Don't fuck some other guy for months, terrorize your current husband because he provides you with a nice house. If you want to be with the love of your life, let your current husband go so he can find the love of his life. Leave your kids with him so you can keep fucking and fucking focusing on yourself, your needs and your desires regardless of who it hurts.
132
I love you, Dan, but please don't take the name of the cunt in vain. That word has been used by some men in a way that is meant to demean women. Many of us women are taking the once hurtful power out of the word by proudly calling their vagina a cunt. My ex-husband called me a cunt in a derogatory tone, and I told him, "Pity you'll never get to enjoy my beautiful cunt again."
135
@ 134 - In Britain, it is used to describe men in much the same way "asshole" is used in the US. It can be used in a unisex manner though.
Gee, another word to describe a "low woman" eh?
Zzzzzzzzz
136
Dang CRAP, I feel ya. For me right now...it's all worth it. Kind of. Takes me days to recover every time I leave him. But it's a process. Sometimes the sex is just THAT hot and the love and missing is that strong to make us into total fools...
137
If she spent as much time working on her marriage as she does pining for the 'grass is greener on the other side', she'd probably be a lot more happier, and so would her husband and kids.

She made her lot in life, time she started living with it instead of running away.
138
@ Hunter 78

I appreciate that words can have different meanings; it enriches our language. It's that cunt, in particular, has been used as a word weapon against women. It's time to evolve the negative meanings, and their power to hurt, out of our language.
139
Dan, I love your word-smithery. Please, though--refrain from using "cunty." Can't help feeling that you are maligning women w/the usage. Yeah, I say "You're a dick," "...a prick," and other male-centric words--but CUNT is so laden w/meaning (all negative) that it's quease-inducing. I LIKE pricks.
140
"Cunty"? For real? For shame.
141
Wow, everyone seems to be hating on this SCIL woman. What about all the pressures a woman might feel to have to get married? Just because you like seeing different people means you shouldn't have kids? I don't know if I can agree, although I don't know a solution for her either.
142
NO, the reason she didn't cheat on him was because in THAT relationship, the male was the jerk. If she leaves her husband to be with him, he will mistreat her and eventually dump her again. He's the one willing to treat her like the shit she feels/knows she it. She respects that. That relationship is doomed, but I don't think she'll cheat on him unless he becomes nuetered like the first two husbands.
143
To Scil, the reason you love him is that he rejected you. This makes him appear knowledgeable, since your self esteem is in the shitter. You need to start having love and compassion for yourself first, then you can start to see what an unbelievable gift your children are, whom you had the good karma to attract.
No one else will give you unconditional love like that. Be true to them. You can do it.

for Crap, of course you still have feelings for her. trust your process. either you are still a junkie using a non-lethal substance that merely wastes precious life-hours, or you are an addict using methodone, and will transition to cold turkey
when and if required. IF you can break away, it will probably save you grief in the long run; then again, good sex doesn't grow on trees...so at least enjoy it, knowing it will end someday.

Dan, I love your column. "Cunty" hmmm I get it, it's
strong, but yeah it hurts to hear that used as
the ultimate put-down when we (females) have cunts that we'd like to see as GOOD things--cunty would
then come to mean "DEEEELicious."
thanks

144
We have a cut and dry case of "dum'bitch" in the first letter and people are picking nits about the language Dan uses. Amazing.

If I were in his shoes, I'd be pretty steamed that she managed to get legally, recongized in all of the US and the whole wide world hitched, do this twice, and he in a decade+ long relationship raising a kid can't. I'm sure if he used "dickish" (which is comparable to cunty - i.e. prejorative word used against one gender or another), no one would complain. He even called her a bitch, and there's no uproar about that. I'm sure there's plenty of guys who think their dicks are pretty awesome (and plenty of girls/guys who'd agree with them). Talk about a double standard/folks looking for reasons to be offended. Seriously, today it's cunt, tomorrow it'll be something else. Meanings will always change.

Also, does she deserve to have children? In a word, no. Children are a gift, and she's wasting hers running after dick. If she is incapable of focusing of their care, then she shouldn't have had then and should probably look into making certian that she does not have any more.

(I'm pretty steamed that there are doctors who would happily fix this moron on the basis of her having two kids already, and I can't find one that'll do the same for me even though I'm around her age, childless, and have no interest in having sex.)

It has nothing to do with her ability to lust after/love more than one person, as there are plenty of non-monogamous folks out there raising well-adjusted kids. The difference between them and her is a fuckton of maturity and self-awareness, and not being a dipshit serial cheater.

So yeah, she doesn't deserve that gift, and I feel really sorry for those kids for having an immature twit of a mother. Hope the second husband is treating them well.
145
About a million years ago, there was a letter to Dan's column about some college kid who met up with a mystery "lady" who wanted him to go to a hotel room in the dark and have him lay on the bed, with the lights still off, whilst "she" came into the room with a towel over her head. The kid wanted to know if he'd had anal sex and Dan told him he'd fucked a dude.
Does anyone remember that letter and if so, could you let me know the title because I've been going through the archives and I can't seem to find it.
147
The flippant lack of respect SCIL has for her current husband is totally disgusting. Get over yourself, sweetheart. You will clearly never be happy with ANYONE until you get over the "Next Best Thing" mentality. I think some honesty with yourself about the kind of person you truly are would go a long way. Maybe it's low self-esteem?

As for your kids: My parents stayed together for the sake of my brother and I, and believe me, when they finally did get divorced 29 years into their marriage, it was MESSY. They both acknowledge now that it was a terrible reason for two people who clearly were incompatible from the get-go to stay married.

I don't know if a polyamorous relationship will work for you, SCIL, because you just sound way too selfish for ANY type of relationship.

Please do not have any more children. There are enough screwed up people in the world.
148
Great on SCIL! This selfish bitch has already given two men broken relationships and two kids dealing with broken home trauma. Get yourself spayed and don't go on any second dates without proclaiming your non-monogamy!

As for CRAP, one month of getting over an unrequited love relationship is NOT a good idea! The only successful FWB are just that, friends who only want friendship with each other despite also wanting the sex. You are not in that category and I suspect you agreed only because the break-up is too recent and you will take anything not to lose the connection.
149
SCIL seems like the kind of woman that I'd kick out of the car after she was done blowing me and not feel guilty about it.
150
SCIL's story is as old as fucking time, probably another reason why Dan never replied to it. We all have that "one that got away," "the first love," "the true love" whatever/blah blah. We only feel that way about them because we could never (completely) have them and the only time they want us is when we're with somebody else. So another possible/probable outcome of her leaving her husband for "her true love," will be that he will dump her ass, like he has before. This man clearly has no stability in his life, nor wants it.
151
is it an advise column or or is it just passing judgement? Its not about credit or sympathy. Giving advise is a position of power and should be done disinterestedly. please comment something intereseting. like what does sex mean if not reproduction? what is the diference between making a choice and behaving youself? How do you know what you want, and given that ignarance how to procede?
152
"like what does sex mean if not reproduction?"

Ask a gay guy, or a lesbian, or a straight infertile couple, or a straight elderly couple, or anyone who uses birth control.

Not that hard to figure out.
153
In fine form this week Mr. Savage! Beautiful advice.
154
For C.R.A.P. I've recieved similar offer. I told her go fuck herself. Too many other women out there and she is just a complication to your next relationship unless she dumps you before then.
155
Everything everybody's said about SCIL is right.

But I still think she sounds hot.
156
I feel fortunate that I have never had anyone like SCIL in my life.
157
Dan, you're the best and I totally love you. If I had anything to proffer up, it's that staying together isn't necessarily the answer. I watched a friend go through it up close and personal as I practically lived at his house. It was brutal to watch their eventual divorce once he became of age.

I think the gal needs to get her tubes tied and some professional help.
158
SCIL: Dan was much nicer than I'm gonna be: GROW THE FUCK UP. Period. Full stop. Pull your head out of your ass and take a deep, cleansing breath of the oxygen you've been deprived of. Seriously, women like you give the rest of us a bad name.
159
@89

That is too old-fashioned these days. Assuming that one or two dates with a person makes them your girlfriend or boyfriend is too clingy. It's better to keep your options open until you have some indication of a commitment. Otherwise you could invest a lot of yourself into a relationship and then turn around and find out that the other person thought you were dating on a casual basis. My take on it is that you can't make assumptions at all about a person's sex life until you talk about it. The first month or two of dating are really about figuring out if you even want to be exclusive or can actually see a long-term relationship. Until you have both said yes to a monogamous relationship, it's really ok to see other people. That doesn't mean have sex with everyone you date- but it does mean making time to meet other people. If you make the assumption that you're the only one, you could put 6 mos. into casually dating someone who's not that into you. Don't stop seeing other people until you are sure that you're in an exclusive relationship.
160
I liked the "THIS BITCH CAN GET LEGALLY MARRIED AND I CAN'T?!?!" part of Dan's answer to SCIL, but I didn't liked the rest of it. That must be the worst and most emotional and girly advice given ever by Dan. First of all, the kids. As some people have pointed, it's not the best for them to keep a marriage because of them. Marriage is between two people. A family has several people. Marriage can be undone, a family can't. This girl's relationships and those kids father's relationships with her or other people are not of those kids fucking business. People teach kids often that it is, but it isn't. And they've got to be taught that it is not, and that there's nothing they've got to expect from their mother or their father's relationships. Please, stop teaching your kids that Disney stories about life: they're not real, and it's not good for kids. It's not fun. It's a pretty shitty thing to do.
Second, shes an asshole, yeah. But she's not an asshole BECAUSE she can't be monogamous. She's an assholes because she tries monogamy even though it's not her thing. Because she lies to herself thinking she cheats on men because she's in love with only one. And because she's not got the girl balls to think about it and get a fucking polygamous relationship with a guy who's into that. So, she could marry. Don't be these judging assholes you're being.
161
So, i won't be judgmental. I don't know how many times this bitch spammed Dan's e-mail. And it must have been many times for him to answer AND post it here, so...
If answer letter is a counter-bully-letter answer, then bravo Dan.
162
Ok did anyone else catch the reference to Fatal Attraction...:I won't be IGNORED Dan is a reference to that movie and what Glenn Close's character says to Michael Douglas' character before she boils the bunny. So, maybe that was her lame attempt at humor?? Other than that, I agree with everyone else's assessment of her completely narcissitic and insufferable attitude. This woman will never be happy.
163
women this nasty should just consider being escorts or porno stars, and never have a relationship...and Dan's advice about staying for the kids is good...think about it...while she goes out to be banged by a stranger...her pussy whipped husband will look out for them
164
SLIC - finally a bigger pile of crap than I am! She sure sounds like a lucky pile of crap though. Gee.
165
Dan's answer to that bitch was great! She is trying to play the victim when actually she is the guilty one and has no ethics at all. I cannot stand that phony whinning.
166
For SCIL- The reason you're still "in love" with your high school boyfriend is because you've never progressed (emotionally or mentally) beyond high school. Congrats- epic fail in life.

For the love of god, just try not to bring a third child into this train wreck.
167
CRAP, nobody ever retains a FWB with their ex and magically gets back together. you previously stated you see why it didnt work and are assured you guys wont get back together but you contradict towards the end and say "we both know id prefer more". That last line my friend is your answer. dont do it. theres no such thing as as a FWB situation with an ex that ends well. THE END.
168
For all you know, the narcissist really has an inferiority complex and is looking for confirmation (from Dan and the rest of the moralistic finger-pointers of the world) of that inferiority. Whatever. But I don't agree with Dan's advice to 'stay put.' I would rather have divorced parents than cheating/abuser-doormat parents.
169
@77 You know what REALLY makes it a great joke? The fact that she's apparently oblivious to the context of that quote, and just how appropriate it is in the meta-sense. You know, since she's a crazy* drama loving bitch who cheats and seems driven towards self-destruction... her unconscious acknowledgment of that makes it FAR more hilarious.

*acknowledging difference between the borderline personality of Glen Close's character and a stupid drama loving bitch like this chick.

    Please wait...

    Comments are closed.

    Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


    Add a comment
    Preview

    By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.