Dear Stranger readers,
2020 is finally behind us, but our recovery is just beginning. Reader support has ensured that our dedicated and tenacious team of journalists can continue to bring you important updates as only The Stranger can. Now we're imploring you to help us survive another year. Ensure that we're here to ring in our upcoming 30th anniversary by making a one-time or recurring contribution today.
We're so grateful for your support. Thank you.
Comments are closed.
Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.
Sign up for the latest news and to win free tickets to events
Buy tickets to events around Seattle
Comprehensive calendar of Seattle events
The easiest way to find Seattle's best events
All contents © Index Newspapers LLC
800 Maynard Ave S, Suite 200, Seattle, WA 98134
Comments
You a tough-ass cracker.
Kudo's for also being the first author failing to touch on Detroit's integral past and present role in American music; Neglecting to indulge in it during your stay, save one warehouse party; And failing to underscore how attitudes like your stepfather's led to the depopulation of Detroit.
See you in the Central District. Or maybe not because you'll probably cross the street.
Grow up. You don't live there, you haven't lived there. It's the murder capital for a fucking reason. Detroit is a zombie that no one has told it's dead. It lumbers on, never trying in the least to fix any of its self inflicted woes. Detroit has NO ONE to blame for its problems save itself. You do not know this because you are not there. Her article is honest and no one in Detroit will fault her for that. Yes color matters there and yes she did very well managing those bondaries.. she survived.
Please pull your race card elsewhere.
I miss home sometimes so much. It's changing, it's rebuilding... sure, it is going to take years before we see any large significant change... but I know it will happen in time.
It's so funny because when I'm home, even when I am walking on the empty streets downtown, or climbing abandoned buildings in order to get a better view of the skyline... it feels comfortable, safe, even though I know it's just perception.
I visit in three weeks, cannot wait.
There is no mention of blaming Kelly O for Detroit's problems in my comment. It's merely a reaction to the boilerplate white-female-survives-black-people/neighborhood scenarios recounted in her stories. It implies there is something extraordinary and pioneering about attending college in urban blight and in your words having "survived". The author is also the one who plays the race card, creating a tone in her stories that at any moment she was going to be attacked, assaulted, or even worse killed by someone who would most likely be African-American.
And contrary to your belief Detroit is not a zombie. It's a music, art, and urban cultural mecca. Home to everyone from the MC5s to the late J-Dilla. It's the "Rock City."
Want to get coffee? : )
It has a bad rap, but shit is dog eat dog, fucking deal with it.
Read your piece. Humorous and sad. Detroit is the great American city in great decline. There's a coffee table picture book recently published that has a montage of it's decline. Check this out:
http://tmagazine.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/…
Today, it was announced that Kwane Kilpatrick, Detroit's former disgraced mayor was sentenced to up to 5 years in prison. The city has more problems than it can reckon with. Motown was once glorious. How unfortunate.
Plus, you don't seem like a very nice person laughing when your landlady's car was torched. Breaking into abandoned buildings? Not nice either.
My grandmother and mother are total 12th Street Detroiters, it's fun to see them butt heads with folks, they don't take shit. Neither do I, of course, so we argue. A lot.
Now I'm all nostalgic.
It also explains why Detroit is one of America's murder and crime capitals and Seattle so safe; there's a reason they don't film America's funniest black comedy show, "The First 48" in Seattle you know.
the only good thing abort Detroit is escaping to Grosse Pointe.
http://www.visitdesign99.com/
http://www.heidelberg.org/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/scotthockin…
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/25/opinio…
http://www.detroitblog.org/
http://journey.eyemaze.net/search/label/…
Also... One was only a victim if one Looked like a victim? Isn't that how rapists decide who they'll rape next? So... Detroit is a bunch of rapists?
Puhlease. If you are from Detroit (or any other 'real' place) and think that makes you all tough and special, get fucked. Seriously, "hurr-durr, my city can beat your city up" is a shitty argument made by weak people.
Dicktation, bitches.
Everyone is so quick on defensive when anyone says anything at all about Detroit. Truth is these stories are amazing because for most northwesterners a city like Detroit is beyond our imagination. It is so much different than any US city and words and pictures don't articulate what has happened there. I don't understand the immediate hate for someone speaking their perspective, especially when that perspective comes from a place of love. People need to know how fucked Detroit is and things obviously need to happen there so how can anything putting light on that situation be a bad thing?
@7 You have a perspective on Detroit's contribution to the past, present and future of American music? Point me to your writing. What positive have you done? If you love it so much why are you in Seattle? Get off your pity pot.
Hey angry black/white Detroit old schoolers: The author is retelling her experience. Stop projecting all of your personal experiences onto her. It aint about you. Dawg.
Hey angry black/white Detroit old schoolers: The author is retelling her experience. Stop projecting all of your experiences onto her. It aint about you. Dawg.
Most Detroiters look back at the things mentioned in this article with a fondness and love and weird admiration. Kelly O's experience was different. She obviously didn't see the beauty that arose out the ashes. Which is totally fine. Give the lady a break. It's her story not yours.
Here is something that surprises me.. I was never assaulted/mugged/monitor stolen, etc during my time in Detroit. I mean, it definitely does happen (like any other city,) and I've had my car broken into for bottle returns (10 cents each goes a long way, I suppose.)
The cops in the D are pretty rigid though, especially in the downtown/tourist areas. And I stupidly used to walk home from St. Andrews, Bookies, Town Pump or the Detroiter (etc.) alone... Sure Seattle is safer by numbers, but Detroit, the downtown area, is actually very safe. I think their crime record is 12 per 100,000 which is safer than many downtown areas, including NYC & Chicago (not sure of Seattle's.)
I say this, because I've lived here two years.. and in Seattle, 2 blocks from the ferry terminal, spit on & hit by a crackhead... was with a group of friends, not alone, and the cops did not even arrest the guy even though he was on probation for assault and four witnesses told police exactly what happened (they later did charge him, after I pushed and pushed to have it done.)
I am much more interested in perspective pieces than bland, top-level "objective" journalism. That's WHY I read The Stranger, not USA Today.
I am willing to believe all of her stories too (even the talking cat), except for the part about Henry Ford Hospital. It is a really great hospital and just because it is in the D, doesn't mean it is ghetto or low in quality at all. My guess: a) she was hopped up on meds, or b) she wasn't actually at Henry Ford or c) needed another cool story to tell so made this up.
Black people read Slog?
There's nothing like packs of feral dogs, dead bodies, and denizens in various states of mental unravelling to make one think one has indeed exited Planet Earth.
Favorite find: climbing to the top floor of an abandoned warehouse to find a mint 1969 crimson-red Shelby Mustang under a tarp. Unfortunately the freight elevator was out of service.
I suspect that calling any modern US city a ghetto does a major disfavor for families and survivors of the Holocaust. However, Detroit has won the murder capitol title more years than any other city. Heck, the tiny town of Flint, MI, chimed-in once to steal the annual title.
Comparing Detroit to Seattle is unrealistic, Tacoma, maybe.
Also 7, 17, and 19, I do understand your frustration. Kelly O could have focused more on the unity in the Detroit community. Many commenters seem to reflect the unity, although she did reflect *some* unity with the 'nub man' story and the police story.
I understand folks being sensitive to the negative tales. But it's from her perspective and whether or not you see it, it's told with love. Yes it's white girl upper (you-per) michigander love, but it's love nonetheless. And if you can't understand that, you don't know what it's like to be her in shoes. So give yourself a voice, write from your own perspective, get it out there, and tell the other tale.
I agree with #47, comparing Seattle to Detroit is absurd. You can't. Even with the music birthplace parallel. Seattle is good but Detroit is a legend. It's like comparing a spoiled toddler eating his fluffed organic carrot puree to his grandfather who lived through the depression and is nursing an Evan Williams and a Black N' Mild.
AKA Stuff WHite People Like in Detroit….you know, guys from Grosse Pointe with tattoos and chic heroin addictions. THink Spawn Range playing at St Andrews in 1991.
Detroit is and has always been packed with more trustafarians from Grosse Point, Birmingham and Bloomfield Hills than you can shake a stick at. Easy to spot them in the 80s and 90s by their tattoos, UM college degrees, heroin habits and parents in mansions. Bored white kids trying to piss off their parents by their only vaguely dangerous alt lifestyles in Indian Village.
Most now do PR work; it's what happens after 20 years in a failed band.
You, on the other hand - it sounds like you came into the big bad city prepared to treat it as a joke, with a pre-set (and fairly racist) view of it you never bothered to challenge by actually engaging with the community and the culture. Detroit can in fact be a dangerous, hostile place to live, but it sounds like that's *all* you saw - or at least, all that stuck with you - and there's so much more to it than that.
(For the record, I spent most of my life in the neighborhoods described here. I should also point out that I've been treated many times at Henry Ford, which is one of the best hospitals in the country.)
Perhaps "racist" is not the best term, however, there is a huge spectrum of racial bias, misconception and preconcieved notion in this country regarding minorities*. Kelly O just proved with this stupid article that she's on that spectrum.
*I mean actual ethinc minorities. Going to Detroit for college does not make a middle class white girl a minority any more than me going to Qwest Field for a football game makes me a Seahawk.
Get the hell out of here. Was this published as supposed fact or fiction? The liberties you take come with consequence. Also, no matter how many exclamation points, put things in all-caps or drop F-bombs, you are moderately funny at best.
Seriously,though, you should be ashamed for this publishing this dribble. You know nothing of Detroit, and this article is not representative of Detroit or Detroiters. You should at least have more respect for your readers.
— Travis R. Wright, Metro Times (Detroit)
Congratulations on having to put up with black people and poor people while you received a college education and mommy furnished your apartment. I really don't know how you managed.
I'm glad so many of you enjoyed this . . .aren't people who are trapped in heart-breaking cycles of poverty HI-larious?
"So when Kelly O sees me will she also describe me as a gigantic black lady? Is that all you saw was the "black" on people but not the humanity of those people including Nub? Post racial society my ass. Every other paragraph seemed to mention black this, or black that. I can not stand folks like that. Moving to the city to be surrounded by black folks is part of the cool factor? Are we fauna? It seems like you lived amongst Black folks, but not with them. Sad."
yeah, Deemeana, I'm sure "Kill Whitey," "Bitch" and "Cracker" made Kelly O. feel right at home amongst 'Black folks.' Typical hypocritical reverse racism bullshit. Sad.
I love this ongoing debate of what real cities and real people actually are. I thought for sure I would never here it again after McCain and Palin were defeated.
And if two big black (or white, or hispanic) cops approach you and the details of the experience don't invoke a sense of subjectivity, then go hang out with fucking Tom Cruise.
Also, this isn't a travel brochure, it's someone's personal experience. And I know, it infuriates me too when other people don't have exactly the same experiences as me!
Allow me to add my own article on Detroit so that everyone can enjoy this piece equally.
Ahem...Last summer I went to Detroit and it was great! I saw men and women and buildings, ate meal and walked dog! Uh oh! Time for bed! Good night dog. Good night moon. Good night D.
Is it my fault I was born somewhere where there was zero racial diversity? Could I control that?
When I finally made it out - went to college - it changed everything. For the better. These are a few stories of human experience. Not race. I wouldn't change any of it. If I could go back in time, and choose anywhere to go to school, I'd still choose Detroit.
You can also stick all the white-privilege assumptions somewhere where the sun doesn't shine. I grew up on a small farm, in the middle of nowhere - Lachine Michigan. I shared a tiny bedroom, in a tiny house, with my younger brother until high school. We heated our entire house with wood, and one year, when we were too poor to buy enough food, my parents illegally poached deer so we'd have something to make Hamburger Helper with.
You shouldn't assume, that if someone's white, that they have money, and/or are a member of suburbian middle class.
That truck wasn't full of Mommy-provided nice-new apartment furniture - it was filled with thrift and garage sale crap I'd collected, for my dreams of making it the hell out of Northern Michigan. I bought most of it myself doing in-home nursing jobs. I changed many an adult diaper to buy that beat-up dresser. And the college education? I'll be paying those loans back until I'm old and gray.
Maybe I should have written about my memories of being poor white trash.
That story, however, has already been told.
http://amzn.to/ak5Tmf
I love this ongoing debate of what real cities and real people actually are. I thought for sure I would never here it again after McCain and Palin were defeated.
And if two big black (or white, or hispanic) cops approach you and the details of the experience don't invoke a sense of subjectivity, then go hang out with fucking Tom Cruise.
Also, this isn't a travel brochure, it's someone's personal experience. And I know, it infuriates me too when other people don't have exactly the same experiences as me!
Allow me to add my own article on Detroit so that everyone can enjoy this piece equally.
Ahem...Last summer I went to Detroit and it was great! I saw men and women and buildings, ate meal and walked dog! Uh oh! Time for bed! Good night dog. Good night moon. Good night D.
If you're offended, you probably think you have a corner on reality. So fuck you.
More Kelly O!
Hmmm.
Hopefully present Mayor Dave Bing and others will succeed in reshaping the city. At present the consensus seems to be that there aren't enough people or funds to support all the present neighborhoods. Unfortunately politics and economics prevent reuse of much of what would otherwise be reserviceable old infrastructure. It seems likely that much of it will be demolished and converted back to agriculture or other open space and that people will be encouraged to live in areas that match what the tax base can support.
Lifting people out of poverty and reducing crime there may be more challenging and complex than changing land use.
Beware that given a few decades Seattle infrastructure could go the same way. There are many similarities between the conversion of open space to suburbs around Seattle and what happened around Detroit in the 1950's. As with Detroit lack of maintenance fails to match what is needed to maintain Seattle infrastructure. Given a few decades some of the present Seattle area mega-mansions may be abandoned or converted to rooming houses, group homes like many of the once magnificent mansions on Grand Avenue in Detroit.
=Made in Detroit=
Here's what I did complain about... You came into my hometown, kicked your feet up, and smiled in my face while telling me that you’re slumming it. I was supposed to be honored by your presence, and you were too self-centered to realize how condescending you were being.
I get to college, and you’re there. However, my classmates are predominately stuck up, trust fund, pampered Kaitlyns and Jacobs like yourself who patronize my world by making it their 'urban experience'. I don't think it’s cute that you got offered crack today by a guy with more genuine character than you will ever possess. I don't think it’s quaint that you are willing to patronize us working slob natives by having a $4 pitcher of PBR with us at Third Street Saloon. Oh My God! You stayed up all night at Detroit Contemporary standing in a corner making fun of people? Hey! That makes you an artist! You and your Abercrombie & Fitch crowd from Sterling Wheights look like complete tourists when you show up the Magick Stick trying to act like you own the place. I don't care that you're in a band, your band sucks. College is not your second chance at being cool in high school. Yes, I know where you can get some marijuana. No, I won't tell you. I don't think its ghetto fabulous that you're drinking St. Ides and Olde English.
Do you think it makes you tough that you braved the Cultural Center area bubble that is the two block radius surrounding CCS and WSU? That area is a pristine adolescent playground where you and your ilk wasted your parents’ money. I know who you are. Your work is shit. You do not possess a working understanding/definition of Post Modernism. Peter W. laughs at you. Mel R. chided you on because he thought he would one day fuck you, proving once again that he has no taste. You're beyond adulthood now and have succeeded in accomplishing nothing other than looking to like-minded failures for passive affirmation about how the world scares and amazes you. Read that last sentence again and again until you get it. Seriously, grow the fuck up.
Years have past, and now we’re both in Seattle. Have you accomplished anything? Did you at least clean up the mess you made in Detroit before you left?
In the voyage that is life you will always be a tourist, and the postcards you write are not worth reading.
In the summer of 1967, a few girlfriends and I took the bus to a friend's house near Dayton, Ohio. We got stranded there when the riots exploded. Some college friends of my parents, both teachers who'd returned to work in the Detroit school system, spent long hours huddled on the floor hoping they wouldn't get hit by stray gunfire.
I don't expect that's what broke Detroit, but the collapse of the auto industry ensured that it was never going to recover. I left Michigan in 1970, before the Renaissance Center was built. My grandparents, who lived in a nice little house in Redford Township, on Bentler Avenue, had long since decamped to Florida. My best memories of Detroit are about Bentler Avenue, and my grandma walking us to the park, or to the dime store on Grand River Avenue. There were so many trees.
I went to Wayne State, although I dropped out to move to another amazing and unique place, Olympia, Wa, where I still reside. I really loved this piece. I really love all of the memories that came flooding back, of old friends, and incredible circumstances, and YES- the human condition. I loved going to school there. I loved all of the people I connected with... like the Nub Man!
My x worked at the Traffic Jam, and we used to go to The Majestic after they closed most Saturday nights. I swear I looked at a house (to live in) on the GP/D border that was across the street from a boarded up house that said "KILL WHITEY".
Yes, I had many other parallel experiences, and I feel the need to explain the synchronicity involved in this. I rarely read The Stranger, but I feel like the only reason I went to our food co-op tonight was to look down and see "Those Days In Detroit".... as I am still living with just enough to get by, but now I have a family, 2 kids and husband. Like that. We find ourselves about to embark upon a month of fund raising, Oly style (secret cafes, puppet shows, raffles...), so we can take our children to meet our beloved relatives who are all still there. Thank you. Yes, this piece is your experience, AND it speaks of the place where I grew up and came of age, and dreamed about living the life I'm now living somewhere else. Really, I got it. And now I have it. Thanks.
Is this supposed to be an excuse? Pathetic.
I live in a Detroit suburb and I'd say half of this story is made up.
The author should teach herself "subject object predicate" before making fun of other people's English too.
"Is it my fault I was born somewhere where there was zero racial diversity? Could I control that?"
Is this supposed to be an excuse? Pathetic.
The author should teach herself "subject object predicate" before making fun of other people's English too.
Seriously, if that's Detroit "heart", I'm perfectly fine with letting you mean shitheads eat each other.
I may very well need that intensive psychological assistance you mentioned. But that's another topic for another discussion. I never argued that Detroit wasn't the shit hole of the world, my beef is with Kelly O.
I have a sneaking fucking suspicion that the only positive reviews of her article were written by her and the people that she owes money to, who want her to keep this job long enough to pay them back. I speak of course of her parents.