Film/TV Oct 8, 2009 at 4:00 am

The Coen Brothers Go Searching for the Jewish Soul

Comments

1
I request a new title for this review: 'No Country for Old Jews.'
2
I feel like I was taken for a long, dark and dirty ride, robbed of my ten dollars, and left in a crappy dank alley wathing a movie with no point and no humor. This movie was NOT FUNNY. AT ALL. You must have to be Jewish (or so fond of sucking off the Coen Brothers that your better judgment has entirely left you) to enjoy this movie. The inside jokes (the entire movie)are best left to those who are of the Jewish culture. If you aren't Jewish, or down with the Jewish, stay away.
3
@2 THANK YOU! You've inspired me to see this film.
4
@2 THANK YOU! You've inspired me to see this film.
5
The movie is more about quantum mechanics than it is about jewish culture. The main character teaching Schroedinger's cat paradox is a direct echo to the unresoved opening scene. What seems to be said here is that we can not know the question AND the answer. It is either one or the other, and the whole movie is itself just a question.
6
Thank you for the great piece. It's great to read a Coen review by someone who clearly understands - or at least thinks very deeply about understanding - their work. As a genuine fan (with the dually noted exception of Lady Killers), it always bothers me when people dismiss Coen movies as having "no point" or "not making sense" - yes, even seemingly intelligent people. Clearly, there is always subtext, and often blatant symbolism (about as subtle as a hammer to the head). A viewer might not get this stuff the first time they see it, and they might not even get it the way the Coens intended us too, but that's what's great about it. These are works of art designed to be difficult, inspiring, and open to interpretation. I am always happy that, somehow, these two philosophical pranksters are allowed to work within the Hollywood glitz-machine and consistently produce thought-provoking, often hilarious, and challenging films. Long live the Coen brothers!
7
I laughed my ass off (the nympho neighbor is mind-blowing) ... but left feeling rather confused (was this about faith or superstition?) and a bit manipulated (the dream sequences went a little over the line) and the set design started to grate on me (think= Wes Anderson goes IKEA shopping in 1972). My vote for Weirdest Film of 2009.
8
@7

Most faith is superstition.
9
"I think bagels are weird and ethnic-y"
-greatgoshalmighty

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.