Comments

1
Well-written book with a cheesy ending. Can't imagine the movie could be better. McCarthy is sort of like the american Lars von Trier or Haenke. He is a sadist, but even more, he is uber-masculine, obsessed with what it means to be a MAN, which limits him, pushes him ultimately into sentimentality and melodrama in his prose. Can get very tedious the more you read him, "All the Pretty Horses" being a good example.

Coetzee is better, so much better; similar style but not limited.

Wonder what McCarthy's relationship with his father is/was like. Not good I'm thinking.

Also significant that the Coen's chose McCarthy for one of their films. Another duo obsessed with "real men," albeit probably more out of nerdy self-anxiety than pleasing an elusive dad figure.

Anyway, it does get tiresome, all the macho shit.
2
the ending is not cheesy. it's a major part of the theme of the entire book. the man has hope and faith despite it all throughout nearly every interaction with the boy. and he carries that to his end. and it has to mean something at some time. douche.
3
@1,You do have to have somewhat of a sociological imagination when reading books about characters from another time and place than now days, Seattle.

Not having seen this film yet, I have hunch Andrew is correct in evaluating it as falling under the category of things much better imagined than seen. Still, I can't wait to see this -
4
Charlize Theron's character is more prominent here because Theron's company optioned the book and produced the film.

I think your penultimate sentence says it all. Some books just don't lend themselves to cinematic interpretation.
5
I've always hated blowhard snobs like realman.
6
Realman? Really? Genderality is the core of your argument? If you think about the content and style of the writer, what else would you expect? It's like expecting Frank Langella to be a good Mary Poppins. You insert your premise like a 13 year old in a brothel. Seems absurd.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.