Jesus fuck. Between the camel toe flash at 1:25 and the harmo-NO-zing at 2:34 you've driven me to get the hell outside away from my computer on this beautiful day. So..thank you?
P.S. I looked her up just now, and though of course if the internet is a race we here have lost again, that aside an interesting comment credited this video as a manifestation of the "Dunning-Kruger effect".
The Dunning-Kruger effect describes a cognitive bias in which people perform poorly on a task, but lack the meta-cognitive capacity to properly evaluate their performance. As a result, such people remain unaware of their incompetence and accordingly fail to take any self-improvement measures that might rid them of their incompetence.
And also that what we (putatively normal) viewers are experiencing is called Fremdscham, the almost-horror you feel when you notice that somebody is oblivious to how embarrassing they truly are. Fremdscham occurs when someone who should feel embarrassed for themselves simply is not, and you start feeling embarrassment in their place.Â
The badness is unintentional - it's a vanity video. She's the middle aged equivalent of Rebecca Black, only less deserving of pity because she's old enough to know better.
My 3-second rule revolves around the cumulative amount of that time this women should be able to sing over the course of the remainder of her natural life.
I hope and pray those cowboys got paid enough never to have to work again after this, but something tells me their checks bounced. I'd cover my face too if I were in that video.
i don't think it is any worse than something from cher's body of work.if you took away the silly video, and added some studio work with p-diddy, this could be a cher song.
So awful it's kind of great. But watching it over and over? I don't think my ears or eyes could handle it, even though the laughter it provokes is good for the soul. Come to think of it, it gives my eyes a good workout, what with all the rolling, so maybe another viewing on mute is in order. Although when things like this go viral, it just encourages them, you know. So Dan, you're only adding to the problem.
Thank you, Gus, for explaining it and giving it its proper name.
Surgeon General's Warning: Repeated viewing of "Three-Second Rule" can cause reduced libido, ear infections, erectile dysfunction (in men), aesthetic discomfort (in women), and brain damage.
Maybe it's because I've got too much on my Desktop to play YouTubes well and it looked choppy and out of sync, maybe it's because I'm actually trying to work here, but I only made it about three seconds after I found out what it was all about.
Why does everyone assume that some guy is paying for this. Did you consider that she may be a successful accountant who decided o indulger herself. Or, is there an underlying assumptions that it is only men that can make a decently living without having any common sense/inteligence.
I really have no clue...I think it's genuine awfulness and not intentional, but you're guess (or lack there of) is as good as mine. But it is awful. Very very awful. Wow.
@19, yes. merely bad to many can also mean really great to many (hunger games?). this is america! personally, i think the execution is very poor. but conceptually, her "3 second rule" is (sadly) as intelligent as any other pop song today. i will give her that, and i think she has earned it.
Wow. Actually made it a minute in. Really, does the world need another reason to hate Texas? I think not.
@34 It's just the casual sexism you see every day. Another way to think about it is this-- only a man would be so blind & stupid as to encourage his woman to perform such a cultural atrocity. It's like letting her off the hook, hey? Of course I don't see it that way. I think women are perfectly capable of making complete idiots out of themselves w/o any help from a man.
I have a strong feeling she bankrolled it herself. As for "putting it out" on the Internet, I don't think she did: first time someone sent me the link, it was at Vimeo. When I revisited (I just had to), it had been made private. I suspect it was personal fantasy fulfillment -- and since when is that such a bad thing? -- that got leaked.
I was certain it was genuinely awful up until the helium voice harmonizing at 2:35. Then I didn't know what to think. Then I felt great shame for watching to that point.
Sincere. Satirists could never muster that many clean-cut guys who can also line dance. There are some hipster types (potential satirists) who can line dance, but they all are a lot more tattooed and hairy.
Like I said on the comments the first time this vid was posted on slog, she removed the video when she got the first wave of "this sucks" responses, but by then it was too late, and others had copied it and re-uploaded it, so she's not even making anything off the fact that this has gone viral, someone else is.
It might have just been a bit of fun for her, but like they say; "it's all fun and games until your really bad video goes viral."
I'm guessing this is the result of a therapist encouraging her to give her dreams a shot after she's spent a lifetime of putting other people's (children, husband) needs first. And by god, if that's the case, then more power to her.
Also, the assumption that she wants strangers to assess her fuckability (ahem, 5280), simply because she indulged in this little vanity project, makes me despair for humanity. I wouldn't fuck her either, but I also wouldn't presume that she's asking me to.
I am surprised and disappointed that you would expend such mean-spirited criticism on a national site toward someone whose greatest crime is lack of talent. You think no one's pointed this post out to her? You owe her an apology, Dan.
Please tell me this woman is from The Real Housewives of Dallas. Why hasn't anybody been honest with her? 30 years ago, somebody married this woman because she was hot.
-Bankrolled by husband. He sprang for a month vacation in the Mexican beach resort so she could write the songs.
-She started voice lessons 2 years ago.
-She's way into Jesus.
-The videographer charges $2000 for an all-day wedding shoot. I imagine the 8 models, makeup, wardrobe, lighting assistant, and location cost a bit. http://proeditproductions.com/
I think we need to look at each part of this video.
Production value isn't bad. Not big leagues, but good cuts, some synchronization of the dance. The choreography is definitely amateurish. For the production value, I wouldn't expect Glee.
The voice is flat, and I agree with @5, the harmonizing at 2:34 definitely needs work. Audacity has a nice pitch modifier you can use. Some notes are hard to hear.
On the tune- I must admit, I watch it this morning and the tune stuck in my head (the chorus anyway).
On the energy - she's definitely having fun. The cowboys seem to be enjoying the paycheck. More power to both her and the cowboys. I do music videos with my kids, and we do it more for fun. Sort of like being in a play - the players are having a lot more fun than the people watching it..
On the Jesus thing - yea, she definitely seems religious.
Which leads to the genuine criticism/issue with the video - the message. Basically, the messages are: (1) you need to control your man and to do this you need rules, just like high school (!) (2) looking at other women is okay as long as it isn’t too obvious. This would work if you man is, well, in high school and hasn’t learned this by being with a woman for more than 5 minutes in his life. That being said, half of country songs have this theme. See Shania Twain's "Any Man of Mine" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8N2k-gv6x…
All in all, fun to watch in a car-wreck sort of way.
Filing this one under #strangeritualshearingpeoplehave
Honestly, I'm baffled. 3 minutes 30 seconds to sing about something in 3 seconds? The men all covering up their faces? They stand in front of a rope and turn around? Three seconds to come? Three seconds to what? (No, don't answer.)
I love how so many people jumped to the conclusion that Dan was criticizing her looks or voice. I think she's above-average in looks for a woman her age and while I don't think her voice is anything special, I don't think there's anything wrong with it. I assumed that Dan thought the attitude of being able to keep a guy from thinking about fucking other chicks just by making sure he doesn't look at them for more than 3 seconds was the awful part, because that's also the part I find awful.
Whoever said 'cultural atrocity' nailed it. However, as a musician, I'm angry with the audio track producer. He/She totally fucked her over. For what Lisa (and her rich husband) clearly spent, she could have afforded a decent band to do this track. Instead, the unscrupulous producer pocketed all the dough, then computer generated the cheesy Casio-tone track himself instead of doing right by her and spending on local musicians for a studio session.
Am I reading too much into this? Listen to the track again and tell me I'm wrong. Wait. Maybe that's not such a good idea.
@10 & @46 nailed it. Who's more pathetic, the woman who at least spent some time, money and effort to realize her country-star fantasy, or those who take a few minutes to insult her before going back to Angry Birds? Vanity projects are what they are, wish-fulfillment for the person who does them. Personally, I think they should be encouraged, because 1 in 1000 will turn out to be awesome. Haters like you all just discourage people from TRYING to be creative -- in my book, trying and failing is better than not trying.
Vanity videos don't bother me. She wanted to feel like a music star and paid for it. So what?
I think it's hilarious and, of course, pretty terrible. Someone please forward this to John Waters.
It is a useful tool for exposing how petty and hateful a lot of people can be toward another's idea of letting their freak-flag fly. Critiquing the music/concept/video is fine.
Commenting on how unfuckable she is? Well, some people have never left High School behind have they?
I just don't see what's so bad about this. I mean, it's not good, but I'm pretty sure most people wouldn't be any better than this if they tried to make a country music video.
She and her husband may both be into Jesus, but I was getting a DEFINITE femdom/cuckold vibe from the whole thing. She makes him turn his eyes away after three seconds, but there she is cavorting with a whole truckload of hot young men, one of them (gasp) black! Not that I would consider that anything notable, but in the culture she's from, absolutely. That along with the obvious fun she was having made me overlook her vocal inadequacies.
OK, so having read thru the comments here, I'm LMAO. Wow. Well, you know, she looks like she's having fun. Ultimately, I think that's all that matters.
But wow, as some of you said, others have never left high school, have they? Why does the appearance of any woman, under any kind of circumstances, warrant a fuckability rating?
@92 Yeah, my first thought was along those lines: her man (all 8+ of them!) get three seconds to look at an attractive woman, but she gets to dance around with eight moderately attractive younger guys? But I suppose that's just because men, sex-crazed animals that they are, have to be kept on a tight leash to keep them from cheating, amirite?
Go ahead. Leave the house.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/evol…
On Slog our chief practitioner of Dunning-Kruger is Will in Seattle, and the person who most keenly feels the embarrassment in his place is Fnarf.
Okay, into the sunshine I go.
Now go outside.
Thank you, Gus, for explaining it and giving it its proper name.
I made it 43 seconds in. The same impulse that makes us watch car accidents is luring me back. Must resist!
BTW, she needs a refund for her bad plastic surgery
- a little offended
I vote unintentionally awful.
@34 It's just the casual sexism you see every day. Another way to think about it is this-- only a man would be so blind & stupid as to encourage his woman to perform such a cultural atrocity. It's like letting her off the hook, hey? Of course I don't see it that way. I think women are perfectly capable of making complete idiots out of themselves w/o any help from a man.
It might have just been a bit of fun for her, but like they say; "it's all fun and games until your really bad video goes viral."
Also, the assumption that she wants strangers to assess her fuckability (ahem, 5280), simply because she indulged in this little vanity project, makes me despair for humanity. I wouldn't fuck her either, but I also wouldn't presume that she's asking me to.
Dan's response is like putting up a picture of someone unattractive and going, "UGLEEE!!"
Grasp how serious this is; I just got done watching the Nostalgia Critic's review of North.
Use this information only for good.
Is pedophilia a mental illness?
This video is Kryptonite for intellectuals.
(I'm trying to decide if it's red or green.)
Peace.
(Probably red.)
Also, I'm gonna go claw my eyes out, and rip my ears off, after hearing that.
Like John McCain before her, Rebecca Black has one hell of a lot to answer for.
http://www.reverbnation.com/lisagailallr…
-Bankrolled by husband. He sprang for a month vacation in the Mexican beach resort so she could write the songs.
-She started voice lessons 2 years ago.
-She's way into Jesus.
-The videographer charges $2000 for an all-day wedding shoot. I imagine the 8 models, makeup, wardrobe, lighting assistant, and location cost a bit.
http://proeditproductions.com/
-Her vocal coach and producer would appear to be this gent:
https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=…
Is pedophilia a mental illness?
Production value isn't bad. Not big leagues, but good cuts, some synchronization of the dance. The choreography is definitely amateurish. For the production value, I wouldn't expect Glee.
The voice is flat, and I agree with @5, the harmonizing at 2:34 definitely needs work. Audacity has a nice pitch modifier you can use. Some notes are hard to hear.
On the tune- I must admit, I watch it this morning and the tune stuck in my head (the chorus anyway).
On the energy - she's definitely having fun. The cowboys seem to be enjoying the paycheck. More power to both her and the cowboys. I do music videos with my kids, and we do it more for fun. Sort of like being in a play - the players are having a lot more fun than the people watching it..
On the Jesus thing - yea, she definitely seems religious.
Which leads to the genuine criticism/issue with the video - the message. Basically, the messages are: (1) you need to control your man and to do this you need rules, just like high school (!) (2) looking at other women is okay as long as it isn’t too obvious. This would work if you man is, well, in high school and hasn’t learned this by being with a woman for more than 5 minutes in his life. That being said, half of country songs have this theme. See Shania Twain's "Any Man of Mine" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8N2k-gv6x…
All in all, fun to watch in a car-wreck sort of way.
Personally, I'd rather make a very bad video than live my life in fear, wanting to but being scared of this kind of judgy meanness. Leave her alone.
Honestly, I'm baffled. 3 minutes 30 seconds to sing about something in 3 seconds? The men all covering up their faces? They stand in front of a rope and turn around? Three seconds to come? Three seconds to what? (No, don't answer.)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hcLrUMxfM…
Am I reading too much into this? Listen to the track again and tell me I'm wrong. Wait. Maybe that's not such a good idea.
I think it's hilarious and, of course, pretty terrible. Someone please forward this to John Waters.
It is a useful tool for exposing how petty and hateful a lot of people can be toward another's idea of letting their freak-flag fly. Critiquing the music/concept/video is fine.
Commenting on how unfuckable she is? Well, some people have never left High School behind have they?
'cool kid' DannyBoy mocks someone and all the mindless pathetic hangers-on jump on.
in high school it was called bullying.......
But wow, as some of you said, others have never left high school, have they? Why does the appearance of any woman, under any kind of circumstances, warrant a fuckability rating?
On the plus side this song would work well to disperse a large drunken crowd.