Music Feb 1, 2012 at 4:00 am

Is Roots Reggae Still Viable in 2012?

Comments

1
Reggae is like a yo-yo - it definitely gets old after awhile, but always seems to refresh itself in the absence. Being stoned doesn't hurt either, which is something I had the pleasure of returning to this summer - after 20 plus years!
2
The only problem with modern roots reggae bands is when they degenerate into jam band music. Need to keep it simple and tight and skip the spacey, endless guitar solos. For example, the Clash was far better at reggae than Phish, yet local reggae shows are more like the latter than the former. I'd rather pay to see a straight up cover band with no original music than the jam band crap.
3
What made Sly and Robbie, and Lee Scratch Perry, great, is that they absolutely REFUSED to play by the rules. They invented new ones.
Remember, reggae started out as commercial pop music, something the Marley dynasty seems interested in keeping it stuck in, but the incredible range of hybrids and tangents that have sprung from dub and reggae are much more interesting than this Kore Ionz stuff, which is basically reactionary sixties revival music.
Unless you define "roots" as meaning they are suitable for playing shows at Indian Casinos, reggae has moved on.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iQVNIaod2…
4
Your example of Phish bashing doesn't make any sense; they weren't a reggae band. What they did do was make amazing original music. There is another similarity, in that most current jam bands suck, as do most current reggae bands - it's hard to put a finger on exactly why, but I think it's mainly because they write terrible songs and don't have much musical identity. Which is of course impossible to prove and entirely subjective. But, really.. it looks like reggae, smells like reggae... hmmm... but the songs suck. The great thing about roots reggae was killer songs, killer singers, killer production, killer players. Maybe it's akin to classic jazz in that sense too; you can recreate it, but there will never be another miles davis quintet or Love Supreme.
5
Kill the white people, but buy my record first.
6
I'm sure the sufferers in Kingston are concerned about life issues other than the relevance of their gospel-music-equivalent to rich (relative to them)hipsters in the U.S. So maybe we should leave the "rules" and the breakage thereof to the people who created the music, not to the people who get baked to it.
7
I have been and i still am Seattle longest resident Reggae Musician here in Seattle Washington for about 30 yrs i have watched the growth of Reggae the only two hardcore roots band are Clinton Fearon & Boogie Brown Band and uo and coming Hard Core Roots band Dub Lounge International Kore Ionz is a great band BUT THEY ARE NOT ROOTS and i say this without apology no Disrespect to them but as a Jamaican they are REGGAE with a twist as how they would be seen in Jamaica plus they are not local they moved here from Hawaii and also they not once played the local Bob Marley fest or have they teamed up with any other groups here in Seattle and some bands don,t even give respect to Jamaica where reggae comes from as i said before great band but Not ROOTS
8
i have been performing reggae in Seattle for 30 yrs and Kore Ionz is a GREAT BAND but they are not ROOTS they are REGGAE with a TWIST if you ask any Jamaican they will say the same thing they are very poppy sounding and very tight but again they are not roots SEATTLE roots are Clinton Fearon and the Boogie Brown Band and SEATTLE,s beat kept secret DUB LOUNGE INTERNATIONAL who had one of their song,s remixed by the GREAT Scientist and i feel if you where to ask anyone who is HARD CORE reggae fan they would say the same thing
9
also The Crucialites are more REGGAE than kore ionz but they get no pub at all which is a shame
10
One thing about DH is that he has an opinion, negative of course, which leads me to invite u DH to come to nectar and be around some positivity..peace DH and to original roots music I'm glad Kore Ionz represents roots with their own twist!!
11
Yeah! What's up with the Crucialites lack of respect in this town?
12
people spend so much time classifying and organizing things into genre, which is super annoying (and often incorrect and illogical), especially when it comes to the arts! Just enjoy it for what it is, which is neither any of these categories or examples, nor can it be entirely separated from them. Promulgating the death of raggae seems a bit like Nas saying that hip-hop is dead, except the person saying it doesn't do it with a good heart or sound; nor do they have a long history and respectable reputation with the art. Calling it a freeze-dried pet sounds like a white person fetish/attachment for their non-soulful rendition of soulful arts that they can't seem to live without, which is not what kore ions is doing (and those who are, you know who you are! I.e., "modern" blues, jazz, soul; (most) white hip-hop, spoken word; etc.). I guess it's not that surprising that writers in the stranger, which, in my limited experience, has all too often been controversial wanna-be hipsters who are too high strung and critical to channel the good spirit of the ganja, have the audacity to call a genre dead, as if they killed it. In the increasingly globalized world, I think Kore Ions genre-bending-rule-abiding-so-called-dead-genre-posiing/reviving-etc. efforts reflect the increasingly globalized world, which warrants lots of criticism but also presents amazing things to appreciate. Peace and Love
13
roots shmoots. kore ionz have soul and passion. you can hear it when they perform live or listen to their album. why don't we just let them play their thing, influences aside? Inspiration comes from all walks of life and labels are no fun. It's like food. Chocolate cake. Who doesn't like chocolate cake? Let's talk about its place of inception and bash any pastry chef who is inspired to take that masterpiece and put their own spin on it...nope, we don't really do that. If it tastes good, and to those who care, looks good; we'll eat it and be satisfied. Simplicity is best sometimes.
14
Of course the second guy is haole... always speaking out of place.
15
True roots reggae is driven by the spirit of the almighty there for we see different forms of fullness of that spirit in all groups playing.Since it is musical vessel used to bring forward that news of HIM it can never die. dem agrow tierd a see we face but them cant get we out of de race!
16
I have been in the live audio industry for more then 23 years and had the pleasure of working with this band when they came to the Bay Area last year. My company did the audio for one of the largest reggae events in Northern California for 20 years and Kore Ionz is better then quite a few of the bands that played the stage. Keep playing guys!! You are awesome!

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.