What a silly thing for the president to say. 'The pandemic has dissipated' would have been wiser.
So we're now in the rounding up people phase of what's totally not a rehash of the late 30s and early 40s. Nope. These people totally aren't nazis. No sir.
Biden's shooting from the hip'll
be good fodder for the Reich wing
to sling at the Socialists and Commies
tho the Nazis'll Never Notice
trumpf's Abrogation of
the Pandemic (now-
that Killed circa
One Million of
@2 not even close. Sending people to Martha's Vineyard is not the same as sending people to concentration camps. Your comparison dishonors those who were victimized by the actual Nazis and is offensive.
I think it's over, too. It's now ENDEMIC, like the flu, just far more contagious and deadly (for the unvaxxed).
Maybe Joe jumped the gun by a few months, but everyone is profoundly Pandemic-fatigued. My impression is that those still dying in the US are unvaxxed idiots or have serious co-morbidities. And poor people. Poor people always have worse outcomes.
@4. Okay snowflake.
It has to start somewhere. Germany didn't jump immediately to gas chambers.
@4 why don't you tell these holocaust survivors they are being offensive: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-01-21/holocaust-survivors-what-worries-them-about-today
Having a highly contagious & mutable virus that causes chronic, debilitating health problems become endemic is bad actually and all the more reason to enforce simple preventatives like mask wearing & improving ventilation in schools & offices.
The virus doesn’t care that people are fatigued & our collective failure to address these ongoing issues will only make escape mutations more frequent & leave us vulnerable to the next pandemic.
@6 call me what you will but stop using the holocaust as a political tool. If you can't see what a truly awful thing that is I don't know what to tell you.
As for your article that was written in Jan and has nothing to do with the current immigration debate. In fact it speaks to the polarization of politics and the insular nature of the extreme edges. You could argue the points made are just as much about the progressive wing of the Democrats as it is about the MAGA republicans.
1. Bolt Creek update: You said "...Highway 2 remains closed to only local residents..." but I'm pretty sure you meant to say "...Highway 2 remains closed to all except local residents"
2. As the accelerating rate of extinctions bends upwards, Ants will be one of the survivors. Whether humans survives depends on whether or not virulent diseases develop enough to kill us all, like super-ebola.
The people whipping up a panic about immigrants are a much bigger threat than the people pointing to history and sounding the alarm. Given the escalation of extremism we’ve witnessed on the right over the past few years these concerns are well founded. We already have a violent and over-armed society, and there have been multiple mass casualty events in recent years from people who cited immigration and racial anxieties as their motive. If you’re more offended by nazi analogies than people following the nazi playbook your concerns are gravely misplaced.
@9 " You could argue the points made are just as much about the progressive wing of the Democrats as it is about the MAGA republicans."
I guess you could. You'd be a goddamn moron. But you could.
We're on a dangerous trajectory and there are a lot of parallels to the rise of Nazi Germany. I can't make you believe that, so keep being a good little centrist with your head buried in the sand.
I'm guessing one day you'll have a pickachu shocked face and say "how could this have happened?!" if we keep allowing people like DeSantis, Abbott and other fascists to run amok.
And if you can't make the connection between 1/6 and the emboldened behavior of RWNJs since then you are blind.
@13 Nice pivot to change the topic. If you want to believe Republicans are facists I won't stop you. I think that word is about as overused as racist anymore but have at it. Just don't invoke the memory of millions of people who were exterminated because of who they were to make your political points. We should be better than that.
4 Fuck Nantucket! Vineyard RULEZ!
DeSantis' team imitate the deplorable* "Reverse Freedom Rides" of the Jim Crow South a mere sixty years ago in the USA.
See what I did there?
right now in this country republicans are:
-banning books & restricting speech
-criminalizing reproductive health care
-actively undermining election integrity after having attacked the capitol on 1/6 for an election they lost
-calling in bomb threats to children's hospitals for providing consensual medical care
i understand the motivations of people who would rather micromanage the language we used to describe these actions instead of talking about the actions themselves but please understand your pearl clutching is not fooling anyone but yourself & your need to find equal fault with "both sides"
@17 are these things not terrible enough on their own? Do you really want to defend the need to politicize genocide so you can label your enemies? The English language is wonderful in that we have so many words and phrases to describe awful things and awful people. Use those words instead of desecrating the history of other people.
18, you have completely lost the plot and you are proving my point by getting more heated about someone calling people fascist for using the power of the state and their media allies to crush their perceived enemies than people using the power of the state and their media allies to crush their perceived enemies
Do you think genocide just happens in a political vaccuum? Like everything is totally normal then one day people are being marched to death camps? Do you think political violence is not a threat to people's lives, their civil rights, or democracy itself if it doesn't involve literal concentration camps?
We've endured 6+ years of people saying we were over-reacting to trumpism, up to and including an attempted coup, and at every step along the way people like you were tone-policing and telling people they were over-reacting. If you want to wait around for death camps before you find it within yourself to be concerned, you are as much a part of the problem as the fascists themselves.
@19 what’s really amazing to me is you are so locked into your facist war you can’t even find agreement on trampling the memory of a victimized people. Is it really so hard to agree using the Holocaust for political points is gross? I’m sorry Blip but you’re the one who can’t see the forest through the trees here.
@20. Good lord you are so full of shit.
I don't think it's 'trampling the memory of victimized people' to learn from their suffering. From my perspective this is how you honor them, and I honestly don't know how you could see it any other way. Learning from the mistakes and failures of the past is the entire reason we teach history.
Besides, it's possible to talk about the contemporary parallels to mid-century fascism without going that far because the nazis did a bunch of other bad things besides the death camp thing -- which was world-historically bad, no objection here -- including banning books and scapegoating immigrants and queer people, and it is the opposite of ahistorical to speak out when we see history repeating itself, as the holocaust survivors in the link brent provided @7 that you keep ignoring.
You are the one dishonoring their memory by using it to silence dissent against escalating political violence. You've got this whole thing upside down.
@11, If the mass killers hadn't been citing immigration and race, they would have cited something else. Mass killers have a pathology, where they irrationally latch onto some slight or grievance. The grievance can't be resolved because its irrational. So to draw all our attention to it, and escape it (by death), they engage in mass murder. If it wasn't immigration or race, they would irrationally latch onto something else.
"Do you think political violence
is not a threat to people's lives,
their civil rights, or democracy
itself if it doesn't involve liter-
al concentration camps?
We've endured 6+ years
of people saying we were
over-reacting to trumpism,
up to and including an attempt-
ed coup, and at every step along
the way people like you were tone-
policing and telling people they were
over-reacting. If you want to wait around
for death camps before you find it within your-
self to be concerned, you are as much a part of the
problem as the fascists themselves." --@blip, brilliantly
@5 -- a nasty & catchy
whist allowing Mutations
will certainly Weed Out
the naysayers but omg
the Collateral Damage
in a Nation sans Healthcare
for the "bottom" third How
on Earth can we fucking
I, for one, welcome our ant overlords.
My money is on ants and bees attaining interstellar travel before us.
"You are the one
dishonoring their memory
by using it to silence dissent against
escalating political violence. You've got
this whole thing upside down." --@alsoblip
[pardon my stacking?]
@23-- and you have the
Facts to back that up?
Yes people with grievances against the minorities & immigrants they are conditioned to fear and hate would kill other people if politicians and media figures chose to scapegoat those people instead. Riveting insight thx for sharing.
@27, They would just fixate on another source for their grievance on something else, if immigration and civil rights were discussed without fear-mongering. You would still have the Buffalo supermarket shooting, probably by the same guy, he would just be trying to draw attention to people depriving us of our fossil fuels, depriving us of disco music by conspiring to flood the airwaves with other genres, or some other obsession.
The issue is why do we have enough of such disaffected people, to make our mass killing RATE (adjusts for population differences between countries), the 11th highest in the word? What is about our culture that produces that outcome.
Hint: Most of these people were traumatically rejected in their formative years. Be it by being bullied, just being chronically not included in one clique or another, or other means, they were excluded from normal human connection.
Breaking: Mayor Harrell selects Interim Chief Diaz as the permanent Chief.
Not a very inspired choice, to put it mildly.
@30, Absent grievances against minorities and immigrants, they would just latch onto something else, and still engage in mass killing to draw attention to the something else.
So true. People would be calling in bomb threats to, idk, random country clubs & grocery stores instead of children’s hospitals if they weren’t being egged on by tucker carlson every night, something that famously happens all the time because some people simply need to threaten to blow up a building or their day is just not complete. I’m sure it is comforting to the minority communities who are being targeted by a coordinated terror campaign to know in some theoretical alternate universe people are being murdered randomly instead of for their identity.
Honestly though it speaks to your complete lack of humanity that you can elbow your way into a conversation about minorities being targeted for violence by politicians & media stars and try to argue it’s nbd because people get murdered all the time. Just glib, willful stupidity & casual disregard for the victims of an ongoing terror campaign. You’re a shitty person, neale.
@32, Yup. The targets would change, and who dies would change, but not how many.
You have to get the overall level of violence down in the society.
Mass killers are a unique category, driven as they are by their irrational grievances, born of alienation from the world they live in, during their formative years. What happens in that category, will be independent of what happens with overall levels of violence.
As far as Tucker Carlson goes (I don't watch him), the real problem isn't him, but us, and our own neurological wiring, according to this documentary series by PBS's World Channel. https://worldchannel.org/show/pulling-thread/
Are you too stupid to understand the difference between terrorism & random acts of violence or does acknowledging this difference throw a wrench in your stupid “grievance killers” hypothesis & you’re too obsessed with the smell of your own farts to let it go? Either way it sucks to be you
I thought this was interesting when I saw it a couple a years ago.
The Billion Ant Mega Colony and the Biggest War on Earth
I'm disappointed that Slog staffers haven't yet seized on the drag queen getting mistaken for Lady Gaga.
@35, Terrorism is a sub-branch of Mass Killing. Both are committed by people with grievance pathology. If you have that pathology you have the ingredients and mindset for mass killing. The only question is whether you employ the pathology for an ideological grievance, or a more personal one. Take the former off the table, and someone with that pathology will pick the latter.
It's not my hypothesis. Google it. You'll find quite a number of articles in Psychology Today and more formal studies in academic journals for the field. Google "Mass Killer Characteristics" and you find a panoply of academic research and non-fiction articles.
Ohhhh nooooo, people illegally immigrating voluntarily to the US, voluntarily got a plan to an uber rich liberal part fo the country (Sanctuary).....
Oh noooooo much concentration camp tier level evil, the horror!
Border Czar Kamala "heels up" Harris should do her fucking job and stop worrying hat govenors do.
They are in the US legally.
@40 I have seen no legitimate source say they were legally granted entry first. You can't come to the US illegally and then claim asylum in good faith. Especially considering Mexico is technically a safe country, picking and choosing where to claim asylum is laughably disingenuous as we saw in Europe (everyone passed through safe countries to get to Germany for free $$$).
Regardless it is moot, they boarded the planes voluntarily.
Conservatives think anyone with brown skin who migrates to the US is here illegally. If someone can look at an event where people are handed off from one set of federal agents to another and still think those people are undocumented, no amount of additional information is going to convince them they’re wrong. This stunt was an appeal to conservatives’ base emotions about immigrants from central/south america and it was “successful” for that reason, even if the people responsible for it might soon find themselves in hot water.
Ooh, looks like someone’s got their asylum understander cap on!
People are allowed to enter this country and surrender themselves to immigration to seek asylum. These people did everything by the book, but we all know why you will never be convinced this is true.
speaking of Hot h20
one may Kidnap
through force or
here get on this plane
you're gonna Meet
& don't Worry
about your Paperwork
we know Just what to Do with it
wanna Be ya!
pawns in their Game:
Life is Cheap
I think we should drop 'fascism' and just call it what it really is, 'Hitlerism.'
@42 Every legal analysis even from leftists rags says this is a nothing burger. But of course, you are going to circle jerk your own bias around. Getting caught by immigration after illegally arriving and then claiming asylum is disingenuous, nothing in the realm of objective reasoning will convince you otherwise because you are a partisan hack who only has appeals to emotion. You can word smith and twist it all you want to make it seem like these people followed the process, but they didn't and you have no evidence that they did.
Anyone with a shred of geopolitical understanding realizes that unchecked immigration or "asylum seeking" is a net negative. We have seen countless times in recent memory. I lived in Germany during the 2015 "migrant" shit show which turned many to the right because of it. Why? Unchecked migration of 18-50-year-old unskilled, horny, males from archaic stone age cultures wanting free handouts into the West/ Europe is a bad fucking idea. Do a google search regarding the aftermath of that if you were asleep for those years.
As I said, they signed waivers and voluntarily boarded a plane (hence all they have is a shitty civil class action). Doesn't matter if it was a stunt or not. It was effective and proves liberal NIMBYs are full of shit. Despite their cute little church buffet, the illegals were carted off the island in 24 hours so their peace and quiet couldn't be disturbed.
they was Gonna
MEET the President!
which is not OK
even if they're
we'll just hafta see
how this plays out
but the Reich wing
don'f GAF about
til they Write
It’s nice that you have personal opinions about asylum but they have no bearing on the facts of the case. These people are here legally
"The migrants allege . . . they were given misleading information promising cash assistance, employment services and housing assistance, which they called 'bold-faced lies.'"
and meet the PREZ!
sure, repubs 'do it all the time'
and think that 'makes it okay'
but they haven't Stolen
the Country quite yet
gotta Wait lads.
@22 so you and I absolutely agree on that point which is why I also think it's important to use such examples in the right context so as not to devalue the entire point you are trying to make. I'm not silencing dissent, I'm against using history so callously that you undermine the future use of such analogies rendering it inert. So let's go back to the original post that set this all off. Brent compared sending people to Martha's Vineyard (literally an enclave of the 1%) to the Nazi's rounding up people in the 30's and 40's. Here's your big moment, please educate me on the lesson we are learning from that analogy and why it is appropriate.
Nice to see that now that the school strike is over, you can relax again and really put a dent in the Franzia.
Some ants communicate via vomit, so have at it!
@19: “…up to and including an attempted coup…”
Oh, please. Assume that dumbass mob had achieved whatever the heck they could — stolen the Electoral College ballot box, set fires in our Capitol, even murdered VP Pence — would any of that have delayed President Baden’s inauguration by so much as one hot second? No. Would the Secret Service have barred him from the White House on the orders of a ‘President’ Trump? Of course not. “Attempted coup”? That fiasco barely qualified as an attempted putsch. Take a deep breath, sit back, have some popcorn whilst you watch the trials. That’s what a functional government does with such criminals.
And stop abusing language; as noted above, you have plenty of words to describe what happened without abusing useful terms such as ‘fascist’ and ‘coup.’ For example, ‘Rebellion and Insurrection’ (18 U.S. Code 2383) and ‘Seditious Conspiracy’ (18 USC 2384) will do nicely.
your Lies are olde
and you tell
they were looking for Pence or Pelosi
to murder sos trumpfy could declare
MartiaL Law, hand the Election over
to the States -- with a Republican
Majority guess who Wins that
one. nah. you're White-
Warshin the Insurrect-
ion won't Change it
even if Tucks Carl-
stone Says so.
@43, Asylum seekers, and other temporary visa holders do everything by the book to get here. Then not so much. The number one source of undocumented aliens is people who overstay those visa's. The people in question haven't been granted permanent asylum. It's temporary asylum, while the permanent claim is reviewed.
That said, they are suing DeSantis. Rightly so. Hope they take the State of Florida for tens of millions.
The coup was more than just a bunch of hillbillies smearing their poop in the halls of Congress in January 6. Feel free to call it whatever you want but there is no question there was a concerted effort by the trump team to overturn the election.
the fourth Reich's
just waiting in the Wings
& standing by
they will have learned
valuable lessons from
their Failed coup and
they'll be Much Better
Prepared Next Time:
first they came for
the Trade Unionists
and since i wasnt one
I kept my mouth Shut
then they came for the
socialists and commies
and anyone with an IQ
higher than their shoe size
& my IQ test came back Negative
so where the Hell's the big Problem?
Enough already. Fascism is bad. We get it.
But we're not in 'Nazi Germany' - get real.
@53, @55: If Trump had declared martial law because of the assault by his volunteer goon squad upon our Capitol, the very first thing the mobilized troops would have done would have been to secure said Capitol, and detain any members of said goon squad who hadn’t already been killed by the troops. So not a really good plan for a coup, that.
A coup attempt, by definition, must have some chance of success. As I wrote, this was an attempted putsch, and now we get to watch the trials. If anything you’ve claimed is correct, then Trump committed Seditious Conspiracy, and can be sent to a windowless cell for twenty years. Let’s hope!
so we'll just Wait'll
we Get there eh
by that time
in Nazi Germany it
was OODLES too fucking Late.
with el trumpfo's teensy
fingers on the mechanisms
it may not have played out quite
like "normal" specially with VP Pence
hanging from the Terrorists' Gallows.* who Knows?
they thought Ahead
and Built their Own!
The republicans’ efforts to undermine our elections are still ongoing. The coup is not a one-shot deal: as we speak they are installing election deniers in positions of power over election certification at the state level around the country, and this “it couldn’t happen here” denialism is as much a part of the problem as a major political party that controls the majority of state houses in this country embracing anti-democratic conspiracism.
Even absent their efforts to undermine our elections, republicans have a stranglehold on power in states where they are not the majority. These people know their policies are broadly unpopular in this country & they are actively working to ensure they are never challenged for it.
@59, @60: No one in this thread has said “it couldn’t happen here,” rather, we’ve noted death-camp analogies are not appropriate for current events, and as @50 noted, there’s been no real attempt to justify these analogies, just personal attacks upon anyone who questions whether use of these analogies is a good idea by defenders of constitutional democracy. (Furthermore, it HAS happened here: at the very least, denial of the vote by racist regimes is as American as apple pie.)
I’ve also been making a subtle point about how to defend our constitutional democracy from fascist* tendencies. Hitler* and other conspirators in the Beer Hall Putsch were not seriously punished by the Weimar government for their seditious conspiracy. Demanding serious punishment for Trump and his goons now would be a good preventative against future attempts.
Finally, on the danger of taking analogies too far: Hitler and the Nazis assumed power in perfect accordance with the Weimar constitution. So voting always leads to fascism?
*See? I used the word! Happy now?
I am not defending the concentration camp analogy but there is more to fascism generally & nazism specifically than genocide & we can speak honestly & accurately about their contemporary parallels without invoking the holocaust.
You objected specifically to my using the word coup to describe the coordinated & ongoing efforts by republicans to subvert the democratic process in this country. I am not the first/only person to call this effort a coup & i will continue to do so. Enjoy the rest of your day.
“When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.'”
Comments are closed.
Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.
Or you can
Forgot your password?