Dear Stranger readers,
2020 is finally behind us, but our recovery is just beginning. Reader support has ensured that our dedicated and tenacious team of journalists can continue to bring you important updates as only The Stranger can. Now we're imploring you to help us survive another year. Ensure that we're here to ring in our upcoming 30th anniversary by making a one-time or recurring contribution today.
We're so grateful for your support. Thank you.
Comments are closed.
Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.
Sign up for the latest news and to win free tickets to events
Buy tickets to events around Seattle
Comprehensive calendar of Seattle events
The easiest way to find Seattle's best events
All contents © Index Newspapers LLC
800 Maynard Ave S, Suite 200, Seattle, WA 98134
Comments
For those frequent readers, don't worry, this will be the last time I post this.
Below is what I have been telling people who ask me what happened in regards to Trump, why he won.
The racism, sexism, homophobia, etc,. isn't primary for most people. It's a knock off effect.
In order to understand what happened you have to understand something about the democratic party throughout the 20th and 21st century.
For most of that time the Democrats were the party of minorities and labor. However, as of around 20 or 30 years ago the Democrats shifted away from labor and towards dot com types. App developers, that sort of thing. The problem was that labor was a HUGE constituency that nobody was speaking to.
Until Trump.
Another factor is that globalization was routinely marketed as having no real downside for decades, all the way back to NAFTA. The problem is that globalization actually does have a negative impact that is disproportionately felt by, you guessed it, labor, in particular labor in rural areas because most small towns depend on a single industry or institution unlike cities which, due to trade and a higher population, can absorb the impact of losing a factory.
Now, there are two more things on top of that.
The third thing is that around the late 90's there was a massive campaign on the part of drug manufacturers to market a new brand of pain medication, marketing it as non-addictive directly to doctors. Through a tragic set of circumstances that created an epidemic of opioid addiction that more often affects, you guessed it, white working class men in rural areas.
The last, and this is frankly the weakest reason, was the loss of respect. Most rural labor has felt disrespected and(honestly) kind of freaked out for decades now.
All of this has two effects.
The first is that non-college educated white men are dying deaths of despair at a rapid and increasing rate.
The second, is Trump.
Links available upon request.
Working class people seem like they are realizing that the Democratic party is not really doing anything for them, and are willing to roll the dice rather than accept 4-8 more years of the same. For better or for worse.
Trump's messaging on trade and jobs going overseas really spoke to those people and got to them in a way that Clinton was not able to. Her support of NAFTA and TPP really screwed her when it came to these demographics.
On the flip side, Trump is only down 2m.
Currently, Clinton has more voters than Trump, but they're increasingly concentrated in liberal enclaves.
YOU'RE WELCOME!
So now what Misanthrope. What is your plan?
Because it better not just be bullshit Monday morning quarterbacking and wrapping yourself in snugglie blanket of smug.
Put your money where your mouth was, get in line with the rest of us, and get to work.
As to whether another candidate would have done a better job of appealing to those folks -- we'll never know. There are plenty of candidates that look great on paper, then crash and burn once the Karl Rove Republican machine gets hold of them.
Everyone who was registered to vote and didn't is also responsible for this outcome.
Because right here, right now, we are facing that shit show.
So fuck all y'all's snotty shrugging this off as the inevitable consequence of an unlikable candidate, and fuck your rehashing of why you just couldn't bring yourself to vote for her.
It's too late. Your reasons don't matter. What matters is what we do now.
So let's get to it.
Imagine being dumb enough to think Republicans oppose minimum wage hikes for any reason other than "they're assholes".
I don't think anyone really saw that coming.
Could it be that in a strange twist of fate, that the Republican, namely Trump actually listened to the middle class and their concerns.
Not that I agree with his proffered solutions and frankly I don't see us building the Berlin Wall around Mexico, but there can be no doubt the concerns expressed did indeed resonate with Joe Six Pack.
I also think we've had enough of the political correctness.....which Trump had clearly put on the table.
Don't fret, we still have two other branches of government...until the vacancy on the Supreme Court is filled. Thereafter we'll have one branch of government.....which still isn't bad.
No you'll have to get used to a different agenda.....hard work, tenacity and self sufficiency. Perhaps if Hillary had espoused those virtues she might have found herself a bit more popular or electable.
ps: Public teachers who don't teach well or do their jobs well should get fired....same as in the real world work place.
We'll find a way to move forward, we always do, but I feel like we'll have to find a way to do it severely crippled by all the haters out there who voted for Trump.
The enemy we all feared was already inside our borders, the house divided has just fallen.
Some people never learn. I'm going to gloat for another day. You lost. Your free trade loving elitist candidate lost. Your rust-belt abandoning, super predator shouting, for profit prison candidate lost. "Get in line" doesn't work as a tactic.
What should we do tomorrow? Find candidates who differentiate themselves from Republicans on an economic level, and promote the shit out of them. Work to replace 2/3 of the DNC leadership who have no idea what's happening. And, promote social equality while also listening to the worries of rural working class.
Fuck man we get it already. But never mind the sizeable number of black and hispanic votes Trump received. Don't wanna ruin the Narrative after all.
Never take a group of voters for granted again and sure as hell don't take a shit on them when they disagree with you. All that does it motivates them to vote against your side
I'm not so sure Bernie would have won either. I mean, obviously we'll never know and this is all conjecture, but Trump got elected by angry white rural men, yes? They weren't going to vote for the democrat regardless of who it was. And although Bernie's more of an outsider than Clinton, he's still establishment. He's been in office and in politics forever. The votes were against that.
Who knows though.
Hillary's strength was the sense of familiarity and normalcy in the face of raging uncertainty, but it wasn't enough. Biden or another nationally known establishment Democrat would have probably outperformed her, but Bernie wouldn't have stood had a chance.
Gay people lost. Poor people lost. Young woman lost. Immigrants and Muslims lost and oh my dear fucking God black people lost.
And we all lost the Supreme Court.
You knew that if you got your "anybody but Hillary" wish that these would be the consequences and it on you, as it is on all of us, clean up this mess.
I am right there with you as to your plan and I will see you in the trenches.
Real people are paying the price of this shit show. Maybe think about them rather than gloating about what put them in this position.
@32: By protecting their rights, he means he'll stop ISIS from blowing them up. He's mostly paid lip service to the religious right, but I don't see him making much of an effort either way on queer issues. He'll follow the political winds on those.
People keep telling me the Trump vote wasn't about racism, misogyny, or religious intolerance. Just a FU to the status quo. So being called a 'nig' isn't racist at all. Merely colorful language? "Uppity nignogs turned into.... lampshades"?
This is the new status quo then? Fringe nativist groups see a Trump win as the green light to kill people. ISIS doesn't need to come here. We've got our very own homegrown terrorist.
I am not talking about real, progressive leftism that deals with real issues, but this whiny shit show that is SOCIAL JUSTICE WARRIORISM. You had a big hand to play in electing Trump, and shitty SJW, regressive-left articles like this just play into his hand. There was bound to be a backlash against SJW, and that is what helped launch Trump in the first place.
Blame whitey, blame patriarchy, call the millions of Americans who aren't as "enlightened" as you names and alienate big chunks of the working class. Yep, that will stop Trump!
@41: The backlash against PC culture wasn't so much of an issue as the backlash against globalization and advanced technology. Except they thought it was actually a backlash against trade. But they'll realize their mistake eventually, once the trade wars fail to improve their lot one iota.
even if we try it just comes busting out.
right there for everyone to see.
and envy.
we know it must be hard sharing the planet with us.
we feel your pain.
we are so sorry.
really.
we've got our best minds working on the problem.
I donated to Sanders and I support Hillary, but it's kind of embarrassing to be on the same side with you.