Savage Love Podcast
Check out the all new Savage Lovecast site!
Got a question for Dan Savage?
Call the Savage Love Podcast at 206-201-2720
or email Dan at mail@savagelove.net.
Savage Love Archives
-
Jun 12
Dyke Drama -
Jun 5
Husbanding -
May 29
Amazing Guys -
May 22
Closure -
May 15
Shorties
More from Dan Savage
-
SL Letter of the Day: Cousin Couple
-
GOP Congressman: We Have to Ban Abortion Because Fetuses Are Masturbating In There
-
The War This Time
Why Was I Thinking About Pat Buchanan, Gay Bars, and AIDS While Colorado Burned? -
SL Letter of the Day: Let Me Think...
-
SL Letter of the Day: The Tell-Tale Handjob
Books by Dan Savage
American Savage
It Gets Better: Coming Out, Overcoming Bullying, and Creating a Life Worth Living
The Commitment: Love, Sex, Marriage, and My Family
Things I've Learned from Women Who've Dumped Me
Skipping Towards Gomorrah
The Kid: What Happened After My Boyfriend and I Decided to Go Get Pregnant
Savage Links
- Babeland
- Fleshbot
- Good Vibrations
- Joe Newton/Savage Illustrations
- Planned Parenthood
- Spreading Santorum
- Planned Parenthood's Teen Wire
- Kinsey Confidential
- Carnal Nation
- Tiny Nibbles
Want a Second Opinion?
Contact Dan Savage
Savage on YouTube
Give 'Em Hope
September 23, 2010
I'm a gay male and have been seeing a terrific guy for a couple of months. Two years ago, during an uncharacteristically wild few months in my life, I had a threesome with a couple, and as it turns out, my boyfriend is very good friends with them. We see them socially and have even all had dinner together. Nothing has been mentioned by anyone, and I've never told my BF. I feel guilty—not because I slept with his friends, but rather because a threesome is inconsistent with his perception of me. I don't view threesomes as morally wrong, but I'm worried he does. Should I tell him?
Threesome Complications
Yes, TC, you should tell him.
He's going to find out eventually—this isn't the kind of secret that keeps—and the revelation will be much more damaging if he finds out about it from the couple or from a malicious third (fourth?) party. And while a threesome may be inconsistent with his current impression of you, TC, that's something he might be able to get over. He's much less likely to get over the realization that you were keeping this secret from him or that you're so stupid as to think that this kind of secret can be kept.
And why are you so sure he would have a problem with it? Right now he's operating under the assumption that his boyfriend isn't the sort of guy who has threesomes. And you're operating under the assumption that your boyfriend thinks threesomes are morally wrong. We know that his assumptions about you are wrong—you are the sort of person who has threesomes—so it stands to reason that your assumptions about him could be wrong. He may not have any problem with threesomes. Or foursomes.
You're the kind of person who can have a threesome and remain on good terms with the couple involved, TC, and that's a selling point, something in your favor, and nothing you should be ashamed of.
The time has come for you to use your influence to pick a day between now and the November election and declare it Masturbate to Christine O'Donnell Day in either the state of Delaware or the entire United States of America. This needs to happen, and you're the only guy who can do it.
Hiding At The Elusive Fuzz Under Christine's Knockers
For Savage Love readers who don't read anything else: Christine O'Donnell is the Tea Party wacko who won the Republican nomination for a U.S. Senate seat in Delaware. She is famous for three things: getting her loony ass endorsed by Sarah Palin, viciously gay-baiting her straight primary opponent, and opposing masturbation because it makes the baby Jesus cry.
I'm all for masturbating to Christine O'Donnell, HATEFUCK, but why limit it to one day? So I hereby declare every day between now and November 2—when O'Donnell's nomination costs the GOP a Senate seat—to be Masturbate to Christine O'Donnell Day. Rub one out for freedom, people!
I just read about a gay teenager in Indiana—Billy Lucas—who killed himself after being taunted by his classmates. Now his Facebook memorial page is being defaced by people posting homophobic comments. It's just heartbreaking and sickening. What the hell can we do?
Gay Bullying Victim Who Survived
Another gay teenager in another small town has killed himself—hope you're pleased with yourselves, Tony Perkins and all the other "Christians" out there who oppose anti-bullying programs (and give actual Christians a bad name).
Billy Lucas was just 15 when he hanged himself in a barn on his grandmother's property. He reportedly endured intense bullying at the hands of his classmates—classmates who called him a fag and told him to kill himself. His mother found his body.
Nine out of 10 gay teenagers experience bullying and harassment at school, and gay teens are four times likelier to attempt suicide. Many LGBT kids who do kill themselves live in rural areas, exurbs, and suburban areas, places with no gay organizations or services for queer kids.
"My heart breaks for the pain and torment you went through, Billy Lucas," a reader wrote after I posted about Billy Lucas to my blog. "I wish I could have told you that things get better."
I had the same reaction: I wish I could have talked to this kid for five minutes. I wish I could have told Billy that it gets better. I wish I could have told him that, however bad things were, however isolated and alone he was, it gets better.
But gay adults aren't allowed to talk to these kids. Schools and churches don't bring us in to talk to teenagers who are being bullied. Many of these kids have homophobic parents who believe that they can prevent their gay children from growing up to be gay—or from ever coming out—by depriving them of information, resources, and positive role models.
Why are we waiting for permission to talk to these kids? We have the ability to talk directly to them right now. We don't have to wait for permission to let them know that it gets better. We can reach these kids.
So here's what you can do, GBVWS: Make a video. Tell them it gets better.
I've launched a channel on YouTube—www .youtube.com/itgetsbetterproject—to host these videos. My normally camera-shy husband and I already posted one. We both went to Christian schools and we were both bullied—he had it a lot worse than I did—and we are living proof that it gets better. We don't dwell too much on the past. Instead, we talk mostly about all the meaningful things in our lives now—our families, our friends (gay and straight), the places we've gone and things we've experienced—that we would've missed out on if we'd killed ourselves then.
"You gotta give 'em hope," Harvey Milk said.
Today we have the power to give these kids hope. We have the tools to reach out to them and tell our stories and let them know that it does get better. Online support groups are great, GLSEN does amazing work, the Trevor Project is invaluable. But many LGBT youth can't picture what their lives might be like as openly gay adults. They can't imagine a future for themselves. So let's show them what our lives are like, let's show them what the future may hold in store for them.
The video my husband and I made is up now—all by itself. I'd like to add submissions from other gay and lesbian adults—singles and couples, with kids or without, established in careers or just starting out, urban and rural, of all races and religious backgrounds. (Go to www.youtube.com/itgetsbetterproject to find instructions for submitting your video.) If you're gay or lesbian or bi or trans and you've ever read about a kid like Billy Lucas and thought, "Fuck, I wish I could've told him that it gets better," this is your chance. We can't help Billy, but there are lots of other Billys out there—other despairing LGBT kids who are being bullied and harassed, kids who don't think they have a future—and we can help them.
They need to know that it gets better. Submit a video. Give them hope.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2009/apr…
This is something that is never said enough to any teenagers, but especially to those ostracized by their peers. Kudos for giving them the support.
8
And anyway, I must admit she is pretty. Maybe we women should mount an e-mail/letter campaign telling Christine how much we'd love to eat her pussy, if only she weren't so hell bent on stopping the whole country from having sex (and good luck with that): http://www.connexion.org/gay-news/politi…
9
I respect and understand Terry's preference to live privately and if this is his only public on-camera moment I believe he chose the right time and place and cause.
12
I applaud your project. I know it was prompted by a particular horrific case of homophobic bullying, but I think it would be great to expand this to address all the freaks, geeks, losers, fags, bitches, sluts, and lowlife who are made to feel like their life will never get better. They all need to hear the message. That it does get better, and really soon! Two or three years until you're a legal adult, can move away from that bullshit and see how fantastic life can be!
I applaud your project. I know it was prompted by a particular horrific case of homophobic bullying, but I think it would be great to expand this to address all the freaks, geeks, losers, fags, bitches, sluts, and lowlife who are made to feel like their life will never get better. They all need to hear the message. That it does get better, and really soon! Two or three years until you're a legal adult, can move away from that bullshit and see how fantastic life can be!
15
17
18
I'll be doing my part to ensure that this message gets broadcast far and wide by sending the link to everyone in my contact list. If anyone knows of somebody in a similar situation, please direct them to Dan & Terry's channel. Let them know that it really does get better and that hope and help are out there.
Take good care all. Peace.
19
Although meant for young gay teens, this is fantastic for everybody who is or has ever been bullied and picked on. And what can us straight people do to get involved?
And your spouse is definitely a hottie...kudos on all fronts, Dan.
32
And your video was wonderful and wonderfully surreal! I actually - FINALLY - just read both "The Commitment" and "The Kid" with in the last month, so it was awesome to actually get to see the two main characters interact! Wow! Thank you both so much for sharing!
Also, I will never understand why so many ridiculously photogenic people are camera-shy! And the way you watch Terry talk is heart-meltingly cute, Dan. Had to say it.
33
34
35
Unfortunately, I can't quite bring myself to masturbate to Christine O'Donnell, as she makes my lesbian-boner run away in horror D= I would if I could, but I can't.
Keep it up Dan, you're my hero.
But on the other hand, there's a certain percentage of kids viewing it that you can't help making false promises to: some gay kids are simply not going to grow up to have lives like yours. Some kids' families aren't going to accept them the way yours have; some kids are not going to end up with long-term partners (much less hot ones!); some kids aren't going to be taking vacations to Paris (or, for that matter, afford surrogate motherhood to become parents themselves).
It's certainly true that a lot of kids are really going to benefit from this video. Someday, though, you're going to hear from or about some viewers who will grow up to be disappointed and depressed when they never realize the idealized, and very lucky, model of gay life that you're presenting here. It would be more honest of you to say that, too.
38
It is currently not known if Billy was gay. We may never know. It may not matter to some people, but it seems the family may have feelings about this. See the FaceBook tab under "Discussions". So few facts are known. It's possible he was gay and the family did not support him when he was alive and desires to hide it after his death. That would be extra horrific if it was true.
Here is the best news I could find so far:
http://www.wishtv.com/dpp/news/local/eas…
There's nothing on this in the Chicago Tribune or most media websites as of Sept 22nd, 13 days after his death.
It's horrible Billy is gone. He had been suspended from school that day for an attempt to stop those with a long history of bullying him. Being called gay was part of the abuse.
I'm a teacher and I've asked Dan back in 2005 to write a book for gay teens in schools. I got in trouble for sending a kid to the office every time he used "gay". I'd make a youtube video but Dan's request is only for people who are gay.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Billy-Luca…
ps: As another teacher said, youtube is blocked in most schools.
@37: you are missing the point - Dan may have a very nice life, but even without all those good things that Dan has you will still escape the horrors of high school and find a life worth living.
I can't contribute, being a straight female. But as a former victim of bullying I would love to tell the young victims of today, gay or straight, that it does get better, and that even if it feels eternal, the dark days of high school are over in a flash. Please do tell us if you decide to open the project up to more people, though I do understand your motivation for targetting GLBTQ teens especially.
Wonderful to do that video!!! God bless you for it and may it be the catapult to something big and to save many, many young men and womens lives.
oh, and.... holy smoking hot terry.
50
Great video. Beautiful family.
55
So thanks for remembering that we're here, and brainstorming regularly how to marginalize the Perkins, Becks, and Grahams of the world.
I mean, if threesomes are morally wrong, then surely all us gays will burn in hell. ...
No, wait! ... That's exactly what they said we would do! ...
Screw the haters. Dan has never lost any debate with them. Everyone should just be aware of this so the hate message can be fought.
The boy hung himself, and verbal abuse about being gay was directly related. Many neighborhoods are so biased against gays that even a straight kid is pushed to suicide for being labeled "gay".
http://slog.thestranger.com/slog/archive…
Don't give the haters any more fuel for their fire. Don't label the kid gay until more info comes out. Do support any effort like this to create more systematic supports.
Can someone creating a video add the 800 phone numbe? 800-273-TALK Here is the FAQ on the teen website.
http://sptsnj.org/faq.html
(866) 4-U-TREVOR
(866) 488-7386
http://www.thetrevorproject.org/
I will, however, most likely be jackin' it to Dan & Terry later tonight, speakinna threesomes.
72
My girlfriend and I (both avid readers of your column and your blog) both own accounts on a blogging site called Dreamwidth, and we've just been inspired to start up a community there with the same name as your project, with links to the videos and to your column as primary resources and inspiration. It's a small site, but it has a very high proportion of GLBTQ account owners, and I'm sure we can get something meaningful going with this.
Here's the link: http://it-gets-better.dreamwidth.org/
Thank you so much, Dan, for reaching out to a silent majority like this. I heard the "you're too young to know you're bi!" at the ripe old age of 18 (although I make allowances for growing up in a village in India) and I'm sure kids who come out earlier have that even worse - to have the community reach out to them in a caring, inclusive way will make a lot of difference to them.
I am a straight girl as well, and totally agree with the other posters about how bullying can be so pervasive in schools, regardless of reasons (I grew up fat), and if indeed, my "Golden Years" of high school were indeed my best, I would have offed myself for sure! When I think of people who truly have their glory days in high school, I think of Al Bundy. Thank goodness for college...I am sure teen viewers can modify content in their minds to suit their needs. Can't wait to see Dan's hot hubby!
75
76
I'm not always your biggest fan, but today, I most certainly am.
My best friend in junior high (also in Spokane) killed himself a year after I moved away, for what I suspect was reasons similar to Billy Lucas. Watching you and Terry together makes me incredibly sad to know that my dear friend missed out on what would surely have been an amazingly good life.
Much good fortune and happiness to you and your family.
G
[found here: http://www.queerty.com/teenager-justin-a…]
I think we're at a point where it's evident that school districts (some, not all) are just NOT going to accept it. Instead of waiting around for them to do it, it may be time for LGBTA folks to go to them, especially in some of the "redder" parts of this country.
It would be nice to see people organizing around this issue – the school won't stop bullying? Unacceptable, but probably not changeable either, so how can it be countered? Perhaps with LGBTA mentoring or something similar.
I hate that this is happening and more I hate that it's being ignored, but it seems that the timeline for social change here is a long one, in the meantime, I hope some quicker, but no less powerful, actions can be taken.
I posted it on my yoga blog here in Toronto to spread the word.
It does get better.
I am going to post a video.
David Good
Thank you thank you thank you. I cried.
86
B. You and your column got FREE national air time today on one of the Wingnut spew-shows on radio!!! All about your Christine Zero comments.
92
I struggled for years with my sexual orientation, but somehow I survived. And things did get better… much better… better than I could ever have imagined when I was 14. I’m in a relationship with a man I love (five year anniversary is coming up), I’m out to my family, and they support me, and I’m comfortable in my own skin.
BUT, and it’s a big but, if a gay person had been there for me when I was 14 with advice, support, and a different perspective, it would have made a huge difference. If you have a camera, seriously consider making a video for Dan's site.
My son began to be subjected to anti-gay bullying when he was in second grade. We pulled him out of that school when it was clear that the administration wasn't going to do anything about it. Three years later, in 5th grade, it started again. Fortunately, we found a middle school/high school that is an open, welcoming community that has made it clear that it doesn't tolerate bullying.
The school administrators who respond with "We have to be nice to the gay kids" are getting it wrong.
We have to stop the bullying.
98
#2 Dan, thank you and Terry from the bottom of my heart. I think this project can really take off and make a difference in how schools approach bullying and the bullied.
As a teenager I was mercilessy bullied for being fat. I was 5'6" and 155 pounds, but was taunted endlessly about being a fatass, worthless piece of shit. Nobody stuck up for me. There was nobody with a message for me, other than my mom and dad who simply told me to ignore them. The teachers and principal disciplined me for sticking up for myself because I was causing a scene. It was ridiculous.
I made it through. I live well, I work in my community for awareness and self-acceptance, and that truly is the best revenge.
99
101
Christine O'Donnell Masturbation Day: ROTFLMAO! I have to admit to mixed feelings on this one, if only because she is not a person I want to associate with masturbation. However, knowing how distasteful she and her supporters would find the idea, I'll power up the vibrator in celebration...
102
"That shame you secretly feel each night for the terrible things you've said & done to some vulnerable kid that day? It gets worse as you get older. It leads to self-loathing, bitterness and isolation. The only way to get rid of it is to stop the meanness while you still can. You don't have to stand up for the bullied kid just yet (you'll want to later), but you do need to quit making the problem worse. Hate can be addictive and is always destructive."
I'd say a lot of the bullying that goes on has a certain pack mentality behind it. Many of the tormentors may be mere bandwagoneers, but are afraid to jump ship for fear of the same fate as their current target. Letting those kids know that it is OK not to hate could be a very useful message too.
104
I can't say thank you to you both enough.
106
I am happy to see that you came up with such a great idea for the gay kids. I hope that it will reach everyone.
I am happy to see that you came up with such a great idea for helping the gay kids going through such a rough time in their lives. I hope that it will reach everyone. Cause lord knows anyone who is being bullied needs to hear that life will get better.
113
115
I've posted a link to the IGB Channel on my facebook and sent messages to every LGBT person I know so that they can participate and spread the word.
What a wonderful, wonderful project.
121
122
I'm thirteen, I'm a girl, and I'm still figuring out my sexuality. My family isn't the most supportive one out there, and I don't really have any ''friends'' I can count on, so seeing your video really gave me hope. I'm always telling people that their life is going to get better, that everything will be okay, but, honestly, I've never really believed it myself. I know that there are reasons for me to keep living, that my future is going to be worth it, and I've always believed that, but lately, the option of giving up had become a much more plausible one than before. I felt weak, and alone, and unimportant. I started watching this video thinking it would be just another generic ''suicide is not the answer'' thing, but it wasn't. It was honest, and real, and I was crying halfway through it. It made me realize that I can, and will, lead a happy life when I'm older, regardless of who I love, and lifestyle I choose to live. It made me find hope, and I know that if I can hope, and dream, I can acheive anything. I can't thank you enough, really.
You've made a difference in a teenager's life.
Thank you.
I went to a little cow college for my first year of school, and I was on very good terms with the shitkickers, rednecks and jocks. Don't think for a minute that they lose sleep over hounding social outcasts to death. They don't. They're fundamentally tribal, and if you aren't in the tribe, you aren't a person.
135
136
I can't think of a more worthy project, LGBT teens need access to role models. Looking back, it was the thing I lacked and most longed for growing up.
I can't think of a more worthy project, LGBT teens need access to role models. Looking back, it was the thing I lacked and most longed for growing up.
And what I love about it and why I think it will make a huge and positive difference is that it isn't selling or promoting a product, it's not made by someone running for office or re-election, it's not advocating only one option, it's not a government add that took 4 months, 12 research teams and 9 million dollars to produce and then subsequently gets trashed around the political parties. No no.
It's humanitarian and it's made with love and respect, and will be contributed to with love and respect.
142
Gay teens are being bullied and messed up across the world. It's crazy and the young teens just don't know how to handle it. I was shocked to see such brutality by other kids at such a young age. We've all been there and never understood it. But then, if you give it a second thought, it seems like people are homophobic only because they are deeply afraid that there may be a homosexual individual hiding inside their own bodies. That's what even this article says, that most men are afraid of a gay side that hides within all of us. http://www.lovepanky.com/men/guy-talk/me… People feel that by abusing and bullying someone else who's gay, it just affirms the fact that they are not gay.
By doing that homophobic people convince themselves that they arent gay. It's a bit like the school bully who used to hit the weak kid because it affirmed the fact that he's cool and powerful. He needs to depend on another boy's weakness to convince himself of his superiority. And this is the same with several other examples in life, abusive parents, etc.
I wonder if people could just accept the fact that some people are gay and others are not. Why do they have to be so homophobic? Can we do anything about it? In this lifetime, I don't know. Everyone's too scared there may be a gay within to try to accept homosexuality. But with people like you, there's still hope. Thank you.
147
While there are bullying kids in high school, there are also supportive kids. It's too easy to get all focused on the troublemakers. Don't let the haters make you mean. When people treat you with kindness and respect and share fun times, remember them, focus on them, and be like them. Ignore, trouble - it feeds on your reactions, don't give it any.
149
While there are bullying kids in high school, there are also supportive kids. It's too easy to get all focused on the troublemakers. Don't let the haters make you mean. When people treat you with kindness and respect and share fun times, remember them, focus on them, and be like them. Ignore, trouble - it feeds on your reactions, don't give it any.
150
Also, bullies can feel remorse. A friend in college told me a story about the boy who bullied his younger (gay) brother. One day, out of nowhere, the former bully showed up the day after Christmas and apologized for the bullying (both attend out of state colleges). It didn't heal his brother's problems, but it was certainly a start. I guess they jog together now or something. Maybe they're raquetball partners.
Side note: I absolutely adore Joe Newton's drawing for this.
Thanks for starting this Dan!
I may not be gay, but I know what it's like to be bullied. I know what it's like to think of suicide as a viable option, not because you actually want to die, but because living is just so fucking miserable. And I know what it's like to have your family cast you out and turn their backs on you. And I know what it's like to have life get better. So the fact that I'm straight doesn't mean I don't have anything to contribute to this discussion.
I'd like to suggest that you pair up with Jodee Blanco. She's a survivor of bullying, has written a couple of books and speaks at high schools across the country. Maybe if you join forces the non-gays with something to say could have a voice in all of this.
You might also try to get the Matthew Shepard Project behind you.
I was one of the kids who Stuck Up For my gay friends [I am still that kid as a grown up naturally]. I never really thought I helped but maybe it did.
This is SUCH an awesome thing. I love that you are doing this...the lives you will save...the important lives you will save....!!!!!!
In general: I think we need to have far more action on bullying of any kind.
When I was in late grade school, about age 9 or 10, the girls I was friends with decided they were the cool clique and I was out of it - thereby losing people I genuinely was friends with, and I spent the rest of my schooling being an outsider, though not actually bullied or taunted.
Now I'm seeing the same thing happening with my nine-year old niece, only with her there *is* name-calling and taunting, and the potential for violence lurking in the background: the clique who are taunting her are friends with some of the biggest, known to be aggressive boys... so she worries that if she stands up to the mean girls, or sasses them back, she may get physically assaulted.
It breaks my heart even thinking she would go through the heartache I did as a preteen and teen, let alone this escalation which is worse than what I dealt with. So many other kids need to know there are adults who've been through the same and care and that it won't always be that way. Maybe they won't ever be so bad as to contemplate suicide, as gay and gay-baited teens do, but we could spare them so much heartache and emotional trauma.
i am a straight, straight female (!haha!) and ive been a fan of yours for a few years now. after watching yours and terry's video i had to create an account to tell you how wonderful you are and how thankful i am for having someone like you in the world. many people look up to you and trust you, myself included. you are always brutally honest and very fair, which i find humorous, but mostly appreciate. i look forward weekly to reading your column, in fact its the first thing i read in the stranger! anyways, its really sad how brutal kids can be to each other. i know when youre young it seems like school will never end. i wish i could articulate how rad it is that you and terry have begun this "it gets better" project. you two lovely gentlemen have created hope for teens from many different backrounds. anyways, i thought i would share my appreciation for you, dan
and also to you terry for putting yourself out there
thanks guys!!!
i am a straight, straight female (!haha!) and ive been a fan of yours for a few years now. after watching yours and terry's video i had to create an account to tell you how wonderful you are and how thankful i am for having someone like you in the world. many people look up to you and trust you, myself included. you are always brutally honest and very fair, which i find humorous, but mostly appreciate. i look forward weekly to reading your column, in fact its the first thing i read in the stranger! anyways, its really sad how brutal kids can be to each other. i know when youre young it seems like school will never end. i wish i could articulate how rad it is that you and terry have begun this "it gets better" project. you two lovely gentlemen have created hope for teens from many different backrounds. anyways, i thought i would share my appreciation for you, dan
and also to you terry for putting yourself out there
congrats on your disgustingly cute family!
thanks guys!!!
I loved you before this particular column, I've loved you since Jr High, but you really knocked this out of the park. You have made me so much more comfortable with sexuality and you are brilliantly scathing. THis project is awesome. I really enjoyed hearing you and your husband's story. You guys are so cute together. It's always enjoyable to see people that really care for each other like you guys, it makes me less cynical. THanks for everything
Fight Religious Extremism Everywhere!
I know, who would have thought with a name like that?
I know everyone is saying the same thing, but I'm adding my voice to the multitude, because your video was very well timed in my personal life. I'm not gay and I'm not even a teenager. I just wanted to be reminded it's going to get better.
So thank you.
www.coachingforlifetoday.com
1) You *can* participate-- by signal-boosting (posting links in your Facebook/MySpace/LiveJournal, sending email forwards, etc), by showing the videos to people you know, by trying to find ways to get news of this project to kids who won't hear about it otherwise. That would be really useful and helpful.
2) It's true that many, many people get bullied, and many people find high school terrible. But statistics do show that, on average, it's worse for queer kids. I'm sure there are exceptions (straight kids who go through hell, queer kids who are just fine), and you may have been one of them, but there are still problems faced specifically by queer kids which are different from the ones faced by straight kids. So it is worthwhile having a project which addresses their problems.
3) I agree strongly with #100. It would be *great* to have a project which reached out to all sorts of kids who are being bullied-- smart kids, disabled kids, geeky kids, kids with mental health issues, kids who are racially in the minority in their school, kids who are perceived to be queer whether or not they are-- so why don't you go start one? You could piggy-back off of this project, if you wanted to, and I'm sure you could do a very useful thing.
I get that people want to help, and that's cool. I feel like the vast majority of everything in our culture is inclusive of (if not designed exclusively for) straight people, and it's not that unreasonable to have a project like this focused on and for queer people.
ONE THING I DO UNDERSTAND; TO GO THROUGH LIFE ALONE IS A SAD AND LONELY EXPERIENCE. TO FIND ONE OTHER PERSON IN THE MIDST OF 6 BILLION ON THIS PLANET WITH WHOM YOU CAN LOVE, NURTURE & SHARE IS A BLESSING. IT DOES GET BETTER, DAY BY DAY.
I HOPE THESE YOUNG PEOPLE CAN RISE ABOVE THE VERBAL, EMOTIONAL & EVEN PHSICAL ABUSE THAT'S OUT THERE, ACCEPT THEMSELVES, FOR THE FINE PEOPLE THEY ARE AN LIVE THEIR LIVES WITH JOY & FULFILLMENT.
This goes beyond a G/L issue – it’s about all struggling youth who feel that high school is IT – nothing could be more permanent or lasting – and think that the fools surrounding them know all.
Fuck that – open your project to anyone that has struggled through bullying and put a true voice at there for ALL the kids suffering daily and doubt their worth. Unfortunately a lot of us (straight folks too) have been there and it would have made a HUGE difference in my teen years to know – hey – this will go away – these people aren’t shit – and someday I’ll be a grown up, making my own rules, picking my own friends and LIVING my own life – with no regard for the douches that tried to make me think I wasn’t worth living.
Love ya Dan…
This goes beyond a G/L issue – it’s about all struggling youth who feel that high school is IT – nothing could be more permanent or lasting – and think that the fools surrounding them know all.
Fuck that – open your project to anyone that has struggled through bullying and put a true voice at there for ALL the kids suffering daily and doubt their worth. Unfortunately a lot of us (straight folks too) have been there and it would have made a HUGE difference in my teen years to know – hey – this will go away – these people aren’t shit – and someday I’ll be a grown up, making my own rules, picking my own friends and LIVING my own life – with no regard for the douches that tried to make me think I wasn’t worth living.
Love ya Dan…
Oh, and xWhatever on the curiosity about your partner being an incentive to click it.
Thanks for the support... don't wait for Dan to tell you what to do to help, get creative! Donate to or volunteer with GLSEN, the Trevor Project or your local suicide hotline. Call your local school district and your legislators and tell them you support anti-bullying programs in schools. Effective ones, not just ones that whine about hurt feelings and so forth... think of your own stuff!
@Non-LGBT People Who Were Bullied:
I think it's fantastic if you all were to start your own projects to combat bullying and teen-suicide. Why you gotta get all up in our hizzouse? ;)
@181 and @186 I agree with 186! -and I'm straight- This project is specifically to show LGBT kids people just like them who have survived and thrived after highschool. Straight people have PLENTY of examples already. Let this one stay queer (I mean that in the best possible sense).
I still remember how breathtakingly wonderful it was for me to see a gay couple holding hands as they walked down the street chatting with their friends. They weren't at a rally. There was no protest or assertion of rights. It was just a crisp New England fall day, and the sight made me smile deeply inside. And to the Tufts boy who leaned his head on his boyfriend's shoulder on the 96 bus - thank you. It was these scenes of normalcy that convinced me more than any advocacy ever could that all could be well.
So please, all you happily partnered/married people, hold hands (when you want), hug (when you want), and have your strangely adorable little fights at the grocery store. Your everyday inspires incredible hope.
But now, possibly due to superficial daddyhood encouragement feelings, he's flopping to a superficial, statistically-unsupported "It gets better" aphorism. Consider the young man already had no social support network, nor skills or other resources for developing one. His parents, if they are good parents, are monitoring his internet access. At the same time, this family was obviously of no social support, and reports on the YouTube page indicate that they continue to remove all socially supportive gay comments.
From this condition and environment of social isolation at high school age, even if he had stuck miserably through high school into college (or as college is more unreachable for most today, into independent adulthood), he would have already been less likely socially to succeed without a set of skills developed through successful socialization at school. Not the least is just a socially attractive generally "happy" demeanor, one of the spoils accumulated by those who do not concede that the biggest social advantage is that nothing succeeds like success.
If Dan had even done the easy "Seek counseling" from his hero Ann Landers, he would have had to if not being superficial confront the fact that most counselors have no idea of how to facilitate socialization for gay people. As anyone who has been there notices, just like 9 out of 10 of the general population are not gay, 9 out of 10 counselors aren't and have no idea what to offer besides "It gets better" with nothing but an unfounded cultural "be encouraging" approach that yields no help. It is unreasonable also to expect the average person to have the financial or other resources to "keep trying to find a better counselor" in most environments. If you're having problems with the statistical facts of what happens *each time* you make a 1 in 10 choice, imagine 10 places for bullets, but one is empty. Spin it, fire, what are the odds you'll get the bad thing happening? Then *replace* the fired bullet with a new one, and repeat for each subsequent 1 in 10 case.
Basically, what you've come up with is just the feel-good "It's easy for people for whom it's worked out" subjectivity and social display. There was little likelihood of the young man's social improvement given his circumstances, just continuing isolation until the point where his depth of emotionality decreased to where absence of supportive, or even less-likely, intimate social interaction became inescapably accepted.
The "It Gets Better" platitude is at its core a "blame the victim" attitude toward those for whom it did not get better. It has no value as far as solving the problems of the person for who things are not better.
Isn't there a reason for the universality of recognition of the truth in Thoreau's observation that "The majority of men lead lives of quiet desperation" ?
Is it because you believe that for you, and the people that you see, that things have gotten better that there is statistical authority to state "Things get better" ?
Is this the new faith-based column from Dan Savage? Faith-based foreclosures are so attractive and rewarding for those who can brandish them as sources of authority. It's gratifying to just go spewing subjective opinion all over everything that presents itself, like the world is your Rorschach blot.
Do you ever let Terry finish his sentences in real life?
Take this to the next level - yes, it gets better, but something more needs to be done to confront the bullying that is still occurring.
Start a movement where students, supportive parents, teachers and other allies confront the school administrators who stand by and allow this to continue. Hold schools accountable for their failure to act. Many states have new, strict anti-bullying laws.
To say it gets better gives a pass to the bullies and schools that are failing our kids. Bullying is a violation of a person's civil rights and it is not acceptable to say it is a part of growing up.
We need to take this to the next level - yes, it gets better, but something more needs to be done to confront the bullying that is still occurring.
Students, supportive parents, teachers and other allies need to confront the school administrators who stand by and allow this to continue. Hold schools accountable for their failure to act. Many states have new, strict anti-bullying laws.
To say it gets better gives a pass to the bullies and schools that are damaging our kids. Bullying is a violation of a person's civil rights and it is not acceptable to say it is a part of growing up.
197
The bullying my son endured started the moment he set foot on school property in Junior Kindergarten, and didn't stop until he left elementary school. The one time he retalliated against the bully, he got double the punishment the bullies ever got. When we had meetings with the school principal, my son was blamed for being "weak". Eventually, we started calling the police, which did help. What helped the most was when my son grew & grew & grew till he was towering over the bullies, & this put a stop to almost all the bullying, but they still tried to bait him with verbal harassment.
My son is not gay, however, he does have a non-verbal learning disability that sets him apart from others. My son is an intelligent, loving boy.
I just wanted to point out that bullying isn't relegated to JUST high school. If the school administrators won't properly deal with the bullies, call the police. It sends a message not only to the bullies, but also to the school administration, that you, as parents, are not going to stand by & allow the bullies to win.
P.S. Thanks Dan & Terry for your great video & the encouragement you give.
Or, is it expanded to include all victims of any kind of detrimental bullying? Whether it's physical, emotional, mental or spiritual? (There's still too much bigotry surrounding various religions.)
Personally, I was a victim, who found himself being 'outed' in high school. I'm not gay. Wasn't then, and am not now. But I am secure in my sexuality, and openly flirt with men (under the right circumstances, and when I know it won't offend anyone.)
The point is, sometimes teens use homosexuality as a sword, cutting undesirables from their community, even if the accusations are false.
And the mental and emotional impacts these situations have on the victims.
If a gay man came to me and told me that it would get better and that I'd be able to live my life as an open homosexual in my adult years, it would've fallen on deaf ears. All because I'm not gay.
But, if someone came and told me that Metrosexualism would be the next hot trend, and that I was just on the leading edge of it, that would've helped. :P
Society will accept us for who we are, even if family and friends cannot.
201
To comment on #198 (Ben B.), i agree with his assertion that the victim doesn't have to be gay in order to be accused of it, but that is just one more weapon in the bully's arsenal, to be brought out & used at their choosing. My son is not gay, but sexual harassment was used on him by many bullies, & it works because it strikes at the heart of the victim's psyche, & in the case of children, usually renders them incapable of responding. Parents must take an active role in their children's school career, especially if their child is bullied - no matter what the bullying consists of - & stand behind their child(ren) & support them all the way. But i know some parents are oblivious. For parents who do take an active role in their child's school, do not be afraid to call the police if the school administration is passing the buck or tries to blame the victim. When school admin starts turning the other cheek or making statements to the effect that the victim was complicit in the bullying, that is when you know they are not "zero tollerance", which is what schools need to be if they are to effectively deal with bullying issues.
I agree with #199 re: FB and the possibility of negative use of "friending" and "shoutouts". The 3rd party privacy issues are enough to keep me from being a member of any such social networking sites, & i caution my children on this topic too, as cyber bullying is huge; just another venue for bullies to get at victims.
For it to "get better", one must live in an accepting & loving environment. For some people, this means leaving their family of origin. Many people are bullied in their work environment, which is an extremely difficult situation, especially in this economic climate.
Counselling is a good direction to take, & with those who cannot afford counselling, go to the library & get some self help books. Believe it or not, books can help, because, yes, the longterm mental & emotional impact that bullying has on people is huge. Not just the victim, but the perp too.
http://www.youtube.com/user/7AwesomeLesb…
http://www.youtube.com/user/7AwesomeLesb…
204
2.) I'd rather masturbate to a liberal, thankyouverymuch. Jerks like Christine O'Donnell don't deserve our sexual energy. They don't deserve sexual satisfation at all.
3.) Dear bullied kids, gay and straight and undecided, it does get better. Your school years, especially middle school and high school, are the worst years of your life. I speak from personal experience. Ignoring the assholes does not make them go away; this causes things to escallate. Beating the living crap out of them, descretely of course, does. If a good old-fashioned beat down is not possible, try something more passive-aggressive and vicious like spreading gossip about bed-wetting or instigating fights between them and their cronies. Get really good grades. It doesn't matter how crap your public school is, find the library and lock yourself inside every free momment available. Hobbies and outside interest will not only expose you to a wider variety of people it will make you a more talented and interesting person. Graduate from high school and go to college. If you can't afford a University, go to community college and get some kind of certificate in a trade, so you can get a decent job and you can afford University in the future. Enjoy sex with college kids (with protection and birth control, of course). Meet all the people you wished you grew up with.
Dear Bullies, high school will be the best years of your life. Bwa, aha, ha, ha, ha, ha! Never again will you be popular or successful. You'll never be top dog again. You're opinion will never again be important to anyone...ever! From the end of high school onward it's all down hill. You're narrow mind and lack of imagination and your fear and hate of anything that isn't "normal", which is another word for mediocre and boring, will cause you to stagnate....which is appropriate since you're pond scum. Ta, losers, me and the rest of the queers are off to enjoy our success and your failures.
Sincerly,
Sad Insignificant Christine
Nothing will ever cure teen bullying, but this kind of bullying will get better when the people at the top of the school power structure get over themselves Resist kiss asses. Examine yourself for assumptions about others AND ABOUT YOURSELF that you are internalizing from authority figures. And realize the strongest defense against this bullying is a refusal to believe what they're telling you about yourself
I'm listening to Savage Love 206, and... you don't know any gay guys that kiss girls when they're shitfaced?
My god, most of my gay friends kiss EVERYONE when they're shitfaced! Most of my straight friends kiss EVERYONE when they're shitfaced!
Haven't you ever just kissed someone and gone, hey, you got good technique, without needing to sleep with them? Or necessarily wanting to? Finding someone sexy, without feeling sexual towards them?
My social group is generally old enough to have fun doing things ironically, so when someone pull out a really nice bottle of cinnamon whisky, obviously you have to mouth shot from someone else. There was that time when a (oops) really drunk friend turned and gave his brother a cinnamon shot, and then there was that slow moment where they both stopped and pondered it for a moment, and the less drunk one pronounced it "Awk-ward" (but tasty).
My gay friends have ruefully declared that the friend group of cute young guys we know who kiss each other on the lips in greeting, are actually.. completely straight.
Basically, they're just from a different generation to us. They're happy to kiss the gay guys on the lips as harmless flirtation, but if any or most of them were really bi or gay, they'd be fucking someone already, because it's *completely socially acceptable* in their social group to be bi or gay.
Instead, it's just a way of showing intimacy in their group.
Well, same in our circles as well.
Oh, and they also kiss their female friends on the lips.
When people are completely comfortable with being bi or gay, they're also more comfortable with being straight and pan-flirty. And we're going to see that more and more.
Dan, do you have a skype number to call? I'm international!
In my opinion... nobody gives a rat's ass about a some internet channel devoted to homophobia, or some video on FaceBook. Go out and have a car wash or bake sale... you're outcome will be the same... there will be no outcome. The ANSWER: go out and do what all good American's do... you file a civil law suit and sue the shit out of the school board, the school administration, then you subpoena and interview every teacher in the school, adding to the suit every teacher who knew, or had the vaguest indication that this student was being tortured by his classmates. After rounding-up every person in the school and administration, I would turn my focus on the real perpetrators, those students responsible for this hate crime.
To be even more precise, I would bankrupt this school system and vigorously pursue jail time for any and every professional educator and administrator who had even the slightest knowledge that "something" was going-on, but chose NOT to get involved.
When are you people going to figure it out; our country, our states, and our communities DON'T need more (useless) laws. We must enforce (to the fullest extent) the laws we already have in place.
I have no sympathy for any teacher, principal, school board member, or superintendent who fails to vigorously enforce the anti-bullying laws or hate crime legislation that already in place, or should be in place. Vicious bullying in middle and high school is old-news. Most teachers and administrators have already received training and should know how to deal with the little Nazi morons who harass and assault these poor kids.
Playing dumb (stupid); "I had no idea these kids were harassing him" has become the Nuremberg Defense of modern day bullying. It was a bullshit and unacceptable defense in post-war Germany, just as playing dumb/ignorant is bullshit and unacceptable today. If however, a teacher or administrator can prove their ignorance to the bullying, then they should be fired on the spot, and possibly sued for negligence.
You want these heinous crimes to stop; enforce the damn laws.
Respectfully submitted,
(a gay) 8th grade English teacher
222
hearing your inspiring message and seeing your beautiful family, i know that life will get better; the bad memories, alienation, self-hatred and shame will slowly fade away and be consumed by all the positives in my future.
thank you,
223
hearing your inspiring message and seeing your beautiful family, i know that life will get better; the bad memories, alienation, self-hatred and shame will slowly fade away and be consumed by all the positives in my future.
thank you,
224
I really think it is the party scene thing. My roommate is a super clubby girl and she tells me that all the gay guys make out with girls for shits and giggles when they are all hammered. I am bi and have friends of all sexual/gender identities, but none of my friend's kiss people they are not attracted to.
226
Doing nothing is so not working so lets do something even if it means filing a lawsuit.
Thank you for Project It Gets Better.
Please, if you're able, highlight the resources of Fenway Community Health's Peer Listening Line:
http://www.fenwayhealth.org/site/PageSer…
The Trevor Project: (866.4.U.TREVOR)
http://www.thetrevorproject.org/
And the Open and Affirming movement of the United Church of Christ:
http://www.ucccoalition.org
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/09…
and a seriously messed up thing to do to your roommate.
230
My girlfriend and I will definitely be participating in "it gets better", along with a slew of of our friends that we are rallying now!
There is a young lesbian, USC film school student named Becca Katz who has created a website called
http://www.IWantTheWorldToKnow.org
It is a video bank of folks telling their coming out stories so LGBT youth and isolated adults have access to other gay adults and the chance to hear their stories. Perhaps the two of you could link to each other's projects. Powerful together.
My girlfriend and I are out lesbian actors and gay advocates. We have both had features travelling the LGBT film festival circuit for the last 3 years, and another coming this year. We have found the internet to be a powerful connecting tool to be able to reach out to our LGBT community. We've created content and a community online to no one ever has to feel alone or isolated. It's good for us all to band together.
Thank you for doing this Dan. We will be participating and supporting.
Bravo -
Cathy DeBuono
My girlfriend and I will definitely be participating in "it gets better", along with a slew of of our friends that we are rallying now!
There is a young lesbian, USC film school student named Becca Katz who has created a website called
http://www.IWantTheWorldToKnow.org
It is a video bank of folks telling their coming out stories so LGBT youth and isolated adults have access to other gay adults and the chance to hear their stories. Perhaps the two of you could link to each other's projects. Powerful together.
My girlfriend and I are out lesbian actors and gay advocates. We have both had features travelling the LGBT film festival circuit for the last 3 years, and another coming this year. We have found the internet to be a powerful connecting tool to be able to reach out to our LGBT community. We've created content and a community online to no one ever has to feel alone or isolated. It's good for us all to band together.
Thank you for doing this Dan. We will be participating and supporting.
Bravo -
Cathy DeBuono
Love is love, and other peoples love is none of my business.
If any teen is being teased in my town, tell them to come over to my place. I will make them hot chocolate, make up the spare bed, and then open up a fresh can of whup-ass for their tormentor.
Bravo a thousand times over.
As a 63 year old gay man, my heart breaks every time I read about a gay young person's suicide.
It Get's Better is so heart warming.
A big pat on the back to you and these videos' submitters.
Michael J. Carlon, MD
Palm springs, CA
After 28 years out of high school, living in another county seems to help.
Dan--THANK YOU and BLESS YOU for yet more PURE GOLD!!! Stop the bullying everybody!
Here's an excerpt from a NY Times article...which hits the nail on the head:
"...In a pair of blog postings last week, Dan Savage, a sex columnist based in Seattle, assigns the blame to negligent teachers and school administrators, bullying classmates and “hate groups that warp some young minds and torment others.”
“There are accomplices out there,” he wrote Saturday.
In an interview, Mr. Savage, who is gay, said he was particularly irate at religious leaders who used “antigay rhetoric.”
These are the people who are responsible for the hate, indifference, bullying, gross negligence that allows gays to be pushed to suicide.
The Federal Government (Justice Department) should be investigating each of these events as a denial of civil rights of the gay, lesbian, transgender persons.
HELLO??? JUSTICE DEPARTMENT???? WHERE ARE YOU???
YOU WERE ABLE TO INVESTIGATE THE LONG SERIES OF BLACK MURDERS AND DISCRIMINATION OVER THE YEARS.
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE RIGHTS OF GAYS WHO ARE BEING BULLIED AND EVEN MURDERED?
WHAT HAPPENED TO FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS AND YOUR RECENT NEW DIRECTIVE TO LOOK INTO GAY HATE CRIMES?
JOIN THE MASTURBATE AGAINST CHRISTINE O'DONNELL GROUP HERE
Join Michael and Marisa in the "It Gets Better" campaign to STOP bullying. The sibling music duo urge their peers to stand up against bullying with their acoustic song "The Same." http://bit.ly/bwXTg0
Here is my "It Gets Better" video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UH46lY25…
Here is my "It Gets Better" contribution
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1UH46lY25…
I dealt with my problems by developing thick skin, using acquired experience and above all, refusing to give up, and not one of your pathetic groups is going to do any of that for a kid.
What you're doing is much more monstrous and cruel than what any of those bullies did, to be honest. You are robbing kids of the reality of life, putting them in a nice safe little bubble that will agonizingly erupt when they get into the real world. You cannot please everyone, and nothing in life is beautiful forever.
Oh yeah, and when someone commits suicide, it's an act of their own free will, and it wouldn't make much sense to sue a rope company because one of their ropes were used by a suicidal teen.
Think about it.
I dealt with my problems by developing thick skin, using acquired experience and above all, refusing to give up, and not one of your pathetic groups is going to do any of that for a kid.
What you're doing is much more monstrous and cruel than what any of those bullies did, to be honest. You are robbing kids of the reality of life, putting them in a nice safe little bubble that will agonizingly erupt when they get into the real world. You cannot please everyone, and nothing in life is beautiful forever.
Oh yeah, and when someone commits suicide, it's an act of their own free will, and it wouldn't make much sense to sue a rope company because one of their ropes were used by a suicidal teen.
Think about it.
http://ireport.cnn.com/docs/DOC-500234
Can we please tell kids who are being sexually abused to hang in there too please? Ask them to come read the pages for kids who are being sexually abused at JustTell.org a new nonprofit which encourages sexually abused kids to tell an adult they trust about what's happening.
Peace
Vivian Farmery
Director, Just Tell
JustTell.org
Thank you.
Vivian Farmery
Just Tell
No it doesn't. Maybe in some cases, but not on it's own and not in most cases.
If you seed hope, you'll be reaping disappointment. Too fluttery, too fragile, too unreliable.
Want to help? Feed them INFORMATION. ARGUMENTS. FACTS.
Don't give them a crutch to survive. Offer them a weapon to live.
For some us it doesn't get better being out of closet, it doesn't give loving relationships or choices. We still struggle, we still struggle cope.
Sometimes there no such thing as hope you learn to take what you can. People still bully each other around difference even as a adult and it gets very hard sometimes to cope with it but you do your best to cope that is all you can do.
My compassion guided me to publish an anthology, "Step Into My Shoes: Expressions from the LGBTQ Community", which will accept submissions until April 20, 2011.
www.jafansta.com/anthology.aspx or poetry@jafansta.com
http://meladermwarning.com/
http://www.self-help-sexuality.com/gay-s…
http://www.self-help-sexuality.com/gay-s…
http://www.self-help-sexuality.com/gay-s…







RSS
Comments (283) RSS