Green star Shoofly Pie Company: CLOSED (West Seattle)

4444 California Ave SW
Seattle, WA 98116
(206) 938-0680
Website

Categories: Bakery, Cafe, Restaurant

Restaurant Details

  • Want some sort of food in a crust? Shoofly Pie Co. has it all—sweet, savory, pot, custard, and, of course, the namesake shoofly—by the slice or whole pie. It is all so, so good. And as a sign inside Shoofly Pie Co. says: "Pie Fixes Everything."
  • Features: Cheap Eats
  • Cuisine: Bakery and Dessert
  • Price Range: $

The Stranger's Reviews of Shoofly Pie Company

 
 

Average Rating:
  • 4.70000/5 Stars.
Reviews/Comments (10) RSS

Newest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a review of Shoofly Pie Company
10

Buttery Goodness

Everything they have is handmade from scratch – no bland factory/frozen pie taste here! Everything is fruity flaky goodness with seasonal changes in the menu. You can also buy Old School’s vanilla frozen custard to take home, so that you can eat your warmed-up pie a la mode, as I did.

Full review and pictures: http://sweettoothinseattle.com/2011/05/2…
Posted by lisarosebruce on May 22, 2011 at 5:53 PM · Report this
9

Heaven is indeed a place on earth-

I didn't even know I liked pecan pie. But theirs is the best pie I have ever had...

The next day I had the mini veggie pot pie for lunch. Perfect.
Posted by Ryan on October 30, 2008 at 12:37 PM · Report this
8

man its good

I bought a marion berry pie at an auction from Shoo fly, it was hands down the best pie I have ever eaten. You just can't eat one piece.. and I honestly felt like I was doign my body good with all that fruit. It was not sickenly sweet,, just perfect
Posted by Chris Mackay on June 8, 2008 at 5:29 PM · Report this
7

Comfort Food Now

You simply cannot go wrong with their pies. What I like about the pies is their simplicity and reliance on real ingredients such as butter and fresh fruit. Now, before I make my own pies, I ask myself "Would I rather just spend $20 and get one right away?" This is the sort of place that makes me proud and fortunate to live in West Seattle.
Posted by naomi on December 28, 2007 at 2:01 PM · Report this
6

Fabulous

I love this establishment and the pie. I highly recommend everyone check it out.
Posted by Katy on November 20, 2007 at 2:50 PM · Report this
5

I brake for shoofly pie

I've tried the blackberry-raspberry, the strawberry rhubarb, and the chicken potpie, and loved them all. It's hand-crafted deliciousness. I can't wait to try the rest of the pies. And the service is wonderful.
Posted by gusta on November 16, 2007 at 4:41 PM · Report this
4

Delicious!

Shoofly Pie is the place to go! I went in got a latte and a slice of pumpkin pie, and I was in heaven. The crust couldn't be better, and the filling is just perfect. Even if you don't like sweet pie, they do have savory, chicken pot pies, onion gallettes and even quiche!
Posted by N-N-N-Nanners on November 15, 2007 at 10:37 AM · Report this
3

Delicious!

Shoofly Pie is the place to go! I went in got a latte and a slice of pumpkin pie, and I was in heaven. The crust couldn't be better, and the filling is just perfect. Even if you don't like sweet pie, they do have savory, chicken pot pies, onion gallettes and even quiche!
Posted by N-N-N-Nanners on November 15, 2007 at 10:37 AM · Report this
2

Yummy

Not sure if I want to invest $20 in a whole pie, but getting a slice with a cup of coffee is a great treat on a blustery day.
Posted by Bob Loblaw on November 14, 2007 at 4:50 PM · Report this
1

That's good pie!

We walked in at the tail end of a lunch dessert rush. All patrons looked happy with their varied slices. We opted for the Strawberry Rubarb and Key Lime. Thumbs up on both for taste, presentation and customer service. Check it out!
Posted by T1 and T2 on August 8, 2007 at 4:20 PM · Report this

Add a review


Click the stars.

Optional

Shoofly Pie Company
Nearby and Recommended

Elliott Bay Brewery (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4720 California Ave SW    phone (206) 932-8695
  • 4.00000/5 Stars.
(based on 6 reader reviews)
Ma’ono Fried Chicken & Whisky (Bar, Pop-Up, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4437 California Ave SW    phone (206) 935-1075
  • 2.33000/5 Stars.
(based on 6 reader reviews)
Buddha Ruksa (Restaurant)
West Seattle 3520 SW Genesee Street    phone (206) 937-7676
  • 4.50000/5 Stars.
(based on 4 reader reviews)
Mission (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 2325 California Ave SW    phone (206) 937-8220
  • 3.71000/5 Stars.
(based on 7 reader reviews)
West 5 (Bar, Restaurant)
West Seattle 4539 California Ave SW    phone (206) 935-1966
  • 4.14000/5 Stars.
(based on 14 reader reviews)
Mashiko (Restaurant)
West Seattle 4725 California Ave SW    phone (206) 935-4339
  • 4.33000/5 Stars.
(based on 12 reader reviews)