Sound Check
Chris Jury of the Bismarck Vents About the Seattle Music Industry
George Jury
THE BISMARCK Big in North Dakota.
Tools
Chris Jury is a guitarist/vocalist from Seattle rock band the Bismarck. In the 20 years he's been playing and working within the business of music, he's formulated some opinions about our music scene—a scene that hasn't necessarily bought what he's been selling. The Bismarck do everything themselves. They make straight-up rock that's of and for volume. Overdriven guitars and screamed vocals fire through a sloppy turret. Originally from North Dakota, the Bismarck are instilled with a workmanlike Midwestern ethic. They record, engineer, produce, and release their own music (three full-lengths since 2002, the latest being Great Plains in May 2010). They book their own shows and tours, silk-screen their own shirts, build their own instruments, drive their own van, and do all their own promotion. Through trial and error, they've learned where to tour and what spots to play. Now, music is something the Bismarck does more for fun. They aren't trying to "make it" anymore.
Stranger Personals
Jury and bandmates have grown frustrated with a scene that hasn't accepted their brand of rock music. They gave up caring about playing Seattle shows years ago, instead opting to tour and play where they are better received. In the Bismarck song "Not If You Were the Last Team Gina Fan on Earth," Jury sings, "Everyone was wearing girl pants... Everyone was on the cocaine... Everyone had an awkward haircut/And everyone was sucking everyone else's dick." Jury and I spoke. No fellatio or girl pants were involved.
Why don't you care about playing Seattle shows anymore?
Because the Bismarck and our music aren't fashionable. It's not for scenesters or buzz-feeding press. We're fine with it at this point. There's plenty of other places we love to play.
What do you think of the current Seattle music scene?
It's a good indication that something is wrong in a given scene when bands like Police Teeth or Kozo can do very well touring the Midwest, East Coast, and Europe, but locally have a hard time getting the time of day. Local bands, both here and in Portland, that have their social infrastructure here often have an easier time and get better receptions elsewhere, and do so consistently. The Hunches are a good example. In Portland or Seattle, they were playing at a two-thirds-full Funhouse or Twilight Lounge, but when they toured Europe, they were playing with JSBX or the Stooges at large festivals.
What's the problem, then?
I think a band that is making outstanding music should have trouble deciding what venues or shows to play, rather than sweating it out on a Saturday afternoon in front of 20 people. And, given an opportunity, local press should be seeking these folks out, rather than writing weekly about the same bands, many of whom are not making particularly great music.
You recently booked a European tour for your band. How was booking that as opposed to booking shows in Seattle?
I actually had a much easier time booking the Newcastle-Leeds-Nottingham-London leg of the tour than I had booking our last Sunset show. Which is why we quit giving a shit about playing Seattle years ago. The Sunset is easy to work with, and I have always had good experiences with the folks who book and work there. But even the relatively easy process at a welcoming venue like the Sunset is harder than booking in many other places—even the process of visas and work permits is more straightforward. I can't really describe it in another way. The level of effort involved is simply less. I send mail, they reply with a yes or no, I move on to the next venue or town.
How often does the Bismarck tour?
We tour once a year. We have jobs and wives and kids that take priority over this hobby. In the past it was more than that, and longer, ragged outings. Prior to that I was in a band that did barn-burning tours several times a year, and so got plenty of practice lifting heavy things and sleeping in vans. We generally do okay on tour, although we opt for doing interesting things rather than profitable things, because this is also our vacation and we'd rather enjoy it than be in situations that are boring or uninteresting. Being able to do a couple nights with Bottomless Pit or IfIHadAHiFi can make you feel like you're in Cheap Trick or something.
Where do you all do best?
The Bismarck seems to do best in the upper Midwest. Some of that is due to the fact that we are all from North Dakota, so our aesthetic and our ethos seem to resonate. Chicago, Milwaukee, Kalamazoo, Minneapolis are great, but Bismarck, Minot, Fargo, Grand Forks are great too. The exciting thing is that you simply never know where something amazing will happen. Places like Tulsa, Memphis, or Cullman, Alabama, have been really welcoming and were routine stops in the past.
How do you go about setting up your tours? What have you learned?
To my mind there are two important things to balance: contact with friends and sympathetic audiences, and then risk-taking with unfamiliar promoters, towns, bands, etc. For example, with this upcoming UK tour we are playing with an aesthetically similar band for a run of shows in Scotland, and will be doing a festival the following weekend. But one night in the middle of the week we are playing in a tiny market village along Hadrian's Wall. That is a risk, but what fun is a tour without risk.
I am perfectly happy playing in a one-car garage in the middle of a cemetery in Cedar Rapids, Iowa. Working with very young promoters, playing in unusual spaces or in towns that are often overlooked is rewarding. I grew up in Bismarck, North Dakota, and started booking touring bands when I was in high school. I had to ask bands to trust me, that I would give them as much cash as I could, find opening bands, get them fed, and give them a place to sleep. I was just reminded that a former bandmate of mine did a show for Dead and Gone on the loading dock at her father's tree nursery around 1996. Locals still talk about that show. Bands need to be willing to take those risks, because they can be very worthwhile. I know Dead and Gone made like $500 playing that show between door and merch, but it would have been really easy to blow it off.
What bands would you like to see get more press?
The Pitch. Meghan from Racetrack. Wyoming Young and Strong. Josh and Josh from Lake of Falcons. Red Hex from Tacoma. Minutes from Kalamazoo. Ex Wives. That Fucking Tank from Leeds. Bottomless Pit. The Family Ghost from Memphis. Trophy Wives from Louisville. And IfIHadAHiFi from Milwaukee are great.
I'm an old man. I work a lot and spend most of my time doing things that are not music-related. So I'm always thrilled to see exciting local bands, bands that are doing something vital and uncalculated. I have had my fill of smug, cool, disaffected bullshit. I want to see people who are enjoying themselves, are excited about what they are doing and have some nervous energy behind them. I don't want to see laconic pop or fake hardcore.
I was happy to see Special Explosion get some attention. I saw one of their first shows when I was helping out at the Monroe YMCA. They had all sorts of technical and "band etiquette" issues to work out, but it was obvious to everyone they were going to do amazing things, and now a year or two later, here they are.
So the Seattle music scene sucks, and you don't give a shit about playing here. Why do you live here?
My wife and I moved here for work. Many of our friends had moved out here as well, so that made it more appealing. I wouldn't say the scene sucks—that would be a bit simplistic. I would say that there are a few specific forms of music-making that are in vogue, and those are the acts that get a disproportionate share of the attention available. My band doesn't happen to be part of that scene, so trying to force ourselves onto an audience that isn't interested is not much fun. We play with friends' bands or when we have the chance to do something interesting, like screening the Grateful Lovers documentary. But we don't look for shows, try to get on bills just to play, or try to make it to the next level here. It isn't worth the time.
Whose fault is all this? The suckiness of the scene, in your eyes?
I'm not sure there is a fault. I think there is a disconnect between local press, local venues, and local musicians. What brought this to the fore was a seemingly endless stream of minutiae about a single local band on Line Out a few weeks back. There is a large pool of exciting bands that haven't been able to garner much attention, and there are venues that want to fill the rooms. Then there is local music press that needs to straddle the line between telling people about stuff they already like and introducing new stuff to at least appear to be a likely source of information on the next thing. I'm not sure how to get them all playing together. One of the nice things is that with a blog, as opposed to a physical paper, there is no limit on content other than what someone can upload, and there are a pile of folks who would do so for free.
Blogging is always the answer.
Yes. [Laughs] I mean, pretending like playing music, or writing about it, or booking shows is difficult or unknowable is a losing proposition. That is what happened in Olympia in the late '90s. Twenty years ago, Olympia was the epicenter of American underground music. The tastemakers went in one direction, the interested public went another, but control of the venues and labels stayed with the first generation. Even as late as '99 I would organize a tour around a date in Olympia. Now maybe one in five bands that tour through here bother to stop in Olympia. None of this is somehow beyond the grasp of the average person. I strongly believe that anyone with the enthusiasm and will to do so can learn to make interesting music, write in an interesting manner, or learn the mechanics of organizing events.
What would make the scene better?
The youth! [Laughs] I think there are real consequences to having an environment where the youth have no space or incentive to step up. If thirtysomethings are running the scene, booking every venue, operating the labels, then it becomes likely that the high school kids won't have much of a voice and that aesthetic differences won't be respected. They could force the issue and reject the old guard or go elsewhere to make their contribution. I want to be pushed aside when I'm behaving like a stubborn old man, assuming I know how things ought to work or what a band ought to do. If I'm doing sound at some community center rock show and a kid feels like they can handle it without me, they should feel empowered ask me to turn over the board.
If you were a club owner/promoter/booker, what would you do? How would you run that type of business? Look at it all from their perspective.
I've been a promoter, a booker, and managed a part-time venue. None of those jobs are easy. Making sure the underlying business is sound and that you are maximizing value from the space is foremost. Music happens at night, so it should be only a portion of your business plan. When I was a younger man I taught at a high school during the day, delivered pizzas at night, and worked construction on the weekends. There are a lot of hours in the day. If the thing you do for four to five hours, three to four nights a week isn't making the nut, then you need to rethink.
If a band can't bring in people, how is the club supposed to make money?
I guess it depends on the business model. I don't think the clubs, like Showbox or Nuemos, are struggling, or if they are it isn't because they are giving too much stage time to unknown local bands. On the other hand, some of the bars that do shows are more or less empty when shows aren't going on. I am particularly impressed with the Sunset using part of their space for pizza—an outstanding idea. I think there is a lot of opportunity for more fully utilizing space and resources. If a venue is relying on me to bring 30 to 40 people on the Wednesday you saw fit to let my band open for some horseshit Alkaline Trio cover band, and the sum total of your promotional effort was to list it in your one-eighth-of-a-page alt-weekly ad, I am not terribly sympathetic to your problems.
What do you want to see happen?
I think there is a lot of opportunity to tap an amazing group of ambitious young people who want to be making music, writing, or promoting. Rather than dumping money into the Vera Project, why don't we work to encourage spaces where bands can play their first shows? Why not let some kid book the first Tuesday night of the month at your empty bar to let them learn the ropes and try to do something fun? Why doesn't Line Out have dozens of posts daily from high school and college kids who are totally into music and want to write about it? It isn't like it costs you anything. So what if you end up with an article about how great Skrillex is. It can't be any worse than that tour diary from Monogamy Party. ![]()
This story has been updated since its original publication.
3
So after 20 years of a hard time in Seattle, you blame everything but your own music? Bismarck isnt bad, but its not great either. There is no shortage in straight forward mid tempo rock anywhere in America. There are a zillion bands in Seattle and I think you guys are way too milquetoast to really deserve any attention. Do you seriously listen to your bands songs and hear something special that sets you apart? I can understand being pissed that other bands are getting way more coverage than others, but I just made it through 6 tracks of your album posted here and I dont see why you think you deserve more coverage than say...MONOGAMY PARTY.
-Jason
I dont think it was a sucker punch to Monogamy Party. I think he was pointing out the fact that it is kind of crazy that one band that gets written up constantly is basically just handed the keys to car. "Fuck it, write yourself up... here's a login"
6
FWIW, Chris explained the intent of that line in the comments of this Line Out post:
http://www.thestranger.com/lineout/archi…
I have already seen a lot of hurt feelings and pushback over what is really a very mild criticism of a few elements of a music scene. It might be important for us all to remember that we are adults (more or less) and that we can survive some needling and some honest criticism. I hear mean, un-constructive things about my band, my movie, my craftsmanship, my male-pattern baldness all the time. It doesn't stop me from playing, editing, building, balding. What I love is the " You fucked up...and here is what you can do about it", which I tried to speak about as much as I could.
8
As the person who *actually* was responsible for this lyric, I would like to clarify that I am not using "dick sucking" in a literal, sexual sense - I'm specifically referring to the practice of critical "dick-sucking", i.e. mindless praise, often motivated by a personal relationship with the subject. This was, ironically, motivated by a string of Line Out posts several years back where the authors were simply going in a circle promoting each other's bands - sorry, make that, DJ-ing gigs. As I've said in the past, where it concerns The Bismarck, all "dick sucking" is metaphorical; all "chick fucking", hypothetical. I would also like to state, for the record: I have no problem with literal dick sucking between consenting adults. The world could use some more happiness.
11
Granted, that's like two mentions in the Stranger/Line Out over the course of two years, for a band that's been playing shows in Seattle since 2003.
14
15
you can type "the bismarck" into the little search box above and see they've had pretty consistent (and positive) mentions over the course of many years.
not to the level of hype that's being vented about, to be sure.
look, i get it. chris is not particularly venting about his own band's coverage. some bands that could be judged as no better than the next get hyped while other good bands (subjective) get overlooked. old saw.
the stranger's had its ups and downs with music coverage, but i think they've been striking a bit of the balance chris is requesting lately.
And for your knowledge, the very thing you say old men should do, help teens book their first shows, set aside time for teens to run their own shows, is what The Vera Project does every day. Why don't you go down there and get involved, instead of bitching about how things aren't working the way you want it to
http://theveraproject.org/getinvolved/ve…
18
Totally true.
And I agree that music coverage has gotten more varied, and several of the folks that write for the Stranger and Line Out have more than gone out of their way to bring attention to new bands, instead of post after post about Shabaza Palaces.
Jaded old rock dude from moderately popular bar rock band popular in places with zero taste in music bitches to weekly "hipster" music rag about how oppressed and underrepresented his band is while receiving a pretty modest write-up in said newspaper. He claims, "We're fine with it at this point." I really doubt he is fine with it, as he seems fairly annoyed and stubborn in general. He's really only in Seattle because of work.
News bulletin complete.
20
It's almost enough to make you wonder if he has a point.
21
So was Prussian Blue not available for an interview for why the music scene sucks? (spoiler: not nearly enough white people)
23
24
26
That song didn't have a specific band name in the title until we had to print up the record covers. It was just "Not If You Were the Last ... Fan on Earth" on set lists; we usually just substituted in whatever band we were playing with. Usually Police Teeth.
At the time (maybe 2008?), it seemed that everywhere I went, everyone (boys and girls alike) were wearing girls' pants. That seemed like a really odd fashion trend - even for Adam Grunke. And don't forget - "pants" is a pretty easy word to rhyme for the unclever among us.
A little while before finalizing the song title, I went to go see a show at El Corazon where Lake of Falcons (a band I really liked) was opening a show that Team Gina was headlining. Lake of Falcons was good as usual and then Team Gina came onstage and did what Team Gina did. And the people who had milled around talking during the Falcons' set loved it. It was just strange - going from a band with a bunch of dudes playing instruments and yelling and sweating and all that to two ladies rapping over an iPod. It was like literally watching your favorite kind of music fall out of favor. I'm sure this happened to disco fans in the 70s and hair metal fans in the 90s and it sure as hell happened to me as a fan of loud independent rock music in the 2000s.
Along with watching my favorite kind of music wither due to the changing tastes (led, in no small part, by outlets like Pitchfork), I also was stuck watching a bunch of DIY venues I really liked (SS Marie, Atlas Clothing, etc.) get shut down and the already tight supply of venues willing to book unpopular music get tighter. Combine all that with getting older - having less time to dedicate to finding new music intersected with less venues in which to see the kind of music I like and less press outlets dedicating space to it.
The frustation that came from all this got channeled into that song. I think frustration is a pretty universal sentiment - gay, straight, old, young, whatever. There's always something that isn't what you want it to be.
Did the people of Seattle really think that "Fuck the Police" was a call to have sex with police officers?
Yale (Hifi) Mke.
The sentiments Chris expresses in this interview are pretty much universal from one town to the next in this crazy country of ours. I could do the same interview about Milwaukee, the Trophy Wives guys could do the same one about Louisville, etc.
Also, the idea that the quality of one's music has anything to do with whether or not that music comes into fashion or becomes popular is pretty hilarious, as the majority of music history is littered with forgotten, excellent bands and mediocre nonsense that becomes popular. How are you guys digging that Lana Del Rey record?
I believe you that when you say that sucking each other's dicks isn't meant to be literal. It's knock on a self-obsessed scene. The problem is that the alternative (what you'd rather be doing) is fucking chicks. The people you don't like are sucking dicks, you and your cool friends are fucking chicks. You can see how people might interpret the song as homophobic, no?
I don't think you're homophobic, you just wrote a bad lyric because it was an easy rhyme. Now you get to live with the consequences. I think you'll live just fine.
Turn The Bismarck records on and remember that rock n roll is supposed to be loud, crazy, stupid and fun!
35
I'm with #33. For the record, I don't think you guys are homophobic, thought the lyrics certainly don't help your case. Also, for the record, I think Team Gina is an abomination to music - we can all agree on that.
@34:
I think anyone at any age has a right to make loud rock music, there are plenty of people in their 40s, 50s, and beyond who are still make vital rock music. I think people are ultimately hung up on the out of touch comments like "It's not for scenesters or buzz-feeding press". It's a self-defeating prophecy, like saying "people don't like good music and since we play good music, they won't like us". People ultimately like what they like, and a lot of it is misguided much of them time, but blaming people for not liking you because they are a "scenester" is really kind of lame.
But I fully agree with your statement, TURN THE BISMARK RECORDS OFF AND REMEMBER THAT ROCK AND ROLL IS SUPPOSED TO BE LOUD, CRAZY, STUPID AND FUN!
But I fully agree with your statement, TURN THE BISMARK RECORDS OFF AND REMEMBER THAT ROCK AND ROLL IS SUPPOSED TO BE LOUD, CRAZY, STUPID AND FUN!
Hey when can we start calling AC/DC homophobic for writing lyrics about oral sex?
But damn do i disagree with@36.
I hear what you're saying. There is some patently offensive shit out there but, in my mind at least, there's a pretty big gap between the "Team Gina" song and, say, Billy the Fridge's "Fat Bitches" or, you know, anything any member of Odd Future says ever. Those examples aside, I do think that when it comes to creative or artistic pursuits, some degree of ambiguity surrounding the artist's intent is fine, desirable even. Playing it completely safe and avoiding words or sentiments that are provocative or open to some interpretation seems like a path towards making safe, uninteresting music. Take Pere Ubu's "Final Solution" or Minor Threat's "White Minority". Or just the name "Joy Division". Given how "straightforward" and "mid-tempo" we are considered, just imagine if we sat around rhyming "fire" with "funeral pyre".
I also think that it's a stretch to assume that every lyric a person sings is a direct reflection of the person's deepest beliefs. To put it another way, do you think Johnny Cash actually shot a man in Reno just to watch him die?
At no point did I say that we did care, and then gave up because we 'were not popular.' We have been a backseat, spare time band from day one.
And Eric @36, I wholeheartedly agree. The Bismarck doesn't need more shows, we don't need more press, and we do not represent any 'fix' for the scene. We are old guys indulging in a hobby, not unlike fishing.
But you guys don't come out when I help a bunch of high school kids put on a show in their gym to raise funds for an after school 'rock' club, or for a skate park in sultan, or school clothes in Arlington, or bilingual materials for a safe-dating program in Lynnwood. Those are the sorts of things I spend most of my time working on (for my day job), and the things that are ignored by the local press, even after I email, call, and beg. In the process we've been able to provide an opportunity for hundreds kids to play their first shows ever, teaching them how to negotiate venue usage and insurance, cobble together PAs, deal with uptight 'headliner' bands, noise complaints, security and all the other headaches that go into doing DIY shows in the real world.
I have been helping people setup all ages shows for 25 years, and do so EVERYDAY as a volunteer in direct support at the Vera Project, and indirectly at Ground Zero, Old Firehouse and KTUB, and assisted in the production of a book about how to navigate those issues with All Ages Movement Project and Vera. Calling out bands like Monogamy Party who have also been involved in doing that for a long time, and complaining in the very press you have issues with is going to leave you in a position that is hard to be sympathetic about.
Music is a business, and with any business, trends, demand, and people's taste change. It is up to the artist to decide if they want to adapt, change or keep doing what they love because they love it.
Sometimes no one cares at all about a band until they have been doing the same thing for years, then all of a sudden hey are the coolest band ever because they never lost their integrity, Dead Moon is a great example of this.
Unfortunately, taking this tone is ultimately likely to make you sound like a whiny person and drive away any people that might actually do things like give you shows. But who knows, as they say any press is good press right?
43
44
45
46
i admire The Bismarck's whole work ethic: DIY, don't worry about popularity, live within your means, do it for fun, etc. But if you really don't give a fuck about people that don't like your music, you shouldn't be fixating on bands you don't like and/or their fashion sense. if you complain that Seattle's music scene is for "scenesters and buzz-feeding press", why sing about buzz-bands like Team Gina? you have to understand that that comes across as accusatory and bitter towards anyone that's not already a fan of The Bismarck. there are "a few specific forms of music-making that are in vogue, and those are the acts that get a disproportionate share of the attention"? let's list off a few press-darlings from the last year: Tiny Vipers, Crypts, Black Breath, My Goodness, The Intelligence, Tit Pig, Shabazz Palaces, Helms Alee, Monogamy Party... have we covered all of those "few specific forms"?
and some of the Seattle-bashing seems dishonest. it's harder to book the Sunset than book an upcoming U.K. tour? really? i've booked a lot of shows in Seattle and toured the U.K. multiple times, and i call bullshit. it's either a gross exaggeration, a sign that you're over-complicating the process of booking in Seattle venues, or a red flag that your U.K. dates are going to be plagued with problems and oversights. sorry to be harsh here, but if you were dead serious, get back to me once you've gone through U.K.'s customs and immigration.
as for what The Stranger/Line Out should be doing by Jury's estimation--the music staff has not grown since Line Out started. that means that in addition to tackling all the stuff associated with the paper, the staff also handles the blog now too. fortunately, there are bloggers like James Burns and I that help with some of the writing here. but everything we write still has to go through staff, which means they still have to edit things. increasing our volume increases their burden. Chris, i'm sorry we didn't write about the shows you coordinated through your day job in Arlington. why didn't you hit up James about it? why didn't you hit me up about it? it's no guarantee that we'd have time to cover it, especially since there's no shortage of stuff already going on within Seattle-proper on any given night and the freelance bloggers here all have day jobs and other shit going on too. if it makes you feel any better, we also don't write too often about shows on the Eastside, or in Tacoma. cuz, you know, it's a Seattle paper.
sorry to ramble. honestly, i want nothing but the best for The Bismarck. solid band, solid principles. but man, you'd really rather read a high school student talk about Skrillex than read a Monogamy Party tour diary? now you're just fucking with us...
47
I should've known better! Damn comments. They're such a tease.
50
article: I was taking it more as all being about Bismarck not getting enough attention, but it's mostly just the opening and the first few questions/answers and then becomes more about bands in general than Bismarck.
comments: Jury's follow up comments comes across way more down to earth and really clears up that he wasnt just trying to whine about his band.
Personally, I read the whole thing the first time and didnt have a strong reaction until the last paragraph. The Vera Project is doing exactly what Jury suggests the youth need and he throws them under the bus. Then my love for Monogamy Party blinded me with rage, but I think commenter J Burns is right, he didnt actually say they were a bad band. For me, it was this part of the interview that really made Jury come across less as trying to improve the scene and more as "a jaded old dude bitching about things he was unfamilar with."
also, people might be accusing him of being an old man, despite being in his 30's, from this quote in the interview: "Im an old man". :)
must...beat...horse...
One thing I'd point out, that people don't seem to be hitting on is the issue of narrative.
People who read a blog regularly, who return and refresh for new content, get accustomed to updates on information they've already got. If I go to a neighborhood news site and read about, say, a series of burglaries, and there's no follow-up, I get frustrated.
Likewise (thoug perhaps less urgent), I think there's a value to a running-throughline that a tour diary provides. If I don't care about the band (or theink they're bad writers) I won't read it, but I see why Lineout would host them.
This doesn't preclude more, newer content about various types of bands and music (brian hits on the preclusions there, in his post) but it makes sense to me why a few names would pop up consistently.
This Bismarck is a superb band.
Not sure why anything here is controversial.
58
59
Even better, Eric, the other guitarist from the Bismarck, has been making documentaries of their tours since 2006. They're pretty much what I refer someone to when they want to know what touring at this level is like.
2006:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GH-tDg32D…
2007:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVUlq9TRN…
2008:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8BmRy1FD…
2009:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COA1GHFt2…
2010:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eu8oOOadO…
And I may have taken a bit of a jab at Vera because while they do help young people, it is not a venue for very young bands. Several young friends of mine have claimed to have been treated poorly there. I hope those cases are exaggeration and misunderstanding.
I am much more infatuated with the MCCC/Liberty model. A group of young folks (18-19) got together, signed a lease for a small retail space, made it a private club with a yearly membership fee of $1 to reduce insurance and security costs/requirements. They operated the space for 10 years, with a rotating cast of young folks running the space, no one over 22 ever being involved in any way-operated solely on income from shows. In many ways I think providing too much 'assistance' is a bad thing. just create the space, and demand that they figure a lot of this stuff out on their own if they want it to happen. Kids have been putting on shows in Rec Center basements for 60 years...If you stay out of the way, and maybe lend an occasional hand with a specific issue or problem, they will do just fine. Opportunity also means the opportunity to fail. The secret is to not let the failure be disheartening or disastrous.
62
Seattle is a small city with a very outsized music scene (though probably not nearly so much as portlandia).
This is really awesome for someone who likes to see tons of very diverse music (in scope, genre, and quality), but if you're producing the music, YMMV unless you're one of the few strike it lucky, typically by virtue of connections or extreme extroverts. And ever heard of a starving artist? Well, yeah... unfortunately the stereotype exists for a reason. All you can do is your best and love what you do and whatever comes of it.
Face it, lots of really great music does make it, as does tons of shitty alternatives. It's going to happen like that anywhere, and in that way Seattle is not atypical in any way.
67
68
I can't find these guys on Rhapsody.
How about flying a slight bit higher so the radar can git you?
69
Ignore the monoculturists on Capitol Hill and live in the Real World of Seattle.
71
lemme guess, your typical show is a pickle party of angsty boys with pit stains who like to "sing along"?
There is an implied reciprocity and homogeneity which perfectly illustrates the songwriter's point. He could have opted for illustrating his point with a reference to 69ing but it loses the aspect of insularity in like which he decries. He could have opted for illustrating his point with a reference to mutual cunnilingus but that might seem like a direct affront to Team Gina. It would definitely seem contrived compared to a reference like a circle jerk or the lyrics he actually settled on.
But don't let my critical thinking get in the way of your recreational persecution. Leave no stone unturned in your search for the offensive. Leave no mind unpoliced. Stay vigilant. The real killers are still out there.
75
How about "ass kissing"? Can we still use that phrase without you reading homophobia into it?
If you are representative of the Seattle rock scene, the situation is even worse than Chris described.
@67- Not sure how you get to 'Butt Rock.' I'd always heard that term applied to late-era hair metal, or perhaps early-period grunge. We usually get tagged with "Ragged post-punk" or the like. Happy to take on a new label-maybe that one will help us get some high paying 'night club' gigs in Stillwater, Oklahoma or something.
@72- Thank you for explaining that better than we could. To this end at all future Seattle shows I will describe the content and context of each song before we play it. Here is an example:
Sandbar Knifefighter Blues: I grew up in Bismarck, ND. The Missouri is a very large river and creates these sandbars that are miles long- noboby owns them and the police can't patrol them, so as long as you can swim out there it is "anything goes." Fighting was a constant, knife fights were common, and the song is about getting ready for one -squaring up your affairs in case it goes poorly. "give my stuff to my brother/except for my jacket/I wanna be buried in that"
77
Also, liquor laws making it extremely difficult for there to be economically viable all ages venues has an extremely negative effect on our music scene.
Also, liquor laws making it difficult for there to be economically viable all ages venues has an extremely negative effect on our music scene.
84
Feel good you fucking bully?
Seriously, since Grandy fucked up the scene, it's never recovered.
I've heard the guys from the Bismarck are from my hometown but I had no idea we were at the same shows 15 years ago!
88
And how did grandy ruin the scene? This, too, confuses me.
@88 -Some of the stuff that gets coverage is amazing, I don't think I ever claimed otherwise, but some of it is fucking aweful. a couple years back I got an ear full of aggression every time I suggested Vampire Weekend might not be the second coming... Just saying.
90
91
There is nothing wrong with this type of music, I realize it still exists and some people love it, I just think we should be honest about its broader appeal: there isn't any. So lets stop with the veteran-rock-obligations, delusions of underground grandeur that could've been and blaming some new non-existent "scene" of mythical tight-pants beasts with weird haircuts that somehow controls the music world in the age of infinite internet. You guys should be doing this for yourselves and if you can't get a decent gig around here maybe you should just shrug your shoulders and start fresh with free basement shows (or better yet, open a small idealistic venue, you're certainly old enough). There is no shame in starting fresh, keeping it small, writing some new songs so all your friends don't have to go to their 85th show and pretend they still enjoy hearing all your classic songs over-and-over-and-over again.
If not, as it was addressed in the article (and I realize this is not as easy as it sounds by any stretch of the imagination) maybe you should move back to the Midwest. Don't take this wrong, I'm not the type to say "get outta town" (I don't feel that way, and local music diversity is a good thing) but it sounds like it would solve all your band's problems.
94
I dunno, I just can't get over the fact that you think think music popularity should somehow be correlated to talent or authenticity. This is rule #1 of the music consumption universe, it's practically a law of physics. There is no way you will somehow change it with lyrics, blog posts or any sort of approximation of music commentary. It's ultimately a fight you will bring to the grave as your band slowly fades away. You can shout about it, plead and beg, reason it out with logic, put all of your energy into convincing kids they shouldn't listen to bands you don't like but you are just wasting your time.














RSS
Comments (96) RSS