Film

The Citizens of the Ruins

Detropia Is the Best Documentary Yet About the Decline of Detroit

The Citizens of the Ruins
  • comments (4)
  • Print

Near the end of this beautiful but also richly informative documentary, two white European men walk into a Detroit cafe and order coffee from Crystal Starr, a black American barista and video blogger. It is very cold outside, and warm and cozy inside. Starr, who is smart and wears fashionable glasses, has seen these types before. She knows they are European, she knows why they are in town, she knows they are tourists of the ruins of a once great American city. The two men don't hide this fact. They say it right to her face—they are here to see what many consider to be the end (and in a way the future) of all civilization.

When you reach this moment in the movie, which is directed by Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (The Boys of Baraka, Jesus Camp), you will realize why it currently stands as the best documentary about Detroit. In other films, the position of the viewer is the same as that of the two Europeans in the cafe—we are tourists, we want to see urban decay on a grand scale, urban decay in the state of the sublime, urban decay as the Grand Canyon. So the pleasure and value at the core of the standard Detroit doc is touristic. In Detropia, however, the viewer sees the city from the other side of the cafe's counter, from Crystal Starr's perspective. The film is not about the visitors, but the citizens of the ruins. As a consequence, the European visitors seem as crass and as soulless as the tourists visiting the land of Mickey Mouse.

Yes, the city has shrunk, it is half what it used to be, and so on and so forth. But lots of people still live and work there. Starr is one such person. She has a job, maintains a blog, and is active in city politics. There is also George McGregor, a UAW chapter president. He deeply loves the city. It raised him from black rural poverty and gave him the American dream: a middle-class life. McGregor drives a big white car, dresses like an R&B star from the early 1980s, and is frequently breaking bad news to the members of his union—they are going to get a pay cut, benefits are going to be cut, the factory is closing. And there is Tommy Stevens, a former schoolteacher who runs a joint, Raven Lounge, that did very well when people had jobs and the plants were not in Mexico. Stevens, who has the intelligent face of a black academic, buys cheap homes with the hope that one day a little of their value will recover (that day can exist only in his head). At night, he cooks in Raven's kitchen because he can't afford a chef. In another part of town, two young brothers sit on a porch, drinking beer and watching the impressively slow decline of their neighborhood.

Detropia also includes the views and perspective of two new citizens, a young white couple named Steve and Dorota Coy. They are artists who moved to Detroit because it's so fucking cheap. If you are not poor, but you want to make things that don't make money, this is the place for you. As a whole, these are the citizens of the ruins. And what we see and feel, what the directors have so brilliantly woven, is an impressionistic polyphony of their lives and thoughts. Detroit is much more than a negative Disneyland. recommended

 

Comments (4) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
Detroit is caught in a spiral that New Orleans will be lucky if they manage to escape. The starting points were different -- race riots vs. a hurricane -- but once a large city loses a big portion of its population, it starts a vicious cycle. With tax revenues down, the city can't maintain services; as services and quality of life decline, more people and businesses leave, further lowering tax revenues. (People hoping for a "lesser Seattle" should take note. Cities do not always grow well, but they're even worse at shrinking.)

I'm also reminded that I once met two guys who were renting a warehouse in Detroit to record their garage band's record in. It gave them the sound they wanted. It occurred to me that there aren't many places where two college-age guys could afford to rent a whole fucking WAREHOUSE just for a few recording sessions.
Posted by Orv on October 17, 2012 at 2:37 PM · Report this
Cascadian Bacon 2
Funny, I saw a lot of urban decay in Europe while touring the former Eastern Bloc, whole cites full of communist architecture just rotting, the train no longer stops there. I was later amazed to see the same kind of thing in Detroit. I wonder how long till it spreads everywhere?
Posted by Cascadian Bacon on October 18, 2012 at 5:48 PM · Report this
3
This is where unfettered LIBERALISM leads.
Posted by Seattlelou on October 24, 2012 at 12:03 AM · Report this
4
Liars will blame ALL "Blacks:,but I know damn well that Detroit is a ground zero of the never-ending War Against "Blacks":send their jobs abroad or give them to needless foreigners for decades,overtax and underfund their communities(including their schools),and dilute their political power by FORCING them to live apart from each other is racist warfare now matter HOW you look at the proceSS . . . .
Posted by 5th Columnist on October 28, 2012 at 8:41 AM · Report this

Add a comment