Features

Young, Poor, Lucky

A Tunnel, an Elevator Shaft, and Living on the Edge

Young, Poor, Lucky

MUDEDE CIRCA 1990 A photo taken by friend Lori King the morning after a long night.

I did not come from poverty. I came from an educated family that lived in an upper-middle-class neighborhood in Harare, Zimbabwe. My father was an economist, my mother a lecturer at the university. When I turned 20, they sent me to America to obtain a respectable degree (law, medicine, business), thinking that I would return to Africa to own property, accumulate wealth, and marry the daughter of an important man in the Ministry of Industry and Technology or the Ministry of Education and Health. But almost immediately after arriving in the land of milk and honey, I rejected this clear future for no future at all. I came to America for exactly what it is famous for: freedom.

The freedom that comes with riches has its double in another kind of economic freedom: the freedom of owning nothing. Both liberate you from time, obligations, and other people. Because the Zimbabwean dollar was weak, because I could not work in America (I didn't have a permit), because my parents were thousands of miles from me, and because my college situation on the East Coast was not yet sorted out, I quickly and deliberately found myself living with five males in an extremely cheap but huge basement in Pioneer Square.

We entered through the alley between First Avenue South and Alaskan Way. Like all alleys in Pioneer Square at the time and today, it had a whole tribe of rats that competed for resources with a wandering tribe of homeless humans. The entrance to the basement happened to be across from the exit for the Underground Tour. Every afternoon, tourists would emerge from Pioneer Square's underworld, impressed by the dead things—streets, sidewalks, and stores—they had seen. At sunset, the tourists stopped visiting the underworld, and artists and anarchists began trickling into the other underworld.

The basement was not a place anyone was supposed to be living in, an abandoned beauty academy: decaying styling chairs with hydraulic pumps, dusty shampoo bowls, broken manicure tables, dryers on rusty wheels, a wall of cracked mirrors, all covered in years of dust. There was an area converted into a kitchen (a toaster oven, a mini refrigerator, a hot plate, a microwave oven that hummed horribly—the expression "nuking" your food made sense with this Dumpster-salvaged appliance). In the center of the primary area was a blue tent where one of the five of us, Luke, slept. He supplied the basement with eggs from his day job as a baker. None of the rest of us had a job. At the back of the basement was a passageway leading to three offices and a broken freight elevator. Three of us made our bedrooms in the offices. I slept in the elevator shaft.

It was hard to pull a buck from the streets of Seattle (then going through the recession of 1990) into the depths of the basement. Money loathed our place. Once inside, it wanted to flee, to fly back to the streets, to find cover in the drawer of a cash register. Cash always looked so unhappy in our hands. Fresh bills rotted instantly in our soiled pockets; the reason our clothes were so dirty was because we did not have enough cash to wash them. We washed our underwear in the sink and hung them in the dusk and dust of the main area.

We each paid 80 bucks a month, and not one of us ever made the rent on time. I completely depended on miracles to come up with my share. I almost always began the month with absolutely nothing and ended it, I don't even remember how, with 80 bucks going to the landlord. He was letting us live there illegally and only had contact with one of us, Kurt, a funk guitarist with long black hair and a stutter that sliced his words into a mess of phonemes. Kurt lived in one of the offices and slept with no clothes on. Nudity was a common thing in the basement.

And the parties we threw were huge and long and noisy and free. These parties began with a band, devolved into drugs and deeds of lust, and dissipated long after the sun first cracked the night sky. There was lots of sex in the basement, because sex costs nothing. There was lots of Rainier beer, because it costs next to nothing. (Wine was totally out of the picture.) Though only five of us lived in the ruins of the beauty school, it caused us no surprise whatsoever to see one or two strangers drifting past an office door, looking for someone who attended a party, a gathering, a band session that ceased hours or days ago. I recall waking up one afternoon and finding in the kitchen area a woman (a pure hippie flower, with golden hair and a slim waist) and a much-older man she'd met the night before and slept with in some dark corner of the main area. The evidence: a sticky condom. The new lovers were microwaving a moist marijuana leaf for breakfast.

W hat American poverty offers—and this is not the case with African poverty, which is nothing but oppressive—is the possibility that anything might happen: miracles of money, one-night stands, movement to anywhere by any means (back of a truck, back of a bicycle, back of motorbike, back of a bus). Other relatives from Africa came to America and joined the middle class, but to me, the middle-class situation was wholly unappealing. The middle class is immobilized by the heaviness of paying bills, borrowing money, saving pennies, and so on and so forth. It does not have true freedom but is constantly in the situation of longing for it, and always fleeing from the other freedom, the freedom of owning nothing, paying little or no expenses. True, poverty is not pleasant, but it does offer freedom from the pressures of being a constant consumer and borrower. In the basement, I went to sleep at any time of the day, woke up at any time of the day. If Luke happened to say, "Let's go and drink mushroom tea near Mount Index," I would go. Because why not go and do drugs in the woods? What was stopping me?

Often on Fridays I would leave the basement and, if I had any money, eat something small at Mitchelli's, which was across the street and double the size that it is today. (Rumor has it that the long-lived Mitchelli's is not going to survive the current recession.) Or I'd drink at the Pioneer Square Saloon, the only place that did not card me. Or I'd visit the three girls who lived in a loft space around the corner on Alaskan Way. One of the three girls, Carrie Akre, had at the time recently joined a band, Hammerbox, and was working on an EP that another friend, Lisa Orth, eventually released on her label, Big Flaming Ego. Orth often boasted that she got the money to start the label from an insurance settlement for an accident that resulted in a metal plate in her forehead. She would let me touch it.

At Akre's loft, which had an excellent view of the traffic on the viaduct, I listened to music (Billie Holiday, Throwing Muses, Miriam Makeba) and tried to say smart things to one of her roommates, a dark-haired girl I secretly fancied. The order and femininity of Akre's loft gave me a break from the nonstop chaos that dominated the basement. Her roommates were studying at the university, had jobs, and seemed to be building their futures. They even had nice furniture—or it looked nice when compared to what we had in the basement.

One Friday night, I returned to the basement and walked right into a strange scene. Near Luke's blue tent, he and two young women sat in a circle of styling chairs. One woman was largish, the other thinnish. The largish one wore camouflage pants and a black T-shirt. The thinnish one wore a long brown overcoat—with no underwear, skirt, or shirt underneath it. The largish woman (who, I later found out, was supported financially and emotionally by the naked woman in the overcoat) dominated Luke's attention. She was telling him about her military days in Nebraska. She had been a soldier and had seen many awful things.

"I saw it with my own eyes," she was saying. "It's at a base near Grand Island, Nebraska. There are these bees that are the size of cats. They kept them in a black warehouse. You had to go inside to see them. It was an experiment. Genetically modified bees, dude..."

Luke, a fast talker who deeply mistrusted the American government and bought all his reading material at the anarchist supply store Fallout, was eating all of this up, and I was on the verge of laughter. The largish woman looked up at me and saw that I did not believe her one bit. Why would the army make bees that are the size of cats?—that was the expression on my face.

"Look, just because it doesn't make sense to you doesn't mean it's not happening. I saw a lot of things in the army that would blow your fucking mind!" she said.

The hand of the woman in the overcoat gave the army woman's leg a reassuring caress. She had seen her partner in this difficult situation before—seen her go crazy at the nonbelievers.

"The army is experimenting on all sorts of shit, man, that's why I left and why they're after me. They can burst through that door at any moment, kill all of you, and take me away!" The largish woman was now vibrating with rage. Fearing that she might be the one to do this killing, and not the government agents swarming in her head, I left this little scene for the solitude of the elevator shaft.

T he elevator shaft was all wood and rusty metal and dead buttons and levers. I'd appropriated one of the beautician's chairs and placed it next to the mattress on the floor. Luke came in and sat in the beautician's chair around two in the morning. A jam session of funk-punk was raging in the main area. Everyone was drunk or high. The soldier woman was long gone, but other crazy people had replaced her and were telling their impossible stories to the other roommates. The regulars who used to waste time with us included a man who made strange movies with a video camera (I was an extra in one or two of them) and a man who'd been to art school in Chicago and was obsessed with art made by serial killers (nearly two decades later, he committed suicide by walking into Lake Washington).

Luke had something on his mind. With his legs crossed in the manner of that famous photograph of Ian Curtis in despair, and a cigarette in his mouth and a dirt-cheap beer in one hand, he said: "Man, you think you know everything."

"Not true. I don't know what death is," I said. "I don't think anyone can know that. But I do know you can look all over the world and not find one bee that is the size of a cat. That I do know."

Luke's eyes had an almost theatrical intensity. Though crazy for the kinds of pranks he picked up from the punk manual RE/Search, he took himself very seriously. His clothes and manner expressed this sense of self-gravity: dark felt dress hat, paramilitary boots. He said, "Charles, do you want to experience death?" He said it as if it were an option, something we could do to kill a few hours.

"You mean to die and come back to life?"
"No, I don't mean like that... I know of a place where you can experience death without dying."
"And where is that?"
"It's only a few blocks away. It's in the middle of the train tunnel. You can't see anything. Just pure blackness. I have been there a few times with Kurt and feel like going there right now. Go with me?"
In my situation, at my age, at that time of night, with all that alcohol in me, how could I say no?

T he Great Northern Tunnel is one mile long, 28 feet high, 30 feet wide, and 125 feet beneath downtown. Its southern portal is next to King Street Station, its northern portal below Pike Place Market. It was made with James "Empire Builder" Hill's capital and the raw muscle of 350 forgotten men. During the construction, which began in 1903, the miners came across a prehistoric forest. At the center of this long-dead forest, they found a completely preserved tree, which, when exposed to the light of day, vaporized like a vampire into a pile of dust and pulp. Above the southern portal's keystone is the year of the tunnel's completion: "1904." Early in the morning, I found myself standing beneath that date with Luke, my Virgil in punk clothes. We drifted into the tunnel without a thought.

Each crunching step diminished the light behind us; utter blackness was slowly approaching. The tracks were dumb and cold. After walking for about 10 minutes, it occurred to me that if a train were to come through, I would be in a spot of trouble. The problem with the freedom that results from an absence of money, the freedom of limitless time, is that the future loses its power. What only ever matters is the now, the present, the primal moment. Now all of a sudden, the future made an appearance in the dark, and it looked quite deadly. My imagination saw the lights of a freight train approaching me at a murderous speed. I saw its wheels crushing my body, crunching my bones. I envisioned the newspaper headline: "Zimbabwean Drifter Killed in Tunnel." I saw a thousand rats feasting on my bloody remains.

Panicking, I asked Luke, who was ahead of me, what to do if the train entered the tunnel. "Hope for the best," I heard. I looked back and saw that the light at the point where we'd entered was almost gone. But I could not abandon the mission at this point. I was so close to absolute darkness. And besides, going forward was now as good as going back. The best thing to do if a train came through, I figured, was to run to one side of the tunnel and crouch down like some terrified animal as its massive bulk roared past. I pictured this happening again and again on that mile-long walk.

Finally we reached the death that I was promised. It exists in the middle of that tunnel. It is the point where the light from behind and the light ahead completely vanish. You can't see the end of your nose. You can't see your hands. You have almost no idea what your feet are doing. Your body is gone, and all there is is your consciousness. It is the sensation of immateriality itself, which is a kind of transcendence. You feel not so much like you're dead, but surprised by the bareness of your being. You sense it in the area of your chest. It seems to flicker there, it seems so frail, it seems that even a light breeze could blow it out. We stopped walking. Many years later, I'd discover that this experience—this reduction of my whole life to just the heart of being alive—was not anything new or exceptional. It took only one visit to a posh health club for me to realize that the train tunnel was nothing more than a poor man's sensory deprivation tank.

"We are lucky. No trains have come by yet," Luke said, revealing for the first time his own fear. "Let's get out now." I could not see him. All that lived was his voice. And a voice in the dark is Hume's voice of God. We began walking again, the gravel crunching beneath our feet. For a while there was no light in either direction, but then a pin of light danced in the distance. It was far ahead, glowing like a tiny star. (Anyone who has seen my movie Zoo will finally know the source of the opening scene.) One of the tracks reflected the light, barely. With each crunchy step, the light slid into a longer and longer silvery line.

When we exited the tunnel, there was a moon, the lights of a sleeping city, and a rapidly approaching train. We crossed the western tracks, and as we reached a parking lot, the train plunged into the tunnel.

An hour later, I was on my mattress in the elevator shaft. There was a little life somewhere in the basement—two or so people playing faux-Gypsy music. Luke was fast asleep in his tent, and I was looking up at the shaft, which for the past three or so months I had lived here had had no significance at all. Now it seemed to mean something sad and true. It suggested that these days of freedom were numbered. It was just so absurd to be living in an elevator shaft. Eventually I'd reach the end of the tunnel of this particular moment in my life and surface in the world of work and wages.

One day a letter arrived from Zimbabwe. It came from my parents, who were terribly upset about my disappearance from the radar of formal society. The letter was handed to me by my cousin Farai, who was studying electrical engineering at the University of Washington. He and his brother Tendai—a civil engineer who worked on the bus tunnel that had then recently opened and was soon to be featured on the first video by Hammerbox, "Size of the World"—were the only Africans who visited me in the basement, and kept the shame of its chaos and lawlessness a secret from the folks back home.

The envelope Farai handed me contained a check for $1,000. This was the end of the tunnel. That kind of money wanted nothing to do with the basement; the figure demanded that I move to a place that housed normal people and hours. I betrayed the basement and used the check to move into a large house near the corner of Harvard Avenue and Roanoke Street, with two stories, three productive roommates, real furniture, and a standard kitchen. We held parties that came to an end at practical hours. More and more of my friends were university students, and fewer and fewer were punks dreaming of becoming the next Jello Biafra. I was back on the surface of society and beginning the long journey to where I am now—a landowning father, salaried writer, credit-card holder, husband, and filmmaker, who lives in a comfortable Pioneer Square loft with a view of expensive buildings, but who knows the value of owning nothing, making nothing, doing nothing. recommended

Share via

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Newsvine
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Email
 

Comments (86) RSS

Oldest First Unregistered On Registered On Add a comment
1
This guy should write a novel. He has the gift to grab the attention of the reader and brings to life memories that would otherwise probably never resurface.
Posted by silvie on March 25, 2009 at 12:19 PM · Report
2
Beautifully written photo....

and we should all be So lucky to have similar indexes of commonality in the stories we tell about name and birth recognition myth and reality and friends who mark our time periods.
Posted by daniel b.kieneker on March 25, 2009 at 12:39 PM · Report
3
i found this article inspiring. reminded me of my homeless phase. amazing charles!
Posted by psmoov on March 25, 2009 at 1:50 PM · Report
4
I normally don't care for what you do, but this one stood out.

I liked it.
Posted by BombasticMo on March 25, 2009 at 2:18 PM · Report
5
Great story Charles. Well done.
Posted by john on March 25, 2009 at 3:15 PM · Report
6
Charles, you are wonderful. Never listen to the reactionaries that say otherwise.
Posted by Jim Bexley-Speed on March 25, 2009 at 3:31 PM · Report
7
thanks Charles, that was great
Posted by Thanker on March 25, 2009 at 4:26 PM · Report
8
best thing i've read all day.
Posted by ndrwmtsn on March 25, 2009 at 4:35 PM · Report
9
Excellent writing, Charles.
Posted by Jeff Kirby on March 25, 2009 at 7:42 PM · Report
10
really beautiful story. couldn't stop reading.
Posted by uppergeorgetowner on March 25, 2009 at 8:06 PM · Report
11
I usually zone out when I see a first-person narrative in The Stranger, expecting indulgent nonsense.

This was stellar. You've got a novel or two in ya.
Posted by Hutch on March 25, 2009 at 9:52 PM · Report
12
You take a lot of shit for some of the things you write on this blog Charles, but this was excellent. Suck it haters.
Posted by Ray Shackleford on March 25, 2009 at 9:54 PM · Report
13
In a paper whose best writing usually resides in the 'I Saw U' section or next to Annie Dillard and company, these words shine.
Posted by K.engle on March 25, 2009 at 10:20 PM · Report
14
I agree with BombasticMo - usually don't care for your articles, but this one was wonderful. You really should write a novel.
Posted by tittie on March 26, 2009 at 1:51 AM · Report
15
that was very well written, it takes you back to a time that most of us forgot or pushed away in the back of our heads. awsome story.

keep up the good work
Posted by Tamia on March 26, 2009 at 4:15 AM · Report
16
Well-written and interesting. Keep 'em coming, Charles!
Posted by Karen on March 26, 2009 at 6:57 AM · Report
17
Excellent feature.
Posted by anon. on March 26, 2009 at 7:39 AM · Report
18
Why oh why when I posted this story to FB was there a picture of a smiling white hipster girl with a Save The Earth T Shirt?! The picture of Charles at the top of the story is so much nicer.
Posted by L on March 26, 2009 at 7:42 AM · Report
19
Yes, we need a full book of this from you, sir. This just wasn't enough. But it was wonderful.
Posted by Chris Estey on March 26, 2009 at 7:51 AM · Report
20
Thanks for writing this. Your story really resonated with me. I've never been as happy as I was at my poorest, and having nothing to loose and nothing to protect really does free you up.
Another thing you don't mention is that poverty makes relationships more genuine- people spend time with you because they want to. In a middle-class setting they might be doing it because of societal norms or work relationships.
Posted by lizza on March 26, 2009 at 10:10 AM · Report
21
It's interesting how this week's theater reviews illustrate everything that's wrong with your writing, and this piece illustrates what a fine writer you are.

I think it helps you to have a story tell, almost as much as it hobbles you to be limited to making arguments or providing commentary.
Posted by thelyamhound on March 26, 2009 at 11:41 AM · Report
22
Incredible! thanks. I agree with Silvie's comment.. Please write a novel!
Posted by starheadboy on March 26, 2009 at 12:04 PM · Report
23
Charles Mudede remains one of the few flickers of light in the overarching grayness of Seattle.
Posted by Quite Spunky on March 26, 2009 at 12:14 PM · Report
24
Thank you, Charles. I'm glad you wrote that.
Posted by tabletop_joe on March 26, 2009 at 12:33 PM · Report
25
What I liked most about it is that people who are interested will now have the opportunity to ask themselves, whatever became of that amiable risk-taking Mudede that made him into such an implacable Marxist, so insistent on the material conditions of life, so impatient with what the rest of us find cozy and comfortable? I like that possibility very much--that people may read something in this trajectory that they have now had the pleasure of reading.
Posted by James on March 26, 2009 at 1:16 PM · Report
26
thanks charles. once again, you have taught me something.
Posted by pancakes and eggs on March 26, 2009 at 1:44 PM · Report
27
Great writing. Great ideas. At age 51, totally drowning in consumer debt and student loan debt, yet owning very little and trying to raise a child as a single mother, I dream of that freedom you describe. Practically everything I acquired with credit and spent money on has been stripped away little by little as I've moved 12 times in the last 13 years... each time losing more and more possessions yet still owning the debt of having acquired them. And all for what? Maybe we'll all be living in poverty soon and something will reawaken in our collective psyche.
Posted by M on March 26, 2009 at 1:51 PM · Report
28
I wish you'd write more like this and less like the asshole critical theory profs that kicked me out of grad school.
Posted by emmaliminal on March 26, 2009 at 2:37 PM · Report
29
Great essay. Should've been part of last week's "Economic Survival Guide". Recessions have their beauty.
Posted by DOUG. on March 26, 2009 at 4:06 PM · Report
30
wonderful, freedom is, when you also have the freedom of being without children or other dependents. Your life, indeed, was full of incipient luxury.
Posted by Oregon on March 26, 2009 at 4:50 PM · Report
31
Nice article, Charles. Thanks for bringing me back to Pioneer Square in the early 90s. Almost makes me wish I could be staggering from the Red Front Tavern to my room in the Alps Hotel again.
Posted by steve potter on March 26, 2009 at 5:15 PM · Report
32
thank you, charles. i needed that.
Posted by sabrinaks on March 26, 2009 at 6:43 PM · Report
33
Awesome and true.
Posted by Grant Cogswell, Los Angeles, California on March 26, 2009 at 7:05 PM · Report
34
You're a terrific writer. It's always a pleasure to read your stuff.
Posted by tharp42 on March 26, 2009 at 8:08 PM · Report
35
Mr. Mudede, thank you for articulating the far reaches of your experience in such an evocative manner. I agree that if you haven't already started a novel, you oughta give it a think.
Posted by fellow immigrant on March 26, 2009 at 8:31 PM · Report
36
Love the photo. I met you at Radio Free Leroy's @ The Pioneer Square Hotel, in the early nineties, your head lowered as you sat at the table, big black saucer eyes glancing up. You then read from a part of a novel you were working on and it had something about Michael Jackson. I read some prose, nervously. You found my number and we met up, you wanted to make films, it was burning in you. After I knew you some time, you announced you were getting married. I said, "but you are a novelist, a writer, you can't get married!" You now have two lovely children and a wife. You write, make films, teach, and here it is, your true voice. Keep going, this is the rich stuff and is damn good. I want to hear more, the attorney's place you lived in that beautiful treehouse of a place in N. Seattle, it seemed so incongruous, and yet you always were lucky; your trajectory as a journalist/editor, filmmaker, father...
Posted by k on March 26, 2009 at 9:55 PM · Report
37
I have, at times, skipped over your slog contributions, but this piece was amazing. Keep these coming!! Thanks Charles!
Posted by BallardG on March 26, 2009 at 10:11 PM · Report
38
Wow, that was one of the most thought inspiring pieces of writing I have ever read. That article was really captivating and intense.
It felt as if I was actually inside the basement.

Agreed, the author should write a novel. :)
Posted by ChrisJ on March 27, 2009 at 2:45 AM · Report
39
Wow - outstanding.
Posted by Lurker on March 27, 2009 at 8:06 AM · Report
40
Wow - outstanding.
Posted by Lurker on March 27, 2009 at 8:12 AM · Report
41
This was absolutely fantastic! It made me appreciate the nothingness of right now - where broke college student has a whole new meaning to it, bring it on then! :]
Posted by ang on March 27, 2009 at 10:01 AM · Report
42
I never read the lead stories in the Stranger. For some unkown (to me) reason I picked on this one and was totally hooked. I have been through the "possesive" phase, for many years and now live with a guy in Sicily in a small village on the slopes of the mountain. I own nothing but he works at a job he doesn't really like but which allows him to interact with people. His pay is small but about four times the allowance he arranged for me from the Italian government. It is a very good life with absolutely no stress, living among people who commonly live to over 90. Because of the family traditions here, the old people are cared for by non-live-in family or by Rumanian girls who are the biggest import into the village!

I agree with Charles that the non-ownership society is good, but, if you can control it, the ownership society is also good. I spent a coulple of years living on a small sailboat with my sole income being the SSI from the American government. It was just enough to pay the moorage and electricity (a 24ft boat doesn't use much) and buy the cheap food in the village and the food banks in the town.

People could not understand how I could be happy in this situation. Americans cannot be happy without endless aquisition of "things."

Now they envy me with no obligations.

Thank you Charles for bringing this back to my mind. I will pay more attention to your writings in future.
Posted by Nomad on March 27, 2009 at 10:31 AM · Report
43
that was a damn good piece!this is good writing.please please please,stay away from the hip hop reviews!stick to more stories like this.this is great.
Posted by 11:30 on March 27, 2009 at 11:17 AM · Report
44
This is the best article I've read in a long time. Couldn't put it down.
Posted by Mr T on March 27, 2009 at 12:11 PM · Report
45
Good stuff, Charles
Posted by Lee on March 27, 2009 at 12:20 PM · Report
46
It was a well written article of an appropriate topic to a captivated audience. Bravo!
Posted by bearandger on March 27, 2009 at 12:36 PM · Report
47
Mudede is WAY too good to be writing for The Stranger. This is the best thing I've read in this rag in a LONG time.
Posted by Dirtytime on March 27, 2009 at 12:39 PM · Report
48
Charles,

Great story. I'm a fan! Once my friend was visiting from out of town and we wandered into that tunnel. We thought it was abandoned. It looked so old, how could it not be abandoned? After we wandered out, perhaps a minute after, a train came barrelling through. We looked at each other.

I'm about to lose my unemployment checks. Being poor (in America) has a dual sensation of powerlessness and possibility. One may as well embrace it, but it's like embracing a live wire. Last recession I had to get so bored and disspirited that it seemed like clocks had stopped. Only then could I embrace the vast opportunities of now. Currently after five great earning years I'm still locked up in the straight word of budgets and externalized hope, I'm afraid. Six more weeks and the money will stop.

Your fan,

mcfnord
Posted by mcfnord on March 27, 2009 at 12:50 PM · Report
49
a joy to read. bravo.
Posted by d-squared on March 27, 2009 at 2:11 PM · Report
50
fucking brilliant, charles. inspirational. took me back to a very similar point in my life, perfectly. that freedom from ownership & the future taught me things i can never forget.
Posted by lar on March 27, 2009 at 3:12 PM · Report
51
Makes me want to leave my life as a married law student and go live in an elevator shaft. Maybe then I would figure out who, and what, I really am.
Posted by unknown on March 27, 2009 at 6:17 PM · Report
52
Great piece, Charles. Thank you.
Posted by homage to me on March 27, 2009 at 8:37 PM · Report
53
Thanks for sharing your story. Made my night!
Posted by Kevin W on March 27, 2009 at 8:40 PM · Report
54
I knew crossed paths with this guy back in the day. One of his cousins had tried to screw my girl. A lot of this is probably fantasy, but what it lacks in truth, he makes up for with imagination.
Posted by Mark on March 27, 2009 at 9:25 PM · Report
55
I will acknowledge it is well written and kind of fun. But come on. Upper class, wealthy kids slumming. A far cry from a real homeless person just trying to get by. go ask a homeless person who just had his stuff thrown away by the city how romantic or great it is to not own anything.

the author had the wits and werwithal to get by, and could make a phone call and get out any time.

but a decent read.
Posted by reet on March 27, 2009 at 10:26 PM · Report
56
ahhh.. "reet," partly true, and well said, however I must say, you miss the bigger point. Yours is implicit. Charles' family wealth is not equivalent to America's, nor is his presence here. He equivocates the cultures in his existence as an artist in the world today, shedding light on a subculture that did and still does exist.
Posted by k on March 28, 2009 at 1:30 AM · Report
57
How old are these commentators? My god, you have a gift for the overly-romanticized hyperbole. I promise you that if there was some nuance to your recollection, the story would shine so much brighter. I have a feeling that you're on the edge. Consider reeling it in, just a tad. Honesty yields good things.
Posted by axel on March 28, 2009 at 2:37 AM · Report
58
sounds like a a liberal becoming a conservative charles
Posted by J-Goldenschwartze on March 28, 2009 at 2:39 AM · Report
59
This is nonsense. You say you "know the value of owning nothing, making nothing, doing nothing" but if that is the point of this article then you've only illustrated how much you truly do not.

American Poverty offers the things that you romanticize so long as they are chosen. You chose to live underground and reject the future you knew was waiting for you while the world of adulthood and responsibility pulsed above your head. You needed to prove to yourself that you could have made it in this country if you weren't born of a well-off family, so you convinced the people around you that you were just an immigrant living with the rats in Pioneer Square.

Into a tunnel and out a changed man?

You know the value of privilege, and not much more.

Posted by Bryce Beamish on March 28, 2009 at 8:17 AM · Report
60
I´m a mexican who lived in seattle for about a year back in 1996-1997. attended high school at Bush... Now and then i read the stranger (i used to pick the printed version every weekend).. most of the times i just browse the pages but don´t read the stuff.. Luckily i started to read this article and found it beautifully written and catchy..
Posted by Ulises A. on March 28, 2009 at 10:36 AM · Report
61
Amazing. It reminded me of my druggie years in Seattle- they were awesome and terrible at the same time. But I'm thankful to have experienced it, which if you haven't had a time in your life like that, you probably can't understand. Really, really great.
Posted by SeattleMichelle on March 28, 2009 at 10:40 AM · Report
62
Hm. Thank you for taking me to so many places I will never see. The shape of my day and my thoughts have been unexpectedly altered.
Posted by Salty Purl on March 28, 2009 at 11:05 AM · Report
63
Great article man.
Posted by biju on March 28, 2009 at 12:17 PM · Report
64
This was a good article. I agree with thelyamhound; write about yourself, not others. Please abandon the police beat stories, in particular.
Posted by HB on March 28, 2009 at 12:41 PM · Report
65
A very thoughtful meditation on freedom, Charles! A tremendous article.
Posted by Wyatt Lai on March 28, 2009 at 3:27 PM · Report
66
Cultural production mobilized by everyday conditions = politics (of comparison).
Posted by redundant on March 28, 2009 at 7:52 PM · Report
67
Terrific story and great writing. I read it twice.
Posted by mkg on March 29, 2009 at 8:41 AM · Report
68
This guy is an idiot. He was homeless and poor by choice and writes about it like he is some kind of hero. Fuck him and his loft apartment. The real brave people are the one's struggling to find work and money and get out of their situations. He was just being lazy and stupid and young. That article was a waste of time to read and a waste of ink.
Posted by natesloss@gmail.com on March 29, 2009 at 9:41 AM · Report
69
So what was the point of this? That he was lazy and young and was homeless by choice?. Not a very noble story. the people that struggle to get out of their homelessness or poverty are real. This guy only told us that he was lazy and did drugs when he was young. BFD. What a waste of ink. If you liked this article you are stupid.
Posted by nobodynowhere on March 29, 2009 at 9:44 AM · Report
70
Charles I have you listed under "religious beliefs" in my facebook profile. I think that captures how i feel about your work.
This is piece is fabulously written. However - and i know this is knit picky - but i see a distinction between the priveldge of choosing poverty and a life without obligations, and being born into structural violence. I know that I'm preaching to the choir. I guess i just get frustrated with the glorification of poverty by those that have a safety net.

The bottom line is the piece was phenomenal and I so appreciate your work.
Posted by Murph on March 29, 2009 at 10:11 AM · Report
71
Your evocation of that time felt true. I returned to Seattle in 1989, and the Seattle I found had a feeling of young poor (often by choice) people collectively forming tribes. Your description of the tunnel and its metaphors was especially insightful.
Posted by earwig on March 29, 2009 at 12:50 PM · Report
72
It's a well-written piece, I'll give you that. But I had more than a moment's pause dealing with your central thesis, which I would boil down to "the freedom of owning nothing," when I realized you never actually owned nothing.

I would submit that you were a tourist in that world, and that despite the readability and great storytelling in your piece, it lacks the true experiential aspect it pretends to have.

You were never truly poor, because you had a ready avenue of escape--your family offered you a way out whenever you chose. There was no risk for you, really. True poverty, in my view, is characterized by the LACK of escape options. You might not have found the whole experience so profound and romantic if living that way was your only possible choice.

Or maybe you're saying that American poverty is always by choice? I hope that's not what you're saying...'cause it ain't.
Posted by schmacky on March 30, 2009 at 11:57 AM · Report
73
I DON'T THINK THE WILL TO NOTHINGNESS IS COOL.
Posted by LAwRiM0rrh0t-E on March 30, 2009 at 2:58 PM · Report
74
He really made me understand the appeal of being a vagrant...very moving story
Posted by pki on March 30, 2009 at 5:03 PM · Report
75
Absolutely beautiful. I was completely engulfed when I reading this. Really, really lovely. It touched a place in me that few things do.
Posted by Sarah on March 30, 2009 at 9:45 PM · Report
76
muh dik
Posted by dat article touched muh dik on March 31, 2009 at 1:04 PM · Report
77
Wonderful Henry V-like story
Posted by anthropomorphize me on March 31, 2009 at 1:20 PM · Report
78
lovely story. One of the rare homeless by choice people out there.
Posted by not an admirerer but an apreciator on March 31, 2009 at 11:26 PM · Report
79
This situation was almost exactly like the one I encountered when I was 19/20.
Posted by And 5 years later I own a place! on April 3, 2009 at 4:34 PM · Report
80
Except I didn't have a choice.
Posted by And 5 years later I own a place! on April 3, 2009 at 4:38 PM · Report
81
wow. this is really beautiful.

i don't really know what else to say. my mind is blown.
Posted by kitsch on April 4, 2009 at 12:37 AM · Report
82
Started reading this story randomly at the gym, and even though I wanted to put it down, I couldn't. Loved it.
Posted by Sara on April 8, 2009 at 2:12 AM · Report
83
Brilliant, beautiful story... knocked it out of the park, and the haters out too I hope.
Posted by Mrs Lucky on April 8, 2009 at 3:33 PM · Report
84
That was a great article. Wow. Your funk guitar player has been my bass player, so funny!
Posted by Sylvia on April 21, 2009 at 7:26 PM · Report
85
That was probably the best thing I've ever read in The Stranger.
Posted by Reader 1 on April 30, 2009 at 2:47 AM · Report
86
Tremendous. Excellent. Thanks, Charles.
Posted by Lincolnish on May 6, 2009 at 11:28 PM · Report

Add a comment

Most Commented in Features