The conventional wisdom wafting up from wonks in California for the past several weeks is that, no, it won’t be. A track of polls shows that support for Prop 19, a measure to eliminate penalties for pot and allow localities to tax and regulate it (if the feds allow the latter), was declining. According to pollster SurveyUSA, Prop 19 never topped 50 percent (with opposition around 43 percent), and undecided voters on ballot measures—the dispatchers of conventional wisdom insist—are all but assured to sway toward opposition. Later polls showed support drop to 47 percent.

But.

Conventional wisdom could be wrong in this case. That downward trend has stopped, according to a SurveyUSA poll released yesterday that shows support staying steady at 47 percent, with 42 percent opposed and 11 percent undecided. While that’s not much, it suggests that if those those undecided voters split evenly, pot will be legal in California this year. That’s not impossible: Between genders, the poll shows, undecided women outnumber uncertain men by nearly two-to-one; and in age brackets, a plurality of undecided voters are over 65. Older women are generally the most considerate, informed voters. And accurate information—not the baseless FUD perpetrated by law enforcement lobbies—makes the case for legal pot. In our corner of the map, when Seattle ran I-75 in 2003, early polling showed only 49 percent support. But the undecideds split evenly and the measure passed easily. The same thing could happen in California.

15 replies on “Is This the Year a State Legalizes Marijuana?”

  1. I’ll say it for you

    Discuss, readers. Wonk away.
    I want to demand of you your participation.

    I’m satisfied with the progression of laws and debate about decriminalization. A quick guess is that McCartney had illegally smoked marijuana before writing ‘Let it Be’. Didn’t he get arrested later for possession? Oh, the humanity, lawmakers and voters and the logical bitching about it. Not for me.

  2. I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: It doesn’t really matter what the states do as long as the feds are still prosecuting this as a crime. And they very definitely are.

  3. @ 2) You’re wrong. Local jurisdictions (state, county, and municipal law enforcement) handle 99 percent of pot crimes. So while federal laws technically hold power of preemption, it’s a moot point except in the largest-scale operations.

  4. If that polling is correct, then the undecideds would have to split roughly 2 to 1 in opposition for this to fail. If the pro-legalization side picks up even 1/3 of the undecideds, it will pass.

    Not a sure thing by any stretch, but I’d say the odds are pretty good, at least based on that poll.

  5. If WA or CA decriminalizes, you’ll STILL have random dudes selling, but you’ll also have those bold enough to sell retail. The point is that if our state decriminalizes, then no one gets arrested except by Feds.

    If state police or local police try to do things like pass on leads or whatnot to the Feds, then I wouldn’t be surprised if the next initiative was a simple,

    “No municipality or the state of Washington may expend any funds or man hours of government labor toward the enforcement or application of any Federal marijuana enforcement, and no Washington state law enforcement may participate in or aid in any Federal marijuana enforcement.”

    What then? Are they going to have Feds patrolling for weed?

  6. #2/4: You do realize there are hundreds of retail shops that sell and advertise marijuana across CA and other states (including WA) right now, right?

  7. @9) Colorado’s medical-pot law allows a patient to grow six plants. But you’re missing the point, again. A state law is, in effect, robust up to the threshold that the offenses it covers don’t stray clearly into federal jurisdiction. So most of what a state law could do for pot reform–e.g., decriminalize possession, allow small-time cultivation, permit low-level exchange (which covers the vast majority of existing enforcement)–can be implemented without a practical federal conflict.

  8. @Dominic and 5280: The federal/state issue is actually a big concern in Oakland. There’s a proposal to make small-grow operations illegal, and to create a permit system so that four large-scale operations could supply Oakland and, ideally, bring some cash into the city by selling surplus elsewhere in the state.

    One of the big issues with this proposal is the worry that big, fat targets like the proposed large-scale grow operations will be too tempting for the Feds to resist. Of course, I’m against the proposal anyway, as I don’t really think clamping down on small-scale growers is a good idea, Feds or no Feds.

  9. Ideally, you’d like the feds out of it too.

    A lot of problems disappear if you can introduce legal large pot farms. If a farmer could grow a 200 acre crop of marijuana, just like corn or wheat, then the price of legal pot would be pennies on the dollar compared to current street prices of illegal pot. Without the profit motive, nearly all of the violent crime related to illegally growing and selling pot would be eliminated.

    Making it legal for me to grow a couple of plants in my yard would be nice and convenient, but it doesn’t do much to eliminate the problems related to large illegal growing operations.

  10. (The below owes practically everything to Daniel Okrent’s “Last Call”, an history of Prohibition…the parallels are numerous, funny, and horrid all at once…not least including rampant fear of Darker People [Jews, Slavs, and Italians back then]) (If he’s to be believed, Prohibition only ended because of the Depression and the fervent hope of a du Pont that alcohol taxes could replace the tax on incomes….paging the Koch Bros….)

    The Eighteenth Amendment, which allowed Congress to make law against the sale of alcoholic beverages, was passed with the provision that the states and the federal government would have concurrent enforcement opportunities.

    Every state but Maryland passed state enforcement laws…but when New York opinion turned against Prohibition, the state repealed it…and alcohol became de facto legal there.

    Now, this was back when the Federal government was much, much, smaller, actually thrifty Republicans ran things federally, so the net effect was that there wasn’t a lot of money for Federal enforcement. Much has changed since then, not least because of Prohibition (wiretaps started in earnest back then, for example)…but still, at the local level, you really mostly have to worry about your state and local authorities. It’s horrible that some are still scooped-up by the feds, and they well may be trying to make examples of the relative few they do get, but still it doesn’t represent much of a threat to the unimportant quotidian smoker/vaporiser/eater.

    Of course, though, as long as growing, selling, and moving the stuff around in quantity is still illegal, the various mafias still have an opening to make money, which is a damned shame. (Note that alcohol possession was at least federally legal…organised crime made all their money from Prohibition mostly from the trafficking…..)

  11. @11, I think what you’re seeing there is the first testing blows in a bigger fight over control of the legal trade, with some big, big players wanting to control it all. In CA, you even have some illegal operators (supplying legal dispensaries) who oppose legalization because it will not only mean competition but make their current criminal intimidation techniques harder to get away with. But once growing is legal, the real fight begins — and small-timers are going to get trampled.

Comments are closed.