This is you (somewhere in there, really).

Civilization V dropped a little while back, and it’s good—so good we lost sleep over it. Not so much that we had to wipe it off our machines and get help, but enough to make us feel more hungover than usual. In some ways, it’s just a prettied-up version of the same world-building-and-destroying game it’s always been, but a few simple, radical changes make warfare, diplomacy, and governing more challenging but more predictable. Read more after the jump.

Those arent fireworks.
  • This is you (somewhere in there, really).

Gamers who already know and love/hate the franchise should already have Civ V in their queue by now, but if you’ve never played before, you might want to try Civ IV ($20 on Steam without add-ons) or even Civ III (just $5 on Steam!) before making the investment. The whole series is rightly praised for its smart tutorials, though, so you shouldn’t feel lost even if you start out with the shiny new version.

In fact, in some ways veteran players are more likely to have problems. Warfare is completely different now, thanks to the simple rule that combat units can’t stack. Older versions featured preposterously huge gangs of army men and horsies and helicopters and cannons and whatnot that could just park on a nearby hill and whittle any city down to splinters over the course of a few turns, which was both anti-fun and counter-intuitive. Attacking cities in Civ V feels much more like a siege, and warfare spreads out a lot farther on the (now hex-based and hence nerdier) map.

Diplomacy is deeper and richer as well, thanks to the addition of tiny AI city-states that offer fat bonuses in exchange for gold and protection. Diplomatic victory is much easier to come by (in older versions, it was basically impossible at any serious level of difficulty), but it takes thoughtful investment from the very earliest stages of the game—as do all the other means of victory, really.

That investment may be one of the major differences between Civ V and its predecessors. It’s hard to win the game without knowing exactly what you want to do from the very beginning—no more switching to a Space Race victory late in the game when France starts churning out culture more quickly than you can. It feels a little weird to be making long-term decisions while you’re still fighting off barbarians and wolves, but maybe that library is worth more down the road than that archer is right now. Decisions like that really get the dopamine flowing and keep us nerds up all night, and that’s what it’s all about.


The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner and Paul Hughes.

The Stranger Testing Department is Rob Lightner, Paul Hughes, and Mary P. Traverse.

15 replies on “Civilization and Its New Contents”

  1. If one wants to jump into Civ, can one do so with the current releases, or is there value to going back in time to the earlier versions?

  2. I tried to play it, but my civilization kept collapsing whenever my major cities tried to build deep bore tunnels they couldn’t afford.

  3. Try “Zeus, Master of Olympus” and “Children of the Nile” for ultra-complex agrarian city-states (with regional trading partners/allies/rivals) for building-up rather than blowing-up civilization. Why gamers prefer destruction over creation is understandable, but it’s still stupid.

  4. I’m happy with the game, but I’ve stopped playing for a few weeks until they patch some of the problems. It’s really good, but can get frustrating.

  5. @4 Depends. Civ 4, with a mod called “A New Dawn”, is a substantially more complex game than Civ 5. Empires can fall to revolutions, there are a lot more techs and units, as well as corporations and religions to spread and deal with. But that does not necessarily mean more fun. I am really enjoying 5, but also still play 4. To me they are very different games with 4 being a long drawn out empire building game where you have to focus on lots of different things. 5 is more of a tactical game with the one unit per tile rule and an end to building massive armies.

    The AI is a bit better in 4, but that has a lot to do with years of fan effort to improve it.

    @5 Jesus fuck Will

  6. I love me my Civ, but when are they going to make Alpha Centauri II? Though I’ll be honest, I won’t be happy until they combine Civ & SMAC in one game.

  7. @6: Zeus OWNED. Really fantasic. Good interface, quirky design, lots of humour. Hell, I want to play it now.

    I didn’t really like CotN because of interface design issues, but I think I’ll give it another shot. My dream game is a well-designed Rome civ game.

    I’m kind of all over Minecraft right now, really.

  8. As far as game play, my favorite was Civ II. The graphics were primitive by today’s standards, but I liked the gameplay. Each version after that seemed to get better graphics but worse gameplay. But Civ V seems to be getting universally good reviews.

    I don’t have time to sink into Civ V right now. I’ll probably put it on my X-mas list. 😀

  9. It’s pretty great. The way that territory and combat are managed is a huge improvement over previous games. There are far fewer stupid accidents of bad luck that end the game for you.

    I’m a huge fan of the series, and so far I think this may be the best overall game out of them all. It’s different enough that I’ll still continue to enjoy IV for what it offers, but I think V is ultimately a more rewarding experience.

Comments are closed.