The story:

Even if there are a few scrapes between them, John Reynolds insists his dogs are friendly. All 17 of them. All pit bulls.

“They were like best buddies,” Reynolds says of his father the 84-year-old Rev. John Reynolds and one of the pit bulls. “My dad would sit there and feed him off his spoon. They slept together.”

Reynolds says no one knew his dogs’ nature more than his father who owned the home and property where John raises the dogs.

Which makes what he found on Wednesday night, October 13th, even harder to understand.

“I could see that he’d been attacked by something,” Reynolds recalls.

He came home that night and found his father on the ground in the pen with severe bite marks. He did not survive the attack.

Why the subject line has a question mark:

He admits it’s only speculation, but Reynolds believes stray dogs or possibly even a mountain lion may have attacked his father and his pit bulls.

Full story here.

David Schmader—former weed columnist and Stranger associate editor—is the author of the solo plays Straight and Letter to Axl, which he’s performed in Seattle and across the US. His latest...

25 replies on “Reverend in Missouri Fatally Attacked by 17 Beloved Pit Bulls?”

  1. @2 and 3, there will be NO bashing of my cousins on here. And pray when we have assimulated THEM into the collective!!! MEOW!!!!

  2. @6, we must duel. Yes, you heard me; I’m calling you out. If people like you aren’t stopped soon we will only be able to buy mountain lion chow at special state-run stores that are always closed on Tuesdays (mountain lion feast day, lilttle-known fact).

  3. Nice Rorschach test. There’s zero evidence except for unspecified “bite marks” (we don’t even know how long the guy’s body was in the pen after he died). So you get to think exactly what you want to think about how it happened.

  4. can’t they tell by the marks and size of the bites? and it would seem if it was a mountain lion there would be lots of scratches and claw marks. and how about paw prints

  5. People, people — correlation does not equal causation. This is just like all those ‘scientists’ who assume that just because the rise in global temperatures correlates to the increased concentrations of man-made greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, the two are somehow related.

    What I’m trying to say is, I think sunspots killed this man.

  6. At the very least, the pit bulls failed to defend their owner. What’s the point of having 17 pit bulls if they cower before a single mountain lion?

  7. And all 17 dogs sat by while their owner was attached by a stray/mountain-lion. Mmm-hmph! Right. *Consults crystal ball* I predict we will see these 17 pit bulls in the news in the future…

  8. I it was a mountain lion, you would see a deep bite wound on the neck, and the vertebrae would be crushed.

    If pit bulls, there would be multiple flesh wounds (I’ve never seen domestic dogs crush bone in maulings–coyotes, yes, dogs, no), mainly around the belly, groin, and arms.

    I bet you anything this was a pack of dogs, and likely a few were not neutered.

    Most pit bulls are fine–no more or less aggressive than any other terrier breed. However, get a few unaltered ones together and pit bulls and jack russell terriers can be extremely violent towards one another.

Comments are closed.