Jeffrey Kuhner at the Washington Times is worried that Americans will go extinct just like, um, Canadians:
The homosexual lifestyle signifies the triumph of neo-pagan Epicureanism. By its very nature, homosexuality cannot fulfill the primary function of sex: procreation and the reproduction of the human race. It is inherently a socially barren act. A homosexual society is a childless one—doomed to extinction.
You have to love this line of reasoning: If we don’t actively discriminate against gay people then—good God!—one day everyone will be gay (because heterosexual sex and opposite-sex relationships hold so little appeal) and then we’ll be living in a completely homosexual society (because there’s no such thing as a straight person, only gay people who have been coerced into forming opposite-sex relationships) and soon the human race will go extinct because no one will remember which hole to stick it in when you wanna make a baby (because people—at least the people who read and write for the Washington Times—are just that stupid).
Oy.
It’s hardly worth engaging a dope like Kuhner—and I shouldn’t have to engage with him at all; it’s straight people who should be most insulted by Kuhner’s “reasoning”—so I’m just going to walk on by. But I do wanna take this opportunity to suggest that procreation isn’t the “primary function” of sex for humans and hasn’t been for a long, long time. Yeah, yeah: it’s the reason we’re all here and we’ll go extinct if we can’t manage to keep track of which hole makes babes and which hole makes booms. But our sexualities, like our cultures, are hugely complicated affairs, and there’s a whole lot more going on than just the grim grinding out of billions of new humans.
A sex act can make a baby… if the people having it are opposite-sexed, fertile, and remember to stick it in the right hole. But sex also cements bonds of love, bonds of marriage, bonds of friendship, bonds of friendswithbenefitsship. By design we have a whole hell of a lot more sex—we have have a lot more orgasms—than we do children. The overkill built into the system is ridiculous: we’re interested in sex constantly, human females aren’t just up for sex when they’re ovulating, men produce more than a 100,000,000 sperm cells per ejaculation, post-menapausal women are horny. All of this overkill was built into the system—excuse me: it evolved into the system—to compensate for short life expectancies and childhood mortality and evolutionary pressures that made it likelier for the horny and fecund to survive and reproduce and pass on their horny and fecund genes.
But that was then.
Mordern humans have adapted sex, like so much else, to other uses. Social uses. And those social uses—the love you make—are arguably the “primary function” of sex in human societies and cultures today.

Ah, SB, the towering genius of our age.
When last I saw him posting about healthcare, I provided OECD statistics, and he countered with an episode of MR. Bean that he saw once. I was intellectually crushed.
So just give it up y’all. We are no match for this here Übermensch. Also it seems that I’ve been going about this liberal thing all wrong. Who knew?
Oh Jeffrey, you need to do more research. Once we gays overthrow society and make gay marriage compulsory, we of course plan to establish mass breeding facilities with captive surrogate mothers. It’s all there in the Gay Agenda. Chapter LXIX, from memory.
@13 Don’t forget about Hera. BTW, “toaster” is a racial slur. (jk)
@16. We read that book in high school. Argh! It read like a homophobic fundi’s fantasy: straight people are normal and good but they’re in the minority and they’re being persecuted (at some point in the novel) by the icky warped homo’s until they finally take a stand and construct a heterosexual colony to try to make the world right again like it was in the past. (The time-travel theme was awesome, however.)
@35. Right! Probably if 90% of the population were strictly gay (and not reproducing for some reason) we could still maintain the human population at uncomfortably high levels for centuries or more.
Jeeesh. What are the chances he’s gay himself? I’d guess around around 99%. The only folks with that kind of world view are the ones repressing their own homosexuality. That’s the only way that sort of fear only makes any sense.
As a straight married guy myself, I can say that with 100% certainty that the legalization of same-sex marriage isn’t going to cause me to leave my wife for the first good-lookin’ guy I come across.
@54: The Forever War was written as an anti-war novel, so I doubt it would be a fundie’s fantasy. IIRC the social change where homosexuality became the norm was just a way to show how the future will likely be very much unlike the present; it took up a page or two in the book. I haven’t read it for some time but I don’t think it was presented as “icky warped homos.”
@46 You lose.
“Just as there is that of God in every person, there is that of God in every relationship that calls upon God. … We agree that spiritual gifts are not distributed with regard to sexual orientation and gender identity, and we affirm that we are all equal before God. Our Quaker testimony guides us to an all-embracing practice of human equality … discrimination against gays and lesbians (is) contrary to the inclusive ministry of Jesus.”
Read the whole thing: [CLICK HERE]
And read these, too.
@46: Isn’t the argument that you’re making there an example of the “Snow Blue Frogman pharmacy”?
Hey Dan, you’ll love this – Hamilton’s rule. If you make society better, and in doing so help pass on your kin’s genes, you’re essentially passing on your own.
So if being a homosexual helps people related to you get along and prosper, by say, improved social cohesion through gay relationships and sex, you ARE passing your genes on.
Canadians are extinct?? Cool.
DebraB (@60)
Snorfle! You mean I’m a figment of my own imagination? Wow!
Just….
Oops. Must have lost that wisp of thought but, then again, I’m not really here either.
Sometimes it feels like a cheap shot to accuse lunatic homophobes of being self-hating closet cases, but in instances like this it’s an argument that’s unavoidably compelling. If he, himself, didn’t have a nigh-irresistible urge to go homo, why would he assume that everyone else would? If he didn’t find homosexuality so fascinating, why would he assume that a society that tolerates it will inevitably become it?
#13- You rock venomlash.
#54 – Hera isn’t human.
Also, was SB making a point? I couldn’t see anything but a lot of hurfdurrrrrrrr.
@58: You mean the One True Scotsman fallacy? I’ve never heard the name you used for it before.
Anyway, no, it’s not. The counterpart to the One True Scotsman fallacy is the Humpty Dumpty fallacy: thinking you can use words however you want. Christian has a specific meaning, and you can’t just call yourself Christian but believe whatever you want, especially when the Christian Bible is not exactly gay-friendly.
Christians are factually wrong, and their beliefs are harmful to society, but at least they’re more honest than gay-friendly “Christians.”
@61
Of course Canadians are a figment of their own imaginations. You expect us to believe that intelligent, socially aware, compassionate, and friendly people would put up with winters like that on purpose? Bah.
But don’t feel bad. I know a lot of Americans who are CLEARLY figments of their own imaginations, and with a lot less class and creativity about it. Really, if you are going to imagine yourself into existence, pretend to be someone worthwhile!
@64
” Christians are factually wrong, and their beliefs are harmful to society, but at least they’re more honest than gay-friendly “Christians.”
Bzzzt.
One of the more common complaints about Christians is that they all take the Bible literally – and that isn’t true. There are plenty of denominations which take an official stance that is far more nuanced and realistic – understanding the intent and worldview of Biblical writers and factoring it into their understanding.
Yes, someone who says that every word of the Bible is literally true and the commands of a pissy God would have trouble justifying being pro-gay.
But someone who says that the Bible is a human document attempting to express a culturally-influenced experience of an ineffable Divinity, and that therefore, human understanding of God can grow and change and evolve over time has no obligation to honor the literal Levitical demands any more than they do the description of a flat earth or toleration of slavery. And they don’t have to turn in their Christian card if that’s what they believe.
Nice try. Individual Christians don’t have any obligation to be what you accuse them of just so it’s more convenient for you to hate them.
@65
Oh, darn. You’re restricting (the dumber) Americans from expressing their overwhelming need to tell the rest of the world (or even the saner elements in their own country) what to do.
OTOH, imagine how quiet it might be. Nah. Seems … unnatural.
@66 The only thing I would add is that being Christian is supposed to mean you believe in a “new covenant,” in which the covenant of the old testament is marked null and void and the era brought forth by Jesus represents a whole new “deal” with a kinder, gentler, more-obviously loving God. So, it boggles my mind that there can be such a thing as a “Christian” who goes all Fundamentalist out of the Old Testament. Dudes! Didn’t you get the memo? There’s a New Testament which reinterprets and supplants the old one! Either that, or maybe you’re not really Christian.
FWIW, even Jews, even Orthodox Jews, don’t treat the Old Testament like a static, prescriptive guide frozen in time. Far from it. For them, religion is a living thing, it’s about spirit and intent, and collected religious texts, even the most honored and revered ones, are to be studied, discussed, interpreted and reinterpreted in light of that spirit.
There’s some truly amazing crap in the OT, which starts off very early on in the development of what we now call the Judeo-Christian tradition, a religion completely unrecognizable today to even the most orthodox Jews. All the stuff in Leviticus having to do with animal sacrifice shows that was a central part of the early religion, probably all animals raised by the followers having to be slaughtered in the Temple, their living spirits gratefully returned to God. In essence, the priests doubled as abbatoir workers for the community, and got a cut of the meat, quite literally, for their labors. If that’s how it was, then the admonitions in Leviticus about all meat having to be consumed before the end of the second day would mean that any Fundies who consume commercially-bought meat or meat products are abominations. Oopsie!
Dan, I thought you read Sex at Dawn. You’re giving up fully half of your argument by stipulating that sex evolved only for baby-making but “modern humans” have adapted it for other purposes. There’s lots of good evidence that our hunter-gatherer ancestors used sex for bonding as well as procreative purposes, just like many other species do.
@ 64 – You’re the one who’s guilty of humpty-dumptyism here: a “christian” is, by definition, a follower of Christ, and therefore not a follower of the old testament (for reasons explained @ 68).
Oh, that’s just a product of the culture war. THEY are out to get US! So WE must fight THEM with all our might until the very END!
Also the insane rantings of a dying philosophy.
Wait what? Canadians are going extinct because of recognized, legal same sex marriage?
So would that make Canadians an endangered species? 😛
Slightly less sarcastic – Same sex marriage is not turning young Canadians gay – if it was, would my (mid-twenty-something) friends facebook pages be full of them and their babies?
@34: to your list of people that shouldn’t be permitted to marry in the first place, I would add that married couples who do have children should be required to divorce as soon as their children have reached adulthood.
Bonobos have sex a lot like we do. Not just for reproduction, but for tension reduction, social reasons, etc. With either sex. That’s right, those dirty homo apes are rubbing nubs! Is that why they’re being hunted out of existence? 🙁
The fact that dolphins have sex with others of the same sex–in such interesting places as the blow-hole–yet still exist and breed seems to mean nothing to these idiots.
For the most intelligent animals, sex as a means of social bonding is commonplace. It has not rendered them extinct.
Notice also, how for these homophobic doom-and-gloom scenarios, bisexuality, asexuality, and pansexuality do not appear to exist. Everyone is just straight or gay, and straight people are apparently easily made gay.
The fact that these fundy-types believe that straight people switch to gay rather quickly says a little something more about them I think.
@75: The blowhole? Really? HOT. Got a link?
@66: My complaint is that Christians don’t take their holy book literally enough. If I believed in god and I actually thought he wrote a book, I sure as hell would take it literally. But most “Christians” don’t, which allows their preposterous beliefs and the harm they do to society to continue. If they actually believed what they said, no one would listen, because it’s so clearly wrong. They’re hypocrites who ignore the parts they don’t like.
I don’t hate Christians. I do think their beliefs are false and actively harmful. They don’t have an obligation to be what I accuse them of being; they do have an obligation to be intellectually honest and examine their beliefs.
@68, 70: I’m not sure you’re right about Christianity completely supplanting the OT, considering Jesus is quoted as being a big fan of the Law of Moses. But even if you are, the NT is hardly “kinder and gentler” what with the descriptions of hell and anti-gay statements. I didn’t mention the OT specifically, and even sticking to the NT, I stand by my comments that it’s not gay-friendly, it’s false, it’s harmful to society, and one can’t call oneself a Christian without accepting it. Therefore, all Christians are part of the problem.
@75 Oh my. That comment about the dolphins reminds me of a joke Robert Schimmel once told about swimming with dolphins. He and his fellow swimmers were told not to stick anything in the blowhole, and he said his first thought was, “Well that’s a waste of fifty bucks.”
Dan-
TRUE or FALSE:
“A homosexual society is a childless one—” ?
“But sex also cements bonds of love, bonds of marriage, “
gawd Dan, you are so wise….
True. Sexual desire, harnessed within the bounds of marriage, is a powerful stabilizing force for good in society.
But sex outside of marriage also destroys bonds of love, bonds of marriage….
Infidelity is a major cause of relationship breakup and divorce.
Children are the biggest victims of infidelity and the social havoc it creates.
Will no one think of the children?
Sex is like fire.
It can heat the home, cook the meals, create an inviting hearth.
Or, used irresponsibly, it can burn the house down.
Sex is like atomic energy.
It can supply the city with clean power.
Or it can incinderate the city.
Sex, outside of marriage, is a socially destructive force.
Danny, won’t you help spread the word?….
Period Troll! That’s a lovely argument you make for marriage equality. My how far you have come.
A returned mormon missionary was the first person I ever heard this argument from.
@78: Alleged, true or false:
“Society can be accurately described as homosexual or heterosexual.”
@79: “Sex is like atomic energy.
It can supply the city with clean power.
Or it can incinderate the city.”
I have this image of a bunch of people humping inside a giant hamster wheel connected to a dynamo.
Also, my face when “incinderate”.
Dan, why are you reading the TIMES fercrissakes? Put down that rag NOW, damnit. No, don’t pick up the Examiner in its place….arrrgh. Don’t you get that SOMEONE has to cater to the 4% of the DC population who are transplanted conservative political staffers?
Just rest assured that you’re one of like 10 people who read that screed. Well, until YOU linked to it.