Mike Huckabee had this to say about gay parents a couple of weeks ago:
“I believe that we’re in denial about potential problems as we see more and more homosexual couples raising families. Essentially, these are experiments to see how well children will fare in such same-sex households. It will be years before we know whether or not [these] little guinea pigs turn out to be good at marriage and parenthood.”
The New York Times today on a horrifying crime in Texas:
The police investigation began shortly after Thanksgiving, when an elementary school student alerted a teacher to a lurid cellphone video that included one of her classmates. The video led the police to an abandoned trailer, more evidence and, eventually, to a roundup over the last month of 18 young men and teenage boys on charges of participating in the gang rape of an 11-year-old girl in the abandoned trailer home, the authorities said. Five suspects are students at Cleveland High School, including two members of the basketball team. Another is the 21-year-old son of a school board member.
Is it fair to ask if any of the little guinea pigs alleged to have participated in this horrifying crime had gay parents?* Or were these rape-y little guinea pigs raised by straight parents?
I’m not saying that gay parents are perfect or that are our kids are perfect. Far from it. But Mike Huckabee insists that the jury will remain out on gay parents until we know how our kids turn out. And since it wouldn’t be fair to kids to let gay people adopt or raise them until we know how kids fare in same-sex households—which is something we won’t know until those kids are fully grown—gay people shouldn’t be allowed to adopt or raise our own biological children. Not until the jury comes in… which the jury can’t do until the kids we aren’t being allowed to raise are fully grown. So, basically, gay people can’t have kids.
See how that prejudice works?
We actually do know how kids with gay parents turn out—lots of cites and data here—but Mike ignores the data with a clear conscience and a spotless soul because the Commandment that forbids bearing false witness against your neighbors doesn’t apply to your gay neighbors.
We’re just going to have trust Mike on this. He is a Baptist minister after all.
* No, I don’t think it’s a fair question.

These are the people who clutch at random facts, throw them together, and come up with scary talking points, which is all the average Fox viewer listens to: “Gay marriage costs the States billions of dollars because straight deadbeat dads aren’t paying child support.” If they can spout a non sequitur like that with a straight face, of course they can say children of gay parents are “guinea pigs.” Although you don’t have to look any further than these threads, and wait for someone like Seattleblues to show up to see that calling one’s self a Christian, and behaving like a Christian are two very different things.
Yeah, I see how the politicisation of the gang rape of an 11 year old child works too.
That Mike-
what a bafoon…..
Doesn’t he knowe The Jury is In?
Didn’t he see the study of 70 self reporting lesbians who all thought they were great moms?
Hasn’t he read the dozen or so studies Prof Savage cites, some going back as far as 10 whole years?!
Boy, that Mike-
what a chucklehead…..
To hear him fret you would think in the whole zillion year history of mankind no society ever anywhere had ever recognized homosexual marriages.
You would think there was absolutely No historical data to refer back to.
Absolutely No historical precedent.
You would think, to hear Mike whine, that we haven’t followed multiple generations of homosexual parents to see the effect gay parenting has on suceeding generations.
You would think we don’t already know what effect recognizing homosexual marriage would have on society’s attitudes toward marriage.
You would think this was some flighty whim of the Homoliberal Fringe of the Liberal Left, to hear Mike…
You would think this was just some obsession concocted in the last decade, to hear Mike…
Why doesn’t he loook to the centuries of homosexual parenting by the Greeks and Romans? Mike probably can’t even spell ‘roman’…
Boy, that Mike-
What a ninny…..
As I’ve said before, he’s a Christian. They lie with impunity because they’re never wrong. If they say it, it must be so!
Wow, this article is sort of offensive and victim blame-y. “Where was her mother?” asks a neighbor. Another claims that “these boys will have to live with this for the rest of their lives.”
This poor little girl, growing up in this horrible community.
Doesn’t Mike read the news?
Doesn’t he read about all the rape and mayhem wrought by heterosexuals and their filthy spawn?
Doesn’t he realize that
the fact that some heterosexual are bad bad people
PROVES
beyond the shadow of a doubt
that homosexuals are undeniable
indisputably
indubitably
undoubtedly
unquestionably
really really great parents?
Didn’t Mike ever study logic?
Ahhhh, dear bellgirl, but didn’t you see that the churches were praying for the victim. That will help, right? Mike Huckabee is a moron, but a moron with a following. It’s a slow fight. Huckabee is attacking STRAIGHT people too. Look at his policies.
The example to always use when Huckabee criticizes others parenting or upbringing is his own son David’s history of animal mutilation and abuse.
@4
I, too, mourn for Greece in 5000 BC, things were just so simple then. I have this neighbour, he drives me crazy, and if I could just get the other villagers to stone him to death, gawd, that would totally make my day. My daughter, oy, the trouble she causes with her lack of modest daytime wear, if only I could have sold her to the UPS delivery guy, I would be minus a headache and have my Visa paid off–win win! I HATE that the world is changing and evolving, why, here in Canada, women not only vote, but they go to the grocery alone, and they flirt with the checkout boy! And last summer, hold onto your panties, period troll, these (shhh) lesbians got married at our friend’s place, and the community had the nerve to not give a shit, can you believe it? It’s almost like it didn’t matter to anyone but them! Cripes! Next thing you know, they’ll probably have a kid, and force it to listen to folk music and eat lentils. Stone them, stone them all!!!
11
Actually we can easily believe that the community didn’t give a shit. That is, after all, the root of the problem.
10
We heard that Huck’s son had been renting his adopted 5 year old son out to pedophiles on Craig’s list.
Surely that proves something, doesn’t it?
If “straight” parents were all treated as science experiments would anyone be allowed to have kids? He’s implying that straight parents have proven and deserve to have children due to the outstanding results they have produced. This is a completely unfounded and absurd point of view. I wonder what’s next… lets see which minorities don’t deserve to have children due to the poor results. Good parenting doesn’t come when a penis is thrust into a vagina.
“We never censor comments based on ideology”
Except when you do!
I’m about as pro-science as someone can get (I even made it my career!) but I can’t help but wonder if arguing from a scientific basis about these things is a mistake.
Bear with me here…
When we point out that there are studies showing (say) that gay parents do just as well as straight parents in response to someone like Huckabee who asserts the opposite or that “the jury is out”, we are engaging him on his own terms. We’re implicitly accepting the premise that population-level outcomes are the only things that matter.
If I were to cite studies that showed (say) that African American children are more likely to be involved in criminal activities later in life, or that first generation Americans have a higher rate of suicide due to pressure from their parents, or that women who conceive after 40 are more likely to have children with Down syndrome, and based on this science, I propose that African Americans, immigrants, and women ought not be allowed to have children, I would (rightly!) be excoriated as a racist, a xenophobe, or a latter-day eugenicist. Because *even if* such things are true in the aggregate, many (most) individual families that fall into those groups do not have those problems. The state therefore has no right to intervene in family matters of people based solely on their group identity.
Which is to say…*even if* the science didn’t support the notion that gay parents (on average) do just as well as their straight counterparts, there *still* isn’t any justification for excluding an entire group of people from parenthood based on their group identity.
Similarly, the question of whether being gay is genetically determined is irrelevant to the conversation about whether gay people deserve equal protection under the law. They do, not because they “can’t help it” but because they DO, as PEOPLE. Full stop.
@18 Exactly! We can’t blame the fact that all 18 rapists in the Texas case are black on black people. The same reasoning applies to pitbills. Just because you see one wandering down your street there is no reason to cross the street. Chances are it’s a perfectly nice pitbull and to treat it any other way only exposes you as a bigot!
@Period Hive Mind, your knowledge of history is flawed, even within post-Classical European history, there have been times when gay marriage has been legal and even church sanctioned.
And the idea that Dan is saying gays are unquestionably good parents and that he is painting all straight people with the BAD PERSON brush is absurd. Some straight people are shit at being parents and, as the events you cite show, some openly gay people are just as shit. The key word, however, is SOME! If the fact that some openly gay people are shit parents means no openly gay people should be parents, then it is only logical that because some straight people are shit parents, no straight people should be parents, and all children should just be raised by the state.
Did Mikey have anything to say about the radical experiment of letting Baptist ministers raise kids? There’s solid evidence in his own family that it turns kids into animal-torturing pieces of shit.
Period Troll, you always say “we”….are you the Queen, or do you have multiple personality disorder?
@11 – Canuck, I love you.
Period Troll – Have you considered moving over to redstate? Your complete lack of sense and inane concepts (not to mention your “unique” pedantic style) would be perfect there. Your jumble of words make my monitor cry and I can’t be the only one. Please, think of the crying monitors!
@19 – Your equating Black people with pitbulls is transparent and asinine.
@18, The Master’s tools will never dismantle the Master’s house.
I dunno, we have the better arguments whether we play by their rules or not.
This awful that poor little girl.
I wish Mr. Huckabee would get off this topic. But, I guess this an acceptable scape goat to keep him in the spotlight, in his opinion. I wonder how he feels about his parenting being criticized with regard to the actions of his son. His life contains evidence that one’s children are capable of cruelty and violence.
I think the majority of children born and/or raised by gay parents turn out just fine. That certainly has been the case for my husband and his siblings. All three are college educated, employed, married, and involved in their community. At present all six grandchildren are doing fine as well and give evidence that they will grow up to be an asset to society. I think the same is true of children born and/or raised by straights.
I share your frustration at the stupidity of Huckabee’s argument and his hypocrisy. I think Huckabee and those who share his attitude will not be swayed by this post. Their minds are closed from the inside.
Hucklebee thinks only good, christian families should be allowed to raise kids.
Good christian families never produce kids that turn out bad. Never ever.
“Your equating Black people with pitbulls is transparent and asinine.”
You’re right, I’ve never had problems with pit bulls.
@27, You are a miserable excuse for a human being.
Thank you for the laugh, Canuck @11!
I think the point here is that the experiment called “Texas” is a miserable failure.
Fuckin Huckabee….
I haven’t been so disappointed in a bass player since Sid Vicious.
🙁
Donolectic and Kim…xoxo
Well if anecdote is what Period Troll and Mr. Huckabee accept as fact, may I submit the example of my Very First Serious Boyfriend. Raised by Lesbians, and now, at the tender age of 45, the CEO of his very own successful company, opposite married these 15-20 years, and the father of a well adjusted, bright and bilingual daughter. And never tortured a dog, or raped an 11 year old, or even ever did drugs! How on earth can we account for this paragon? Could it be he is the product of Good Parenting™? By LESBIANS? Oh surely not! Such a thing is inconceivable and certainly unsupported by study! And yet there he stands.
Oh, and good morning to Gus, Canuck and Kim. I’d like to take this opportunity to derail this thread by giving you much love, and by announcing that I had a cupcake for breakfast.
Ooo, the green-eyed monster of jealousy is upon me, Lissa….I loooove cupcakes. And good morn to you, too, honeybunch! (haters gonna hate, what can we do?)
Happy birthday, Lissa.
Ps. This is the second thread that I’ve placed wishes. So, I accept the scolding and will make Chocolate and Guinness Cupcakes with Baileys Irish Cream Frosting as a token of good will.
Oh Kim what scolding? Not that I won’t take the virtual cupcake! It sound awesome. I tried a whiskey maple bacon cupcake last night as part of my week of festivities, and while it was yummy, I don’t think it would hold a candle to the one you have just so mouth wateringly described!
Great post, Dan!
Actually this Huck story is the perfect example of how minorities in this country still suffer from regular and routine discrimination.
When a straight WASP (like Huck, for example) does something bad, then he and only he is held accountable… but when a member of a minority behaves inappropriately, all members of that specific group (black, hispanic, gay, Muslim, whatever, etc) have to suffer a bit because minorities are ALWAYS held accountable for what other members of their group do.
White guys don’t suffer because Ted Bundy raped and killed young women… but any Muslim in an airport is for some reason a potential terrorist.
It’s not fair, but as a gay white male, I’ve spent most of my adult life trying to convince people that I’m not like any other gay man… I’m just me. Judge me if you like, and hold me accountable for anything I might do, but don’t assume that I’m just like so-and-so because we both happen to be gay.
But damn, wouldn’t it be fun to see ol’ Huck get a taste of his own medicine one day.
Ooo, happy birthday from me, too! And oh, would I love a Guinness cupcake right now, and not the protein shake I brought for lunch, bleh!
Omg that poor girl… : (
A joke for being off topic, but the cupcakes will be real when finished, Lissa.
My heartaches for that little girl.
Yeah, WTF Mikey? (Well, I know what the fuck, but it’s more fun to pretend you’re not just being disingenuous or straight-up lying to try to protect the systems of privilege that benefit you.) I have a couple friends my age (mid-twenties) whose parents are gay (not adopted: I’m guessing turkey baster or grin-n’-bear-it hetero sex). They’re fine (though, if you’re presuming that godlessness and an acceptance of homosexuality as something to not be persecuted are ‘bad’ outcomes for children, then you’re right, though I disagree with your valuation for whether children turn out ‘okay’). All of the evidence that we have, and we have plenty, as Dan links, refutes the claim that gay parents are universally or statistically more likely to be worse parents than straight parents.
Just stick with “Yahweh says Teh Gay is Wrong”; you don’t actually have any other arguments.
@38: That’s privilege for you.