To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes.
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
@50 Provided that you have unlimited time and resources (like putting an app on an app store), I don’t agree with anybody censoring, or asking a company to censor, anybody else.
51, So you feel Apple should just put up any app that anyone creates? Say a virtual child porn app? Is photo realistic, computer generated pictures with the likeness of your children (Nieces, nephews, what ever applies) on the iPhone okay with you?
@52 If somebody makes that app, and it is well within the limits of legality, yes Apple should consider it. I don’t agree with it, but they could.
The question I have for you is how they got pics of your related children in the first place to distribute over the net.
53, They could get pictures on the street, or in a park. There’s no expectation of privacy under those circumstances. So computer generated child porn with the likenesses of the children in your life should be on the app store if someone wants it? Okay, somehow I think you’d object if it actually happened.
@54 You’re adorable when your pushing buttons trying to show me my limits when I actually have been a proponent for free-for-all society for years. Decades, even.
P.S. Using your, or your child’s likeness, for something other than a news story about that person, is actually a liability, and illegal, regardless of where they got the photo. You kind of need to consent to that. Also, this is doubly true for personages under the age of 18, as there are laws of consent that specifically define underage children.
55, So, it’s okay for you to rely on the government to do your censorship dirty work for you? Well now, that gets you off the hook doesn’t it?
You don’t need consent to take photos on the street or public places. There is no expectation of privacy. Since that actual image created would be a computer simulation, no consent would be required, as no real human beings actually did any of the acts being illustrated. So again, for the sake of free speech, would you be for an app that simulated images of children you love in sexual situations?
To add, if your for a “free for all society”, you’d be against consent laws anyway, wouldn’t you?
Read up, moron.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personality…
58, But in the name of free for all society, you should be against such regulations. Again you want to rely on the government to do your censorship dirty work for you. You would freely offer up the photos and likenesses because somebody wants that app. Why would you censor them?
Again, if the name of free speech would you be for a child porn app with virtual images of children you love featured? Quit side stepping.
@57 Red herring (you’re full of them)–the discussion was about speech and its regulation by private companies not TheMisanthrope’s view on ages of consent.
@59 “Quit side stepping.” Oh, the irony!
60, No, he said he was for a “free for all society” with absolutely no censorship, yet he is willing to let the government censor on his behalf, and would censor folks who wanted to have the above mentioned app. Beside, he brought up the consent thing, not me.
Rob, you brought up kiddie-porn and chemical weapons which are totally non-analogous to this. Both (simulated likenesses and instructions for building weapons) are legal according to SCOTUS, btw, although again not analogous.
What if Apple was a little more rightwing and they kept their original abridgment of Oscar Wilde? Would you not have a problem with that as well?
Look at what Dan himself calls censorship, btw. Wasn’t this just a private entity doing the same thing as Apple? Not saying it’s good or bad, although my sentiment is on the side of free expression more than limited expression. I also think you do have to take into account market share and anti-trust concerns over the app store before you write off censorship entirely.
I was asking what iPhone apps would be okay with people, since they’re okay with the anti-gay app in the name of free speech. As you can see people who claimed to be for unlimited free for all societies aren’t really. They would censor under certain circumstances. It’s just a matter of where they draw the line versus where Apple drew the line.
Actually Troll in Baltimore, I’m also for retaliation. So, if you wanted to sue the people who made the kiddie porn app for invasion of privacy, and personality rights, I’m all for that too. I’d also be for permanent enslavement and murder, in this theory.
Just to quote from Dan’s post, because it’s really good–he should read it sometime:
“Censorship is wrong when they do it to us, when we attempt to do it to them, and when we do it to ourselves.
And censorship always and everywhere backfires.”
65, Down to name calling? Slavery, and murder are done to real people. Computer generated images aren’t real people. They’re ideas being expressed. You would censor that using lawsuits.
66, Yet Dan was for the removal of this app, so he’s not totally against censorship.
@68, Yes, which highlights his hypocrisy.
69, that’s between you and him.
My exception to people saying “X is a private entity, they can do whatever they want” is that this is the standard free market neo-liberal utopian refrain we hear from so-called conservatives and faux liberals. People who are otherwise “progressive” have no problem spouting this off especially when the censorship fits their narrow progressive world-view. What’s not factored in is the disproportionate control of the market and the tendency for further limitation of speech perpetuated by that initial act.
71, I’ve never claimed to be completely against all censorship, and folks have the right to censor what is presented via their business. People also have the right to react to a company’s decisions, and request that they change practices. The company can choose to yield to, or ignore the requests. Oh! they had a petition! So what? That’s not legally binding.
When you open up a business, you can let people post all the Nazi, KKK, NAMBLA, Exodus, promotional flyers on your property. You won’t be in business long, but feel free. It’s your right.
To add, if you disagree with Apple’s decisions, tell them. That is your right to. If they ignore you, don’t buy their products.
@67 Only for those trolls who I think are either playing Devil’s Advocate to try to get somebody to admit they’re wrong somebody who is trying to make other people wrong so they don’t have to feel guilty over their actions, or an actual troll. I think you’re wavering between the three instead of having an honest conversation. I think, deep down, you know you’re a hypocrite for thinking the way you do, and that your own inconsistencies are deeply flawed. But, you want me to come out and say something hypocritical in order to make yourself feel better about your own hypocrisy.
74, Project much?
@75 Are we down to “I know you are, but what am I?”
Really?
Both of you stop necroing this thread; the butthurt is intolerable.
/sage
76, Since you decided to make this about me, rather than the merits of your argument, I guess we’re done here.
Its not necro’d if it never died.
/Parsley
@78 I agree, especially since your argument never had any merits to begin with.
@12 lame, that game sounds fucking awesome!