But just the gay ones.

We were told the “hold” on the deportations would be indefinite (or until DOMA was decided, which could be years), then we were told that it would be in force for a week, and now we learn that it’s already over—in just two days.

The “hold” on same-sex married bi-national couples’ green card applications—celebrated by immigration and LGBT advocates—is over, according to the spokesman for the agency that processes those requests. “The guidance we were awaiting … was received last night, so the hold is over, so we’re back to adjudicating cases as we always have,” U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services press secretary Christopher Bentley told Metro Weekly this morning. The agency will continue to “enforce the law,” he says, which means that the Defense of Marriage Act—which prohibits the government from recognizing same-sex marriages—prevents those green card applications from being approved.

The Obama administration hasn’t “enforced the law” when it comes to the widow’s penalty for almost two years now. If you marry an American citizen and you’re straight and your American spouse dies before you qualify for a green card, you can stay in this country indefinitely after the death of your spouse in violation of the law. If you marry an American citizen and you’re gay, the federal government will tear you from your spouse and you will be deported. Because your genitals don’t clash, they match. (When is a member of the White House press corp going to ask about this?) Says Andrew:

The US recognizes the marital and familial bond as the most sacred factor in deciding immigration questions. Why? Because it is understood that the right to marry whomever one chooses is an elemental human right, and that a government that insists on breaking up such marriages, or forcing those in them to leave their own country, is violating basic human rights.

Which means to say that the US government regards gay Americans as sub-human in their needs and wants and rights. Their loves and relationships mean nothing under the law every time they encounter federal authoritah. Aaron and I are total strangers to one another in the eyes of federal law. And because we are legally married, I am paradoxically more vulnerable to being deported than I would be if I were single—because it’s plain that I intend to reside in the US indefinitely, even though my visa has an expiration date. So I’m a risk—hence my huge anxiety if I ever leave the country.

Many countries that don’t recognize same-sex marriage still allow gay citizens to sponsor their same-sex partners for residency. Even non-citizens: when my boyfriend-at-the-time got a fellowship from the German government to study the arts in Berlin, he was able to get me a work permit. That was in 1989.

When will we catch up to the rest of the free world?

16 replies on “Feds Resume Deportations of Foreign-Born Spouses of American Citizens”

  1. Dan,

    Have you considered leaving? I’m serious, here. Obama’s the most progressive president we’ve gotten in decades, and given the general direction of political discourse, probably the most progressive we’ll get in the foreseeable future. He’s not improving the situation, which suggests improving it is just politically not going to happen.

    Other countries treat gay immigrants better than we treat gay CITIZENS. I’d sure be thinking about saying, “look, I’m not wanted here” and emigrating. You clearly have the means, and this country is going down the tubes anyway.

  2. When will we catch up to the rest of the world?

    At the rate we’re going, I’d say we’ll be there around 2030, at about a 2000 mark.

  3. I wish I knew and could answer that question for you, love. I really wish I could. I’ll keep writing, e-mailing… Keep up the good work.

    xo

  4. @4: It’d be nice, but the way our voting system gives more weight to rural states means they have an edge over us politically. We may just have to let them have their country. At this point I really don’t expect to still be in the U.S. in 20 years.

  5. If a law is unconstitutional, the law is illegal, and the deportation is illegal. Obama has always set himself for trouble by saying that DOMA is invalid under the constitution — and it is — while at the same time saying that he will enforce an illegal law — something in itself is illegal. Those couples should sue the administration under 42 U.S.C. 1983 for a civil rights violation.

    It is not as if there is a teensy weensy bit of evidence that DOMA serves any purpose whatsoever. It is not like courts did not examine this. Two Federal courts have already have ruled DOMA illegal.

    Staying those deportations until the cases like Gill have concluded is really required, because there is not a shred of evidence for a rational basis — any — for DOMA — the minimum requirement for a law to be even arguably constitutional.

  6. This is fucked up. Blatant discrimination against US citizens and their partners and spouses. But.. Let s not go thinking that all of Europe is like Germany or the netherlands. The European Union varies greatly in terms of immigration policy. Some, like, Italy are just as backwards and in some cases worse than here.

    “The main provision is that you can recognise marriages or partnerships only when the hosting country has similar provisions”

  7. I continue to be dazzled by the POTUS’s Fierce Advocacy ™ of gay rights… Quick! Where’s my check book? Must. Send. Him. More. Gay. Dollars.

    Ha!… Right…

  8. …I don’t even know how to express how angry this makes me.

    Dan, isn’t there anything that you can send us off to do to make this better? I’m just–I’m just so sick of this! Two of my good friends from high school (both women) had a wedding ceremony, but can’t even get a civil union, despite having been together for going on six years. One of them is an illegal immigrant, brought here when she was a few months old. She’s bilingual, did relatively well at a good high school, and can’t get any job other than cleaning houses. Couldn’t get financial aid.

    They want to have kids. They want to get a house together. Why don’t they have the right to these things? It just makes me so sick. I just don’t know what to do.

    It’s one thing for me to get mad about the fact that I can’t get married to a woman. It’s another to sit and think about how the lives of two of my friends could be utterly ruined due to this–this–this disgusting–argh! I’m beyond words.

    I was surprised and pleased to hear that the policy was being suspended. I am unsurprised but enraged to learn that they changed their minds.

    Isn’t there anything that I can do?

Comments are closed.