Nothing new here: Santorum doesn’t think that same-sex couples should have any rights—no access to marriage, no civil unions, no domestic partnerships, no nothing—but he concedes that we are “free Americans” and that we can live our lives however we like. In other words: all Americans have a right to assfuck their partners in their asses but only straight Americans should have the right to make medical decisions for their partners in an emergency. (But what about assfucking emergencies? We’ll need to get a clarification from Santorum about that.) This is growth: Santorum used to argue that gay sex should be a felony. At this rate Santorum will come out for marriage equality sometime after 2089.

35 replies on “Santorum: Assfucking For All! But No “Privileges” for Gay Couples!”

  1. If I ran the world: Every time one of these dumbasses got on TV and started talking about “no rights for gays,” I would require the interviewer to ask why they were wasting precious time/money/resources attempting to deny rights to a relatively small number of people when there are so many other huge issues out there. I would make them answer that question every single time: “Why are you working to restrict LGBT rights when so many people are out of jobs?” Every time. You know, if I ran the world…

  2. The piece that I find interesting about this interview is what Dan mentions in the post title. When I was one of them, the language was that marriage was a uniquely sacred institution and that denial of marriage was about the protection of the family and of religious freedoms. Over the last set of years, that argument has been destroyed in all sorts of ways.

    So, now the new argument is that marriage is a “privilege” not a “right.” If it’s a privilege, then the state gets to decide to only give the privilege to people that the state decrees. Also, then being against marriage equality isn’t about denying people their rights.

    In response, our next set of arguments have to include quoting the Loving v. Virginia decision and any other places in US law that indicate that marriage is a right, rather than a privilege. Every time a scumbag like Santorum calls marriage a privilege, someone from our side needs to respond with citations of where it’s been held up as a right.

  3. @4 – Right, they’re trying to shift the legal grounds. If something is a privilege, like a driver’s license, then it’s easier for the state to restrict it (though systematically denying even a privilege to a protected class is still legally suspect). But the U.S. Supreme Court has rules at least 14 times that marriage is not simply a privilege, it is a fundamental right. Even convicted felons in prison cannot be denied the right to marry (though I believe there are some limitations to that, like felons on death row).

  4. Danny really can’t get Rick out of his craw.
    Obviously Rick gave Danny a noxious STD in a bus station bathroom back in the 80s…..

  5. Don’t forget that having to construct your own voluntary contracts with your partner is bullshit — it’s imperfect, it’s patchwork from state to state, and there are rights conveyed by marriage that can never be replicated through alternative means.

    Frothy Mix is irretrievably bigoted and cynical. But journalists and citizens can refuse to accept this rights v. privileges nonsense, and push him and others to answer why gays should be denied equal standing under the law. Equal, not special. Equal.

  6. @6 Disagree. They spend huge amounts of money on their various anti-gay campaigns. How many millions of dollars does NOM raise to do just that? And sorry to disappoint you, but your “Canuck=Polack” simply isn’t accurate…next time, go with the bigot version for Irish/English, o-tay?

  7. If people like Frothy get their way, murderers, priest rapists, embezzlers, terrorists and door knobs will all have more “Privileges” than gay people. And not one of them see the irony in this.

  8. When will these people acknowledge that same-sex couples ALREADY have children? Is it not politically expedient to campaign on taking biological children away from lesbian couples or openly gay fathers?

  9. He still thinks gay sex should be a felony. He’s only saying that Americans are free to commit felonies and be sent to jail. At the rate Santorum is evolving he will support gay marriage in… never.

    (In 20 or 30 years, a reporter will go knocking on Old Man Santorum’s door just for the sake of a hilarious troglodyte quote. Everyone will laugh.)

  10. “Santorum for marriage equality” sounds like it could be a fun activist event, as long as chocolate milkshakes were prominently featured 😀

  11. When he’s asked the question, “You oppose gay marriage?” the smile on his face when he says, “I do,” kind of makes me want to punch him in the face. And I don’t consider myself a violent person. Ugh.

  12. I do so hate watching this asshole’s smarmy, smug, lying face and hearing the frothy mixture that spews from his mouthhole.

    If Santorum had his way, only Christians who ascribe to his brand of Conservative Christianity would be granted the privilege of marriage. Fucktards like him don’t want civil marriage for anyone; they want religiously sanctified marriage only, because relationships that don’t have Christ at the centre (and doesn’t that mean that all those relationships are three-ways?) are valueless.

    Civil unions and other non-marriage contracts don’t create kinship, pure and simple, and kinship is what matters from a legal and societal viewpoint.

    Canada has recognized the RIGHT of same-sex couples to marry for eight years now, and we haven’t seen any negative consequences.

  13. @15 Nice try. It’s called a false equivalency, and you either don’t see the obvious difference between couple-marriage and polygamous marriage, or you’re just a troll. Or possibly both.

  14. Dan, you need to update the Spreading Santorum site (after the definition, I mean). It’s woefully out of date and since Frothy Mix is running (and running his mouth) this needs to be revamped. I know you’re busy as hell, but surely you could assign this to a competent underling?

  15. @Tampax, far more eloquent people then me have explained why your argument is wrong, if you haven’t listened to them you won’t listen to me. However, why the fuck shouldn’t people in a polyamorous relationships, who what to make a legal commitment, be able to get married? I don’t really understand why that is so wrong. Sure it has historical connotations of female oppression, but so does good old fashioned Christian marriage…

  16. Canadian Nurse @ 3, et al.

    All of this right v. privelege talk only plays to the PR angle, which is important for the polls, but irrelevant to the law.

    If anyone wants some romping good reading check out the trial transcripts for the Perry V. Scharzenneger case [the challenge to Prop 8, now more or less heading to the SCOTUS]: http://www.afer.org/our-work/hearing-tra…

    Or reenactments of thet trial: http://marriagetrial.com/

    Wherein the defense of prop 8 gets shredded. The plaintifs’ legal team puts up days of testimony from respected experts, from individules, &c. and build a superb legal case.

    The defendants get clubbed over the head with their own innane BS. Their own witnesses [only 2 out of 6 were even willing to testify] end up making the plaintifs case, and judicial hilarity abounds.

    Seriously, this trial was about a year ago, has gotten to the 9th Circuit appeals, and will go to the top. Anyone who has missed out on this one has missed out on seeing bigots get a sound leagal spanking.

    For good commentary: http://prop8trialtracker.com/

    And for the brilliant organization fighting the good fight: http://www.afer.org/

  17. Come out for gay marriage, Dan, or just Come Out?

    I dunno about you, but the louder someone whines about gay rights, the louder it dings my gaydar.

  18. I thought it was interesting there though that he says “They have the right to employment…”

    Santorum supports ENDA, then? Or would he smarm his way around that too?

  19. I just can’t listen to this guy talk without thinking that at some point in his past he had one hell of a good time with a big greasy dick in his ass.

    So what went wrong, Rick? What went wrong?

  20. See my sarcastic hackles rise. Oh, sure, Mr. F-M, people can get the same level of protection with … uh … contracts rather than needing to infiltrate the elitist country club of marriages. And hospital administrators, etc. will continue to take one look, shrug their shoulders as if to say it’s out of their hands – if they’re pretending to be polite – or get the hell out of this place before I call security – if they’re nasty. Right. NO difference at all. /loads of sarcasm.

  21. I think it’s important to note that the “privilege” to marry is, according to Santorum, about making more kids. Nothing new here, but that does mean he thinks people who can’t have kids (sterile, too old) or don’t want them should not have the right to marry either.
    I don’t get how these people propose to enforce that. Make a marriage null and void if no baby is produced in the first two years? Have to pass fertility tests to get a marriage license?

    They use the argument of “marriage is about kids”, but come on, everybody knows it’s not true. People who can’t have kids or don’t plan to have any get married all the time, and nobody’s passing laws against it. Nor is it illegal to have kids out of wedlock.
    I’m sure they’d want to make it so, so make them say it. Surely it would lose them some support if people knew that, right? There have to be some homophobic people who want to get marriage but can’t/don’t want to produce kids.

    And any argument revolving around adoption is void considering adoption is already legal and happening by same-sex couple. Preventing them from marrying isn’t preventing them from raising kids (fortunately) so saying “we oppose same-sex marriage because of the kids” doesn’t make a whole lot of sense.

Comments are closed.