The marriage pledge from evangelical conservative Iowa group the Family Leader, which Michele Bachmann and Rick Santorum have already signed, is about to be updated:

The original “marriage vow” from the Family Leader, unveiled last week, included a line at the opening of its preamble, which suggested that black children born into slavery were better off in terms of family life than African-American kids born today.

“Slavery had a disastrous impact on African-American families, yet sadly a child born into slavery in 1860 was more likely to be raised by his mother and father in a two-parent household than was an African-American baby born after the election of the USA’s first African-American President,” read the preamble.

Bachmann’s representatives say that Bachmann signed a version of the pledge that didn’t include the racist language, which seems fishy, but of course they have to say that because the other two options—that she endorsed the preamble or that she didn’t read the pledge before signing it—just make Bachmann look stupid.

The Family Leader is not going to update the bigoted language in the pledge about homosexuality being a choice, of course, because it’s apparently still okay to be bigoted against gay people if you’re a Christian.

27 replies on “Conservative Pledge Updated to Say Black People Were Not Better Off Under Slavery”

  1. A commenter at Raw Story makes what I think is a very astute comment:

    Oh, please. You’re trying to convince WHO EXACTLY that a 55-y.o. former tax lawyer for the IRS doesn’t read what she signs? She read it. She agreed with it. She’s only backpedaling now because her handlers have realized that people are furious about it. They didn’t expect the reaction. That’s why the pretend apology — we’re sorry YOU PEOPLE were so unreasonable as to “possibly misconstrue” the fact that we said slavery was better for y’all pickaninnies. Fuck them all.

    Most people seem to take the position that Bachmann is stupid, but by many accounts, she may be crazy, but she’s actually really smart, unlike Palin. Don’t underestimate her.

  2. Slave owners routinely broke apart families by selling off mothers, fathers, and children separately; slaves weren’t afforded the right to civil marriage; and female slaves were often impregnated (willingly or by force) by white men who did not take responsibility for their mixed race children; but obviously the African American family was more intact in 1860 than today.

  3. Heterosexual monogamous households: WAY more important than freedom. In other words, controlling your private behavior is priority number one for these people.

    Pay attention, supposedly freedom-loving Americans.

  4. Well, sure, it’s a two-parent household if the mother is the slave and the father is the slave owner.

    This country is so, so fucked.

  5. @1– Smart, intelligent, well-educated people believe the craziest crap, no matter their background, race, religion, etc. (Some of them even write for free news-weeklies) The crazy-believing part of their brain always mucks up their rational thinking, because pretty much everyone has a hard time in separating that which is verifiable truth and that which is speculation/belief. (And pretty much all political theory falls under “speculation & belief.” 99% of it is driven by parental imprinting.) Batshit crazy doesn’t discern on the basis of IQ. Like seagull shit, it’ll fall on just about anyone.

    @2 It’s a sad state of affairs that even into the 21st C, this still needs to be pointed out to people.

  6. As tends to be the case, this is not the anti-choicers first mind-numbingly inept attempt to tie race to abortion.

    If only they were as concerned about African American children as they were about African American fetuses. Sadly, they want to make damn sure the kid is born, but appear to be less concerned that her mom has prenatal care, or that she has access to health care even if she happens to be poor.

  7. It’s not just bigoted (and it is). It’s also unscientific. All reputable modern medical, psychological, and psychiatric associations recognize that sexual orientation is not a matter of choice, and also not that it is not a disease or disorder, and it does not need to be “fixed”.

    If some politician tried to claim that green-eyed people should be denied rights because a purple unicorn told them so, they’d be laughed out of the public discourse, but we still lend implicit legitimacy to arguments that people make because a bunch of really old books written by iron age desert nomads says so (according to some interpretations). It’s time these viewpoints should be laughed out of the public discourse, too.

  8. @9, you’re correct, of course, but you’re putting that forward as if it should settle the question, when in fact the problem runs much deeper: the (nominal) ideology of the Republican party outright rejects science as a method of knowing things, even while occasionally co-opting its trappings and language in an attempt to steal some apparent legitimacy.

    In the language of modern American politics – all politics, because over the last 30 years the far right has successfully pulled the middle far over into their side – whether something aligns with your “values” has far more weight than whether or not it’s scientific, ethical, useful, or realistic.

  9. @1 – I can believe she’s smart. And clearly crazy. But it’s the “out-of-touch” aspect that give her particular brand of smart-crazy the tint of “stupid”. Seriously, she read that statment and thought it would be fine because it attacks Obama? And then signed it. Oops. Stupid, smart-crazy fool.

  10. @ #4,
    White (AND Asian, Hispanic, Native, Other, etc) peeps are still taking care of the blk folk- who do you think is footing the lion’s share of the bill for all the disproportionately illegitimate children born in this community?…

  11. @14 O, hai! You must be our new troll. Pleased to have you. Gosh, it’s been so long since we had a racist. Usually we just get the homophobes. Well, anyway, you can have LovesChild’s old chair. Poor old dear; haven’t heard from her in months. Well, take care; you’ve got big shoes to fill…

  12. Black children under slavery were often born to two parents who were socially (not legally) married, but they very often weren’t raised all the way to adulthood by those two parents, since the odds of one or both of their parents being sold were quite high. Furthermore, plenty of black kids were born to mothers who’d been raped by, or been in nonmarital relationships with, their masters, overseers or other white men who lived nearby. And I can’t imagine that the normal processes of infidelity and relationship breakdown didn’t sometimes happen among slave couples. So unless they have reasonably reliable data to support the idea that black kids in 1860 were more likely to have two parents than black kids today, I am deeply skeptical of that claim’s accuracy.

    And of course, in any case the outrage is correct: having only one parent isn’t exactly a good thing, but it sure beats getting sold and sent away from everyone you know.

  13. @7 True dat… This past week I met a microbiologist for the Mayo Clinic who also happens to be a Young Earth Creationist. I’m not quite sure how that works.

  14. 2
    16

    That is all true.

    However, despite those horrible circumstances, a black child born into slavery in 1860 still had a better chance of being raised by both parents than a black American child born today.

    There are studies about it- google away.

    (do any of you girls even know what percentage of black American children currently are raised by both parents? The slave family is competing against a pretty low bar….)

  15. @ 15 stating a fact- albeit sarcastically, does not make anyone a troll or racist- but it does make you a hyper-sensitive, afro centrist… the term “Social prejudice” may be a better word for you than racist, cuz racist implies someone who thinks their race is superior (which I don’t). My statement (which can be backed up by Federal Gmnt data) has nothing to do with racial superiority.

  16. @19: A racist does not necessarily believe that his own race is superior; look at Hitler’s Aryan ideal, and then look at what Hitler actually looked like. A racist simply believes that some races are superior or inferior to others.
    And if your statement can be backed up by data from the Federal government, why don’t you back it up? There are no reputable studies that explicitly say “black people owe their survival to white people in today’s United States”. If you think you can find data that support your assertion, you need to show it; the burden of proof is on you.

  17. @18: Oh, there are studies on it. I happened to stumble across some nationwide data on that topic. In this report, it is listed that in 2009, 72.8% of children born to black women were born to parents who were not married, as opposed to 29.0% for children born to white mothers and 41.0% over the population as a whole. HOWEVER, this is still FAR lower than the rate in the antebellum era; nearly 100% of black children were born to unmarried parents, for the simple reason that enslaved blacks were not considered people, and as such were not allowed to marry.
    Put THAT in your pipe and smoke my pole.

  18. 21

    Those children weren’t born to parents who weren’t married, they were born to women who didn’t live with the men who fathered the children, men who would never parent those children.

    The statement in question says nothing about ‘marriage’:

    “Slavery had a disastrous impact on African-American families, yet sadly a child born into slavery in 1860 was more likely to be raised by his mother and father in a two-parent household than was an African-American baby born after the election of the USA’s first African-American President,” read the preamble.

    The study you cite bears that fact out.

  19. 21

    Your President agrees-

    “More than half of all black children live in single-parent households, a number that has doubled — DOUBLED — since we were children.”

    – Barack Obama’s 2008 Father’s Day address

  20. @22: Co ja kurwa czytam?
    I mean, what you just wrote makes no fucking sense. It’s not even internally consistent.
    @23: Yes, the percentage of black children living with a single parent has doubled since Obama was little. The overall percentage (for all races) has TRIPLED since then. Your point?

  21. Hey #20…

    NOBODY said “black people owe their survival to white people in today’s United States”- you did…

    Here are the statistics on welfare recipients:
    Traits of families on AFDC
    Race
    ————–
    White 38.8%
    Black 37.9 (yet they are only 12% of the population)
    Hispanic 17.2
    Asian 2.8
    Other 3.4

    Another way to look at this data is based on the total number of people who receive welfare:

    39% white 11,661,000 of 29,900,000 recipients

    38% black 11,362,000 of 29,900,000 (only 12% of population- yet they make up over 1/3 of welfare recipients)

    17% Hispanic 5,083,000 of 29,900,000

    http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/laws_…

    Also interesting: http://www.bus.lsu.edu/economics/papers/…

  22. @25: Yes, I specifically said that NOBODY said that in a paper. Are you thick in the head?
    Also, you’re talking about numbers of people on welfare. That says nothing about the amount of money given to people on welfare.
    No, I think you’ve had enough to drink already if you’re spouting such garbage.

  23. Dang #26 sorry if the truth hurts…
    Doesn’t matter how much $$$ is dispensed via welfare because Blck Peeps on Welfare are clearly disproportionately higher than all other ethnic minorities AND white people. 1 in 4 Black families are on welfare as compared with 1 in 10 for white families. That means that a quarter of black families are being supported by Whites, Hispanics, Asians, and Native Americans, etc… In addition, the average time a family spends on welfare is 1 year as opposed to 2 or more for blks. And the illegitimacy rate and single parent household rate continues to grow at a disproportionate rate for the blk community. And who do you think will be footing the bill for these children? It ain’t their baby-daddies.
    The truth will set you free Venomlash!
    Now I will have that drink… hic…

Comments are closed.