Mentioned in morning news but worth repeating: One year from today, insurance companies will begin offering women full coverage on all forms of birth control approved by the Federal Drug Administration—including birth control pills, IUDs, the morning after pill, and implantable hormonal contraceptives.

Seeing as how half of pregnancies in the US are reportedly unplanned, this is great news for all women, their partners, and their sex lives (i.e., nearly everybody).

So who’s first in line to oppose the new progressive mandate? The largest organization of proudly sexless men on the planet: “Pregnancy is not a disease and fertility is not a pathological condition to be suppressed by any means technically possible,” said the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops in a statement released today.

Meanwhile, a two-year trial study of a male birth control injection has been aborted (HAR HAR?) because of its high failure rate and other “serious side effects”:

One in ten men experienced side-effects including depression, weight gain, increased libido and acne. The older the trial person, the worse the symptoms were. These side-effects had not emerged in earlier national tests of the drug.

“It worked for 90 per cent of the men, but a 10-per-cent (failure), that is simply too much,” Zitzmann said.

Former Stranger news writer Cienna Madrid has been a writer in residence for Richard Hugo House, a local literary nonprofit. There, she taught fiction classes and wrote 4/5 of a book about a death-row...

37 replies on “Free Birth Control; Failed Birth Control”

  1. Those side effects for the mens’ contraception sound a lot like the side effects for the women’s contraception.

    But still, YAY for not having to pay $75 a month for my pill next year!

  2. Side effects of WOMEN’s contraception include: “weight gain, and other side effects such as irregular menstrual bleeding, amenorrhea, headache, nervousness, abdominal cramps, dizziness, weakness or fatigue, decreased sexual desire, leg cramps, nausea, vaginal discharge or irritation, breast swelling and tenderness, bloating, swelling of the hands or feet, backache, depression, insomnia, acne, pelvic pain, no hair growth or excessive hair loss, rash, hot flashes, and joint pain.” (from the Depo-Provera website)

    But yes, 10% failure rate is bad enough.

  3. For some reason I’m remembering a picture of horse-faced women from the 20’s under a sign that said “Lips that touch liquor will never touch ours”.

  4. But for some reason, women’s side effects from the pill including depression, loss of sex drive, blood clots, high blood pressure and yeast infections are OK.

  5. So many things that could be commented on in that male-contraception story.

    I’ll bet a startup pharmaceutical company funded and run by female entrepreneurs, as opposed to fucking Bayer, could bring a male contraceptive to market.

    Also, wasn’t acne a fairly common side effect of some female birth-control-pill formulations? That didn’t stop its use and improvement.

  6. Of course, should note: this only helps women with insurance.

    We’ll have to wait till 2014 — when everyone has equal access to insurance (assuming no GOP anti-ObamaCare shenanigans) — before this actually becomes effectively “universal” and can start to have an impact on the real rate of unwanted births.

  7. @6 – Pretty much all medications are going to have side effects. Nobody is saying “Yeah, whatever, they’re just women.” The important part of the story you’re looking at is the rate at which those side effects happen. Does anybody know the rate of side effects in women’s birth control? I don’t have the figures myself, and I’ve never been concerned with birth control, but I’d guess it’s probably lower than one in ten.

  8. The failure rate, I understand. What the hell do these men think women go through when they go on hormonal birth control? All that, in addition to increased risk of blood clots as we age.

  9. @12, it’s a really poorly written article, but I think what the German researchers are calling failure (or what the journalist is calling failure) is the 10% rate of side effects:

    One in ten men experienced side-effects including depression, weight gain, increased libido and acne…”It worked for 90 per cent of the men, but a 10-per-cent (failure), that is simply too much,” Zitzmann said.

    There’s no mention whatsoever of pregnancy rates or sperm counts in the study group.

  10. I agree with @13, it makes sense to nix the drug for now until the failure rate is lower. But yeah, women experience side effects from birth control too — and just from my own observations of friends on BC, I would bet the rate is far higher than 1 in 10. Wikipedia says that “the majority (about 60%) of women report no side effects at all”, which, to me, means that about 40% of women experience some side effect(s), usually minor (which is subjective).

    And @9 is right, this only helps women with insurance — and the right kind of insurance, as my high-deductible individual catastrophic plan covers absolutely nothing until I’ve already spent $5k of my own money.

  11. @14, wow, you’re right, that’s really…odd. I just read the article, also, and the injection works by seriously fucking up men’s testosterone levels, which can’t be healthy for extended periods of time (just as fucking with women’s estrogen/progesterone levels often isn’t).

    Ugh. Fertility awareness, spermicide, withdrawal, barrier methods. What is so effing wrong with all those that we need to poison ourselves? I don’t want to take away anyone’s choice, but it’s worrying to me that we seem to value and advocate hormonal methods over methods that have far less impact on the delicate system of the body.

  12. Also, I’ll maybe pay some fleeting notice to anything a Catholic priest has to say about sexual or reproductive ethics the day they all line up for Depo-Provera injections.

  13. @3, don’t assume you won’t pay. You, or your employer, will in the form of higher healthcare premiums. They can’t impose co-pays but insurance companies can raise their rates as needed to cover the costs. This is true of all of the other required coverages. Every one you add makes the rates go up.

  14. @18: Winzor!

    (For those who may not know why this is so fucking spit-take-worthy funny: Depo is given to some compulsive sex offenders to lower their drive.)

  15. There’s no reason men would take birth control even if it was 100% effective and had no side effects. They don’t get pregnant; they don’t care.

  16. This will save the insurance companies so much money. (I’m assuming birth control costs less than delivering a baby and then covering its health costs until it’s 18.)

    The bewildering thing is that it took a mandate to get them to do it.

  17. @25 Yes, to your first question. But not all women are so invested in preventing pregnancies, as is clear by the number of unintended pregnancies there are in the world, so I’m sure there’s plenty of guys that care more about preventing pregancies than some women. Obviously I’m sure the actual percentages swings strongly the other way, but #22’s absolutist tone just really irked me. And at least I do equate not caring at all if you get your partner pregant with being scum.

  18. @25 @22 – Do you have any idea how much more fuckable you will be if you can prove you are on it? Or how much less fuckable you’ll be if you don’t and others do? I’d say about 10,000 times in either direction.

  19. For all of you men bitching about how your condoms aren’t covered I’d like to point out Bob Dole’s Dick Pills have been for all the years our birth control hasn’t.

  20. @17 Those options may work for some women but not all. In my case I have an IUD with hormones even though my boyfriend has had a vasectomy. Why? Because one of the (in my mind positive) side effects which I do experience with it is complete cessation of menstruation. I would rather take the chances of side effects to the certainty of the effects I suffer from my periods (heavy bleeding, anemia, incapacitating cramps that aren’t helped by any over the counter medication and last for a minimum of three days, painful but not incapacitating cramps for the remainder of my period, etc.). What’s my point? Don’t assume you know the reasons women have chosen the form of birth control they have.

    Fertility awareness? Useless for me, my cycle has never once in my life been regular. Spermicide? It’s an irritant which I really don’t need shoved up my vagina to make sex less enjoyable, I always make sure condoms have no spermicide in the lube. Condoms? I use them when not in a fluid bonded relationship to reduce my chances of STIs but I’m paranoid and don’t think they are reliable enough for pregnancy prevention (and I NEVER want kids and would really prefer to never have to have an abortion). Withdrawal? See my answer on condoms. Personally I’d prefer to be sterilized but have you ever tried to convince a doctor to sterilize a healthy woman in her 20s who has no kids? Forget it.

  21. @22, 23, 25, 27, I’m a woman, and 23’s delivery irritated me me as well. She did kinda lump all men in together, and call them irresponsible, uncaring louts.

    However, there are a few men like that. And there are a few who might *tell* women they were using male birth control just to have sex without a condom (just as there are a few women who tell men they’re on the Pill when they’re not).

    I think a larger worry for women, though, is the idea that their male partners may not be as vigilant as they could be about birth control, because pregnancy does not have the immediate and total impact on men as it does on women. This may be less of an issue with a quarterly (yearly?) shot than with a daily pill.

  22. @30 Like you, I take hormones for bc and I appreciate the side effects (painless periods).

    But I wanted to correct the idea that you need regular periods in order to use FAM (fertility awareness methods. Whether your goal is to get pregnant or to avoid getting pregnant, FAM is not about reading a calendar. It’s about reading your body’s signals (cervical position, basal body temp. & cervical mucus), to learn when you are fertile.

  23. Another thing it covers is breast pumps for nursing mothers, given the health benefits of breast milk for babies; that’s a great thing too.

    Wonder if it covers tube tying?

    Also, how long until women’s BC becomes OTC, if they aren’t going to cover the other OTC methods of BC. And will diaphragms be covered? IIRC I needed a prescription for those.

    Side effects from women’s BC have to be fairly common. For me, hormonal BC induced huge mood swings; making them unusuable. They also completely shut down my libido, which probably made them even more effective, but not perhaps useful in a relationship :). It’s a very common side effect, which may not end after discontinuing the use of the contraceptive:

    http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases…

    I also do not know if I would have been counted. I simply stopped using it and switched to barrier methods, I never wrote the pharma company and told them why.

  24. I can’t believe this passed without a 6-month round-the-clock Fox-rant-fraught debate! Now I can stop being bitter about my insurance covering Viagra but not the only kind of health care I ever actually use!

  25. @33, thanks, that’s just what I was going to say. Certainly having a regular cycle makes FAM a little easier, but depending on the calendar is a terrible idea for anyone, regular or not.

    @30, I’m sincerely happy that the Mirena works so well for your needs, and like I said, I don’t want to take away anyone’s options, I just wish the society we lived in didn’t value the pill/patch/ring so much more highly over condoms, FAM, spermicide and the like. I was talking more about the tendency I see in my younger female cousins (I have ten of them, ranging in age from 14 to 25) to not think for themselves and just accept their doctor’s casual advice for what they should do for birth control, which is almost always “use the pill/patch/ring in case the condom breaks” without being really explicit about how those mess with your body. So then the girl gets on it, and suffers through side effects, thinking it’s normal and everyone has little things that bother them about BC (well, they do — or at least 40% of women do if the wiki stat can be trusted) and this is just a necessary inconvenience, when it’s not necessary at all.

    Some of the responsibility, sure, lies with the women who don’t fully inform themselves about other options, but especially as a teen, this is an intimidating topic and societal norms make a significant impression. I sure wish that when I was younger, my Planned Parenthood provider had not been so quick to just switch me to a different brand of hormone every time I complained about side effects on a brand of BC. It took me until I was 24 to figure out that the problem wasn’t the brand, it was using hormones at all, and even after years of using FAM and condoms successfully, they frown and glare disapprovingly, and try to talk me into using the pill/patch/nuvaring “for backup” when I answer the question of “what birth control are you using?”

  26. @37, in case you come back to read this — maybe your GYNs would be more supportive if you showed them your binder of charts and then pulled out some cervical fluid and discussed it like a pro.

    I can see how, otherwise, they might chalk up to “just luck” the fact that you haven’t gotten pregnant after “years of using FAM and condoms.” Especially if they don’t really understand FAM themselves.

Comments are closed.