She reportedly threatened to give gay kids conversion therapy:

An attorney for a graduate school counseling student told federal judges in Atlanta on Tuesday that the student’s First Amendment rights were violated when professors at a Georgia university sought to punish her for her biblical views on gay rights. Augusta State University put Jennifer Keeton on academic probation for saying it would be hard for her to work with gay clients, and threatened to expel her unless she attended events like Augusta’s gay pride parade…

University faculty were concerned that Keeton was scheduled to practice counseling in middle and high schools as part of her degree program and could possibly harm young students with her views, Correia said.

The poor dear. She probably feels like authority figures are trying to tell her what to believe, how to feel, and what’s morally right and wrong.

86 replies on “Bible Thumper Ordered to Attend Gay Pride”

  1. @38, Alas, she’s not in a clinical psych program. She’s in a school counseling program, which is a master’s degree and doesn’t require any damn biology classes. Much easier to get into, I’m sure–having gone through a school counseling graduate program. As it was a few years after my bachelor degree, it didn’t require a letter from a professor. The interview was with two professors and a current student, alongside two other applicants. Her letter of intentions could very easily have avoided any mention of gay kids. It would not have hard for her to slip in, without telling a single lie.

    As usual, Kim wins the thread.

  2. @41, you keep not responding, so I’ll keep trying. This is from last week:

    So, I wrote this in a thread from a couple weeks back, but you wandered off and never replied. So, here we go:

    Saying that being gay is a choice implies that being straight is a choice. So: did you choose to be straight? I seem to recall you saying that you did not, that your attraction to women is completely natural to you. So, why is it so difficult to believe that same-sex attraction is completely natural to other folks?

    Now, you may say that gay folks should just deny those attractions. That doesn’t seem very Christian. Why would God make folks gay, and then punish them by not letting them be happy? You seem very happy with your family, fulfilled with your marriage. Why deny that to gay folks? What do you get from that? How would it harm you? Oh, wait, you’ve already said it wouldn’t harm you or your marriage.

    Then you’ll claim that there’s some societal cost to this, that we won’t see for at least a generation. However, I can’t recall if you’ve ever been clear on what that damage would be, or would look like. Could you help me out here?

    The Declaration of Independence says that we have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. The 14th Amendment to the Constitution says that citizens must be treated equally under the law. Why do you hate America?

  3. A similar situation arose at Eastern Michigan University (Ypsilanti, MI) in 2009. That case is currently making its way through the legal system after the student sued EMU. She lost on her first attempt, and appealed to the Sixth District Court of Appeals.

    A multitude of articles exist, but here’s some basic ones..

    http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?…
    http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?…
    http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/…

  4. Fuck her. Her belief that homosexuality is wrong is rooted in her religious beliefs, so she would in effect be pushing them upon the kids she counseled if she was suggesting conversion therapy. She can no more do that than she can suggest they convert to Christianity. Now if she was going to be a pastor… But no credible institution would turn a graduate out into the world with degree in hand if she was going to up the odds of her clients committing suicide.

  5. @46

    Whatever you’re smoking at the moment is almost certainly illegal.

    I’m very thankful that I understand almost nothing you wrote. Potty training is something I did with my kids and in the long ago days in which I was a toddler. Oddly, as a toddler I didn’t have any kind of mistress, never mind whatever a BDSM one might be. As for the, umm… cultural… references they all escape me.

    But please- for the love of God- don’t enlighten me. Some things I’m much happier not knowing.

    @56

    Inclinations may not be choice driven. Behavior always is. I didn’t choose to be vaguely repelled by gambling and casinos (noisy, never any natural light, too many people) narcotics of any kind, being drunk and so on. It doesn’t mean acting on these impulses is good for the actor, or that they’re any less a vice or a potential addiction because I’m not personally prone to them.

    The concept of original sin is pretty universal in Christian churches. The fact that we’re subject to unhealthy desires doesn’t excuse our acting on them, nor does it indict the deity ipso facto. Cancer happens naturally, but if I contracted it I’d fight it anyway.

    I don’t personally punish anyone. Not my call. But society has a right to protect its’ key structures, like law and family, against minority attacks upon them. This is discrimination. It is anyway if you use that term in its classical sense. That is, it is judgement based on experience and history of a circumstance and acting accordingly.

    The Declaration of Independence and Constitution are not blanket grants of autonomy. We still owe accountability for our choices to those in our social circle, and to the larger polity. Want to sleep with other men or women? Okay, not my business. Want to make others give 3 rousing cheers and a lot of legal protection to that choice. Now that’s the business of others.

  6. SB, wow, you hit the trifecta there. You’ve compared homosexuality to cancer, called it a vice, and labeled it a sin. I think there was also an ‘unhealthy desire’ and ‘potential addiction’.

    Now, where is your evidence that homosexual behavior is any of these things? There must be some concrete evidence, if you’re going to deprive folks of their civil liberties. The state must have at least a rational basis for doing so, or a compelling interest. Can you show anything of this nature?

    The 14th Amendment is very clear about equal protection under the law. It most certainly is a grant of autonomy.

    I notice you did not address my questions regarding why it’s all right to deny some adults the chance at happiness and fulfillment that you and your wife enjoy. I didn’t indict any deity. You seem to agree that homosexuality is natural to some people; does it not follow that God made them so? If so, then why do you get to deny them that happiness and fulfillment of marriage that I keep coming around to? Remember, you have to prove homosexuality is ‘unhealthy’ before you can use that as an argument.

  7. Fuck them. Their belief that homosexuality is acceptable is rooted in their religious beliefs, so they are in effect pushing them upon the graduate students in the program. They can no more do that than they can suggest she convert to faggotry.

  8. @clashfan

    No.

    I noted that not all things which seem to be biologically natural are also desirable. Not all urges we may feel are those which we should indulge. Which is why I mention vice. Not all things that occur naturally should be celebrated, which is why I mention cancer. This is different from equating homosexuality with vice or disease.

    I have no right whatever to deny an adult the right to practice whatever consensual sex they wish based on my values, religious or otherwise. Conversely, the strident gay special citizen status groups have no right to force a view of homosexuality as inherently benevolent and desirable on others in public policy. At best they can say (and have done so with appropriate success in legal challenges) that private sexual practices between consenting adults aren’t the business of the state. To go from there to an assertion that gay men or lesbians should be able to redefine social terms for their choice driven minority convenience is what I object to.

    No violation of due process or equal protection has happened to the LGBTPQRSTUVWXYZ and whatever other splinter designations they’ve come up with community. Dan Savage can marry any woman willing to marry him. So can I. Cienna Madrid can marry any man with the dubious taste to wish it, so could my wife. Perfect equality under the law. QED.

  9. @65: I keep asking these questions and you keep avoiding them.
    If only same-sex marriage was allowed, would marriage equality be present?
    What if same-sex and opposite-sex marriage were both allowed? How about then?

  10. @65 You keep citing biology, but marriage isn’t an issue of biology. It’s a social construct. You do recognize the difference, don’t you? Once you understand that there’s a difference maybe you’ll admit that even your poor understanding of biology isn’t a basis for denying marriage rights. For most people marriage is about love. That may not be true of your marriage, but some people marry because they genuinely care about each other and want to share their lives. I know you don’t have a glib comeback for that so you’ll ignore it, but it doesn’t change the fact that your argument isn’t based on anything but your religious beliefs. And in spite of claiming that “I have no right whatever to deny an adult the right to practice whatever consensual sex they wish based on my values, religious or otherwise” you’ve proven that’s exactly what you believe.

    Besides, you’ve already admitted elsewhere that Dan and Terry are married. So either you were wrong then or you’re wrong now. I would say pick one, but I know your beliefs change to fit the argument.

  11. Eveybody is picking on my friend, Seattleblues, and I think it’s just that they don’t understand him the way I do. Let me see if I can explain just one of his points!

    When he wrote “I don’t expect them (the homosexuals) to mold their behavior by my choices, but I object to being asked to mold mine by theirs either,” this is kind a what he means.

    Back when I was a boy in the South, everybody knew how they was supposed to behave, and if somebody wasn’t following the rules, it was okay to let em know. Didn’t take much. You just had to kind of be a little bit rude to em. Now I know that being rude is bad. Practically a sin. But some times, like when people wasn’t following the rules that made things better for everbody, a little rudeness could go a long way.

    So if, for example, a white man was running around with a negress, or a nice Baptist lady started seeing some jew boy, or two men started acting like they had some kind of unnatural attraction, well, you could snub them a few times at church, or not talk to them at the store, or pretend like you didn’t see them on the street, and usually, more often than not, they got the message. They either straightened up, or they moved some place like New York where that kind of behavior wasn’t that abnormal, and the situation usually didn’t call for any more than that. Everybody knew the rules, and they played by them, and life went by smoothly for everybody and it was good.

    These days, though, people aren’t following the rules, and I can’t take my grandchildren to Wal-Mart without seeing all kinds of miseginated babies. Or I go to Lowes and see two men agruing about whether to put natural stone or ceramic tiles in their bathroom. And there are two lesbian couples living in the mobile home park where I rent spaces now. And there are so many jews in town that they don’t drive to Jackson for services any more, but they’re talking about building a church here, and they’ve married into all kinds of good families. And if I try to keep to the old rules and try to get them in line by snubbing them at church or not talking to them in the store, and I’m doing all of this for their own good, just to let them know where the boundaries are. But all of a sudden, I’m the bad guy! So it’s like Seattle Blues says: I have to change my behavior for the sake of theirs, and it’s just not right, I tell you, because all I’m trying to do is keep things normal.

  12. @68, that was brilliant, thank you.

    @69,

    @65: OK, now we’re getting closer. You say: “Not all urges we may feel are those which we should indulge.” I infer from this that you believe people should not have sex with people of the same sex as themselves. Why do you believe that? I mean, if you’re not equating homosexuality with vice or disease, then what *is* the problem?

    I don’t think of myself as a ‘gay special citizen’. But I am a citizen, and I currently don’t enjoy the same rights as you do–the right to legally marry the person I love. Forty years ago, some states had laws prohibiting interracial marriage. You had the right to marry any white person you wanted–just like any other white person. You fell in love with a woman of a different ethnicity from yourself. In Virgina, pre-Loving, you’d not have been able to marry her. How would that make you feel? Luckily for you and your wife, others fought to “redefine social terms for (your) choice driven minority convenience”.

    Homosexuality is not inherently benevolent; it is neutral, just as is heterosexuality.

    Once again, you have not addressed my arguments about what rational basis or compelling interest the state has in denying me the fundamental human right to marry. You have not attempted to answer my question about why you want to deny those rights–that happiness and fulfillment that you enjoy in your marriage–to people whom God has created gay.

    Nor have you attempted to define just what societal ill will befall the culture is we allow a few more of its people to get married.

  13. @66

    I’ve answered them before, but if you wish…

    If you think you can garner the popular will to pass same sex marriage as legally normative, go for it. I won’t be holding my breath, however.

    But in a hypothetical (and infeasible) world where 97% of adults were gay and 3% heterosexual I suppose your standard would apply. In that case gay marriages would be the norm and heterosexuals those asking that their choices entitle them to alter the structure for their convenience. Your point?

  14. Your satire is at least a welcome change from blind hatred of anyone who dares to hold slightly different ideas.

    You’re wrong of course, but that goes without saying.

    My marriage to my differently skin colored wife wouldn’t have been possible 40 years ago in many states. We still fit the basic definition of marriage, a man and woman coming together in a romantic partnership for life, with the likelihood of child rearing. Loving recognized this injustice and rectified it. A court case that averred that gay ‘marriage’ was a marriage would be fundamentally altering the definition of the term, not recognizing the exclusion of those who otherwise would fit the definition.

    No thanks necessary. It’s one of my daily acts of kindness.

  15. “blind hatred of anyone who dares to hold slightly different ideas.”

    Because anyone who thinks you’re an asshole does so blindly.

    “with the likelihood of child rearing”

    Infertile or choosing-to-not-have-kids heterosexuals and homosexuals who adopt, you ceaseless dullwit.

  16. “fundamentally altering the definition of the term”

    Reality fundamentally alters the definition of the term as marriage is currently practiced. Your particular definition means nothing to the State.

  17. @76 and 77

    In construction contracts there’s usually a governing assumption as to how work will be done. It’s called ‘standard practices and procedueres.’ For instance, walls are generally framed at 16″ OC. If a client wishes them framed at less or more, he or she must explicitly say so, or the framing will be done as it usually would be on any other job.

    I know that some people marry late in life, with the intent never to have kids, or find themselves unable to have children. This in in way alters fundamenal assumptions about the role of child-bearing and rearing in marriage.

    Marriage has meant what it means for millenia, in basic form. Sometimes multiple spouses are part of the culture. Opposite sex spouses. Sometimes the element of romance is secondary, as with arranged marriages, but still with opposite sex spouses.

    What Canada chooses to call a marriage, or the State of New York for that matter, is not. It fails the very basic assumption of opposite sex unions. Child rearing or not, this never has altered.

    Or is that too difficult for you to understand, that the exceptions don’t prove the rule?

    But you’re exactly right. My personal definition of marraige carries no weight with the state. Nor does yours, or Dan Savages. The collective opinion of generations of the majority of the culture though? Yeah, that might carry some weight.

  18. SeattleBlues, this ‘definition of marriage’ is extremely provinicial, in both place and era. Different cultures throughout history have had different marriage customs. We have never insisted that married couples rear children; as Zombie Dagny says, many straight couples are infertile or choose not to have children. Also, many couples marry late in life with no expectation of children. Are their marriages invalid?

    I’m just going to cut and paste this, since it still applies, as you’ve not attempted to address any of these points:

    Once again, you have not addressed my arguments about what rational basis or compelling interest the state has in denying me the fundamental human right to marry. You have not attempted to answer my question about why you want to deny those rights–that happiness and fulfillment that you enjoy in your marriage–to people whom God has created gay.

    Nor have you attempted to define just what societal ill will befall the culture is we allow a few more of its people to get married.

  19. @78: ” fundamenal assumptions about the role of child-bearing and rearing in marriage.”

    Your fundamental assumptions. Which is not what we’re discussing. Your religious views have fuckall to do with the State.

  20. @74: I said nothing about the relative proportions of gay and straight people. If, in today’s world of ~95% heterosexuality, only same-sex marriages were allowed, would that be just?
    (Let me tell you why the proportions of gays and straights do not matter for the purposes of this thought experiment. If you were the only man, and your wife the only woman, who wanted to marry someone of a different race, would it be just to keep you from each other simply due to lack of popular demand?)
    @75: What makes you so sure that “the basic definition of marriage” is “a man and woman coming together in a romantic partnership for life, with the likelihood of child rearing”? What gives you the right to define it for everyone else?
    Marriage, for many in society, has historically and widely had little to do with romance, and been purely a political alliance. Marriage has never, to the best of my knowledge, been withheld from a sterile couple whether or not they intend to adopt. Marriage, in certain parts of the world, does not require that the two spouses be of opposite genders.
    You claim that gays want to redefine marriage for everyone, but you seem to be the one intent on imposing your own definition on others. If Dan and Terry get legally hitched in the USA, or if my cousin and her partner do the same, it does not affect you one whit. If you are allowed to define marriage how you see fit, millions of your fellow citizens are affected.

  21. @78 “My personal definition of marraige carries no weight with the state. Nor does yours, or Dan Savages. The collective opinion of generations of the majority of the culture though? Yeah, that might carry some weight.”

    In other words you’re admitting that you’re against same-sex marriage because of the religious belief held by a large number of people over a long period of time is that it’s wrong. I know you’re trying to pretend it’s something else but it really comes down to you wanting to impose your religious beliefs on others. You’re admitting that logic doesn’t carry any weight for you, and neither do facts.

    I really thought you’d given up making this argument because you’ve had your ass handed to you so many times, and, really, I think it’s like every other argument you make. It’s not what you really believe. I don’t think you really care of people of the same sex get married. I think you just bring it up because you enjoy stirring people up. Be my guest. Nobody’s going to infringe on your right to sound stupid. I just hope you remember how childish your own behavior is when you accuse others of being immature.

  22. “I really thought you’d given up making this argument because you’ve had your ass handed to you so many times”

    He’s got nothing else.

  23. @78–you wrote: “In construction contracts there’s usually a governing assumption as to how work will be done. It’s called ‘standard practices and procedueres.’ For instance, walls are generally framed at 16” OC. If a client wishes them framed at less or more, he or she must explicitly say so, or the framing will be done as it usually would be on any other job.

    This analogy is so inexact that I’m not even sure it’s relevant. Presumably it is an attempt to justify heterosexual marriage (and only heterosexual marriage) when there in no desire or possibility for children. At least that’s the argument it *seems* intended to address. But I don’t see the application.

    My brother divorced when his children were young. While single, he got a vasectomy. When he remarried in his middle forties, he clearly knew that he wasn’t going to have any more children. Additionally, his second wife–approximately his age–had a grown son from her first marriage, and didn’t want any more children. I’ve never asked about the state of her reproductive organs, because since my brother is obviously and involuntarily infertile as an individual, they are, for all practical purposes, infertile as a couple.

    If the purpose of marriage is to provide a stable family framework for children (the point you seem to want to make in this thread), presumably my brother and his wife are the walls that are to be framed at something other than 16″ OC.

    But here is where your analogy makes no sense: you state, “If a client wishes them framed at less or more, he or she must explicitly say so, or the framing will be done as it usually would be on any other job.” My guess is that this is a (somewhat tortured) reference to the marriage license, which would be the relevant contract signed before the family “framework” was put in place. But my brother and his wife did not have to have any special clauses put into the lisence explicitly stating that they had neither the desire nor the ability to have children. They just went down to City Hall and got the lisence along with all the other (presumably–but not necessarily) fertile couples that day. Nobody asked any questions about the state of their reproductive organs, and do you know why? BECAUSE IT IS NONE OF THE GOVERNMENT’S BUSINESS WHETHER PEOPLE GETTING MARRIED ARE GOIGN TO HAVE CHILDREN OR NOT! Even the wedding services typically performed in Christian church weddings ask the couple to vow to stay together for better or worse (etc. etc.) without *once* making a single reference to children.

    So how does your analogy make sense here? And how does it provide a rationale for denying marriage to same sex couples? If neither the government nor the church requires proof of ability or desire to have children before allowing a marriage to take place, and if neither requires an explicit statement of reproductive intent (or a specific statement denying reproductive intent) before the wedding takes place, how is it that having children is the defining feature of marriage?

    And if it’s not, then how is allowing same sex marriage a fundamental change in the institution?

  24. So the whole point of this was to encourage freedom, yet they were going to force her to go somewhere with people who believe the opposite of her as a repercussion…They’re cool *sarcasm* -_-
    SN: I do agree someone so biased shouldn’t really have that position but forcing them to do something to keep it is not a good look

  25. @86: “forcing them to do something to keep it is not a good look”

    Oh no, she must be around the people she is legally required to understand for her licensing! What hell is this!

    You’re a shitty “supporter” if you believe that she should be given an exemptions to the requirement to provide fair and equal treatment to all she counsels.

    If she wants to be licensed to treat others, she must follow the code of conduct.

  26. she has every right to become a counselor with those beliefs. through a private school where bigotry isn’t supported with public money.

  27. @88, she has a right to whatever beliefs she wants. What she can’t do, according to her desired profession’s code of conduct, is treat gay clients/students as if their sexuality is morally wrong and must be changed.

  28. @88: “she has every right to become a counselor with those beliefs”

    Unless being a “counselor” requires licensing, that is.

Comments are closed.