*This post has been updated with a Feminist Killjoy GIF, courtesy of Alithea. Simply click on ALL HAIL… for viewing pleasure.

During last night’s Very Beary Slog Happy hosted by the adorable bears of Diesel—which featured the perfect combination of strong drinks, Swedish meatballs, hairy bears, cock shots, and gift-wrapped bed pans—it was brought to my attention that I’ve been slacking in my duties as Slog’s resident Feminist Killjoy™.

So Alithea, queen of Feminist Killjoys, this one’s for you:

When the Afghan government said Thursday that it would pardon a woman who had been imprisoned after she reported that she had been raped by a relative, the decision seemed a victory.

But when the announcement made it clear that the woman was expected to marry the man who raped her, the moment instead revealed the ways in which efforts guided by the best intentions to redress violence against women in Afghanistan run up against the limits of change.

The pardon holds grave risks for the woman, since the man could be so humiliated that he might decide to kill her, despite the risk of prosecution.

I have nothing to add except, ALL HAIL THE FEMINIST KILLJOY!

Former Stranger news writer Cienna Madrid has been a writer in residence for Richard Hugo House, a local literary nonprofit. There, she taught fiction classes and wrote 4/5 of a book about a death-row...

39 replies on “Afghan Rape Victim Jailed, Ordered to Marry Rapist”

  1. when I first ran across this story I was like “Oh good for her!” then read that she had to marry her rapist and then was “Oh. Sad panda.”

  2. I hope Diesel is compensating you well for all those promotional posts. I wonder about those who continue to defend Islam as a religion of peace when we are constantly reminded of how terribly they treat women and minorities.

  3. @3, who are you calling “they”?

    Good thing we spend all those trillions of dollars winning the war on terror. Huh. The fact is, Afghanistan kicked our ass in the military department.

  4. @3, who are you calling “they”?

    Good thing we spend all those trillions of dollars winning the war on terror. Huh. The fact is, Afghanistan kicked our ass in the military department, with nothing but will.

  5. @3 let’s be clear – it is not islam that is responsible for this horrible situation, it is fucked up and culturally backwards people that are responsible.

  6. @8, look, I’d like to point out there is a pretty clear link between stranger staffers talking about diesel which is funded covertly by islamacist terrorist dollars and then coverted to news coverage on a blog which uses comments to power HAARP which uses heat beams to activate fluoride in the water which weakens our minds to allow up to believe in communisim and sharia law in america.

  7. Now that the topic has been broached, Will having an awesome person tag means I don’t really want mine any more. Can I get my old “Strangercrombie Donor 2010” tag back, please please? It has vintage appeal, hearking back as it does to times when it was not so hard to get businesses to donate.

  8. Add me to the list of Feminist Killjoys wishing to advertise as such via Slog tag and t-shirt.
    Also last night was a blast. Especially the hand made artisanal cock cookies.

  9. paulus, initially i did not think my gif would be appropriate for this particular post due to its sensitive nature and the fact that nobody has said anything really, really dumb. except 3. SO THIS ONE IS FOR YOU, COMMENTER #3: cool thoughts on race, dude! http://i.imgur.com/qrmT4.gif

    also YES i am 100% for a FEMINIST KILLJOY tag.

  10. @25, I have embedded your killjoy spirit into the post. ALL HAIL!!!!

    Re: FEMINIST KILLJOY tag–certain someones tell me that would be an impossible amount of work for our already overworked tech monkeys. A t-shirt might be doable, though…

  11. @4 you mean Pakistan.

    We have consistently been attacked by Pakistani-created and Pakistani-financed forces, not Afghani.

    Which you would know if you had relatives actively serving in Afghanistan or six of your former colleagues and people you trained died there.

  12. @26, wouldn’t it be cool if we could buy t-shirts and have the funds donated to a feminist-friendly cause like Planned Parenthood, or maybe an international charity that provides aid to Muslim women? I’d totally be down with that, and wear it with pride.

  13. Well, duh, I see that Planned Parenthood has been mentioned a million times already. But I am kinda leaning toward an international charity, after re-reading the linked article. God that’s fucked.

  14. @4and 5, I guess I meant the Afghan Muslims specifically and religious governments generally @6 Do you actually believe that Afghanistan’s fucked up and culturally backward culture exists independently from Islam ? Would you believe that any dominant religion is a major component in a culture, and those religious ideas might have a hand in laws and customs that would excuse rapists and punish the raped woman in this case. That’s all I’m trying to address. And Cienna, It wasn’t any kind of accusation, I was just jealous that my small business doesn’t get regular mention in your slog posts and articles. I guess you just really love that amazing awesome gaybear bar. No conspiracy theories here. I just see religions that oppress women and minorities as a bad thing.

  15. @2: BULLSHIT.
    The Biblical rule is that if two people have sex out of wedlock (whether consensual or not), the man is obligated to marry the woman. If her father does not wish for this to happen, he can refuse to give his daughter away and the man must pay the bride-price to the woman and her family anyway.
    If, however, the woman is engaged to be married, the man is to be put to death. The woman is to be put to death as well ONLY if it is known that she was complicit* in the act; otherwise she is guilty of nothing.
    You may also be thinking of the punishment for falsely claiming to have been a virgin when wed, which is stoning. (The punishment for making a false accusation is a hefty fine and the loss of any right to a divorce.)
    There are legitimate arguments to be made against certain Biblical rules, but you don’t help your position much by claiming untrue things.

    *The literal wording is that if she was taken in the city, she is to be killed for she did not cry out against the attack, but if she was taken in the countryside, she is innocent because even though she cried out there was nobody there to hear her.

    @33: Go bowb yourself, you ignorant swine.

  16. @25

    OK, if we’re being all gender-issues-aware and stuff, then why use a hand motion signifying male masturbation — a normal, healthy sexual behavior — when miming the role of a “killjoy?”

    Aren’t you perpetuating sex-negative stereotypes when you do that?

  17. @35 there are two things at hand here (no pun intended).

    1: the gif is is meant to be a flippant mockery of the self-masturbatory behavior of those who often argue by being purposefully obtuse or willfully contrary. see: the majority of slog commenters.

    2: the term feminist killjoy is not directly related to the act of masturbation, but rather, it is coined for the perspective of constantly reminding others about the feminist perspective of the modern world (including issues of race, gender inequality, class inequality, etc., all feminist issues) in a way that often deflates an otherwise “fun” conversation.

  18. This is nothing.

    During my first tour in Afghanistan, we were on patrol in some backwoods – even for Afghanistan – corner of Kunar Province. We came across a village – half a dozen mud buildings serviced by two ruts in the road.

    I was with the PL and our terp when he went to go talk to the village elder and ask about any possible Taliban activity in the area.

    We sat down across from him and the terp started asking quuestions. I noticed a small boy behind the elder – no more than 6 or 7 – nearly naked, and mute silent. He just stood there with one hand on the sleeve of the old man.

    As we were continuing our patrol, I asked the terp who the boy was. He told me that the boy was the elder’s pleasure boy, who serviced the elder sexually, and that the boy had been given to the elder by his parents freely – evidently believing it was some kind of honor. And that this was common in Pashtu culture, particularly in the more rural areas (which is most areas). When I went back for my second and third deployment, I found the same scene repeated over and over.

    My point? There is nothing redeeming about these people or this culture.

  19. So the bible and the Qu’ran both say that raped women must marry their attackers.

    Ask me again what harm religion does. Ask me again why I “attack people’s deeply held beliefs.”

  20. @36

    1. The term “self-masturbatory” is perhaps a wee bit redundant, no? No pun intended. More importantly, why are you equating the pejorative “purposefully obtuse or willfully contrary” with male masturbation, which is, again, a normal, healthy sexual behavior?

    2. If the term “feminist killjoy” has no relation to male masturbation, then why invoke that particular sexual behavior in the visual iconography you deploy to disrupt typical, tedious patriarchal discourse?

Comments are closed.