The same-sex marriage debate at Town Hall on January 18 is canceled.
Sorry to all the folks who had free tickets (in hindsight, they were overpriced).
So what happened? Even though we’ve got stacks of anti-gay-marriage leaders in the state, not a single one of them was willing to defend their position at Town Hall in a fair debate moderated by Dave Ross. As we mentioned on Monday, Pastor Ken Hutcherson and Stephen Pidgeon canceled, even though they had confirmed the week before. But we didn’t call it off at the time. We scoured the state for replacements.
On Monday Pastor Joe Fuiten at the Cedar Park Assembly of God and Joseph Backholm, the director of the Family Policy Institute of Washington, agreed to take part in the debate. “Joseph Backholm has said he will do it with me,” Fuiten wrote in an email on Monday evening after seeing all the debate format details. He was even working on confirming attorney Austin Nimocks as a backup. “It will either be the two Joes or the other Joe and Austin,” Fuiten added. But then he canceled the next day, saying they got “cold feet.” Mars Hill Church Pastor Tim Gaydos also agreed to debate against gay marriage, with his assistant Steven Kwan writing in an email, “Pastor Tim is in! January 18th would be the best date.” Gaydos backed out of the January 18th debate two days later, citing unspecified “personal” reasons.
Plenty of other people—people who have repeatedly gone on the record opposing marriage equality—also refused to argue against same sex-marriage at Town Hall. Other folks who refused include: Mars Hill Church Pastor Mark Drisoll, State Senator Val Stevens; State Senator Dan Swecker; the entire state GOP legislative caucus, according to a spokeswoman; conservative radio host Michael Medved; SPU political science professor Reed Davis; and City Church Pastor Judah Smith. We even put in a request to anti-gay-marriage attorney general Rob McKenna, but we never heard back.
These are the same people who evangelize against gay marriage in front of their congregations, espouse anti-gay positions in editorial board meetings, record anti-gay videos, take votes against gay rights in the legislature, go on their radio shows to denounce marriage equality, and help run anti-gay campaigns.
Tickets to the event were promoted action alerts sent out by Hutcherson’s Antioch Bible Church, so the audience wasn’t going to be hostile or unfairly stacked against the anti-marriage-equality side. The debate was to be moderated by fairsy-squaresy Dave Ross. It was going to be recorded and replayed on the Seattle Channel and live-streamed so it could reach the largest possible audience. Sure, you could claim that The Stranger is biased—we are—but we worked closely with Ken Hutcherson to make sure it was a fair debate. But they don’t seem interested in fairness. They prefer to churn out lies in venues where they can’t be challenged on their facts or their logic.
In the end, they refused to come to the table. And if you’re going to fight to deny equal rights, the least you can do it stand up in a room of mixed company and explain yourself. But they won’t do it.

There is only one debate that will matter, and we all know it. Whatever the venue costs, whatever the tickets cost.
Pay-per-view it, whatever. You just have to wait till he’s free that is…
The 2012 Marriage Equality Debate
Savage Vs. Santorum.
…for the love of Jesse, somebody make this happen.
It would be great if the next mention of Ken Hutcherson in The Stranger is in a post about HIM contacting YOU because he misses the attention. Wait long enough, and it’ll happen.
Also, a style suggestion: Rather than (for example) “City Church Pastor Judah Smith,” can it be “Judah Smith, pastor at City Church?” Giving clergy capitalized titles seems unwarranted; let them do that for themselves if they want.
Why not ask SLOG’s own Seattleblues to debate? At the very least, he’d get to meet his man-crush Dan Savage in person.
53
oh no, never….
Danny wouldn’t be able to delete comments he finds awkward and impossible to answer….
DUDE!
Purocuyu @ 51 has an abso-fucking-lutely brilliant idea!
A Savage vs. Santorum debate on contraception and marriage equality as a pay-per-view event would rake in bucks. Mr. Santorum might accept because he could use the money to pay campaign expenses. It would provide his supporters with an unregulated method to support his campaign, like book sales for Gingrich, Obama, and Cain. I don’t imagine that Mr. Savage would object to some national exposure and windfall income.
I think the area of discussion would have to be expanded beyond marriage equality to contraception, anti-sodomy laws, and all manner of reproductive rights. It would really center around the government’s authority to regulate citizen’s intimate behavior. That way it would include the broader scope of interests – both Mr. Santorum’s and Mr. Savage’s.
….trolls for thee…..
The other team stayed home? FORFEIT.
Why would anyone want to be associated with Savage after the “Frothy” google bombing of Rick Santorum?
WEAK WEAK WEAK LAME LAME LAME.
Buncha weenies.
@44 It would be one thing if this post was finger-pointing at people who were asked to participate but declined. However, the anti-gays mentioned all agreed to participate and then reneged for whatever lame reason. They deserve to be singled out as the cowards, liars and hypocrites they clearly are.
Let’s be real. Why would Hutcherson, or anyone of his ilk, agree to a debate sponsored by the Stranger, on their their turf, with a liberal moderator? In Hutcherson’s case the answer is of course his apparently limitless exhibitionism (which — as 52 points out — the Stranger feeds on a continuing basis), but apparently even that does have a limit and it has been reached. 58 does have a point as well. From the anti-gay position, engaging with Savage dignifies his Santorum google antics (which many progressives also find distasteful) in an unacceptable fashion.
Don’t get me wrong. I was looking forward to the show! Sounded like a hoot and a half. I’m disappointed it won’t happen — but not surprised. I second 14’s motion.
Let’s be real. Why would Hutcherson, or anyone of his ilk, agree to a debate sponsored by the Stranger, on their their turf, with a liberal moderator? In Hutcherson’s case the answer is of course his apparently limitless exhibitionism (which — as 52 points out — the Stranger feeds on a continuing basis), but apparently even that does have a limit and it has been reached. 58 does have a point as well. From the anti-gay position, engaging with Savage dignifies his Santorum google antics (which many progressives also find distasteful) in an unacceptable fashion.
Don’t get me wrong. I was looking forward to the show! Sounded like a hoot and a half. I’m disappointed it won’t happen — but not surprised. I second 14’s motion.
Isn’t the rule that if you back out and refuse to play the game you forfeit the game?
I’ve been thinking about this all day, since seeing it yesterday.
Someone recently suggested here on SLOG that many of these “advocates” for “traditional values” are cynical exploiters of their flocks, using the issue to raise money and for little else. That they don’t give a damn about the issue other than to use it for self-aggrandizement.
This proves it.
They have a good deal, a money-making machine in their big fish/fetid pond scenario. They know that the underlying issue, their position on marriage (in)equality is not defensible, though. It can be easily shredded on legal, moral or religious grounds. They can’t allow that.
As long as they don’t show up, they can keep selling their fear and hatred to the rubes, and keep filling their coffers. If they show up and get publicly embarrassed, it’s game over.
Fred Phelps?
You win by default. They are cowards who know they are wrong.