THERE’S A CERTAIN amount of conceptual invincibility that comes with doing a show like Scott Bradley and Ian Bell’s Return to the Garden of Allah. Based on An Evening at the Garden of Allah — a book collecting oral histories about one of the nation’s first gay-owned cabarets that operated on First Avenue from 1946 to 1956 — Bradley and Bell’s Allah plays to every friendly prejudice of the Seattle theatergoer: It is local history on a neglected and worthy subject; it reinforces the notion of theater as a powerful act of community self-expression; and it’s about the act of performance rather than its effect.

Bradley (who also directed) and Bell mix live performance and backstage drama, with the dance space at Re-bar serving as a rough equivalent of the nightclub, right down to a few characters joining the audience as patrons. The musical numbers carry the evening. There is a great deal of pleasure to be derived from watching accomplished performers work their way through double-entendre-fests like Will Lutey on “Hot Nuts,” or unadorned slow numbers like Karen Gruber’s “Come Rain or Come Shine.” And the girl-group bounce of “Pistol Packin’ Mama,” featuring the show’s primary drag performers Andrew Tasakos, Wade Madsen, and Benjimen Blair seamlessly backing up Jennifer Jasper’s Nick Arthur, is alone worth a ticket.

Maintaining the backstage drama proves infinitely more difficult, as 10 years of personal history and multiple, complicated social interactions are compressed into just two nights at the Garden of Allah. Gruber’s Wanda Brown, for instance, has a fascinating marriage and parenting dynamic that is talked about but never shown. Even dramatic high points are explained rather than revealed: Several stock scenes of police payoffs defer, rather than build, to an explanation that the musicians will ask for money based on the club’s books rather than the actual money coming in. Instead of revealing the layers upon layers of human experiences that lead to the stage show, the backstage drama seems like another evocation of period performance. It keeps a highly entertaining show from being a great one.