As the Seattle City Council stands poised to pass next year’s $9.1 billion (mostly) balanced budget, one clear loser has emerged: affordable housing.
While Mayor Katie Wilson and the city council managed to close a $175 million deficit without sweeping cuts, it came at the expense of new affordable housing development funded by the city’s JumpStart payroll tax.
It’s not a good time to cut back on affordable housing. The housing crisis isn’t getting any better. And many nonprofit developers are contemplating selling off buildings to make ends meet.
The biennial 2027-2028 budget freezes JumpStart investments in Seattle’s Office of Housing, which distributes money to nonprofit affordable housing developers, at about $140 million a year. With construction and maintenance costs constantly rising, that’s an effective cut.
Money for the Equitable Development Initiative (EDI), a program that helps nonprofits serving communities of color and other groups affected by displacement build affordable housing, has also been frozen at $22 million annually. Collectively, that means only 36 percent of JumpStart revenue will go to affordable housing. The rest is being used to balance the budget.
JumpStart As Seattle’s Piggy Bank
As Seattle’s flagship tax on wealthy corporations, JumpStart funding and its uses have always been politically contentious. When it was passed in 2020, the city council designated that 71 percent revenues would go to new investments in affordable housing. But in practice, the city’s never met that goal, with much of the tax revenues being used to fend off austerity.
Over time, the diversion of JumpStart money from affordable housing has gotten bigger and bigger. Mayor Bruce Harrell cut JumpStart affordable housing funding from 50 percent to 29 percent in 2025. Although as an advocate Wilson objected to the cuts at the time, her own budget proposal has largely kept them in place. In real terms, it translates to at least $60 million a year not going to affordable housing.

A significant portion of that $410 million a year is instead going to the Human Services Department to help pay for Wilson’s ambitious shelter expansion program (her scaled-back goal is to have 1,000 new units completed by the end of next year.) But almost half of the JumpStart funding—$180 million—is going straight to the General Fund.
For Seattle City Councilmember Dionne Foster, reversing the diversion from affordable housing was her top priority. During the budget process, she passed a non-binding directive for the city’s budget office to restore affordable housing to make up at least 50 percent of JumpStart revenues by 2033. Foster also sponsored an amendment restoring $5 million—or about 1.25 percent of the JumpStart fund—to the Office of Housing.
Fiscal Responsibility for Thee, But Not for Me
While Wilson’s initially balanced budget proposal maintained Harrell’s slashes to affordable housing, the city council’s actions have made it worse.
The budget package assembled by Councilmember Dan Strauss added in about $40 million in additional spending on various council member’s priorities like adding $7 million for SDOT to build new road projects in each council district, $3 million for arts and culture organizations, and even $150,000 for a 40-foot-tall Jimothy statue in Ballard.
This extra funds came mainly at the expense of not putting more money into affordable housing. Some of it was covered by an $18 million increase in expected JumpStart revenues, while another $19 million came from the JumpStart reserve fund, which cushions against future economic downturns. Tax revenues fluctuate a lot based on the price of tech company stocks—so that’s definitely not a problem with an impending AI bubble crash, right?
All this additional spending has spurred accusations of fiscal irresponsibility. Last year, the city council passed a law requiring the mayor’s initial budget proposal to be balanced six years into the future. But on Monday, the city council voted down a bill sponsored by Foster that would hold the council to the same standard. At the time, budget chair Strauss said the council didn’t need a law or executive order “to tell me how to do my job well.”
In a November 6 letter to the city council first reported by PubliCola, City Budget Office director Aly Pennucci wrote that adding a bunch of one-time spending on programs that need recurring funds inflates the budget deficit. She warned Wilson’s office might freeze funding for some of these one-time programs if there is a downturn in revenue. There’s no doubt this budget has only made things more bitter between Strauss and Wilson.
“The more that we put these one-time adds in the budget that are actually ongoing expenses, the more we risk continuing to eat into that 30 percent in the future,” Foster said, referring to the proportion of JumpStart funds still going to the Office of Housing.
House Our Neighbors co-executive director Jeff Paul put his criticism of the council’s misaligned priorities more bluntly.
“I am really not a big fan of Strauss this year,” Paul said. Strauss’s budget package “was an absolute dismissal of what Dionne Foster is pushing for, along with a bunch of other community members, in favor of a fiscally irresponsible package that doesn’t prioritize what is really needed by the community.”
Interest Rates, an Orca Lawsuit, and those Damned Feds
The stagnation in Seattle’s affordable housing investments come at quite possibly the worst time for the sector, which is facing a bevy of challenges.
Firstly, the feds. The Trump administration’s hostility to “housing first” programs means that the Department of Housing and Urban Development is likely to cut off $67 million in funding to the Seattle region, putting 4,500 units of permanent supportive and transitional housing at risk. The threat has led Seattle’s Office of Housing to stockpile $37 million that could have gone to new projects for the worst case scenario.
Next, since the COVID-19 pandemic, the actual costs of building housing have risen faster than inflation, and interest rates remain high.
“Operating costs have increased across all affordable housing by something like 50 percent since 2021, and construction costs increased about 30 percent too,” said Housing Development Consortium government and policy director Jesse Simpson.
The cost of maintaining affordable housing has risen a lot more than revenue from rents (after all, it’s supposed to be affordable.) This has led the Office of Housing to increasingly dedicate JumpStart money to subsidizing operating expenses instead of new construction.
All this has resulted in a massive slowdown in the affordable housing pipeline. Community Roots CEO Colleen Echohawk says that as city money shifts to keeping existing buildings afloat, funding opportunities for new development dries up. This in turn spooks other funders, who rely on the Office of Housing to back up their investment.
“Without an award from the city of Seattle … it’s going to be a big struggle,” Echohawk said. “It’s sobering.”
Add into the mix the lawsuits claiming that more new housing development kills orcas, salmon, and trees. They have stalled Seattle’s comprehensive plan rezones, including Wilson’s “taller, denser, faster” initiative, until at least 2028.
Instead of siphoning off that much affordable housing money, Foster says the city needs to introduce new taxes on the rich and big corporations to fill future budget deficits.
“When we have unsustainable budgets, we can hide the need for progressive revenue and equitable taxation, because it seems like we have more money than we really do to pay for everything,” Foster said.
